Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Newest Conference Rumor (2012-2020 Archive)
Author Message
brizzock Offline
Galactic Overlord
*

Posts: 1,641
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 19
I Root For: JMU
Location: Easton, PA
Post: #8521
Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 09:11 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  If Alger does not feel FBS is where JMU belongs, how about reconsidering our FCS affliation? JMU, W&M, TU and UD to the Patriot League? Others have suggested this tongue and cheek but honestly, with the additon of the four CAA schools it would be a stronger FCS league with all sports. It also has high academic standards.

I have been to Lehigh and it is a very nice stadium. Definitely better than most of the CAA stadiums. How about the facilities with the rest of the league?

If Alger is so concerned about academics, re-aligning with the Patriot league would fit that vision.

Lafayette's stadium and field house were built in the past 5 years--very nice as well.

That being said, JMU does not fit whatsoever with at least some of the small schools associated with the Patriot League. Can't see JMU ever fitting in there.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
03-30-2014 09:35 AM
Find all posts by this user
JMUNation Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,319
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8522
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
Isn't the Patriot League considered Ivy like? Why not be a large Ivy? If academics are the driving force in Alger's university vision, then why not? I keep hearing that Alger does not like the academics of the Sun Belt. CUSA isn't much better. If the MAC is not an option, then shouldn't he be seeking the best FCS affiliation there is that is inline with JMU's academic mission?

CAA football is a mix of schools from various conferences. While it has had good football success, the schools affiliated with the league have little to no commitment to one another. The Patriot should ask Georgetown to join for all sports or find another home (we know the answer here). It should then accept the CAA four as all sports members (maybe Elon too). G'town could join the CAA as an affiliate football only member along with the other affiliate football only members. It would be a great fit for them.
03-30-2014 09:49 AM
Find all posts by this user
Atbjmu09 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 82
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 6
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8523
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Areso said. “We think we’ll be a cohesive stable group of 12. That doesn’t rule out us thinking about expanding down the road if the right institution made sense, if there was good, academic, athletic and cultural fit.
03-30-2014 10:17 AM
Find all posts by this user
DoubleDDuke Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,616
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 12
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #8524
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
Well, we have all three of those and nobody wants us.
03-30-2014 11:11 AM
Find all posts by this user
s2dsayer Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,492
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 39
I Root For: Duuuuukes
Location: Jersey, yo
Post: #8525
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).
03-30-2014 11:17 AM
Find all posts by this user
ODUalum78 Offline
Overseer of the Unwashed Masses
*

Posts: 9,874
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 167
I Root For: ODU
Location: Chesterfield, Va

Lion's Den Poster of the Year
Post: #8526
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
Why would you want to join the Patriot? You would be slightly restricted as per scholarships, and not allowed redshirts.
In the Patriot you would NOT be playing at the highest level of FCS football.

As has been pointed out in a number of forums, the CAA is very stout academically now; indeed by admissions metrics, very close to the ACC (better top to bottom now that Louisville is in play), and better (admissions wise) than the B1G.
With the recent changes, the CAA and the Patriot are extremely close, if not almost identical now.

The only way JMU could noticeably improve it's academic conference affiliation now is to join the Ivy.

I cannot place myself in your shoes, but this obsession with academics and athletic conferences is curious.
National programs like Vanderbilt, Stanford, Rice, and even Tulane don't seem to be concerned, and yet seem to be doing ok.....
(This post was last modified: 03-30-2014 02:33 PM by ODUalum78.)
03-30-2014 11:53 AM
Find all posts by this user
JMU1985 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 628
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 23
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8527
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).

I just did a quick look at some data and it does look like academic fit is important to conferences. ACC for example, they have high standards and usually on the top 10% of the high school class is admitted across all schools. I doubt that the ACC would take a great football program with a crapping academic standing over one with both. I don't think the ACC ever thought of throwing out Wake Forest and Duke when their football programs struggled for years in favor an up and coming team in a good market like FIU (Miami). I think there is merit in academic fit.
03-30-2014 12:09 PM
Find all posts by this user
s2dsayer Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,492
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 39
I Root For: Duuuuukes
Location: Jersey, yo
Post: #8528
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 12:09 PM)JMU1985 Wrote:  I just did a quick look at some data and it does look like academic fit is important to conferences. ACC for example, they have high standards and usually on the top 10% of the high school class is admitted across all schools. I doubt that the ACC would take a great football program with a crapping academic standing over one with both. I don't think the ACC ever thought of throwing out Wake Forest and Duke when their football programs struggled for years in favor an up and coming team in a good market like FIU (Miami). I think there is merit in academic fit.

