(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.
And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.
And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.
I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.
Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not as the overriding decisive thing as the CFP obviously did). Nothing has been more irksome to me than the blind shouting of "head to head!" by media commentators, failing to take into account how weak and wimpy that H2H result was. It was the weakest possible - at home, and by the slimmest of margins, and yes, three months ago to boot. I agree that recency bias is bad, but *some* recency bias is IMO warranted. It makes sense that since the playoffs are now, how a team is playing now should count a bit more than what they were three months ago.
All H2h are not equal, or at least shouldn't be considered equal. A win like Texas AM over Notre Dame on the road, even by a small margin, should carry much more weight than a win by a home team by a small margin. HFA is a real thing, statistically proven, and the loser didn't get a chance for a return game on their home field. Had the selection come down to ND vs TAMU, I would have had no problem with the H2H result being the decider. You win on the road, you truly proved you were better.
But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.
In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.