Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
Author Message
stever20 Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #41
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 10:40 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

True. But a potential benefit is that a transparent algorithm would allow all parties to know what win/loss combos (even from far distant games) would allow them to advance. The NFL and most sports seed their playoffs in this way.

When Duke advanced to Charlotte, Hurricane and Yellow Jacket administrators did not pull a Bevacqua and take a flame thrower to ACC headquarters on social media… because the selection process was 100% transparent. If we used a transparent ranking algorithm for the CFP we’d get much the same effect, no matter if Alabama or Notre Dame or Miami was the odd team out.

The freak out in the early BCS days was because the rankings were forbidden from examining margin of victory and were not really vetted to conform to the SOR norm college football fans expect. You can’t really build an SOR without MOV. Start picking playoff teams by an ELO or RPI ranking and people will (and did) freak out at the computers. Each computer ranking shifted from 1/6th the BCS total to 1/18th by the time the BCS wrapped.

actually it was the opposite. Computers started out able to consider MOV but after one of the controversial years- I forget which one- they were required to take it out.
12-09-2025 10:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #42
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 10:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).

We've seen it for decades. They start it way too early and contradict themselves and ruin their credibility. The NCAA tourney only does one.

Now I think maybe 4 would be ok, but the 6 they are doing now do damage to the process.

Honestly, they can still do 6 rankings, but maybe for the latter 3 rankings weekly and the former 3 every other week with ESPN able to do a mock rankings during the weeks there aren't rankings released (so ESPN gets even more shows if they want).
12-09-2025 10:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,980
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #43
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 10:45 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 10:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).

We've seen it for decades. They start it way too early and contradict themselves and ruin their credibility. The NCAA tourney only does one.

Now I think maybe 4 would be ok, but the 6 they are doing now do damage to the process.

Honestly, they can still do 6 rankings, but maybe for the latter 3 rankings weekly and the former 3 every other week with ESPN able to do a mock rankings during the weeks there aren't rankings released (so ESPN gets even more shows if they want).

I think 2 look-ins would be enough.

Week 10 - look in 1
Week 13 - look in 2
Week 16 - final rankings

This would have been just about the smoothest final rankings release in history, if the Committee hadn't appeared to change their criteria at the last minute to accommodate the ACC. Nobody would have questioned eventually moving Miami ahead of ND, or not many anyway, but the small changes that were made along the way, and the one big concept of constantly keeping ND ahead of Miami, led to much angst and claims of bias. Certainly nobody would have complained about putting the SEC runner up (and regular season leader going into the CCG) into the CFP, but Alabama somehow got dragged into the Miami-ND discussion.
12-09-2025 11:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #44
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 10:43 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 10:40 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

True. But a potential benefit is that a transparent algorithm would allow all parties to know what win/loss combos (even from far distant games) would allow them to advance. The NFL and most sports seed their playoffs in this way.

When Duke advanced to Charlotte, Hurricane and Yellow Jacket administrators did not pull a Bevacqua and take a flame thrower to ACC headquarters on social media… because the selection process was 100% transparent. If we used a transparent ranking algorithm for the CFP we’d get much the same effect, no matter if Alabama or Notre Dame or Miami was the odd team out.

The freak out in the early BCS days was because the rankings were forbidden from examining margin of victory and were not really vetted to conform to the SOR norm college football fans expect. You can’t really build an SOR without MOV. Start picking playoff teams by an ELO or RPI ranking and people will (and did) freak out at the computers. Each computer ranking shifted from 1/6th the BCS total to 1/18th by the time the BCS wrapped.

actually it was the opposite. Computers started out able to consider MOV but after one of the controversial years- I forget which one- they were required to take it out.

If our schedules are going to be more uniform going forward (9 conference games, 1 P4 non-conf opponent, 2 G6/FCS games), what if we went the way of the NFL with Rankings and used record and uniform tiebreakers? It would be tough to compare P4 and G6 opponents so maybe the G6 need weighted if used for all teams. At the very least, have more uniform tiebreakers for conference standings and maybe consider NFL tiebreakers or more similar to the NFL.

https://www.nfl.com/standings/tie-breaking-procedures

I think it could look like this for conference standings and potentially overall rankings
1. Head to Head
2. Head to Head Sweep (if more than 2 Teams)
- Team selected if they beat all tied teams or eliminated if lost to all tied teams
3. Common Opponents
- NFL used 4 game minimum, but may not be needed for CFB
4. Common Opponent tiebreaker based on order of finish (used by CFB, not by NFL)
5. Strength of Victory (win % of teams beaten, used by NFL, not by CFB)
- maybe tiebreaker split in 2 by conference games and all games
6. Strength of Schedule (win % of teams played)
- maybe tiebreaker split in 2 by conference games and all games
7. Best Combined Rankings of Points For and Points Against (used by NFL)
- split up by conference and all games
- at this point, can use in place of #7 or add CFP Rankings, SportsSource Analytics, etc., after #7, used in CFB
8. Net Points (probably not needed, but an option, used in NFL)
- split up by conference and all games
9. Net TDs (same as #8)
10. Coin Toss

