Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
Author Message
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #21
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
As the CFP committee debacle is the only system we’ve got, in that respect one could call it ‘the best’ we’ve got.

We can still imagine better ways of doing business, and build to that.

07-coffee3
(This post was last modified: 12-08-2025 09:49 PM by Gitanole.)
12-08-2025 09:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #22
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-08-2025 09:46 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  As the CFP committee debacle is the only system we’ve got, in that respect one could call it ‘the best’ we’ve got.

We can still imagine better ways of doing business, and build to that.

07-coffee3

This thread got me thinking, and tbh, we should play more games to help with bloated conferences playing a more even conference schedule, more non-conference P4 games to compare conferences (instead of assuming a conference is better) and play non-conference rivalries, and to provide the CFP committee with more data points with the 13th game + CCGs and potential WCGs for a 14th game for teams. The CFP would need to remain at 12-14 teams if this happen with the season beginning Week 0 and CCG Weekend on Army-Navy weekend. CFP schedule would remain the same while the format could be 5+X or multi-AQs.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 06:37 AM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
12-09-2025 06:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,982
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #23
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-08-2025 03:28 PM)FoUTASportscaster Wrote:  I'd suggest taking it to the bowls and the NCAA formally establishing its own postseason, similar to mane's basketball with the NIT and NCAA Tournament decades ago.

While you see bias and issues in the tournaments the NCAA sponsors (literally every other sport but FBS), the bowls care about money first and avoiding lawsuits second. Anyone who knows that system knew Alabama was in while BYU was not.

This idea is a nonstarter. The NCAA relinquished control of FBS bc we would leave the NCAA if they did not.
12-09-2025 07:30 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,982
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #24
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.
12-09-2025 07:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #25
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not as the overriding decisive thing as the CFP obviously did). Nothing has been more irksome to me than the blind shouting of "head to head!" by media commentators, failing to take into account how weak and wimpy that H2H result was. It was the weakest possible - at home, and by the slimmest of margins, and yes, three months ago to boot. I agree that recency bias is bad, but *some* recency bias is IMO warranted. It makes sense that since the playoffs are now, how a team is playing now should count a bit more than what they were three months ago.

All H2h are not equal, or at least shouldn't be considered equal. A win like Texas AM over Notre Dame on the road, even by a small margin, should carry much more weight than a win by a home team by a small margin. HFA is a real thing, statistically proven, and the loser didn't get a chance for a return game on their home field. Had the selection come down to ND vs TAMU, I would have had no problem with the H2H result being the decider. You win on the road, you truly proved you were better.

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 07:54 AM by quo vadis.)
12-09-2025 07:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,165
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1265
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #26
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.
12-09-2025 07:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #27
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:49 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.

I have no problem with ND living with the consequences of all 12 games they played. IMO the consequences for losing to Miami three months ago, at the buzzer, on their home field were simply blown way out of proper proportion by the CFP. Should have been one factor among many, not the decisive one. ND's advantages on all the major metrics should have been decisive.
12-09-2025 07:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,719
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #28
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
The unbalanced schedules and the tough OOCs being a complete zero sum game are what is creating the problem. You just need to add a round of games to remove the fluff, whether it is intra-conference play-ins or a 9-24. The regular season has already been irreparably harmed with 12-team expansion. It's best to go back to the BCS in this P2 world, after some additional realignment.
12-09-2025 07:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #29
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 08:41 AM by Frank the Tank.)
12-09-2025 08:39 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #30
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not as the overriding decisive thing as the CFP obviously did). Nothing has been more irksome to me than the blind shouting of "head to head!" by media commentators, failing to take into account how weak and wimpy that H2H result was. It was the weakest possible - at home, and by the slimmest of margins, and yes, three months ago to boot. I agree that recency bias is bad, but *some* recency bias is IMO warranted. It makes sense that since the playoffs are now, how a team is playing now should count a bit more than what they were three months ago.

All H2h are not equal, or at least shouldn't be considered equal. A win like Texas AM over Notre Dame on the road, even by a small margin, should carry much more weight than a win by a home team by a small margin. HFA is a real thing, statistically proven, and the loser didn't get a chance for a return game on their home field. Had the selection come down to ND vs TAMU, I would have had no problem with the H2H result being the decider. You win on the road, you truly proved you were better.

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

Maybe we should advance Alabama every round if they only lose by three!
12-09-2025 09:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #31
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:56 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:49 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.

I have no problem with ND living with the consequences of all 12 games they played. IMO the consequences for losing to Miami three months ago, at the buzzer, on their home field were simply blown way out of proper proportion by the CFP. Should have been one factor among many, not the decisive one. ND's advantages on all the major metrics should have been decisive.

