Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Author Message
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #21
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 11:12 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  If the SEC had any sense, they will get right back on board with the B1G on the 4-4-2-2-1 model. Big own-goal if they don't.

BTW, for whatever reason, when I see "Tony Pettiti" my mind registers "Tom Petty".

Just thought I'd share that.

1. The SEC doesn't need to do anything but "Stand my ground, 'cause I won't back down!" Seriously the best possible compromise is the 10 P game schedule. And the reason the Big 10 wants 9 conference games is because they fear Notre Dame getting a scheduling agreement with the SEC which would be complicated given the number of crossover season ending rivalries with the ACC and other in state rivalries to the west which "could" be played in a 10 P game format. 10 P games gives a level schedule for consideration regardless of the 4 P conferences and Notre Dame.

2. Bryan was correct up above. The monetary advantage of the Big 10 contract has about a year, two at the most, to live. The SEC will be in great shape regardless. They might as well get what they want.
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2025 02:06 PM by JRsec.)
06-16-2025 02:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #22
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.
06-16-2025 02:28 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #23
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 01:18 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

But the SEC would like more objective criteria.

Realistically, if people were betting on a neutral site game, how many would:

Bet on Boise St. over Clemson and Arizona St.;
Bet on SMU over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina, or even BYU who beat them in Dallas and had the same number of losses;
Bet on Indiana (although this would be closer) over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina? IU had a G5 level strength of schedule. They had a weak ooc and it worked out that they mostly got the weaker opponents in the Big Ten.

I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:

Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win

Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams

Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)

Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents

These are measurable, on-field results—not projections or assumptions—and they give a more accurate picture of a team’s true strength. Additionally, they are transparent—everyone knows what they need to do to make the playoff.

I know this isn't perfect so don't beat me up too bad on the metrics / weightings. It was for example purposes only, not what is should be.

More important than direct SOS is Strength of Record. Playing Oregon and Penn St. on the road and Indiana and Michigan at home, its tougher to go 10-2 than a team with a similar strength of schedule who didn't play any top 25 teams, but played a lot of teams in the 30s. There's a kind of a normal curve on how difficult it is to beat teams. Going 3-0 vs. a 9, 11 and 100 strength teams is tougher than doing it against 39, 40 and 41, even though both schedules average a 40.
06-16-2025 02:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #24
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 02:43 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 01:18 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

But the SEC would like more objective criteria.

Realistically, if people were betting on a neutral site game, how many would:

Bet on Boise St. over Clemson and Arizona St.;
Bet on SMU over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina, or even BYU who beat them in Dallas and had the same number of losses;
Bet on Indiana (although this would be closer) over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina? IU had a G5 level strength of schedule. They had a weak ooc and it worked out that they mostly got the weaker opponents in the Big Ten.

I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:

Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win

Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams

Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)

Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents

These are measurable, on-field results—not projections or assumptions—and they give a more accurate picture of a team’s true strength. Additionally, they are transparent—everyone knows what they need to do to make the playoff.

I know this isn't perfect so don't beat me up too bad on the metrics / weightings. It was for example purposes only, not what is should be.

More important than direct SOS is Strength of Record. Playing Oregon and Penn St. on the road and Indiana and Michigan at home, it's tougher to go 10-2 than a team with a similar strength of schedule who didn't play any top 25 teams but played a lot of teams in the 30s. There's a kind of a normal curve on how difficult it is to beat teams. Going 3-0 vs. a 9, 11 and 100 strength teams is tougher than doing it against 39, 40 and 41, even though both schedules average a 40.

Perhaps they should gauge the schedules using the Strength of Finish of all of the opponents of the schools under consideration. Early and midseason rankings are B.S. Evaluate the CFP slots by how all under consideration finished against the finished records of everyone they played. The postseason is the only picture which gives some clarity of distinctions. And...get rid of the politics ridden selection committees.
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2025 03:02 PM by JRsec.)
06-16-2025 03:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,940
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #25
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 11:12 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  If the SEC had any sense, they will get right back on board with the B1G on the 4-4-2-2-1 model. Big own-goal if they don't.

BTW, for whatever reason, when I see "Tony Pettiti" my mind registers "Tom Petty".

Just thought I'd share that.

