(04-06-2014 01:00 PM)DoubleDDuke Wrote: You think we'd lose to Memphis 31-7? Lafeyette lost to Akron 35-30 and we couldn't even get a ball spotted to win the game with 22 less scholarships. They lost to Georgia State by 14. Georgia State, not Georgia Southern.
You think we'd lost 70-7 to anyone like LA-Monroe did or get the doors blown off like Arkansas State and South Alabama?
You think we'd lose to Navy 42-14?
You think we'd lose to Western Kentucky 38-7?
This is the Sunbelt conference.
Actually yes we think you'd lose a lot of games and some of them badly upon your transition. I'm sure you guys have great motivation and some pretty good players on your team. You might even have a good coach too. But what you don't have is depth. The teams you'll be playing have bigger and faster players than you do. And they have more of them too. The third and fourth quarters will be where you guys sag in your transition.
Yea, if you played Baylor last year - especially early, you'd get beat like ULM (or Wofford, or Buffalo - finished 6-2 in the MAC, or West Virginia did)
The team that lost to WKU 38-7 was playing in its first year as a full FBS member. That team finished 7 of 8 in the Sun Belt and demolished the 8th of 12th place team in the MWC.
Look at Old Dominion. They had to ask for the 'mercy rule' at a not that great UNC. That's what transition teams do. Even good ones that could probably beat JMU.
South Alabama was in its' first year of FBS full membership last year. We're happy with where we are at. We were in every game we played last year except at Navy. The result was disappointing, but it was one of 12 games. We disappointed in 2. That's probably the best a transitioning team can expect. We also beat a MAC team (badly) and a CUSA team on the road that finished with a winning record.
Arkansas State got caught by a rival that hadn't beat them in years. It happens. They also beat a MAC team with 10 wins (and went 7-1 in the conference) on a neutral field.
We still want you guys, but its not for what we expect you guys to produce in year one of transition. Or year two. Pretty much every SBC team comes from a FCS pedigree. We know what's likely to hit you guys upon transition.
The Sun Belt that you are likely turning down is light years ahead of the Sun Belt of a decade ago.