You’re delusional. They look pretty even except that Miami has better wins. AND they won on the field.
12-09-2025 09:16 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
curtis0620 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,985
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 66
I Root For: Pitt
Location:
Post: #32
CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
Here is my CFP proposal:

32 teams
First Round: teams ranked 17-32 play
Second Round: 8 winners play 9-16 ranked teams
Third Round: 8 winners play 1-8 ranked teams
Quarterfinals: 8 winners
Semifinals: 4 winners
Finals: 2 winners

All 10 conference winners qualify and 22 at large.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
12-09-2025 09:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bluesox Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,546
Joined: Jan 2006
Reputation: 93
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #33
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
I think the big 10 and SEC should be more focused on creating value for their own conference playoffs for a conference championship rather than the national playoffs. Given how big the leagues are and how valuable and wanted games between members are, just create an 8 team, 3 round in conference playoffs to determine a conference title winner,

The sec/ big 10 8 team playoff format

1st round on campus, first week of December
Second round, second week of December in Atlanta and Indy
Third round, third week of December at the sugar bowl and Fiesta for a conference title

Thus, you have 2 big 10/sec schools emerge for the final round. I would let the other leagues create their own 8 team playoffs during the first 3 weeks of December so you end up with 3 teams for the final round. Seed the final 3 and give the higher seed a bye into the title game.

Rose Bowl Jan 1
Title game mid January
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 10:01 AM by bluesox.)
12-09-2025 09:57 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #34
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 09:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:56 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:49 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.

I have no problem with ND living with the consequences of all 12 games they played. IMO the consequences for losing to Miami three months ago, at the buzzer, on their home field were simply blown way out of proper proportion by the CFP. Should have been one factor among many, not the decisive one. ND's advantages on all the major metrics should have been decisive.

You’re delusional. They look pretty even except that Miami has better wins. AND they won on the field.

Miami won at the buzzer on their home field.

Notre Dame is ahead of Miami on every major metric I can find - SOR, SOS, FPI, KPI, SP+, Sagarin, Massey Composite ... everything.

And even the human writers and coaches agree as well.

Only the dense-headed, witless CFP.
12-09-2025 01:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,982
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #35
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 01:39 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 09:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:56 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:49 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.

I have no problem with ND living with the consequences of all 12 games they played. IMO the consequences for losing to Miami three months ago, at the buzzer, on their home field were simply blown way out of proper proportion by the CFP. Should have been one factor among many, not the decisive one. ND's advantages on all the major metrics should have been decisive.

You’re delusional. They look pretty even except that Miami has better wins. AND they won on the field.

Miami won at the buzzer on their home field.

Notre Dame is ahead of Miami on every major metric I can find - SOR, SOS, FPI, KPI, SP+, Sagarin, Massey Composite ... everything.

And even the human writers and coaches agree as well.

Only the dense-headed, witless CFP.

I can't wait to see you argue the other side of this h2h thing next year or the year after when it adversely impacts, or has the potential to adversely impact ND or the SEC. In fact, I'm bookmarking this post so I can link it back to you down the road.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 01:50 PM by bryanw1995.)
12-09-2025 01:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,257
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #36
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).

Thats exactly how I feel---for two main reasons.

One---The regular season conference races NEED to have a significant value to remain relevant and meaningful. You dont want three quarters of the college regular season football schedule to largely be meaningless exhibitions that simply function as a sifting mechanism for a committee. The games on the field have to matter---even if upsets yield a less desirable result. There will be plenty of "at large" selections to guarantee that every team broadly viewed as a legit championship contender will still be included in the playoff.

Two---There needs to be a way for a team to simply win its way to a CFP berth directly on the field of play. Unlike the committee room deliberations----these games are COMPLETELY transparent to the public and play out in real time on national TV before an audience of millions. At the start of each season, every team in FBS has to have a defined direct path to the playoff that is completely within their own control without obtaining the blessing of some Selection Committee. The very minimum needed for the CFP to NOT be an "invitational" is for the P4 champs and the top G5 champ to automatically advance to the playoff---regardless of whether the Committee (or anyone else) deems them worthy or not.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 02:08 PM by Attackcoog.)
12-09-2025 02:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #37
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 07:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:17 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.

I would have picked Miami over ND due to the h2h. Computers don’t factor that in.

Not all computers 03-wink.
12-09-2025 10:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #38
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 01:39 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 09:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:56 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:49 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(12-09-2025 07:41 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Well I think the computers were wise not to make an at-the-buzzer, at Miami H2H loss three months ago decisive (had no issue with it being considered as a factor, just not decisively as the CFP obviously did).

