(06-19-2025 03:46 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: (06-19-2025 01:52 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote: Just wait, at large picks will eventually turn into wild card games.
2/2/2/2/1+5 or 7 with 3-5 or 4-7 at-large play-in games while preserving CCGs if you guarantee the top 2 champs a bye and next 2 champs a home game.
Not sure how anyone gets a first round bye in a 16-team field. I'll leave that aside for now and show you what this format would have looked like last year if it had been in effect (final CFP rankings in parentheses):
AQ bids
B1G: Oregon (1), Penn State (4)
SEC: Georgia (2), Texas (3)
ACC: SMU (10), Clemson (16) (guaranteed home game)
Big XII: Arizona State (12) (guaranteed home game), BYU (17)
G5: Boise State (9)
Wild cards (Note: to avoid certain all-conference matchups, I adjusted in certain cases):
Colorado (23) at Notre Dame (5)
Army (22) at Ohio State (6)
Syracuse (21) at Tennessee (7)
Missouri (19) at Indiana (8)
Illinois (20) at Alabama (11)
South Carolina (15) at Miami (13)
Iowa State (18) at Ole Miss (14)
If you go with a 14-team field with 5 at-large bids, then:
Missouri (19) at Notre Dame (5)
South Carolina (15) at Ohio State (6)
Iowa State (18) at Tennessee (7)
Ole Miss (14) at Indiana (8)
Miami (13) at Alabama (11)
SEC fans might enjoy seeing those games, but I'm struggling to find a planet on which this would be considered a fair format. Then throw in the fact that only Notre Dame and Ohio State would be guaranteed to host first-round playoff matchups with a win.