Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Author Message
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #41
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.
06-17-2025 03:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #42
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 10:35 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 05:59 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 05:27 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 02:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.

Are you saying that Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have less influence on policy at their schools than some anonymous paper pushers? SOME ADs wield a lot of influence, but all football coaches do, and generally a whole lot more than the AD unless the coach is on the hot seat.

It depends on the school. A lot of coaches have very little influence on matters that don't involve play on the field.

ADs hire, evaluate, and fire coaches. Fans can ignore them as ‘anonymous paper pushers’ when munching pretzels in front of the TV but on campus, and especially in the athletic departments they helm, ADs are anything but anonymous. They carry a great deal of responsibility. If you work for one you ignore that at your peril.

It’s also fair to say that the cherry-picked examples of Mr Smart and Mr Kiffin do not represent the typical job situation of the typical coach, even in the SEC.

Frank’s observation is why I say Mr Petitti’s first, best play is to approach the SEC ready to do some horse trading. The SEC is already doing a lot of that internally. The B1G may as well be a factor in the discussion and help the SEC resolve things if it can.

I'm sure that other conferences are different, but Kirby and Lane are pretty representative of the SEC. Elko has a boss on paper, sure, but he makes 5x as much money, and Alberts doesn't get to tell him what to do, at all. Nor does Alberts have ultimate hiring/firing decision making ability on the head football coach. Everyone in the State knew that Jimbo was getting the axe, A&M had an interim President, and Bjork still had to get permission to do what we all needed to be done. How much less sway does Alberts have over Elko? I'll repeat, any SEC football coach that is not on the hot seat has much more influence than any AD.

It's best to look at it like the football coach is the AD of the football program, and the Athletic Director is the AD of all the other sports. Is this less true at some SEC programs than others? Sure, but for most of the Conference it is pretty much as I described. Vanderbilt? Kentucky? Well, no. Probably not Texas, Del Conte might be the best AD in the sport. But for Georgia, Alabama, LSU, Tennessee, A&M, Florida, Auburn, OU, Ole' Miss, USC, etc etc...the AD is the glorified paper pusher, though admittedly the better ones are out there focused on raising big $$ and ignoring the football coach unless told to pay attention to him by his bosses.
06-17-2025 03:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #43
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

Was just about to say schedule 10 P4 games and I'd have no issue. I'd even be okay with some exceptions for certain traditional non-conference G6 rivals for P4 teams like Oregon St. and Washington St., maybe USF, UCONN, Memphis, and Tulane. Pushing it Rice and Navy. As long as all conferences and ND agree to which teams can be exceptions aka defacto P4 rivals. Maintaining rivalries should be just as important as playing a balanced schedule.

In terms of conference scheduling, though I prefer H&H in 4 years, as long as teams are playing each other at least H&H in 6 years (half of what crossover matchups were when the SEC had divisions), that should be sufficient for conferences. For the SEC with 8 conference games, since rivalries are important, you can protect 4 primary rivalries annually, alternate 2 secondary rivalries every other year, and play the remaining 9 teams H&H in 6 years. Obviously if teams don't want to protect 4 rivals annually, they could play the rest of the SEC more frequently, but I'd leave that to the individual teams to determine who they want to protect.

8 games with 16 teams will be messy regardless of how many teams you protect unless you protect just 1 annual rival, which will certainly mever happen in the SEC. At 9 games, the SEC could protect up to 6 rivals annually and play everyone else H&H in 6 years if SEC teams really wanted that many protected games (or alternate the 2 secondary rivals as a non-conference game to maintain 6 annual rivals). I know SEC fans aren't fans of flex protect that the rest of P4 uses to a degress (M2 slightly, B1G significantly), but there's potential using it maintain primary rivals annually while playing secondary rivals, regional opponents (drivable games), and/or brand vs. brand games more frequently than the rest of the league.
06-17-2025 03:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #44
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

This is exactly it.

The Big Ten schools, for the most part, each have one true rival. There are a handful of major secondary rivalries (e.g. Michigan-Michigan State, the multiple Iowa rivals), but it’s otherwise more that the “Original 10” played each other annually or close to annually. In contrast, much of the SEC has multiple teams that they consider to be rivals, but never had the history of everyone playing everyone else in the league annually or close to annually even when the SEC was a much smaller league.

