Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
Author Message
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #61
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 03:51 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:41 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:45 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.

That's exactly why they would leave.

Right. The G5 would leave. Don't let the door hit you on the backside.

Do you not know how to read?
12-11-2025 03:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,980
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #62
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 03:09 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:34 PM)stever20 Wrote:  you want that go to FCS. It's not happening. FAR greater chance we get straight top 12 or 16 or 24 and no auto bids than that trash. We're never seeing all champions make the FBS playoffs. NEVER.

Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

Your admins/boosters/etc clearly feel like being in the same Division as ND and the P2 is in your school's best interest. Do you think they're wrong? If so, you guys could always drop back to FCS.

It's what the P2 really want. Leave the ACC/B12/and the G6 and start their own league. You know that's what they want, they're just too scared to pull the trigger.

I actually don't think that's what most of the decision makers want. I know I don't want it. Most of the people in Athletic/Conference administration worked at smaller schools or attended smaller schools in past years. There's a huge advantage for FBS to keep football enthusiasm high in every nook and cranny in the country, and even though Ohio isn't a threat to OSU, they can still claim that they're in the same "League" or "Division". Let's face it, there's a severe stigma associated with playing an FCS school that just isn't there if that school is instead in the SBC or CUSA. A lot of schools have rivals that would be splintered. To name a few:

ND-Navy
Colorado- Colorado St
Washington-Washington St (maybe?)
Oregon-Oregon St (maybe?)

The issue is not having lots of smaller schools in the top division per se, it's the incessant comments about sharing the wealth/opportunity equally that are really a sign that many believe that everyone in FBS is the same, or close to it. Like it or not, nobody in the g5 is the equivalent of an avg M2 school, and only a couple schools currently in the g5 have any hope of reaching such a lofty perch in the next few decades. But even then, the comments about sharing access and wealth aren't aimed at Texas Tech or Wake Forest, they're aimed at Texas and Michigan. Only 25 schools got more than 20m eyeballs for the entire season in 2025. Only 15 of those got over 30m eyeballs. Only 8 got over 40m.

So, even looking at the P4, if you want to discuss who brings value and who doesn't, only somewhere between 8 and 25 schools really moved the needle all that much in the regular season this year. I'd lean closer to the 25 number just b/c Indiana only had 22.6m in the regular season but then pulled out an astonishing 18.3m in the B1G CCG, so they deserve full credit ++, but that still leaves out a majority of the P4 and all of everyone else (counting ND as part of the P4 ofc). I don't know what the highest total viewership was for a g5 program, but I'd guess it's 10m or less.

Looked at in this light, not only is the g5 unnecessary, but much of the P4 is, too. Does that mean we want to go to an 8-25 school league? No, of course not. But we also don't want Alabama St pretending that they're Alabama and making unreasonable demands for playoff access or financial windfalls. I don't think that's an unreasonable objective.
12-11-2025 04:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #63
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 04:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:09 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:43 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  Yeah, you'll need to expand the CFP to at least 76 teams just to get the P4 to consider including all 10 conferences if that's any indication.

Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

Your admins/boosters/etc clearly feel like being in the same Division as ND and the P2 is in your school's best interest. Do you think they're wrong? If so, you guys could always drop back to FCS.

It's what the P2 really want. Leave the ACC/B12/and the G6 and start their own league. You know that's what they want, they're just too scared to pull the trigger.

I actually don't think that's what most of the decision makers want. I know I don't want it. Most of the people in Athletic/Conference administration worked at smaller schools or attended smaller schools in past years. There's a huge advantage for FBS to keep football enthusiasm high in every nook and cranny in the country, and even though Ohio isn't a threat to OSU, they can still claim that they're in the same "League" or "Division". Let's face it, there's a severe stigma associated with playing an FCS school that just isn't there if that school is instead in the SBC or CUSA. A lot of schools have rivals that would be splintered. To name a few:

ND-Navy
Colorado- Colorado St
Washington-Washington St (maybe?)
Oregon-Oregon St (maybe?)

