(12-09-2025 10:43 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-09-2025 10:40 PM)Crayton Wrote: (12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).
True. But a potential benefit is that a transparent algorithm would allow all parties to know what win/loss combos (even from far distant games) would allow them to advance. The NFL and most sports seed their playoffs in this way.
When Duke advanced to Charlotte, Hurricane and Yellow Jacket administrators did not pull a Bevacqua and take a flame thrower to ACC headquarters on social media… because the selection process was 100% transparent. If we used a transparent ranking algorithm for the CFP we’d get much the same effect, no matter if Alabama or Notre Dame or Miami was the odd team out.
The freak out in the early BCS days was because the rankings were forbidden from examining margin of victory and were not really vetted to conform to the SOR norm college football fans expect. You can’t really build an SOR without MOV. Start picking playoff teams by an ELO or RPI ranking and people will (and did) freak out at the computers. Each computer ranking shifted from 1/6th the BCS total to 1/18th by the time the BCS wrapped.
actually it was the opposite. Computers started out able to consider MOV but after one of the controversial years- I forget which one- they were required to take it out.
If our schedules are going to be more uniform going forward (9 conference games, 1 P4 non-conf opponent, 2 G6/FCS games), what if we went the way of the NFL with Rankings and used record and uniform tiebreakers? It would be tough to compare P4 and G6 opponents so maybe the G6 need weighted if used for all teams. At the very least, have more uniform tiebreakers for conference standings and maybe consider NFL tiebreakers or more similar to the NFL.
https://www.nfl.com/standings/tie-breaking-procedures
I think it could look like this for conference standings and potentially overall rankings
1. Head to Head
2. Head to Head Sweep (if more than 2 Teams)
- Team selected if they beat all tied teams or eliminated if lost to all tied teams
3. Common Opponents
- NFL used 4 game minimum, but may not be needed for CFB
4. Common Opponent tiebreaker based on order of finish (used by CFB, not by NFL)
5. Strength of Victory (win % of teams beaten, used by NFL, not by CFB)
- maybe tiebreaker split in 2 by conference games and all games
6. Strength of Schedule (win % of teams played)
- maybe tiebreaker split in 2 by conference games and all games
7. Best Combined Rankings of Points For and Points Against (used by NFL)
- split up by conference and all games
- at this point, can use in place of #7 or add CFP Rankings, SportsSource Analytics, etc., after #7, used in CFB
8. Net Points (probably not needed, but an option, used in NFL)
- split up by conference and all games
9. Net TDs (same as #8)
10. Coin Toss
Worth noting Miami finishes above Duke for 2nd in ACC if SoV used, SEC order remains the same for their top 4.