Dedicated non-conference rivalries are also much more prevalent in the SEC (such as any in-state rivalries against ACC teams) and those need to be locked in, whereas the main legacy non-conference rivalry in the Big Ten is Iowa-Iowa State and now there is USC-ND (plus whether we see the Oregon-Oregon State and Washington-Washington State rivalries maintained). So, that’s another major difference where most of the Big Ten doesn’t have a locked in non-conference rivalry game in the way a lot of SEC schools do. That naturally means that the SEC prizes more non-conference flexibility while the Big Ten isn’t anywhere near as bothered by giving up a non-conference game to play another conference game.

Those are all reasons totally outside of any CFP or strength of schedule considerations. It’s neither right or wrong - they’re based on historical traditions and DNA within each league.
06-17-2025 03:40 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #45
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 09:11 AM)stechs02 Wrote:  Flugar hinted at a growing rift between the Big Ten and the SEC. Are we buying that? And if it’s real — what’s actually at stake?

There’s definitely some smoke here, and it feels like more than media noise, although my glass half full self hopes it is nothing more than negotiation. If tensions are rising between the sport’s two most powerful conferences, the fallout could be massive across several fronts:

Big Ten–SEC scheduling agreement:
Dead in the water? There was legit momentum, but it feels like that’s completely stalled. Is this type of collaboration realistic anymore? I'm selling.

CFP structure post-2026:
Major uncertainty looms. The 5+7 format is locked through 2025, but the SEC is pushing hard for a more power-friendly model — fewer auto-bids, more emphasis on strength of schedule. The Big Ten doesn’t appear eager to follow that lead. Could we end up in a stalemate? Possibly. If the SEC demands a move to 5+11 or no auto-bids, I don’t see the Big Ten caving. My guess? We stay with the current structure.

Realignment:
If SOS becomes a bigger factor in CFP selection, don’t be shocked if the Big Ten makes a serious play for Florida State and Miami. Expanding into the South not only counters SEC influence — it strengthens the Big Ten’s own SOS profile. I’m not saying FSU prefers the Big Ten right now, but a shifting selection model might force a fresh look at the possibilities on the Big Ten side.

Governance model:
This might be the biggest domino of all. Can you build a unified structure for college football if one side feels blindsided or betrayed? A collaborative governance model only works if the top leagues trust each other — and that seems fragile right now.

The bigger question: Is this a simmering cold war between the SEC and Big Ten… or just offseason drama?
What say you?

Last point, I'd really like to hear from Petitti. He needs to be more vocal and a bigger public advocate for the Big Ten. I'm getting bad Kevin Warren flashbacks at a point in time where strong leadership is needed. +1 to Sankey in that department.

Oddly, Flugaur seems to be on to something here. Having said that, I'd call it more "polite disagreements" than "knife fights to the death". More like the old disagreements between Power conferences instead of the Yormark/Kliavkoff talk of going shopping in each others' conferences. Is it possible that nothing gets sorted and we're still at 12 playoff teams in 2032? Absolutely. That might even be the most likely outcome. However, it will depend on the money. My old boss used to say that making lots of money is the best deodorant...we'll all get along like best buds if there's a huge chunk of additional cash in to go to 16, enough cash for the P2, M2, ND, g5, everybody. Ditto scheduling alliances, if there's a lot of money there then all the details will get ironed out, if there's not much money there then it won't happen (at least for now).

As for actual Realignment...how much would adding a couple of ACC schools to either of the P2 boost our average SOS? Not much, if at all, right? It's kinda like the talk of adding basketball bluebloods to the SEC, talk that seems far less urgent after we had the best season in the history of college basketball collectively in '24-25. The B1G and SEC mid-tier teams are poised to get such an enormous raise over the next 5 years that they'll be able to effective keep up with or even outpace the spending of the largest of the M2. Kansas? Clemson? UNC? Move over, Indiana or Mississippi St just stole your recruit. That doesn't mean that we won't decide to add them for other reasons, like huge TV ratings potential, fan support, long term success, etc etc, but neither of us needs anyone else to boost our SOS.
06-17-2025 03:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #46
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

I don't think that we're dead set on anything. Sankey seemed agreeable to the 4-4-x-x model, and after input from various stakeholders, he's also agreeable to 5-11. Not saying that he should try passing the buck on this issue, but it feels much more like we need to mediate between the B1G and M2. Assuming the money is there for 16, I'm confident that's exactly what will happen. If there's not enough money there, well, a 12 team playoff looked pretty good last year.
06-17-2025 03:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #47
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

That one is running hot again right now, though, long term, they're roughly equal to Arkansas.