The issue is not having lots of smaller schools in the top division per se, it's the incessant comments about sharing the wealth/opportunity equally that are really a sign that many believe that everyone in FBS is the same, or close to it. Like it or not, nobody in the g5 is the equivalent of an avg M2 school, and only a couple schools currently in the g5 have any hope of reaching such a lofty perch in the next few decades. But even then, the comments about sharing access and wealth aren't aimed at Texas Tech or Wake Forest, they're aimed at Texas and Michigan. Only 25 schools got more than 20m eyeballs for the entire season in 2025. Only 15 of those got over 30m eyeballs. Only 8 got over 40m.

So, even looking at the P4, if you want to discuss who brings value and who doesn't, only somewhere between 8 and 25 schools really moved the needle all that much in the regular season this year. I'd lean closer to the 25 number just b/c Indiana only had 22.6m in the regular season but then pulled out an astonishing 18.3m in the B1G CCG, so they deserve full credit ++, but that still leaves out a majority of the P4 and all of everyone else (counting ND as part of the P4 ofc). I don't know what the highest total viewership was for a g5 program, but I'd guess it's 10m or less.

Looked at in this light, not only is the g5 unnecessary, but much of the P4 is, too. Does that mean we want to go to an 8-25 school league? No, of course not. But we also don't want Alabama St pretending that they're Alabama and making unreasonable demands for playoff access or financial windfalls. I don't think that's an unreasonable objective.

I agree.

I've always said if the G5 didn't exist the P5 would have to invent them. Michigan and Ohio State can't play every week, heck Michigan and Rutgers can't, and if the former did, we'd all soon get bored with it and nobody would go 11-1 anymore, which fans love.

The G5 is a big pile of 65 schools that are willing to run their athletic departments at massive operational deficits, deficits in the tens of millions each year, for the privilege of claiming to be in the "same league" as you say, as Alabama, USC, Notre Dame etc.

And they cost the P2 almost nothing. They get a paltry CFP payout, and the A4 collectively went 85-12 against them this season.
12-11-2025 05:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,980
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #64
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 03:44 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

It isn't more transparent. Its just more inconsistent. Garbage data (November 4th rankings) adds no value and just damages their credibility.

I think their credibility will always be questioned either way. That is my skepticism about fewer rankings helping at all. Are college football fans going to truly be *less* crazy just because they see fewer rankings? Are they suddenly going to be more reasonable? Needless to say, I have my doubts there.

You're right on that one, but the specific circumstances of this season would have been avoided if there had only been 2 instead of 6 rankings released. ND fans would have known that the gap with Miami, they'd have been worried that it might close completely, but they wouldn't have 5 previous polls leading up to the last one to give them optimism.
12-11-2025 05:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,980
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #65
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 05:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 04:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:09 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

Your admins/boosters/etc clearly feel like being in the same Division as ND and the P2 is in your school's best interest. Do you think they're wrong? If so, you guys could always drop back to FCS.

It's what the P2 really want. Leave the ACC/B12/and the G6 and start their own league. You know that's what they want, they're just too scared to pull the trigger.

I actually don't think that's what most of the decision makers want. I know I don't want it. Most of the people in Athletic/Conference administration worked at smaller schools or attended smaller schools in past years. There's a huge advantage for FBS to keep football enthusiasm high in every nook and cranny in the country, and even though Ohio isn't a threat to OSU, they can still claim that they're in the same "League" or "Division". Let's face it, there's a severe stigma associated with playing an FCS school that just isn't there if that school is instead in the SBC or CUSA. A lot of schools have rivals that would be splintered. To name a few:

ND-Navy
Colorado- Colorado St
Washington-Washington St (maybe?)
Oregon-Oregon St (maybe?)

The issue is not having lots of smaller schools in the top division per se, it's the incessant comments about sharing the wealth/opportunity equally that are really a sign that many believe that everyone in FBS is the same, or close to it. Like it or not, nobody in the g5 is the equivalent of an avg M2 school, and only a couple schools currently in the g5 have any hope of reaching such a lofty perch in the next few decades. But even then, the comments about sharing access and wealth aren't aimed at Texas Tech or Wake Forest, they're aimed at Texas and Michigan. Only 25 schools got more than 20m eyeballs for the entire season in 2025. Only 15 of those got over 30m eyeballs. Only 8 got over 40m.

