RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Updated After Nov. 22 Games:
3rd loss, bye bye:
Big Ten: USC
Big 12: Houston
SEC:
#3 Texas A&M (11-0): Currently only has played two ranked opponents and #22 Missouri is in danger of falling out of next Tuesday's rankings having lost their fourth game. If Alabama dropped from #4 to #10 despite having beaten ranked teams, A&M probably will fall significantly if they lose at Texas next week.
#4 Georgia (10-1): I don't expect much of a problem from Georgia Tech. They're now hoping Texas can beat A&M (or maybe they're not, do they really want to lose to Alabama again?) They may have a better chance at a bye not playing the SEC Championship.
#6 Mississippi (10-1): Looking at Alabama I wouldn't think Mississippi is in with a loss and I have a feeling they're going to hit them way worse for losing to Mississippi State than they did Alabama for losing to Oklahoma, not to mention Mississippi doesn't have as many ranked wins as Alabama. They did beat Oklahoma (on the road no less).
#8 Oklahoma (9-2): Beat LSU and they're in and LSU beat Western Kentucky 13-10 in Death Valley at night.
#10 Alabama (9-2): They're an Iron Bowl win from the SEC Championship Game. If they win, where do they rank? If they lose the SEC Championship, what happens? One thing's for sure, lose to Auburn and they're out of the Playoff.
#14 Vanderbilt (9-2): They won but unfortunately so did practically everyone ahead of them. Even if they win at Tennessee, they'd need someone ahead of them to lose and would you penalize Alabama or BYU if they lost their conference championship (and could you keep Alabama out in favor of a Vanderbilt team that lost to Alabama anyway?) There's also Miami ahead of them as well.
SEC Outlook: Vanderbilt probably won't get in but the top five probably will. Last year they only had three.
Best Case scenario: Texas A&M wins the SEC undefeated. Michigan upsets Ohio State, Oregon sneaks into the Big Ten Championship and upsets Indiana, A&M is the #1 overall seed. On the other hand, I can see in this scenario Oregon, Indiana, and Ohio State all getting byes, squeezing out Georgia. Maybe the SEC would rather have 2 byes than the #1 overall seed.
Worst Case scenario: Texas A&M loses to Texas. Texas is blocked from getting in. Ohio State finally beats Michigan. Alabama wins the SEC Championship. The top three seeds are Ohio State/Indiana in either order followed by #3 Texas Tech with Alabama #4.
Big Ten:
#1 Ohio State (11-0): If this was any other school, they'd be sitting pretty with a Playoff bid locked up and if they lose they won't have to play in the Big Ten Championship Game. But this is OSU and losing to TTUN is inexcusable.
#2 Indiana (11-0): Don't know if IU will call for Cignetti's head if they lose at Purdue but, nah, like that would happen?
#7 Oregon (10-1): There's a lot of teams waiting in the wings if Oregon loses, I wouldn't recommend it. On the other hand, a win and a Michigan win and they can go to the Big Ten Championship Game.
#18 Michigan (9-2): Are they too low even if they beat Ohio State? Consider that they're still behind three loss Texas.
Big 10 Outlook: Probably not going to help themselves much. Hope Oregon wins.
Best Case Scenario: Ohio State beats Michigan, Alabama wins the SEC Championship Game, OSU and IU are the top two seeds. 1 and 3 wouldn't be too bad as long as they are on opposite sides.
Worst Case Scenario: Oregon loses and doesn't make the Playoff. On top of that, Ohio State loses to Michigan. In this scenario, Michigan would go to the Big Ten Championship. Assuming Indiana wins, the Big Ten is a two team conference. Vanderbilt somehow sneaks in, giving them six teams.
Big 12:
#5 Texas Tech (10-1): Win next week (at West Virginia) and they should go, even if they lose in the Big 12 Championship Game. The Big 12 wants TTU to lose but Tech wants the bye or at the very least the #5 seed. Chances are good that no one in the top 3 would choose to go to the Cotton Bowl so if Tech is the #5 seed they'll still play in the Cotton Bowl vs. the #4 seed.
#11 BYU (10-1): Big win at Cincinnati to get them into a likely Big 12 Championship appearance. The problem is looking at the current standings they're out and it would be unlikely they can jump anyone other than winning the Big 12. If both Alabama and BYU lose their conference championships, how can BYU jump Alabama? And other than that, what opening would BYU have?
#12 Utah (9-2): The good news is they survived. The bad news is BYU won and their chance at the Big 12 Championship closed and BYU would have priority over them if it came to the two Utah schools and BYU probably isn't getting in either.
Big 12 Outlook: I'm not seeing BYU getting in unless they win the Big 12 Championship ... in Dallas.
Best Case Scenario: They want two teams but if they get them Texas Tech's seed gets hurt and they likely have to play away from Dallas in the QF round. It's a question of getting BYU in or giving TTU a better chance. Tech has a small chance to win a national championship. Does the Big 12 really want to hurt that so BYU loses in the first round to say Mississippi?
ACC:
#13 Miami (8-2): They weren't helped by BYU winning at Cincinnati nor by Vanderbilt. They did get some help by Pittsburgh beating Georgia Tech. It's likely Miami's only chance of getting in is via the ACC Championship and the window, while narrow, is still open, and had Georgia Tech won it would have closed completely.
#19 Virginia (9-2), With GT losing, they have to be a fairly big favorite for the ACC Championship and an automatic bid for the Playoff now. They probably don't want to see Miami make it to Charlotte so root for SMU!
#16, loss, Georgia Tech (9-2): Still here by record. Might still be in the ACC Championship race. Have to play UGa in Atlanta.
ACC Outlook: Don't ask.
Best case scenario: By some miracle enough teams ahead of Miami lose and they sneak in as an at large. At this rate, the ACC would take Miami being the ACC Champion, at least they'd have a better chance to actually win a game than Virginia.
Worst case scenario: SMU winning the ACC with 3 losses.
#9 Notre Dame (9-2): Only 70-7. They don't really have the schedule and USC losing yesterday doesn't help but the CFP Committee has been giving them the doubt all season, especially over Miami, and I don't see that changing.
I think our Playoff field will be:
SEC: Texas A&M, Georgia, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Alabama
Big Ten: Ohio State, Indiana, Oregon
Big 12: Texas Tech
Notre Dame
ACC Champion
G6 Champion
I don't think Texas beating Texas A&M or Michigan beating Ohio State will do a damn thing. The chaos will happen if BYU wins the Big 12 and then someone will be out. It will be very interesting between Alabama and Notre Dame then assuming Alabama loses the SEC Championship. If Alabama wins the SEC Championship, Notre Dame's gone. I can only see the SEC if Alabama gets left out again in this scenario.
|