I could get behind scheduling many of the SEC vs many of the B1G (leaving out Georgia, Florida, and USCe b/c they have huge ACC rivals ofc). We'd still have enough quality to get 13 outstanding games. Spread those throughout the season and you have the makings of a $300m tv contract in today's climate. It would probably get better ratings than CBS did last year.

$150m/conference is ~ $9m per P2 school, enough to give up a body bag game even for my Aggies or PSU, but also yet one more chance to boost national exposure and provide all of us football crazies yet more entertainment. Ofc, when is it broadcast? Do they take over Friday night for that game? Play it in a 1/2 step between 2 primary broadcast windows on Saturdays? How does that impact the value of the contract? As I've said multiple times, if the money is there then we'll all get it figured out.
06-17-2025 04:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #48
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 04:07 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

That one is running hot again right now, though, long term, they're roughly equal to Arkansas.

I could get behind scheduling many of the SEC vs many of the B1G (leaving out Georgia, Florida, and USCe b/c they have huge ACC rivals ofc). We'd still have enough quality to get 13 outstanding games. Spread those throughout the season and you have the makings of a $300m tv contract in today's climate. It would probably get better ratings than CBS did last year.

$150m/conference is ~ $9m per P2 school, enough to give up a body bag game even for my Aggies or PSU, but also yet one more chance to boost national exposure and provide all of us football crazies yet more entertainment. Ofc, when is it broadcast? Do they take over Friday night for that game? Play it in a 1/2 step between 2 primary broadcast windows on Saturdays? How does that impact the value of the contract? As I've said multiple times, if the money is there then we'll all get it figured out.

Rough equivalent of Arkansas? They have 4 national titles in Football. How many does A&M have?

Agree about the rest.
06-17-2025 04:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #49
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

Speaking as a fan of a school that’s relatively new to the SEC, not all that unlike PSU in the B1G, I’d say that I’m VERY enthusiastic to play everybody. Not just the old SEC West, but Georgia, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, everybody. I would strongly prefer to go to 9 games, and I’d also love adding a tenth against (insert name of B1G school here). At 9 games we could play 3 rivals every year and all others twice every 4 years. It’s almost perfect. However, I’m not interested in either of those things unless they both put a significant amount of money in the TAMU Athletic Dept coffers. We will eventually get paid for the 9th game, whether it’s now or in 2034, and I feel the same about a scheduling alliance, which could happen now, in 2030 or perhaps 2034. Likely but not certainly now for both.

What I am less worked up about is the exact format of the CFP. I’d like to go to more games, again assuming the money is there, but the exact format….well, I’m pretty flexible on that front. I know that Trev strongly prefers the 4-4-x-x model, but I think he’s either toeing the company line for Sankey or he’s been fed a bill of goods. A&M will be fine regardless of the future CFP format, as will the SEC. I really like our position right now tbh, this gives Sankey a great opportunity to play peacemaker with the other 3 conferences. 5-11? Great! 4-4-x-x? Awesome? Some other weird compromise that still gets everybody more money and 16 instead of 12 playoff teams? Cool! I do think that both of the P2 should be cognizant of the federal legislation, largely based upon House, that’s slowly working its way towards becoming a bill. Now would be an awful time to alienate the entire M2 and their elected Government officials…
06-17-2025 08:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #50
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

I intentionally did not pursue the Penn State reach for the reason you stated. What you don't have a good read on is that schools like Florida and LSU seldom played each other until they were forced to accept that concocted rivalry in 1992 to make the schedule work. Florida desired to continue to play Auburn and Georgia and didn't want to have to pick between them. And what youngsters don't remember is that the 12 team SEC of the mid 60's only played 10 total games and only had a minimum requirement for 6 conference games, which is why Bear liked to schedule 7. It broke ties and gave Alabama conference championships. It was so different then. Bowls were important and schools played those they wanted to play. Auburn kept playing Clemson on a regular basis for years before 1991 and kept playing Georgia Tech for 14 years after they left the SEC until Ga Tech ended it when they joined the ACC. Similarly, LSU played Tulane regularly into the 70's.

