Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Author Message
schmolik Online
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #41
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
If the AP and Coaches polls are any indication, Texas is going to be way lower than #11. The question is what will happen if they beat A&M? The third loss could very well be a deal breaker but you could consider Ohio State the 3rd loss and if UT is out that will severely discourage future non conference strong scheduling. If Texas scheduled an easier P4, they'd be a lock if they beat A&M.
11-16-2025 03:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #42
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.
11-16-2025 03:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #43
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 01:56 PM)Lurker Above Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 09:36 AM)schmolik Wrote:  Updated After Nov. 15 Games...

3rd loss, bye bye...

SEC: Texas (Yes I can see a scenario where UT gets in with 3 losses but for now I'll say they're out and Oklahoma winning does hurt their chances despite the head to head win).

ACC: Louisville, Pittsburgh

Big 12: Cincinnati

SEC:
#3 Texas A&M (10-0): Will the CFP Committee give the Aggies credit for coming back from 30-3 or penalize them from being down 30-3 to a 3 win South Carolina in the first place? They'll be a Playoff team but if they don't win at Texas they likely won't be going to Atlanta and you have to question them vs. Alabama or Georgia in the SEC Championship Game anyway.

#4 (Loss) Alabama (8-2): Last week I said I jinxed them with their longest home winning streak! Win at Auburn and they're still going to the SEC Championship although their chances at a 1st round bye could be in question (Could the SEC Champion not get a bye?)

#5 Georgia (9-1): If Georgia Tech can barely escape Boston College I'm liking UGa's chances vs. GT. Are hoping Texas beats A&M (or are they? Maybe they'd prefer not to lose to Alabama again although the last time they played Bama twice in the same season they won the rematch ... and a national championship!)

#7 Mississippi (10-1): Are we sure Lane doesn't want to go to UF? He sure coached like he did. Sorry, different thread. Mississippi's SEC SOS likely keeps them out of the SEC Championship Game but barring a disaster at Mississippi State will make the Playoff and even a loss might still make it.

#11 Oklahoma (8-2): I still don't know how OU won at Alabama. After losing at home to Mississippi they've won back to back road games at Tennessee and Alabama. Well if they want to make the Playoffs they'll have to win two home games vs. Missouri and LSU. Should they agree to play on the road these two games instead? They're undefeated in road games (other loss was the Texas game in Dallas).

As for Oklahoma's Playoff chances at 10-2? I think really good, especially if Alabama wins the SEC Championship and/or Michigan beats Ohio State.

#14 Vanderbilt (8-2): Oklahoma's upset is going to hurt Vandy's chances. Oklahoma is going to get priority if both win out. Vandy would love for Cincinnati to beat BYU, Texas Tech to win the Big 12, and the Big 12 to be a 1 bid conference.

SEC Outlook: Oklahoma winning really helps them and gives them a leg up should Michigan upset Ohio State. Texas is also a good team to have as a potential three loss team as they can argue their third loss is to Ohio State, a game they didn't need to schedule, and they have wins over both Oklahoma and Vanderbilt. Could the Committee put a three loss Texas in over a two loss Oklahoma or Vanderbilt? I think Oklahoma is likely no as they have good wins but Vanderbilt I wouldn't rule it out.

Big Ten:

#1 Ohio State (10-0): They'll get in. The question is what their seed would be and can they beat Michigan for the first time in five years?

#2 Indiana (11-0): Really? Indiana needed a bye week before playing Purdue?

#8 Oregon (9-1): I'm not sure if Oregon gets in if they lose one of their last two games now. They're probably two wins and a Michigan win over Ohio State over a 2nd straight Big Ten Championship game and a rematch with Indiana and the first game was 30-20. Problem is that game was at Eugene and this game would be in ... Indianapolis.

#17 USC (8-2): I'd be very surprised if USC were in this list after traveling to Eugene. Then again, Oklahoma won at Alabama...

#18 Michigan (8-2): That Northwestern game was really scary. The bad news for UM is Oklahoma likely will get in over them even if Michigan beats Ohio State.

Big 10 Outlook: Will there be a spot for Michigan if they beat Ohio State? How about for both USC and Oregon if USC wins? Maybe the Big 10 is better off having the favorites win now.

Big 12:

#6 Texas Tech (10-1): Can anyone stop them in the Big 12? Alabama's loss might help them get a 1st round Playoff bye. For TTU, your ultimate goal is getting to play in the Cotton Bowl in the QF round which very well could happen if you finish in the top 5.

#12 BYU (9-1): Look at the ratings this week to see if Alabama and/or Texas fall below BYU and if BYU gets a bump if they beat Cincinnati. I'm not sure BYU can get in as an at large even if they win out and lose to Texas Tech in the Championship Game.

#13 Utah (8-2): Oklahoma's win really hurts Utah's chances of getting in any other way other than flat out winning the Big 12.

Houston (8-2): Even less chance than Utah, heck, they lost to Utah.

