(03-30-2014 11:17 AM)s2dsayer Wrote: (03-30-2014 10:17 AM)Atbjmu09 Wrote: When discussing expansion and UMASS, Mike Aresco from the AAC said they look at the following variables in this order: academics, cultural fit, and athletics. So as much people on here want to say that academics don't matter with conference affiliation, they do. Sure, the first two can be overlooked if the athletic side is that strong such as the case with Louisville joining the ACC.
Not buying that one for a second. This is what he's supposed to say. The real order is probably 1) Market size (or marketability), 2) Athletics, 3) see 1) and 2).
Zactly. It's like how the NCAA always calls them "student-athletes" when they know that 99.999 percent of those at the game or watching on TV could not give one whit of a damn about their academic standing. But it's bad optics if you don't act as though academics is the driving force behind everything you do, even if in this case it's clearly not.
I never understood the "academic fit" issue when it comes to athletics anyway. If you're joining the Ivy, or even the Patriot, that's a little different because they have an association that goes deeper than sports. But an institution should associate with similarly aligned institutions in their specific fields, not necessarily how they compare as a whole.
Take Vermont Law School. It's nothing special, a third-tier private school in the middle of nowhere. If you were in a position of power at a higher-tiered law school, a William & Mary or Washington & Lee, you may not considering associating with them because their academics as a whole rate lower than yours. But if you have an environmental law program and you take that same attitude, you're a damned fool, because VLS's environmental law program is consistently ranked among the best in the country -- more often than not THE best. Breaking bread with them on environmental law studies doesn't mean you're aligning with them on everything from accounting programs to men's basketball, it means you consider them a peer in this very specific setting.
The Sun Belt may not have the greatest classroom reputation, or CUSA for that matter, but you're not entering into academic agreements with all of their schools just because your football team plays them every season. If you can say "our sports align with Appalachian State's" then the rest doesn't matter -- at least as far as atheltic affiliation goes.
That's why I also never got the anger over even talking about Liberty at the Sun Belt boards -- you're not going to Sunday meeting with them or discussing how Ken Ham should be the Secretary of Education, you're sending your sports teams to play their sports teams once or twice a season.
But if you're a university president and you don't maintain the fiction that academics is the first and foremost issue in purusing conference affiliation, you look bad in the eyes of those at the school who have a passing or nil interest in sports. In theory, sure. In practice, it's pointless. What's next, choosing a food service provider based on the servers' median SAT scores?