So, even looking at the P4, if you want to discuss who brings value and who doesn't, only somewhere between 8 and 25 schools really moved the needle all that much in the regular season this year. I'd lean closer to the 25 number just b/c Indiana only had 22.6m in the regular season but then pulled out an astonishing 18.3m in the B1G CCG, so they deserve full credit ++, but that still leaves out a majority of the P4 and all of everyone else (counting ND as part of the P4 ofc). I don't know what the highest total viewership was for a g5 program, but I'd guess it's 10m or less.

Looked at in this light, not only is the g5 unnecessary, but much of the P4 is, too. Does that mean we want to go to an 8-25 school league? No, of course not. But we also don't want Alabama St pretending that they're Alabama and making unreasonable demands for playoff access or financial windfalls. I don't think that's an unreasonable objective.

I agree.

I've always said if the G5 didn't exist the P5 would have to invent them. Michigan and Ohio State can't play every week, heck Michigan and Rutgers can't, and if the former did, we'd all soon get bored with it and nobody would go 11-1 anymore, which fans love.

The G5 is a big pile of 65 schools that are willing to run their athletic departments at massive operational deficits, deficits in the tens of millions each year, for the privilege of claiming to be in the "same league" as you say, as Alabama, USC, Notre Dame etc.

And they cost the P2 almost nothing. They get a paltry CFP payout, and the A4 collectively went 85-12 against them this season.

Yeah, there is real synergy there, but the smaller schools (and their fans) need to be smart about how things operate. When you slay a whale, brag to your buddies about it. When you make a NY6 bowl or the CFP, go out there and kick butt and take names as much as you're able to. Maybe win one of those games every now and then. But don't think that something like that will ever elevate the g5. All it might do is it could give your school a better shot at moving up the next time a power conference wants a new member.
12-11-2025 05:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #66
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

First of all, I don't believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking. They may want to know, but they don't need to know.

What we would have guessed from the AP polls was that Miami, Notre Dame, BYU, and Alabama were the bubble teams for the last spot in the CFP, in some order that the CFP is not bound by. As it turns out, that was indeed true. We also knew that neither Notre Dame nor Miami was playing another game, but Alabama and BYU were.

If the committee had not released its penultimate ranking, which showed Alabama at #9, ND at #10, BYU #11 and Miami #12, we probably wouldn't have been greatly surprised by the final CFP ranking. After all, the committee isn't bound to follow the AP (or we wouldn't need them in the first place).

But they did release those Week 14 rankings. Nothing happened to either Miami or Notre Dame that should have changed the committee's judgement about where they should be ranked relative to one another since neither of them played in Week 15. The only reason for the controversy was the self-inflicted wound caused by the Week 14 rankings.

Let's face it. Once again, the committee shot itself in the foot unnecessarily.
12-11-2025 05:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #67
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:05 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)bullet Wrote:  They mentally lock in their previous selections. And their evaluation is based on very limited data and heavily influenced by the last couple of weeks.

They lose all credibility with the show because they use completely contradictory explanations week to week.

Sure but they're still going to release the rankings. So it doesn't actually change anything. People are going to infer their own reasoning anyway.

By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

Don’t see it as a trial. It’s probably closer to running a race. And in every race I’ve ever run I could see my positioning with other runners.
12-12-2025 04:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #68
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 03:53 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:51 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:41 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:45 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:43 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  Then the SEC, B10 and ND need to leave the NCAA and quit their whining

nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.

That's exactly why they would leave.

Right. The G5 would leave. Don't let the door hit you on the backside.

Do you not know how to read?