I would agree that with the ACC academics used to be an important factor. But did academics have anything to do with the decision to add Louisville? Or FSU or Miami or VT for that matter? These were football based decisions (with Louisville's MBB as a bonus). And I would think for a conference like AAC, academics is even less of a factor. All that truly matters anymore is a school's ability to generate revenue for the conference.
03-30-2014 12:30 PM
Find all posts by this user
ODUalum78 Offline
Overseer of the Unwashed Masses
*

Posts: 9,874
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 167
I Root For: ODU
Location: Chesterfield, Va

Lion's Den Poster of the Year
Post: #8529
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 12:09 PM)JMU1985 Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).

I just did a quick look at some data and it does look like academic fit is important to conferences. ACC for example, they have high standards and usually on the top 10% of the high school class is admitted across all schools. I doubt that the ACC would take a great football program with a crapping academic standing over one with both. I don't think the ACC ever thought of throwing out Wake Forest and Duke when their football programs struggled for years in favor an up and coming team in a good market like FIU (Miami). I think there is merit in academic fit.
But it did; Louisville. (relatively speaking)
And you aren't going to the ACC unless you go FBS somewhere else first.
03-30-2014 12:31 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cyniclone Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,673
Joined: Nov 2012
Reputation: 882
I Root For: ODU
Location:
Post: #8530
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).

Zactly. It's like how the NCAA always calls them "student-athletes" when they know that 99.999 percent of those at the game or watching on TV could not give one whit of a damn about their academic standing. But it's bad optics if you don't act as though academics is the driving force behind everything you do, even if in this case it's clearly not.

I never understood the "academic fit" issue when it comes to athletics anyway. If you're joining the Ivy, or even the Patriot, that's a little different because they have an association that goes deeper than sports. But an institution should associate with similarly aligned institutions in their specific fields, not necessarily how they compare as a whole.

Take Vermont Law School. It's nothing special, a third-tier private school in the middle of nowhere. If you were in a position of power at a higher-tiered law school, a William & Mary or Washington & Lee, you may not considering associating with them because their academics as a whole rate lower than yours. But if you have an environmental law program and you take that same attitude, you're a damned fool, because VLS's environmental law program is consistently ranked among the best in the country -- more often than not THE best. Breaking bread with them on environmental law studies doesn't mean you're aligning with them on everything from accounting programs to men's basketball, it means you consider them a peer in this very specific setting.

The Sun Belt may not have the greatest classroom reputation, or CUSA for that matter, but you're not entering into academic agreements with all of their schools just because your football team plays them every season. If you can say "our sports align with Appalachian State's" then the rest doesn't matter -- at least as far as atheltic affiliation goes.

That's why I also never got the anger over even talking about Liberty at the Sun Belt boards -- you're not going to Sunday meeting with them or discussing how Ken Ham should be the Secretary of Education, you're sending your sports teams to play their sports teams once or twice a season.

But if you're a university president and you don't maintain the fiction that academics is the first and foremost issue in purusing conference affiliation, you look bad in the eyes of those at the school who have a passing or nil interest in sports. In theory, sure. In practice, it's pointless. What's next, choosing a food service provider based on the servers' median SAT scores?
03-30-2014 12:53 PM
Find all posts by this user
JMU1985 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 628
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 23
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8531
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 12:30 PM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 12:09 PM)JMU1985 Wrote:  I just did a quick look at some data and it does look like academic fit is important to conferences. ACC for example, they have high standards and usually on the top 10% of the high school class is admitted across all schools. I doubt that the ACC would take a great football program with a crapping academic standing over one with both. I don't think the ACC ever thought of throwing out Wake Forest and Duke when their football programs struggled for years in favor an up and coming team in a good market like FIU (Miami). I think there is merit in academic fit.

I would agree that with the ACC academics used to be an important factor. But did academics have anything to do with the decision to add Louisville? Or FSU or Miami or VT for that matter? These were football based decisions (with Louisville's MBB as a bonus). And I would think for a conference like AAC, academics is even less of a factor. All that truly matters anymore is a school's ability to generate revenue for the conference.