We would have had 6 last year in a 5-11 model, and it’s quite likely that we’d never dip below 4 between 2026-2032. Why should we care about 4 auto bids when there isn’t unanimity among the other 3 conferences about it? You think that Texas Tech booster is causing issues right now? Just wait until the big 12 is cut down to a g5 level for auto bids. Do that and we’ll never have a chance at getting favorable legislation passed. We’re far better off looking out for our interests where it makes sense but keeping our eyes on the long term. What’s good for CFB long term is “more” good for the SEC than for anybody else, right? Ted Cruz isn’t going to get this across the finish line if he’s up inundated with anti-SEC messages. Ditto reps in Florida, Georgia, Oklahoma and South Carolina.

Like it or not, we are constrained in ways that the other conferences just don’t have to consider.
06-16-2025 03:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,940
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #26
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 12:23 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 11:44 AM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 06:53 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-15-2025 09:52 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  It’s obvious that the Big Ten is the one that really pushed for 4-4-2-2-1 CFP model. But, Petitti has remained radio silent, even as reporters and pundits have asked him to speak out since Greg Sankey’s SEC spring meeting.

I’m not sure if Petitti will start speaking publicly to sway opinion. He seems to prefer working behind the scenes, possibly using pro-Big Ten media (Joel Klatt?) to communicate.

i do expect Petitti will try to persuade the ACC and/or Big 12. If one or both of the M2 conferences endorse an AQ model and the SEC comes around, we would see a 4-4-x-x model. Joel Klatt has already floated a 4-4-2.5-2.5 idea on his show, which might signal the Big Ten’s willingness to offer an additional AQ to the M2 conferences.

I also suspect the ACC might be more receptive than the Big 12. Jim Phillips previously mentioned a potential play-in game. The problem is , during the ACC spring meetingg, many in the ACC pushed for three AQ spots, which may be too much for the SEC to accept.

So I’m very curious about how Petitti will solve this.

What do you think?

Interesting question. Mr Petitti can get 4-4-2-2-1 if he can win the SEC on it, so his first effort would surely be invested there. If the P2 leagues agree on format the other conferences will likely have to live with it.

Of course, I bet Petitti thought the SEC was on the same page when they had first proposed the 4-4-2-2-1.

But, while the Big Ten firmly prefers the AQ model, the SEC is open to a 5-11 or no-AQ model, IF the selection criteria are revised to favor SOS (probably using a metric like ESPN’s FPI).

In other words, it doesn’t look like the P2’s interest are completely aligned. The SEC doesn’t need to push for the AQ model against public backlash. Petitti does if he really wants it.

That’s why I’m curious about his next move.

0, ZERO, nil, naught, goose egg chance the B1G would ever agree to the bolded terms. Way way way too much conflict of interest. SOS is vastly skewed and biased towards the SEC. Go looks at ESPNs FPI... You'll notice things like Illinois at #44 & SC in top 15, despite what we saw just months ago and not a large change in variables. It's legit JUNK, dog poo, biased trash!!

EDIT: I feel strongly that ESPN should have no influence over the selection of the 16 teams. Beyond that, I’m just not a fan of ESPN in general. That said, please don’t take my passion as a criticism of you or your reasoning—I respect your perspective.

I get annoyed at times that FPI, BPI, etc don’t “properly” rank my Aggies. I can see how someone from outside the conference would feel that the entire SEC gets too much love, too. TBH, I’d be 100% ok if zero changes are made to auto qualifiers OR the selection committee’s criteria. Last year’s committee might have just been a 1 off, right? It certainly did things differently than previous committees, and one year’s worth of data on a committee that returns over half its members every year is hardly conclusive. 5-11? 4-4-x-x-1? Either works for me. The only thing I really care about is getting to 16 games and getting everyone in FBS paid for those extra 4 games. Full stop. If we get 0 additional money I think we should stay at 12. If the 4 conferences can’t reach consensus despite additional money on the table, I think we will be forced to stay at 12. That’s unfortunate, but it’s reality.

Ultimately, I expect that everyone will be able to reach consensus as long as there’s a big raise in it for us to go to 16 teams, but we will all have to compromise. The SEC will have to. The B1G will have to. M2. ND. Perhaps the g5 will be even further marginalized and get a smaller than hoped-for raise. I don’t know. But what I do know is that if Petitti was willing to hammer Michigan in 2023 during their historic season, he’ll be gunning for tOSU next. When that happens, just have Bjork call me and we’ll handle your move to the SEC expeditiously…. COGS
06-16-2025 04:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,308
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #27
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:

Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win

Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams

Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)

Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents

These are measurable, on-field results—not projections or assumptions—and they give a more accurate picture of a team’s true strength. Additionally, they are transparent—everyone knows what they need to do to make the playoff.

I know this isn't perfect so don't beat me up too bad on the metrics / weightings. It was for example purposes only, not what is should be.