Big 12 Outlook: They're thinking screw you Oklahoma. They're also thinking come on BYU...

ACC:

#15 Miami (8-2): They're currently the highest ACC team in the CFP rankings but they also need help getting to the ACC Championship Game and they're also a victim of Oklahoma's upset over Alabama. It also didn't help that Notre Dame thumped Pittsburgh. At least the good news is Miami goes to Pittsburgh in two weeks, maybe they'll be that bad then too.

#16 Georgia Tech (9-1): The team that played at BC is never going to beat UGa. The good news is beat a reeling Pittsburgh and they have a good chance of going to the ACC Championship and a likely Playoff berth (the AAC continues to cannibalize themselves)

#19 Virginia (9-2), Not only a win but a convincing win. They now are VT at home from a 1st place tie in the ACC.

ACC Outlook: Miami is their only chance at a 2nd bid and it could be slim.

#9 Notre Dame (8-2): If that was their audition for the Playoff, it was pretty good.

Overall: Oklahoma likely jumps into the field with Texas being out. Alabama probably falls below Oklahoma. I think it would right now be...

1. Ohio State
2. Indiana
3. Texas A&M
4. Georgia
5. Texas Tech
6. Mississippi
7. Oregon
8. Oklahoma
9. Alabama
10. Notre Dame
11. Texas
12. BYU

The issue with Notre Dame right now could very well be Texas. I think Texas could easily jump back over Notre Dame if they beat Texas A&M and #10 would likely be the cutoff for the Playoff with the ACC and G6 spots having to be accounted for. We're also not considering Michigan who could skyrocket if they beat Ohio State (and what if USC beats Oregon as well?) Miami probably won't have much of a chance to move up.

Meanwhile BYU could be in trouble. Other than flat out winning the Big 12, how are they going to crack the top 10? They'd likely need Mississippi or Oregon to lose.

If you are in a non-P2 conference a 10-2 Vandy not getting into the playoffs is pptentially not a good thing. The SEC will not allow that moving forward and the new rules will assure it. And they should. A 2 loss and otherwise undefeated SEC team needs to be in the playoffs every year. You can disagree if you like, but it is not realistically possible for there to be 10 teams having a better season than being 10-2 and 7-2 (starting next season with the 9 game SEC regular season) in the SEC.

What's our argument on Vanderbilt? Their SOS is weaker than BYU's! So is Ole Miss' btw, but Ole Miss only has the one loss so they're safe as long as they can beat Miss St (hardly a guarantee, no rivalry game is a guarantee). Our best case scenario is OU, Alabama, Georgia, Ole Miss, Vandy and Texas win out (as much as I would hate that last one), in that case we get at least 5 and perhaps 6 or even 7 depending on what happens elsewhere. Our worst case scenario?

UGA loses to GT
Alabama loses to Auburn
Texas loses to A&M (even though that would make me very happy)
OU loses 1 of their last 2
Ole Miss loses to Miss St
Vandy loses to Tennessee

Most likely ofc, we'll end up with something in between those 2 extremes. Hopefully, we end up with more of the last teams in and fewer of the first teams out than we did last season.

FWIW, I think it would take a lot to get a 3 loss SEC team in, unless that 3rd loss is the CCG. Everything we've seen/heard from the Committee thus far puts a premium on number of losses and eye testadvanced metrics, just like last year. It will be telling to see how they rank Alabama and OU after this past weekend. Does Alabama get credit for going 1-1 vs current top 10 teams and 3-0 vs the rest of the current top 25, or does ND get credit for that 1-2 record vs ranked teams but running up the score on decent but not super strong teams like Navy and Pitt? Clearly the polls like ND more, as usual giving more credit to pretty wins over so-so teams than grinding out a 4-1 record vs ranked teams.
11-16-2025 04:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #44
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside. Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.
11-16-2025 04:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,945
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #45
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside. Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

I don't even feel badly about that as our 4 toughest games were on the road, and we made our nonconference schedule a lot tougher than it had to be with ND. Besides, who knew that LSU and Texas would have 7 losses between the 2 of them with 2 weeks to go? Last year, things didn't break our way at the end, this year feels like they have, at least thus far. FYI, Missouri is top half right now. Our SOS, despite getting a lot of lucky breaks with SEC opponents, is still #18, much stronger than Ole Miss or Missouri and a bit stronger than Vanderbilt. It's only in SEC tiebreakers that it looks bad.
11-16-2025 04:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #46
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside. Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Well the two potential Big Ten bubble teams are all under-dogs. If you get fancy and make deliberately weird scenarios you will get deliberately weird results.

Anyways, Vandy has three ranked wins versus Utah's 2 and they were against then-ranked 10, 11 and 15 versus Utah's 17 and 21. Vandy plays UTenn on rivalry weak, who are currently ranked 22nd and that could be the impetus to get them over the Utes. Its a little tougher for BYU, who actually have an even weaker schedule (1 ranked win and one ranked loss) but will be in their CCG with that 11-1 record and, based on last year, the committee doesn't like punishing losers.