The SEC and Big Ten aren't leaving. They already control FBS thru the CFP. Know that chafes you but what ever, deal with it.
12-12-2025 08:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #69
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
The more I see of the CFP committee, the more I like the Magic 8-ball.

https://magic-8ball.com/
12-12-2025 08:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,957
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #70
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-12-2025 08:42 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:53 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:51 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:41 PM)GreenBison Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:45 PM)stever20 Wrote:  nope. They aren't leaving. They hold all the cards. G5 conferences hold none of the cards.

That's exactly why they would leave.

Right. The G5 would leave. Don't let the door hit you on the backside.

Do you not know how to read?

The SEC and Big Ten aren't leaving. They already control FBS thru the CFP. Know that chafes you but what ever, deal with it.

I said they "Need To", I didn't say they were leaving.
12-12-2025 09:54 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #71
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 05:10 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 03:44 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 01:37 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

It isn't more transparent. Its just more inconsistent. Garbage data (November 4th rankings) adds no value and just damages their credibility.

I think their credibility will always be questioned either way. That is my skepticism about fewer rankings helping at all. Are college football fans going to truly be *less* crazy just because they see fewer rankings? Are they suddenly going to be more reasonable? Needless to say, I have my doubts there.

You're right on that one, but the specific circumstances of this season would have been avoided if there had only been 2 instead of 6 rankings released. ND fans would have known that the gap with Miami, they'd have been worried that it might close completely, but they wouldn't have 5 previous polls leading up to the last one to give them optimism.

FWIW, my two cents about how I viewed the whole six-show CFP process and how it unfolded, not necessarily correlated with your specific comment, but you sparked me to think about the whole thing:

1) I understood all along that the CFP had the idea that if Miami and ND being "next to each other" or whatever, then H2H would come in to play. I forget the actual verbiage, but the basic idea, that in their view ND and Miami were too far apart for H2H to matter in those early shows, was conveyed. So IMO they made themselves clear on that.

So during the time when like ND was #10 and Miami was #16, or whatever, i never had the notion that this meant we were safe from being compared with Miami and put behind them due to H2H. To be clear, I did not think that Miami should automatically be ahead of ND based on H2H, I wanted to see the computers, but IMO the CFP made it pretty clear that the H2H thing was on their mind and it could happen if they got next to each other.

2) What outraged me about the process (I was outraged by the substance, the CFP carrying through on their threat to move Miami ahead of ND based on H2H too of course) wasn't a false sense of security created by having six or whatever selection shows with ND ahead. Heck, we could all see that as Miami and ND kept winning during the second half of the season, that ND had hit their ceiling at #9 or so, while Miami, thanks to attrition, was creeping closer and closer to the same place.

The process outrage was the fact that in the last two weeks, the CFP first flipped Alabama ahead of ND for absolutely no good reason, and then in the last ranking failed to drop Alabama behind us when they were blown out in their CCG, but *did* drop BYU behind Miami when they were blown out in their CCG, thus putting Miami next to ND.

It was that IMO outrageous and unjustifiable last steps of the dance, so to speak, that was infuriating. And FWIW, I'd rather see that brazen kind of political manipulation, rather than have it hidden in a smoke filled room. I want the right to see the screwing so I can be outraged by it, dammit. And the six or seven week series allows for that. :)
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 07:07 PM by quo vadis.)
12-12-2025 06:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #72
RE: CFP committee isn't perfect, but it's the best system we've got - Wetzel
(12-11-2025 05:38 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-11-2025 12:44 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:18 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(12-08-2025 05:08 PM)bullet Wrote:  By no shows, he's saying no preliminary rankings.

Ah gotcha. That makes more sense I suppose. But it also means teams have no clue where they stand so I think it’s still a bad idea.

Given that the AP and Coaches' Polls are always nearly identical to to the weekly CFP reveals, teams absolutely have a clue where they stand. Doing away with preliminary CFP rankings won't improve the final decision, but it will reduce the criticism of the committee.

Would you want a judge to give periodic hints during a trial as to what he/she is thinking about which side is winning?

I don’t agree on that front. The polls and CFP rankings have differed enough where it matters the most - the bubble teams - that I believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking for all of November at a minimum. Look at the last AP Poll this week: they had #10 ND, #11 Miami, and #12 Alabama. That’s a totally different outcome than the CFP rankings.