This all sounds like BCS 1.0 all over again. Cherry picking thresholds like Record vs. Top X, or “power” opponents, or “points” for certain wins… is the wrong direction.

There are many computer rankings out there that do an excellent job. Pick one (or a handful) that are simple and transparent. “Strength of Record” is the correct ‘type’ of ranking.

But I do agree with the main points:
1) Selection Criteria is currently the main pain point
2) Transparency and consistency are needed ASAP
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2025 05:19 PM by Crayton.)
06-16-2025 05:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,940
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #28
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 02:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.

Are you saying that Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have less influence on policy at their schools than some anonymous paper pushers? SOME ADs wield a lot of influence, but all football coaches do, and generally a whole lot more than the AD unless the coach is on the hot seat.
06-16-2025 05:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #29
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 05:27 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 02:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.

Are you saying that Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have less influence on policy at their schools than some anonymous paper pushers? SOME ADs wield a lot of influence, but all football coaches do, and generally a whole lot more than the AD unless the coach is on the hot seat.

It depends on the school. A lot of coaches have very little influence on matters that don't involve play on the field.
06-16-2025 05:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #30
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 05:59 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 05:27 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 02:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.

Are you saying that Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have less influence on policy at their schools than some anonymous paper pushers? SOME ADs wield a lot of influence, but all football coaches do, and generally a whole lot more than the AD unless the coach is on the hot seat.

It depends on the school. A lot of coaches have very little influence on matters that don't involve play on the field.

ADs hire, evaluate, and fire coaches. Fans can ignore them as ‘anonymous paper pushers’ when munching pretzels in front of the TV but on campus, and especially in the athletic departments they helm, ADs are anything but anonymous. They carry a great deal of responsibility. If you work for one you ignore that at your peril.

It’s also fair to say that the cherry-picked examples of Mr Smart and Mr Kiffin do not represent the typical job situation of the typical coach, even in the SEC.

Frank’s observation is why I say Mr Petitti’s first, best play is to approach the SEC ready to do some horse trading. The SEC is already doing a lot of that internally. The B1G may as well be a factor in the discussion and help the SEC resolve things if it can.
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2025 10:38 PM by Gitanole.)
06-16-2025 10:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #31
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition.
....

I agree 100%. It seems expansion could help the SEC resolve this if the money works out.

Both P2 leagues can go to 9 games. This balance smooths the way toward scheduling games between the two leagues. That can take quite a few committee ‘eye test’ issues off the table—and smooth resolution of the AQ matter as well, given each league’s chances to field at-large qualifiers.
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2025 10:53 PM by Gitanole.)
06-16-2025 10:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #32
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 05:27 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 02:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote:  The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do

Eh - I think a lot of people haven’t read the actual quotes.

The SEC *coaches* have pushed back on multiple AQs.

In contrast, the SEC *ADs* - the ones that want as much guaranteed revenue as possible each year to set their budgets - have generally been insisting up on multiple AQs, particularly if they decide to go to 9 conference games and a Big Ten-SEC scheduling alliance.

I think that’s a critical distinction that a lot of people are glossing over. As we have seen in a lot of college sports decisions, the coaches provide a lot of quotes (as they should as the public faces of their respective programs), but they are totally overrated (and often even non-factors) when it comes to influence over such decisions.

Are you saying that Kirby Smart and Lane Kiffin have less influence on policy at their schools than some anonymous paper pushers? SOME ADs wield a lot of influence, but all football coaches do, and generally a whole lot more than the AD unless the coach is on the hot seat.

I will highly disagree here. Maybe true God-like coaches such as the Nick Saban was at Alabama or Coach K was at Duke had influence over actual *policy*. However, that is exceedingly rare. I’m not talking about asking for facilities or NIL budgets, but actual long-term college sports *business* decisions such as conference realignment or TV contracts or the CFP itself.

Most college coaches hate adding more games, hate nationalized conference realignment, need a Goldilocks “not too hard and not too soft” schedule, and pretty much only care how a decision impacts their recruiting. That’s all fine because that’s in their rational self-interest for their own jobs, but schools also know that and, thus, don’t assign much weight to their opinions when it comes to long-term strategic decisions for the university. The fact that most college sports decisions for the past 20 years have largely gone against what the coaches want is empirical evidence that they don’t have much influence beyond the Saban/Coach K level.
06-17-2025 08:40 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stechs02 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 553
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 227
I Root For: Ohio State
Location: Akron, Ohio
Post: #33
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Flugar hinted at a growing rift between the Big Ten and the SEC. Are we buying that? And if it’s real — what’s actually at stake?

