(06-18-2025 03:07 PM)stechs02 Wrote: Josh Pate just posted a really insightful video on the ongoing Big Ten vs. SEC power struggle and the future of the playoff model. I think he absolutely nails it. When you combine his perspective with Joel Klatt's recent take, it becomes even clearer to me that Tony Petitti’s next move should be to stand firm on the automatic qualifier (AQ) model. I truly believe it's the right approach for a wide range of reasons—though I can't articulate them nearly as well as Pate and Klatt do. If you haven’t already, take a serious look at the case for the AQ model. Both do a really good job advocating for it.
Josh Pate's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4XKnXl92c4
Joel Klatt's Take
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nirHj1r3SA
You enter a boardroom, and you know your company's presentation and what changes it will seek. Almost always the CEO will have designated someone to speak on behalf of the opposition so they can get that obstacle out of the way by introducing it and explaining it away after it has been introduced.
Petitti here is the CEO, and Sankey had his ADs be the voice of opposition. Why? Because if you are going to have consensus or simply a super majority in favor for the proposal you must first listen to the position of the dissent, but you want someone you trust to introduce it in a way that voices the oppositions strengths and sets up the counters to their position and you want to control that narrative within that room.
Well, the boardroom here is the viewing public. Petitti has introduced the proposal, the SEC's ADs have voiced for the opposition though their commissioner has been in agreement with Petitti on this matter. Now those who like to drive narratives have run with it (reporters and bloggers) and they are essentially sucking the oxygen out of the room for opposition as they talk about what it does for the Big 10 and SEC, they are framing the 2 slots promised to the Big 12 and ACC as you should be grateful you have even these, they are conceding the 1 G5 for now, but that could go away with a breakaway upper tier, and they are preparing the public for the Irish to be covered by an at large leaving 2 at large spots which their argument has likely set up for a 5th from the SEC and Big Ten.
This, folks, is a tried-and-true process. It's not about AQs for the SEC and Big Ten but about enhancing the "regular season." So you move the discussion beyond guaranteed slots and onto doing what is best for the regular seasons of the SEC and Big Ten because..., that's what is best for the promotion of those games on a major network and will impact their ability to draw larger audiences later into the season and from a greater number of schools and that agenda is not mentioned because corporate profits, even though they enhance conference profits, are not a line of reasoning the public is easily sold on. Helping the two bell cow conferences improve their regular season sounds reasonable, so that's what you push because automatic qualifiers sound, well, "unfair."
Therefore, Petitti introduces the concept, Sankey lends some support, the ADs in the SEC get to play spokesman for the Big 12, ACC and G5, the debate over the issue is corporate-splained away so that bloggers and reporters and others of their ilk then sound clever for mansplaining more of it and echoing the preapproved sentiment.
What Klatt and Pate have done is advance the company line by getting to inform their audiences, while the real progenitors of this plan (FOX and ESPN) get to set up extra conference playoff games to go along with an expanded playoff with no byes. Meaning they get to earn a helluva lot more and pass some of it onto the SEC and Big 10 driving a larger wedge in the revenue gap and setting up an eventual move to mini-NFL model which can be tweaked in many ways to make even more.
Realignment has really been consolidation with product placement to enhance the value of the associated product lines. Business 101. And the courts now imply by ruling that it is a business.
This isn't the final stage of change, but it is close to moving us toward it.
Edit: And please note Pate says this will all be done in a couple of months. It's very likely already done. They want to explain their reasons for change, acknowledge resistance and then get her done before anyone has time to organize against it. It's not the Mandalorian but it is the way!