Louisville is definitely an academic outlier. So, your right on that one. I guess I still don't think of them as ACC yet. I see that their average SAT (math/verbal) is around 1100. U of Miami is actually 1325 and is listed as Very Difficult for entering freshman. FSU is SAT is 1200 or 600 math and verbal and moderately difficult for entering Freshman. Who knows? The "calculus" for these decisions seems non repeatable doesn't it. Each situation is just a little different. Maybe there are some state schools that simply favor in state students in a large way and they are willing to lower the SAT and Grade (numbers) to educate the HS students who seek higher education in their state.
03-30-2014 12:54 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cyniclone Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,673
Joined: Nov 2012
Reputation: 882
I Root For: ODU
Location:
Post: #8532
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 12:09 PM)JMU1985 Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).

I just did a quick look at some data and it does look like academic fit is important to conferences. ACC for example, they have high standards and usually on the top 10% of the high school class is admitted across all schools. I doubt that the ACC would take a great football program with a crapping academic standing over one with both. I don't think the ACC ever thought of throwing out Wake Forest and Duke when their football programs struggled for years in favor an up and coming team in a good market like FIU (Miami). I think there is merit in academic fit.

Well, they already have Miami, so why they'd double down there with a program that's many years away from competing at that level is anyone's guess. Plus the core of the ACC was grafted generations ago; they're not going to kick anyone out for nonperformance in the main sports even over decades because there's a ton on institutional relationships (it's why people fantasizing about, say, kicking Washington State out of the Pac 12 are completely out to lunch, because they only get what they see on the field or court).

The only major conference that uses an academic metric consistently to determine future members is the Big Ten, and that's because of the AAU thing. And if the right school were available, they'd probably work around that.
03-30-2014 01:00 PM
Find all posts by this user
JMUNation Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,319
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8533
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
'78:

Where in my post did I say I wanted the Patriot League? I do not.

I am speaking from perspective. Mr. Alger is on record to say that the members of the Sun Belt have academics that are not on par with JMU. I have not heard him say that he feels JMU should seek FBS membership.

If Mr. Alger's football vision is FCS, then there is no need to discuss FBS football. That is the whole point of my post. I do not know Mr. Alger's vision for JMU football. If academics are so important, the Patriot is a better all sports option than the CAA who does not offer all sports. There are excellent football and basketball programs in that conference.

I am not sure what you are referencing about scholarships. My understanding is the conference voted to fully fund at the FCS level of 63 scholarships.
03-30-2014 01:04 PM
Find all posts by this user
ODUalum78 Offline
Overseer of the Unwashed Masses
*

Posts: 9,874
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 167
I Root For: ODU
Location: Chesterfield, Va

Lion's Den Poster of the Year
Post: #8534
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 01:04 PM)JMUNation Wrote:  '78:

Where in my post did I say I wanted the Patriot League? I do not.

I am speaking from perspective. Mr. Alger is on record to say that the members of the Sun Belt have academics that are not on par with JMU. I have not heard him say that he feels JMU should seek FBS membership.

If Mr. Alger's football vision is FCS, then there is no need to discuss FBS football. That is the whole point of my post. I do not know Mr. Alger's vision for JMU football. If academics are so important, the Patriot is a better all sports option than the CAA who does not offer all sports. There are excellent football and basketball programs in that conference.

I am not sure what you are referencing about scholarships. My understanding is the conference voted to fully fund at the FCS level of 63 scholarships.
Apologies, I was not directing the Patriot League comment to you, but to some here who have proposed that move.

My understanding is that the Patriot limits it's scholarships to 60 for football vs the 63 allowed by FCS standards.
I think that the "no redshirt" rule of the PL would have even more of a negative competitive impact.
(This post was last modified: 03-30-2014 02:33 PM by ODUalum78.)
03-30-2014 01:17 PM
Find all posts by this user
JMUDuke25 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,391
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 56
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8535
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 01:17 PM)ODUalum78 Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 01:04 PM)JMUNation Wrote:  '78:

Where in my post did I say I wanted the Patriot League? I do not.

I am speaking from perspective. Mr. Alger is on record to say that the members of the Sun Belt have academics that are not on par with JMU. I have not heard him say that he feels JMU should seek FBS membership.