All well before most who post here's time. Who knew consolidation (called realignment) would end so many of those games, and alter the way conferences were conceived and functioned, because it began so innocently with OU and UGa winning the right to sell their own rights to their product of football. Why didn't that logic apply to basketball too? It was only logical along the same reasoning that yielded the court decision on football. 16 was the construct of market footprint pay models and rotating half divisions and the brainchild of a minor network exec. A few sleepy decades with changes and we are staring a mini-NFL model directly in the eyes.

One size does not fit all for the SEC and Big 10, but 10 conference games, while jumping ahead in the timeline, would likely quell the petty differences we have now, and would also likely pay us all more as well. Let's bypass the hooey each is putting out and move to 10. Fans will like it better, networks would too, and the ADs still get 7 home games per season with the 2 buy games.
06-17-2025 09:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #51
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

This is exactly it.

The Big Ten schools, for the most part, each have one true rival. There are a handful of major secondary rivalries (e.g. Michigan-Michigan State, the multiple Iowa rivals), but it’s otherwise more that the “Original 10” played each other annually or close to annually. In contrast, much of the SEC has multiple teams that they consider to be rivals, but never had the history of everyone playing everyone else in the league annually or close to annually even when the SEC was a much smaller league.

Dedicated non-conference rivalries are also much more prevalent in the SEC (such as any in-state rivalries against ACC teams) and those need to be locked in, whereas the main legacy non-conference rivalry in the Big Ten is Iowa-Iowa State and now there is USC-ND (plus whether we see the Oregon-Oregon State and Washington-Washington State rivalries maintained). So, that’s another major difference where most of the Big Ten doesn’t have a locked in non-conference rivalry game in the way a lot of SEC schools do. That naturally means that the SEC prizes more non-conference flexibility while the Big Ten isn’t anywhere near as bothered by giving up a non-conference game to play another conference game.

Those are all reasons totally outside of any CFP or strength of schedule considerations. It’s neither right or wrong - they’re based on historical traditions and DNA within each league.

Most SEC schools played 6 conference games and some played 5 back when the SEC was a 12 team (with Tulane and Georgia Tech) and a 10 team conference. It wasn't until 1988 that the SEC standardized on 7. Then they went to 8 when they expanded to 12 in 1992. But then at first it was a 5-2-1 schedule, so you played 4 of the teams every 4th year.
06-17-2025 09:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #52
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 09:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

This is exactly it.

The Big Ten schools, for the most part, each have one true rival. There are a handful of major secondary rivalries (e.g. Michigan-Michigan State, the multiple Iowa rivals), but it’s otherwise more that the “Original 10” played each other annually or close to annually. In contrast, much of the SEC has multiple teams that they consider to be rivals, but never had the history of everyone playing everyone else in the league annually or close to annually even when the SEC was a much smaller league.

Dedicated non-conference rivalries are also much more prevalent in the SEC (such as any in-state rivalries against ACC teams) and those need to be locked in, whereas the main legacy non-conference rivalry in the Big Ten is Iowa-Iowa State and now there is USC-ND (plus whether we see the Oregon-Oregon State and Washington-Washington State rivalries maintained). So, that’s another major difference where most of the Big Ten doesn’t have a locked in non-conference rivalry game in the way a lot of SEC schools do. That naturally means that the SEC prizes more non-conference flexibility while the Big Ten isn’t anywhere near as bothered by giving up a non-conference game to play another conference game.

Those are all reasons totally outside of any CFP or strength of schedule considerations. It’s neither right or wrong - they’re based on historical traditions and DNA within each league.

Most SEC schools played 6 conference games and some played 5 back when the SEC was a 12 team (with Tulane and Georgia Tech) and a 10 team conference. It wasn't until 1988 that the SEC standardized on 7. Then they went to 8 when they expanded to 12 in 1992. But then at first it was a 5-2-1 schedule, so you played 4 of the teams every 4th year.