There’s definitely some smoke here, and it feels like more than media noise, although my glass half full self hopes it is nothing more than negotiation. If tensions are rising between the sport’s two most powerful conferences, the fallout could be massive across several fronts:

Big Ten–SEC scheduling agreement:
Dead in the water? There was legit momentum, but it feels like that’s completely stalled. Is this type of collaboration realistic anymore? I'm selling.

CFP structure post-2026:
Major uncertainty looms. The 5+7 format is locked through 2025, but the SEC is pushing hard for a more power-friendly model — fewer auto-bids, more emphasis on strength of schedule. The Big Ten doesn’t appear eager to follow that lead. Could we end up in a stalemate? Possibly. If the SEC demands a move to 5+11 or no auto-bids, I don’t see the Big Ten caving. My guess? We stay with the current structure.

Realignment:
If SOS becomes a bigger factor in CFP selection, don’t be shocked if the Big Ten makes a serious play for Florida State and Miami. Expanding into the South not only counters SEC influence — it strengthens the Big Ten’s own SOS profile. I’m not saying FSU prefers the Big Ten right now, but a shifting selection model might force a fresh look at the possibilities on the Big Ten side.

Governance model:
This might be the biggest domino of all. Can you build a unified structure for college football if one side feels blindsided or betrayed? A collaborative governance model only works if the top leagues trust each other — and that seems fragile right now.

The bigger question: Is this a simmering cold war between the SEC and Big Ten… or just offseason drama?
What say you?

Last point, I'd really like to hear from Petitti. He needs to be more vocal and a bigger public advocate for the Big Ten. I'm getting bad Kevin Warren flashbacks at a point in time where strong leadership is needed. +1 to Sankey in that department.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2025 09:16 AM by stechs02.)
06-17-2025 09:11 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,299
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #34
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 05:14 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:

Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win

Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams

Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)

Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents

These are measurable, on-field results—not projections or assumptions—and they give a more accurate picture of a team’s true strength. Additionally, they are transparent—everyone knows what they need to do to make the playoff.

I know this isn't perfect so don't beat me up too bad on the metrics / weightings. It was for example purposes only, not what is should be.

This all sounds like BCS 1.0 all over again. Cherry picking thresholds like Record vs. Top X, or “power” opponents, or “points” for certain wins… is the wrong direction.

There are many computer rankings out there that do an excellent job. Pick one (or a handful) that are simple and transparent. “Strength of Record” is the correct ‘type’ of ranking.

But I do agree with the main points:
1) Selection Criteria is currently the main pain point
2) Transparency and consistency are needed ASAP

There is no correct type of ranking, only different types. So why use any as the primary way to select participants? I favor using three things to select P4 teams: AQs, conference standings, and WCGs. For the other 69 teams, this isn't practical, but you can use WCGs to select two from this group. If Notre Dame isn't one of the four highest ranked teams by whatever method is used, they don't deserve a chance to play into the CFP.
06-17-2025 09:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Eggszecutor Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 358
Joined: Jun 2020
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Nebraska
Location:
Post: #35
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.
06-17-2025 12:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,308
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #36
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 09:42 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 05:14 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 01:55 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.

The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.

Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:

Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win

Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams

Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)

Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents

This all sounds like BCS 1.0 all over again. Cherry picking thresholds like Record vs. Top X, or “power” opponents, or “points” for certain wins… is the wrong direction.

There are many computer rankings out there that do an excellent job. Pick one (or a handful) that are simple and transparent. “Strength of Record” is the correct ‘type’ of ranking.

But I do agree with the main points:
1) Selection Criteria is currently the main pain point
2) Transparency and consistency are needed ASAP

There is no correct type of ranking, only different types. So why use any as the primary way to select participants? I favor using three things to select P4 teams: AQs, conference standings, and WCGs.

I’m talking about rankings in which a fifth SEC team is compared against a third ACC team. Conference standings cannot help with that.

I’ll make a stance that SOR is the correct type of ranking. In these bloated conferences, SOR is what the conferences use to break these 6-way ties anyway. Albeit the conferences ignore difficult non-conference opponents when doing so.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2025 02:49 PM by Crayton.)
06-17-2025 01:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #37
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2025 01:48 PM by The Beaver.)
06-17-2025 01:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #38
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.
06-17-2025 02:21 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #39
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.
The SEC schools had notably tougher schedules than the Big 10 schools even with only 8 conference games.
06-17-2025 02:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #40
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2025 03:03 PM by JRsec.)
06-17-2025 03:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.