(04-04-2014 10:55 AM)arkstfan Wrote: (04-03-2014 09:48 PM)Atbjmu09 Wrote: (04-03-2014 09:35 PM)jmu@uva Wrote: (04-03-2014 09:28 PM)All Dukes_All Day Wrote: If JMU does not have an outstanding invite to the Sun Belt, we're in big trouble.
It's all semantics. You don't get asked unless it's obvious you'll say yes. We won't say yes to the Sun Belt. So they won't formally invite us.
We should say no...always.
Football is just one small component of a university. I use to be all for moving up, but not if it is at the expense of all the other programs (athletic and academic) at JMU.
OK Sun Belt basketball isn't as good as CAA.
Sun Belt football is better
Sun Belt baseball is better
Sun Belt softball is better.
Volleyball is at worst a push.
As to "expense" to the academic programs... unless you plan to join the Ivy or Big 10 as a general rule athletic conferences do not maintain any sort of formal academic exchange. There are no roving bands of bully presidents who kick their way into your school forcing you to hire dumber faculty or lower your admission standards.
We serve different places. JMU serves a state where the rate of bachelor's degrees held by the population is well above the national average, we serve a place where it is well below. Virginia is below the national average in poverty, Arkansas is above. We serve a state with a slightly higher than average minority population, you serve a state with a below average minority population.
For this reason you can't compare schools between states based on SAT scores and draw meaningful conclusions about their academics. Some states have more competitive students than others. While there is some general correlation between admission rates and a strong academic reputation it isn't always the best interpretation of the numbers.
Mission is the best indicator, IMO of what type of school your dealing with. Also enrollment relative to the other schools in state is important.
For instance, you know that ULM isn't a Morril Act school for Louisiana. It doesn't have an engineering college or a school of letters so its can't be a specialty public like the Colorado School of Mines, Michigan Tech or William & Mary. The course offerings at ULM are of the most basic variety outside of a health sciences school which is only an average health sciences school.
Then you take a look of ULM's enrollment of 9,000 which is about half of ULL and less than LaTech up the road. Then look at the FCS schools in the state of Louisiana and you find numbers that are more comparable. ULM is a local college with 80% of the students from within a 50 mile radius.
LaTech functions as a specialty school in engineering within the state. It has a full scale engineering school and an average ACT of 24.5 which is very high for that state. Its debatable that the school is big enough for FBS but I can see where they would want to play at that level as a secondary option to LSU in the northern part of LA.
ULL is designed along the lines of North Texas, a large regional university for the state. Its not too different than WMU, CMU and EMU in mission. The support they get for football games justifies playing in FBS but if they didn't have the support they would be comfortable from an institutional standpoint in playing at the FCS level.
-Historic Comprehensive
-Land Grant
-Specialty Colleges
-Regional
-Local Colleges
What I'm listing above is your 5 primary types of public universities. All schools fit into one or another category.