Did you mean to repeat what I said 1 post above? It's okay, just odd.
06-17-2025 09:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OdinFrigg Offline
Gone Fishing
*

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
Post: #53
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
“Illinois head coach Bret Bielema recently had some harsh words for the SEC and the way teams in that conference do their schedules.

“Bielema spoke with reporters Tuesday night about the College Football Playoff potentially expanding to 16 teams and said that the SEC needs to make some changes before that should happen.”

(read on)

https://www.pennlive.com/sports/2025/06/...agues.html

Doubtful the SEC is troubled by what the ex-Arkansas and current Illinois fb coach has to say about the SEC’s number of conference games scheduled.
06-18-2025 12:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #54
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:33 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

Was just about to say schedule 10 P4 games and I'd have no issue. I'd even be okay with some exceptions for certain traditional non-conference G6 rivals for P4 teams like Oregon St. and Washington St., maybe USF, UCONN, Memphis, and Tulane. Pushing it Rice and Navy. As long as all conferences and ND agree to which teams can be exceptions aka defacto P4 rivals. Maintaining rivalries should be just as important as playing a balanced schedule.

In terms of conference scheduling, though I prefer H&H in 4 years, as long as teams are playing each other at least H&H in 6 years (half of what crossover matchups were when the SEC had divisions), that should be sufficient for conferences. For the SEC with 8 conference games, since rivalries are important, you can protect 4 primary rivalries annually, alternate 2 secondary rivalries every other year, and play the remaining 9 teams H&H in 6 years. Obviously if teams don't want to protect 4 rivals annually, they could play the rest of the SEC more frequently, but I'd leave that to the individual teams to determine who they want to protect.

8 games with 16 teams will be messy regardless of how many teams you protect unless you protect just 1 annual rival, which will certainly mever happen in the SEC. At 9 games, the SEC could protect up to 6 rivals annually and play everyone else H&H in 6 years if SEC teams really wanted that many protected games (or alternate the 2 secondary rivals as a non-conference game to maintain 6 annual rivals). I know SEC fans aren't fans of flex protect that the rest of P4 uses to a degress (M2 slightly, B1G significantly), but there's potential using it maintain primary rivals annually while playing secondary rivals, regional opponents (drivable games), and/or brand vs. brand games more frequently than the rest of the league.

We don't have 2 Ohio States, we have 10 of them. Leaving scheduling decisions in the SEC up to individual schools would be anarchy. The Conference is quite aware of existing rivalries, I'm quite confident that they're not going to kill off an A&M-Texas or Alabama-Tennessee just b/c we only have 8 Conference games instead of 9. They'll just do some modified version of what they did with A&M and Missouri. Perhaps OU only plays South Carolina once in their first 15 years, a la A&M vs Georgia?
06-18-2025 12:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #55
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 09:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

I intentionally did not pursue the Penn State reach for the reason you stated. What you don't have a good read on is that schools like Florida and LSU seldom played each other until they were forced to accept that concocted rivalry in 1992 to make the schedule work. Florida desired to continue to play Auburn and Georgia and didn't want to have to pick between them. And what youngsters don't remember is that the 12 team SEC of the mid 60's only played 10 total games and only had a minimum requirement for 6 conference games, which is why Bear liked to schedule 7. It broke ties and gave Alabama conference championships. It was so different then. Bowls were important and schools played those they wanted to play. Auburn kept playing Clemson on a regular basis for years before 1991 and kept playing Georgia Tech for 14 years after they left the SEC until Ga Tech ended it when they joined the ACC. Similarly, LSU played Tulane regularly into the 70's.

All well before most who post here's time. Who knew consolidation (called realignment) would end so many of those games, and alter the way conferences were conceived and functioned, because it began so innocently with OU and UGa winning the right to sell their own rights to their product of football. Why didn't that logic apply to basketball too? It was only logical along the same reasoning that yielded the court decision on football. 16 was the construct of market footprint pay models and rotating half divisions and the brainchild of a minor network exec. A few sleepy decades with changes and we are staring a mini-NFL model directly in the eyes.