Worth noting Miami finishes above Duke for 2nd in ACC if SoV used, SEC order remains the same for their top 4.
12-10-2025 12:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #45
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .
12-11-2025 12:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #46
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.
12-11-2025 12:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #47
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.
12-11-2025 12:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #48
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  What does getting rid of the show do? lol

They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?
12-11-2025 12:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #49
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.
(This post was last modified: 12-11-2025 01:00 PM by Frank the Tank.)
12-11-2025 12:58 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #50
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 10:43 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 10:40 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

True. But a potential benefit is that a transparent algorithm would allow all parties to know what win/loss combos (even from far distant games) would allow them to advance. The NFL and most sports seed their playoffs in this way.

When Duke advanced to Charlotte, Hurricane and Yellow Jacket administrators did not pull a Bevacqua and take a flame thrower to ACC headquarters on social media… because the selection process was 100% transparent. If we used a transparent ranking algorithm for the CFP we’d get much the same effect, no matter if Alabama or Notre Dame or Miami was the odd team out.

The freak out in the early BCS days was because the rankings were forbidden from examining margin of victory and were not really vetted to conform to the SOR norm college football fans expect. You can’t really build an SOR without MOV. Start picking playoff teams by an ELO or RPI ranking and people will (and did) freak out at the computers. Each computer ranking shifted from 1/6th the BCS total to 1/18th by the time the BCS wrapped.

actually it was the opposite. Computers started out able to consider MOV but after one of the controversial years- I forget which one- they were required to take it out.

And a couple of the best systems refused to do that and dropped out of the BCS. Sagarin did a whole new system.
12-11-2025 01:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #51
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 11:19 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 10:45 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 10:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).

We've seen it for decades. They start it way too early and contradict themselves and ruin their credibility. The NCAA tourney only does one.

Now I think maybe 4 would be ok, but the 6 they are doing now do damage to the process.

Honestly, they can still do 6 rankings, but maybe for the latter 3 rankings weekly and the former 3 every other week with ESPN able to do a mock rankings during the weeks there aren't rankings released (so ESPN gets even more shows if they want).

I think 2 look-ins would be enough.

Week 10 - look in 1
Week 13 - look in 2
Week 16 - final rankings

This would have been just about the smoothest final rankings release in history, if the Committee hadn't appeared to change their criteria at the last minute to accommodate the ACC. Nobody would have questioned eventually moving Miami ahead of ND, or not many anyway, but the small changes that were made along the way, and the one big concept of constantly keeping ND ahead of Miami, led to much angst and claims of bias. Certainly nobody would have complained about putting the SEC runner up (and regular season leader going into the CCG) into the CFP, but Alabama somehow got dragged into the Miami-ND discussion.
The early ones are problems. They get fixed by their earlier valuations.
12-11-2025 01:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #52
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

It isn't more transparent. Its just more inconsistent. Garbage data (November 4th rankings) adds no value and just damages their credibility.
12-11-2025 01:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #53
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining
12-11-2025 01:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #54
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.
12-11-2025 01:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,980
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #55
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

Your admins/boosters/etc clearly feel like being in the same Division as ND and the P2 is in your school's best interest. Do you think they're wrong? If so, you guys could always drop back to FCS.
12-11-2025 01:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
whittx Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,908
Joined: Apr 2016
Reputation: 129
I Root For: FSU, Bport,Corn
Location:
Post: #56
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/st...bama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

We definitely don't need 6. At least cut it to 4.

They actually kind of need one run through to get the feel of what they are supposed to do.

3. One at the end of Oct. One before Rivalry Week, Sunday after CCG's.
12-11-2025 02:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #57
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 01:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

Your admins/boosters/etc clearly feel like being in the same Division as ND and the P2 is in your school's best interest. Do you think they're wrong? If so, you guys could always drop back to FCS.

It's what the P2 really want. Leave the ACC/B12/and the G6 and start their own league. You know that's what they want, they're just too scared to pull the trigger.
12-11-2025 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #58
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 01:45 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:26 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  It’s not rocket science! 2 options…

1. Copy the FCS playoff.

2. All conference champs (10) get an auto bid. The next 14 are plucked out of the top 24 by ranking .

you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.

That's exactly why they would leave.
12-11-2025 03:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #59
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 01:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

It isn't more transparent. Its just more inconsistent. Garbage data (November 4th rankings) adds no value and just damages their credibility.

I think their credibility will always be questioned either way. That is my skepticism about fewer rankings helping at all. Are college football fans going to truly be *less* crazy just because they see fewer rankings? Are they suddenly going to be more reasonable? Needless to say, I have my doubts there.
12-11-2025 03:44 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #60
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 03:41 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:45 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.

That's exactly why they would leave.

Right. The G5 would leave. Don't let the door hit you on the backside.
12-11-2025 03:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.