(08-28-2019 08:37 AM)Atlanta Wrote: (08-27-2019 11:05 AM)WiseMan Wrote: (08-27-2019 10:14 AM)tigernole79 Wrote: (08-27-2019 07:47 AM)Atlanta Wrote: Taylor should be a great back for us this season. Well over a 1000 yds. But I'm afraid the difference is that Henderson could score on virtually every play. Don't think PT can out run most DBs, so Memphis will have to find other ways to get in the end zone from close - this will require a power game in the red zone that we have not had in the past. If this is true, we'll score less points. Hope we have a more effective passing game to take up the slack.
That is the opposite of reality. He HAS been our power back that scored from in close. Not to mention that he has multiple runs/receptions over 40 yards.
I don't think you understand the talent level that will be playing for Memphis this season, but I will let them surprise you.
I don’t think Atlanta watched our football games last year because 7-8 times out of 10, Patrick was put in when we were inside the 10.
You guys obviously lack critical thinking capacity. DH could score on any play potentially, PT does not have that same ability. Yes he had some long runs but nothing like DH & PT was caught on several long runs unlike DH. But without the 'score on any play' ability that DH had, our drives will likely consist of more plays if we approach the offense like was done with DH in the game. More plays mean more chances for TOs & penalties, fewer points...... unless the passing game can take up the slack.
That is not what you said. There is a difference in critical thinking and then trying to fill gaps in logic that are unaccounted for, not to mention that you make several strong assumptions even in your statement.
1. IF we approach the offense like was done with DH in the game. Of course there will be adjustments, just like there was last season when DH wasn't in the game. We still scored more TD passing than DH had rushing... and even scored more TDs rushing than DH had.
2. Like I said, you are not accounting for any backups being able to break long plays, nor giving PT6 the same benefit of increasing his ability from last season the way the DH did from Soph to Junior season.
3. "More plays means more chances...." It doesn't guarantee, nor does it necessarily limit total scoring. Because...
4. You totally don't account for changes in defense. Much like the 2018 defense was better statistically than the 2017 defense, I predict even bigger changes in this years defense than last years. If the defense doesn't give up as many long drives, then the offense gets more scoring chances.
But to address the flaws in your original statement that I applied my critical thinking to... Red zone scoring and our "lack of a power game". That was PT6's specialty. And since we finished 27th in the nation overall in red zone, but were even higher in TDs scored, I don't think it was a weakness the way you expressed it.
Outrunning and not being able to be tackled by most DBs one on one were what separated DH and PT6. While few could catch DH (some did unlike your statement) just as few could stop PT6 unless they pulled him down from behind, which didn't happen that often on his break away runs.
Even in your first statement, you hedged with "if that is true". That defeats your logic by saying that if your initial supposition is correct, but they simply aren't given last years statistics.