One size does not fit all for the SEC and Big 10, but 10 conference games, while jumping ahead in the timeline, would likely quell the petty differences we have now, and would also likely pay us all more as well. Let's bypass the hooey each is putting out and move to 10. Fans will like it better, networks would too, and the ADs still get 7 home games per season with the 2 buy games.
You're repeating my conclusion on scheduling preferences back to me but failing to see why it would affect a preference towards 8 or 9 games. The SEC cares about specific rivalries and thus 8 conference games is all that is needed while the Big Ten cares about seeing all teams and thus needs to have the 9th game.

And while Bryan might want to see all SEC teams a lot, my guess is that most Aggies care far more about beating Texas, LSU and maybe Arkansas and Oklahoma.
06-18-2025 01:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #56
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 01:39 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 09:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
Penn State clearly paved the way to Maryland and Rutgers as their partner. A road to hell, I suppose, from the fan perspective but it got the conference money. And then I don't think Nebraska was really a prerequisite for adding the Pac schools, either.

But you seem to miss the point on what the "original 10" Big 10 schools want, which is to actively play eachother. Auburn, as a school right on the fissure, probably feels the same way as those Big Ten programs do but its not felt across the conference and not by all of the power programs. Not by Florida, by LSU, by the new schools, etc. And for a good deal of the rivalries that exist, the SEC did preserve them in a way that the Big Ten didn't (Ole Miss-Vandy is a good example here.) One and only one of those games existed in the Big Ten divisional format and only because a state had to be split in half. Once again pointing towards a cultural difference where the Big Ten cared more about seeing all teams while the SEC cared more about maintaining specific games.

I intentionally did not pursue the Penn State reach for the reason you stated. What you don't have a good read on is that schools like Florida and LSU seldom played each other until they were forced to accept that concocted rivalry in 1992 to make the schedule work. Florida desired to continue to play Auburn and Georgia and didn't want to have to pick between them. And what youngsters don't remember is that the 12 team SEC of the mid 60's only played 10 total games and only had a minimum requirement for 6 conference games, which is why Bear liked to schedule 7. It broke ties and gave Alabama conference championships. It was so different then. Bowls were important and schools played those they wanted to play. Auburn kept playing Clemson on a regular basis for years before 1991 and kept playing Georgia Tech for 14 years after they left the SEC until Ga Tech ended it when they joined the ACC. Similarly, LSU played Tulane regularly into the 70's.

All well before most who post here's time. Who knew consolidation (called realignment) would end so many of those games, and alter the way conferences were conceived and functioned, because it began so innocently with OU and UGa winning the right to sell their own rights to their product of football. Why didn't that logic apply to basketball too? It was only logical along the same reasoning that yielded the court decision on football. 16 was the construct of market footprint pay models and rotating half divisions and the brainchild of a minor network exec. A few sleepy decades with changes and we are staring a mini-NFL model directly in the eyes.

One size does not fit all for the SEC and Big 10, but 10 conference games, while jumping ahead in the timeline, would likely quell the petty differences we have now, and would also likely pay us all more as well. Let's bypass the hooey each is putting out and move to 10. Fans will like it better, networks would too, and the ADs still get 7 home games per season with the 2 buy games.
You're repeating my conclusion on scheduling preferences back to me but failing to see why it would affect a preference towards 8 or 9 games. The SEC cares about specific rivalries and thus 8 conference games is all that is needed while the Big Ten cares about seeing all teams and thus needs to have the 9th game.

And while Bryan might want to see all SEC teams a lot, my guess is that most Aggies care far more about beating Texas, LSU and maybe Arkansas and Oklahoma.

Project much do you? Your last paragraph is what I've been saying. You miss my point. 10 P games required for upper tier participation is all that is needed. The SEC doesn't need but 8 conference games per school. That's understood. 10P games merely requires one cross conference rival (ACC or B12) and one OOC slot for any other P school. At 10 P games the Big 10 can play 9 conference games or all 10 if they wish, but there's money in that scheduling agreement.

The point is 10 P games being required is a large enough umbrella to accommodate both. It never has needed to be a uniformed requirement for a particular number of conference games. But to satisfy networks, accommodate the Big 10's desire to play each other more, and to satisfy the SEC's need to showcase and preserve rivalries a 10 P game requirement covers both and still leaves 2 buy games for 7 home tickets per upper tier school. IOW all of this is a BS disagreement over something the networks won't like and would prefer to reward the solution with more revenue.