But, one of the strengths of the BCS rankings in-toto, not just the computers, was that they blended both. We got computers for their "objectivity", and also the votes of human pollsters, coaches and writers, who could factor in elements like H2H that computers do not.

In this case, the human pollsters, coaches and AP, both said Notre Dame was more deserving than Miami, btw. It was the CFP voters who were alone on this, among selectors.

If any school is going to reap the benefits of playing in an opening weekend "made for TV" match up, living with the consequences is just the price you pay for fame, notoriety, and money.

I have no problem with ND living with the consequences of all 12 games they played. IMO the consequences for losing to Miami three months ago, at the buzzer, on their home field were simply blown way out of proper proportion by the CFP. Should have been one factor among many, not the decisive one. ND's advantages on all the major metrics should have been decisive.

You’re delusional. They look pretty even except that Miami has better wins. AND they won on the field.

Miami won at the buzzer on their home field.

Notre Dame is ahead of Miami on every major metric I can find - SOR, SOS, FPI, KPI, SP+, Sagarin, Massey Composite ... everything.

And even the human writers and coaches agree as well.

Only the dense-headed, witless CFP.

You're going to hang your hat on an FPI that has Notre Dame 3rd (Miami not far back at 7) and Penn St. at 17? SOR is 13 and 14. What were you saying about close results? None of those have them separated by much.

And you haven't addressed the fact that Miami has much better wins. ANYBODY can lose a game. Winning is hard.
12-09-2025 10:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #39
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  The main thing that I care about is having each of the P4 champs (even with the wacky situation with the CFP) and the top G6 champ in the CFP. The way to reduce the impact of ranking systems is to at least have those objective conference champ AQs to minimize the number of subjective at-large spots.

I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

At the same time, I’m a bit perplexed by people wanting the CFP rankings to only come out once or twice per season. We complain about the transparency of the committee, but then want to have the committee to release rankings *less* frequently? That just seems to saying we’d rather be ignorant of how committee is thinking during the course of the season so that we won’t get as mad at them for switching spots like they did with ND and Miami. If they’re being inconsistent, then we should want to *know* it and *see* it to hold them accountable. For me, I want to see their logic play out over the course of several weeks with warts and all.

Also, the NCAA Tournament bracket reveal isn’t a good comparison. Everyone in the top 30 teams in college basketball know that they’re in the tourney and it’s a matter of seeding. The bubble teams that are being discussed the most are all very flawed teams.

That isn’t the case with the CFP. The bubble teams in the CFP are the equivalent of no-brainer 2 and 3 seeds in the NCAA Tournament. Teams really need to know where they stand going into the last month of the season because it’s much more about outright qualification for the playoff for the elite teams than it is a seeding exercise as is the case with elite teams for the NCAA Tournament.

Therefore, I strongly believe that the weekly rankings should continue during the last month of the season. More information is better and it’s totally inconsistent to want more transparency but then remove the most transparent way of evaluating the committee of them all where they need to defend their thinking multiple times (and not just at the very end of the season).

We've seen it for decades. They start it way too early and contradict themselves and ruin their credibility. The NCAA tourney only does one.

Now I think maybe 4 would be ok, but the 6 they are doing now do damage to the process.
12-09-2025 10:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #40
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-09-2025 08:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I think a LOT of people are having collective amnesia about how much the BCS rankings were hated and *specifically* the computer rankings component. Any time that a computer ranking caused an outcomes that didn’t align with the human poll portion, people freaked out. Computer rankings aren’t a panacea because they still require a human to program it based on their own subjective opinion on what’s important or not important. A computer ranking is the equivalent of basing playoff qualification on a single voter’s AP poll (and it might even be someone well-respected and trusted, but still a single voter nonetheless).

True. But a potential benefit is that a transparent algorithm would allow all parties to know what win/loss combos (even from far distant games) would allow them to advance. The NFL and most sports seed their playoffs in this way.

When Duke advanced to Charlotte, Hurricane and Yellow Jacket administrators did not pull a Bevacqua and take a flame thrower to ACC headquarters on social media… because the selection process was 100% transparent. If we used a transparent ranking algorithm for the CFP we’d get much the same effect, no matter if Alabama or Notre Dame or Miami was the odd team out.

The freak out in the early BCS days was because the rankings were forbidden from examining margin of victory and were not really vetted to conform to the SOR norm college football fans expect. You can’t really build an SOR without MOV. Start picking playoff teams by an ELO or RPI ranking and people will (and did) freak out at the computers. Each computer ranking shifted from 1/6th the BCS total to 1/18th by the time the BCS wrapped.
12-09-2025 10:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.