If Mr. Alger's football vision is FCS, then there is no need to discuss FBS football. That is the whole point of my post. I do not know Mr. Alger's vision for JMU football. If academics are so important, the Patriot is a better all sports option than the CAA who does not offer all sports. There are excellent football and basketball programs in that conference.

I am not sure what you are referencing about scholarships. My understanding is the conference voted to fully fund at the FCS level of 63 scholarships.
Apologies, I was not directing the Patriot League comment to you, but to some here who have proposed that move.

My understanding is that the Patriot limits it's scholarship to 60 for football vs the 63 allowed by FCS standards.
I think that the "no redshirt" rule of the PL would have even more of a negative competitive impact.
You mean one uva fan, right?
03-30-2014 01:29 PM
Find all posts by this user
DBJMU2006 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,829
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 8
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8536
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
So is Bourne headed to Texas for the Final Four?
03-31-2014 08:37 AM
Find all posts by this user
HolyCityDuke Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,735
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 21
I Root For: Duke Doge
Location: The Belt of Suns
Post: #8537
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-31-2014 08:37 AM)DBJMU2006 Wrote:  So is Bourne headed to Texas for the Final Four?

He'll monitor it from his home in Harrisonburg.
03-31-2014 08:45 AM
Find all posts by this user
JMUDukeDawg Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,491
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 21
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #8538
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-31-2014 08:45 AM)HolyCityDuke Wrote:  
(03-31-2014 08:37 AM)DBJMU2006 Wrote:  So is Bourne headed to Texas for the Final Four?

He'll monitor it from his home in Harrisonburg.

I heard he was going to Ham's.
03-31-2014 08:51 AM
Find all posts by this user
Crump1 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,747
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 107
I Root For: stAte
Location:
Post: #8539
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-30-2014 12:53 PM)Cyniclone Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote:  
(03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote:  When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.

Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).

Zactly. It's like how the NCAA always calls them "student-athletes" when they know that 99.999 percent of those at the game or watching on TV could not give one whit of a damn about their academic standing. But it's bad optics if you don't act as though academics is the driving force behind everything you do, even if in this case it's clearly not.

I never understood the "academic fit" issue when it comes to athletics anyway. If you're joining the Ivy, or even the Patriot, that's a little different because they have an association that goes deeper than sports. But an institution should associate with similarly aligned institutions in their specific fields, not necessarily how they compare as a whole.

Take Vermont Law School. It's nothing special, a third-tier private school in the middle of nowhere. If you were in a position of power at a higher-tiered law school, a William & Mary or Washington & Lee, you may not considering associating with them because their academics as a whole rate lower than yours. But if you have an environmental law program and you take that same attitude, you're a damned fool, because VLS's environmental law program is consistently ranked among the best in the country -- more often than not THE best. Breaking bread with them on environmental law studies doesn't mean you're aligning with them on everything from accounting programs to men's basketball, it means you consider them a peer in this very specific setting.

The Sun Belt may not have the greatest classroom reputation, or CUSA for that matter, but you're not entering into academic agreements with all of their schools just because your football team plays them every season. If you can say "our sports align with Appalachian State's" then the rest doesn't matter -- at least as far as atheltic affiliation goes.

That's why I also never got the anger over even talking about Liberty at the Sun Belt boards -- you're not going to Sunday meeting with them or discussing how Ken Ham should be the Secretary of Education, you're sending your sports teams to play their sports teams once or twice a season.

But if you're a university president and you don't maintain the fiction that academics is the first and foremost issue in purusing conference affiliation, you look bad in the eyes of those at the school who have a passing or nil interest in sports. In theory, sure. In practice, it's pointless. What's next, choosing a food service provider based on the servers' median SAT scores?
04-cheers Agree completely with this post. Very good.
03-31-2014 09:46 AM
Find all posts by this user
Purplehazed Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,829
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 211
I Root For: James Madison Dukes
Location: Virginia
Post: #8540
RE: Newest Conference Rumor
(03-31-2014 08:45 AM)HolyCityDuke Wrote:  
(03-31-2014 08:37 AM)DBJMU2006 Wrote:  So is Bourne headed to Texas for the Final Four?

He'll monitor it from his home in Harrisonburg.

If he goes to the final four I'll bet dollars to doughnuts he is with his buddy Tom Yeager. There are people on this board that have been talking about Bourne and the Final 4 for months...good question, is he even going so he can enter the secret AD room.
03-31-2014 11:21 AM
Find all posts by this user




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.