Part of the reasoning to have the rankings shows in the first place (besides providing ESPN programming) was that the CFP committee was definitely (and IMHO validly) concerned about fans believing that the polls and CFP rankings would end up largely the same and they needed to socialize how different they could end up being clearly with the weekly rankings.

I just don’t understand wanting less information, particularly when this is a sport where rankings directly determine the playoff field unlike pro sports where it’s solely determined by on-the-field results.

I mean, could you imagine if all we had were the final AP rankings that showed ND ranked ahead of Miami and Alabama, but then we see the CFP rankings for the first time with Bama jumping ahead of both and ND falling out entirely? That would have made the outcry against the committee even worse than now.

This like what Churchill said about democracy: it’s the worst form of government… except for all of the others.

Similarly, a human committee is the worst CFP ranking system… except for all of the others.

Making things more opaque only makes things worse.

First of all, I don't believe the whole public needs to know what the committee is thinking. They may want to know, but they don't need to know.

What we would have guessed from the AP polls was that Miami, Notre Dame, BYU, and Alabama were the bubble teams for the last spot in the CFP, in some order that the CFP is not bound by. As it turns out, that was indeed true. We also knew that neither Notre Dame nor Miami was playing another game, but Alabama and BYU were.

If the committee had not released its penultimate ranking, which showed Alabama at #9, ND at #10, BYU #11 and Miami #12, we probably wouldn't have been greatly surprised by the final CFP ranking. After all, the committee isn't bound to follow the AP (or we wouldn't need them in the first place).

But they did release those Week 14 rankings. Nothing happened to either Miami or Notre Dame that should have changed the committee's judgement about where they should be ranked relative to one another since neither of them played in Week 15. The only reason for the controversy was the self-inflicted wound caused by the Week 14 rankings.

Let's face it. Once again, the committee shot itself in the foot unnecessarily.

When the penultimate rankings were released, some people - wiser than me as it turned out - immediately said this was ominous for Notre Dame, that the CFP was setting ND up to get put next to Miami and bounced based on H2H.

I disagreed, I thought that what the CFP was really doing was protecting Alabama, in case they lost their CCG. Because losers of CCG typically drop a spot or two, and Alabama at #10 was in a position where if they got beat bad they might drop out, and for political reasons (SEC power), that was not acceptable. I didn't see any danger that Miami, with BYU sandwiched between us, could be brought next door.

Retrospectively of course, I was wrong. It was in fact about a Miami/ND maneuver, not about Alabama at all, because as it turned out, Alabama got blow out in their CCG, the worst possible outcome, and they didn't move at all. So they would have been safe at #10 as well as #9.

So IMO what triggered the Alabama/ND 9/10 switch was when the November 30th games were played, and Duke became the mind-boggling participant in the ACC title game. That set up a scenario where the ACC could be left entirely out of the playoffs, which for whatever reason, the CFP found politically untenable (I have no idea why, as who cares if the ACC is pissed, but that seems clear to me now). Of course as I said, others recognized this all along.

So flipping Alabama and ND made it possible for the CFP to make one final flip, moving BYU behind Miami (or ahead of both of us, should they win the B12 title game), and thus putting Miami next to ND, giving the ACC a backstop should Duke win the title. Duke won the title, and the CFP triggered their backup to save the ACC.

So yeah, those who say had UVA won, Miami would not have gotten in, I think are correct. Had UVA beaten Duke, BYU stays ahead of Miami, and ND gets in.

Long story long - if the CFP felt they *had* to get an ACC team in, then they really didn't shoot themselves in the foot. They made an unjustifiable, awkward move, because they felt getting an ACC team in was worth the flak that would come with it. I mean, not many really thought that Duke at 7-5 would end up in the ACC CCG. That was thrust on them on November 30, so they didn't have time to react to it before in earlier polls.

Just MO.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 07:22 PM by quo vadis.)
12-12-2025 07:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.