(12-11-2025 05:38 PM)ken d Wrote: (12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote: (12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote: By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.
Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.
Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.
Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?
I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.
Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.
I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.
I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.
This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.
Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.
Making things more opaque only makes things worse.
First of all, I don't believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking. They may want to know, but they don't need to know.
What we would have guessed from the AP polls was that Miami, Notre Dame, BYU, and Alabama were the bubble teams for the last spot in the CFP, in some order that the CFP is not bound by. As it turns out, that was indeed true. We also knew that neither Notre Dame nor Miami was playing another game, but Alabama and BYU were.
If the committee had not released its penultimate ranking, which showed Alabama at #9, ND at #10, BYU #11 and Miami #12, we probably wouldn't have been greatly surprised by the final CFP ranking. After all, the committee isn't bound to follow the AP (or we wouldn't need them in the first place).
But they did release those Week 14 rankings. Nothing happened to either Miami or Notre Dame that should have changed the committee's judgement about where they should be ranked relative to one another since neither of them played in Week 15. The only reason for the controversy was the self-inflicted wound caused by the Week 14 rankings.
Let's face it. Once again, the committee shot itself in the foot unnecessarily.
When the penultimate rankings were released, some people - wiser than me as it turned out - immediately said this was ominous for Notre Dame, that the CFP was setting ND up to get put next to Miami and bounced based on H2H.
I disagreed, I thought that what the CFP was really doing was protecting Alabama, in case they lost their CCG. Because losers of CCG typically drop a spot or two, and Alabama at #10 was in a position where if they got beat bad they might drop out, and for political reasons (SEC power), that was not acceptable. I didn't see any danger that Miami, with BYU sandwiched between us, could be brought next door.
Retrospectively of course, I was wrong. It was in fact about a Miami/ND maneuver, not about Alabama at all, because as it turned out, Alabama got blow out in their CCG, the worst possible outcome, and they didn't move at all. So they would have been safe at #10 as well as #9.
So IMO what triggered the Alabama/ND 9/10 switch was when the November 30th games were played, and Duke became the mind-boggling participant in the ACC title game. That set up a scenario where the ACC could be left entirely out of the playoffs, which for whatever reason, the CFP found politically untenable (I have no idea why, as who cares if the ACC is pissed, but that seems clear to me now). Of course as I said, others recognized this all along.
So flipping Alabama and ND made it possible for the CFP to make one final flip, moving BYU behind Miami (or ahead of both of us, should they win the B12 title game), and thus putting Miami next to ND, giving the ACC a backstop should Duke win the title. Duke won the title, and the CFP triggered their backup to save the ACC.
So yeah, those who say had UVA won, Miami would not have gotten in, I think are correct. Had UVA beaten Duke, BYU stays ahead of Miami, and ND gets in.
Long story long - if the CFP felt they *had* to get an ACC team in, then they really didn't shoot themselves in the foot. They made an unjustifiable, awkward move, because they felt getting an ACC team in was worth the flak that would come with it. I mean, not many really thought that Duke at 7-5 would end up in the ACC CCG. That was thrust on them on November 30, so they didn't have time to react to it before in earlier polls.
Just MO.