I'm a business guy very accustomed to working out petty disagreements between parties who can make more working together than against one another, and that happens in many industries even when niche specialties actually would complement each party's offerings and make them both more money.

There's a constant pissing contest between the SEC and Big 10 leadership to be able to show their constituents that they toed the company line on something. They need to pack that crap and work on the most important line item, namely maximizing revenue so they all have enough capital to cover their new overhead without selling out to P.E.

The same crap is going on now with the portal situation.

When you get into a discussion where both sides claim to know what is best for the other you have crossed into "double dumb***" territory and nothing good will come of it. It becomes emotional and bypasses reasonable business agreements. The same garbage about the portal with the Big 10 wanting to protect the "academic calendar" and the SEC coaches wanting to preserve the sanctity of Spring Practice is asinine on both parties. One reality is that they will now always be athletes before students because that is their profession. And Spring Practice is and has been a problem for 2 sport athletes, for coaches' families, and an unnecessary risk to athletes who will not maintain continuity during the time off they through part of the Summer.

That such positions are championed by either side is stupid and nonproductive gamesmanship and one-upmanship by two colossal egos. This is why corporate control has been asserted. The corporations know it requires profit, and cooperation will assist the generation of more. It's time the SEC & B1G's coaches and ADs, sit down and shut up and let their commissioners work with the networks and then simply comply with whatever is agreed upon. In the end those who are best monetized will be best positioned to win. It's about business and the Big Ten and SEC are both big businesses which have a synergy between them regardless of the rest of the rivalry spew, which is good for ginning the public's interest in the business, but lousy when it gets in the way because of who has the say so spats and the ubiquitous blather about "but we have always done it this way." It's "adapt and thrive" or "fail to and die time" because the 20.5 million or whatever it is now comes due every year and the longer we wait to earn more the less everyone will have to use to compete.

I never gave a damn about what the Big 10 wants to do or why and what the SEC wants to do or why. College athletics has been professionalized, it is now a business, and will suffer until it takes full advantage of that change!
06-18-2025 02:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OdinFrigg Offline
Gone Fishing
*

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
Post: #57
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
The role of a selection committee is getting questioned. We see the alleged favoritism and politics that have infiltrated the NCAA basketball selection committees over the past years concerning pickings and seedings. Hopefully for football playoff selections, controversy about selections can be minimized going forward. The greater the at large pics are, and criteria judgments are left to interpretations, the greater the selection committee has power to use their discretion.

https://www.cbssports.com/college-footba...-in-focus/
06-18-2025 02:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stechs02 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 553
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 227
I Root For: Ohio State
Location: Akron, Ohio
Post: #58
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Josh Pate just posted a really insightful video on the ongoing Big Ten vs. SEC power struggle and the future of the playoff model. I think he absolutely nails it. When you combine his perspective with Joel Klatt's recent take, it becomes even clearer to me that Tony Petitti’s next move should be to stand firm on the automatic qualifier (AQ) model. I truly believe it's the right approach for a wide range of reasons—though I can't articulate them nearly as well as Pate and Klatt do. If you haven’t already, take a serious look at the case for the AQ model. Both do a really good job advocating for it.

Josh Pate's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4XKnXl92c4

Joel Klatt's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nirHj1r3SA
06-18-2025 03:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #59
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 03:07 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  Josh Pate just posted a really insightful video on the ongoing Big Ten vs. SEC power struggle and the future of the playoff model. I think he absolutely nails it. When you combine his perspective with Joel Klatt's recent take, it becomes even clearer to me that Tony Petitti’s next move should be to stand firm on the automatic qualifier (AQ) model. I truly believe it's the right approach for a wide range of reasons—though I can't articulate them nearly as well as Pate and Klatt do. If you haven’t already, take a serious look at the case for the AQ model. Both do a really good job advocating for it.

Josh Pate's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4XKnXl92c4

Joel Klatt's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nirHj1r3SA

You enter a boardroom, and you know your company's presentation and what changes it will seek. Almost always the CEO will have designated someone to speak on behalf of the opposition so they can get that obstacle out of the way by introducing it and explaining it away after it has been introduced.

