CSNbbs
CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel (/thread-1021656.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - bryanw1995 - 12-08-2025 01:10 PM

https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - HP-TBDPITL - 12-08-2025 02:28 PM

(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - FoUTASportscaster - 12-08-2025 03:28 PM

I'd suggest taking it to the bowls and the NCAA formally establishing its own postseason, similar to mane's basketball with the NIT and NCAA Tournament decades ago.

While you see bias and issues in the tournaments the NCAA sponsors (literally every other sport but FBS), the bowls care about money first and avoiding lawsuits second. Anyone who knows that system knew Alabama was in while BYU was not.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - WhoseHouse? - 12-08-2025 04:46 PM

(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

What does getting rid of the show do? lol


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - bullet - 12-08-2025 04:46 PM

(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

We definitely don't need 6. At least cut it to 4.

They actually kind of need one run through to get the feel of what they are supposed to do.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - bullet - 12-08-2025 04:52 PM

(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

What does getting rid of the show do? lol

They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - WhoseHouse? - 12-08-2025 05:05 PM

(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

What does getting rid of the show do? lol

They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - bullet - 12-08-2025 05:08 PM

(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 01:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/47241875/college-football-playoff-committee-decision-imperfect-notre-dame-alabama-miami

I'm a bit concerned b/c I usually disagree with Wetzel, but I think he hit the nail on the head on this one. All that angst from ND this year? From SEC corners last year? FSU the year before that? It's always going to be there. The IDEA of the Committee is fine, but perhaps they could make a couple of changes.

1. No more sitting Athletic Directors - clear conflicts of interest, even if they can't talk about their own Conference, they can try to strategically push agendas that will help to promote their own Conference or team
2. More former coaches - if they're going to dominate the room anyway, put a bunch more of them in there so that we get more viewpoints
3. No AP voters - just a personal pet peeve of mine, but AP voters are the ultimate "eye test" and "recency bias" people
4. Only release one final ranking - Wetzel discussed this idea in his article. We'd still have the AP poll, coaches poll and old BCS standings to give us a pretty good idea of where the Committee was leaning, but no more yoyo-ing with the feelings of an entire fan base.

Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

What does getting rid of the show do? lol

They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - WhoseHouse? - 12-08-2025 05:18 PM

(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:46 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 02:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  Herbstreit advocated for no more Tuesday night shows.

Former Athletic Directors and Coaches makes the most sense.

What does getting rid of the show do? lol

They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - ballantyneapp - 12-08-2025 05:23 PM

this will never happen because TV marketing, but we should just eliminate the AP and coaches poll and only have the CFP poll untelevised and released only after week 10.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - Garrettabc - 12-08-2025 05:32 PM

How bout some clear defined rules that automatically qualify a team? It will leave the guess work out.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - Fighting Muskie - 12-08-2025 05:57 PM

Bring back the BCS ranking system β€” no more political shenanigans


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - andybible1995 - 12-08-2025 05:58 PM

(12-08-2025 05:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Bring back the BCS ranking system β€” no more political shenanigans

Agreed. This is the only thing I would trust AI on.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - stever20 - 12-08-2025 05:59 PM

(12-08-2025 05:57 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  Bring back the BCS ranking system β€” no more political shenanigans

SEC would I think be totally fine with that. They'd still have the exact same 5 teams in.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - andybible1995 - 12-08-2025 06:06 PM

Keep the AP and Coaches Polls.

Don't reveal the CFP rankings until the day after the CCG's.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - The Beaver - 12-08-2025 06:13 PM

Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - stever20 - 12-08-2025 06:14 PM

(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - HP-TBDPITL - 12-08-2025 06:17 PM

(12-08-2025 06:06 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  Keep the AP and Coaches Polls.

Don't reveal the CFP rankings until the day after the CCG's.

Isnt that the way the NCAA tournament is picked? We dont really know although lots of projections are made.

You may get a massive watch situation if no one knows what they will do. The other thing is then you can rank AFTER the CCG's and take them into account, because there are no rankings before to factor in.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - The Beaver - 12-08-2025 06:17 PM

(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And without the drama, claims of bias and last minute flips that aren't related to on-field performance. The human comittees haven't disagreed with the computers very often but every time they have the computers have been right.


RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel - andybible1995 - 12-08-2025 06:18 PM

(12-08-2025 06:14 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 06:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Lol, BCS computers are far superior and it really doesn't take a genius to see it.

And the exact same 5 SEC teams would be in the playoffs as a result.

And the same 3 BIG teams would be in as well.