Petitti here is the CEO, and Sankey had his ADs be the voice of opposition. Why? Because if you are going to have consensus or simply a super majority in favor for the proposal you must first listen to the position of the dissent, but you want someone you trust to introduce it in a way that voices the oppositions strengths and sets up the counters to their position and you want to control that narrative within that room.

Well, the boardroom here is the viewing public. Petitti has introduced the proposal, the SEC's ADs have voiced for the opposition though their commissioner has been in agreement with Petitti on this matter. Now those who like to drive narratives have run with it (reporters and bloggers) and they are essentially sucking the oxygen out of the room for opposition as they talk about what it does for the Big 10 and SEC, they are framing the 2 slots promised to the Big 12 and ACC as you should be grateful you have even these, they are conceding the 1 G5 for now, but that could go away with a breakaway upper tier, and they are preparing the public for the Irish to be covered by an at large leaving 2 at large spots which their argument has likely set up for a 5th from the SEC and Big Ten.

This, folks, is a tried-and-true process. It's not about AQs for the SEC and Big Ten but about enhancing the "regular season." So you move the discussion beyond guaranteed slots and onto doing what is best for the regular seasons of the SEC and Big Ten because..., that's what is best for the promotion of those games on a major network and will impact their ability to draw larger audiences later into the season and from a greater number of schools and that agenda is not mentioned because corporate profits, even though they enhance conference profits, are not a line of reasoning the public is easily sold on. Helping the two bell cow conferences improve their regular season sounds reasonable, so that's what you push because automatic qualifiers sound, well, "unfair."

Therefore, Petitti introduces the concept, Sankey lends some support, the ADs in the SEC get to play spokesman for the Big 12, ACC and G5, the debate over the issue is corporate-splained away so that bloggers and reporters and others of their ilk then sound clever for mansplaining more of it and echoing the preapproved sentiment.

What Klatt and Pate have done is advance the company line by getting to inform their audiences, while the real progenitors of this plan (FOX and ESPN) get to set up extra conference playoff games to go along with an expanded playoff with no byes. Meaning they get to earn a helluva lot more and pass some of it onto the SEC and Big 10 driving a larger wedge in the revenue gap and setting up an eventual move to mini-NFL model which can be tweaked in many ways to make even more.

Realignment has really been consolidation with product placement to enhance the value of the associated product lines. Business 101. And the courts now imply by ruling that it is a business.

This isn't the final stage of change, but it is close to moving us toward it.

Edit: And please note Pate says this will all be done in a couple of months. It's very likely already done. They want to explain their reasons for change, acknowledge resistance and then get her done before anyone has time to organize against it. It's not the Mandalorian but it is the way!
(This post was last modified: 06-18-2025 04:09 PM by JRsec.)
06-18-2025 04:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,308
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #60
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 03:07 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  Josh Pate just posted a really insightful video on the ongoing Big Ten vs. SEC power struggle and the future of the playoff model. I think he absolutely nails it. When you combine his perspective with Joel Klatt's recent take, it becomes even clearer to me that Tony Petitti’s next move should be to stand firm on the automatic qualifier (AQ) model. I truly believe it's the right approach for a wide range of reasons—though I can't articulate them nearly as well as Pate and Klatt do. If you haven’t already, take a serious look at the case for the AQ model. Both do a really good job advocating for it.

Josh Pate's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4XKnXl92c4

Joel Klatt's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nirHj1r3SA

Klatt is correct that the M2 would get more spots longterm with the guaranteed minimum of 2. Though there is question on whether that should be their top priority. Does this render the M2CG a pointless seeding exercise? Will we be asking the M2CG loser to participate in a play-in round on Army-Navy weekend?

Pate is off with his 9-1 Tennessee example. They won’t be resting starters the last 2 weeks. If they finish 9-3 they’ll be in the 4-team play-in round. Win an extra game and they avoid that round; win out and they get 1 of the 2 byes to the NYD QFs.

The real question above 5+11 vs 4-4-2-2-1+3 is the WCGs. That is the hundred million dollar question. Expansion to 14 or 16 won’t result in any meaningful revenue gain. Frank may be right that you can’t have WCGs without AQs.
06-18-2025 04:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.