Most likely scenario? Between BYU and all those would-be 10-2 SEC teams at least one of them gets upset and its all moot.
11-16-2025 04:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #47
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside. Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

There are 19 P4 teams with two or less losses at this point aiming for 11 slots. I think Texas is the only current 3 loss teams with a non-zero chance at a wild card spot in the playoff and its pretty low. (and that's not even factoring in having to beat Arkansas and Texas A&M). Pitt, SMU, Arizona St. and Cincinnati still have a shot at a conference title (and maybe there is some crazy scenario where Duke, Kansas St. or Arizona get in a CCG).
11-16-2025 04:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #48
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 04:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside. Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Well the two potential Big Ten bubble teams are all under-dogs. If you get fancy and make deliberately weird scenarios you will get deliberately weird results.

Anyways, Vandy has three ranked wins versus Utah's 2 and they were against then-ranked 10, 11 and 15 versus Utah's 17 and 21. Vandy plays UTenn on rivalry weak, who are currently ranked 22nd and that could be the impetus to get them over the Utes. Its a little tougher for BYU, who actually have an even weaker schedule (1 ranked win and one ranked loss) but will be in their CCG with that 11-1 record and, based on last year, the committee doesn't like punishing losers.

Most likely scenario? Between BYU and all those would-be 10-2 SEC teams at least one of them gets upset and its all moot.

I discounted M2 teams like Utah and also presumed Michigan and USC are out. Even still, we have 1 team too many; 6 SEC, 3 Big Ten, and Notre Dame. In the chalk scenario, Vanderbilt is the odd team out.

And citing the ranking of teams “when they played” is cherry picking. South Carolina is 3-7, not a win to bandy about as proof of Vanderbilt’s playoff-worthiness.

And while a 10-3 Alabama is the only 3-loss team I have with >50% playoff odds, I think a Longhorns team that defeats Texas A&M will find itself a spot above a 10-2 Vanderbilt.

These are the fun discussions about college football.
11-16-2025 06:23 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
tf8693 Online
All American
*

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
Post: #49
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside.

Not following your reasoning here. If 12 is the number, that means only one of those teams would get bounced (or two if the ACC champ has three losses, which is a distinct possibility with Pitt and SMU both still in contention with three losses apiece).

Quote:Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Agree with you on Vandy. But I think Texas is done, even with a win against A&M. They have three losses, including one (Florida) to an unranked team with only three wins to date. I think Texas has the worst loss of any team looking for an at-large bid, including Alabama's loss to Florida State. That was a Week One loss, and Florida State at least looks like it will get a bowl bid, and figures to be a favorite over Florida according to FPI.
11-17-2025 09:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #50
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-17-2025 09:28 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside.

Not following your reasoning here. If 12 is the number, that means only one of those teams would get bounced (or two if the ACC champ has three losses, which is a distinct possibility with Pitt and SMU both still in contention with three losses apiece).

Quote:Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Agree with you on Vandy. But I think Texas is done, even with a win against A&M. They have three losses, including one (Florida) to an unranked team with only three wins to date. I think Texas has the worst loss of any team looking for an at-large bid, including Alabama's loss to Florida State. That was a Week One loss, and Florida State at least looks like it will get a bowl bid, and figures to be a favorite over Florida according to FPI.

If 12 is the number of “P2/ND” teams, you have to make room for 3 non-P2 champs.

Texas also has a week 1 loss to arguably the best team in the nation; they are a quasi-2-loss team in that regard. I think both Texas and Vandy are “done” in the sense that they need lots of chaos to climb into the playoff, but if it comes down to those 2 I think head-to-head favors the Longhorns.
11-17-2025 11:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #51
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-17-2025 09:28 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside.

Not following your reasoning here. If 12 is the number, that means only one of those teams would get bounced (or two if the ACC champ has three losses, which is a distinct possibility with Pitt and SMU both still in contention with three losses apiece).

Quote:Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Agree with you on Vandy. But I think Texas is done, even with a win against A&M. They have three losses, including one (Florida) to an unranked team with only three wins to date. I think Texas has the worst loss of any team looking for an at-large bid, including Alabama's loss to Florida State. That was a Week One loss, and Florida State at least looks like it will get a bowl bid, and figures to be a favorite over Florida according to FPI.
FSU has played 2 teams who are currently ranked. Florida has played 3 of the top 5 and 2 more in the 2nd 10 with Tennessee to go and other than their FCS opponent hasn't played anyone with less than 5 wins already.
11-17-2025 12:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #52
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-17-2025 12:33 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-17-2025 09:28 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside.

Not following your reasoning here. If 12 is the number, that means only one of those teams would get bounced (or two if the ACC champ has three losses, which is a distinct possibility with Pitt and SMU both still in contention with three losses apiece).

Quote:Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Agree with you on Vandy. But I think Texas is done, even with a win against A&M. They have three losses, including one (Florida) to an unranked team with only three wins to date. I think Texas has the worst loss of any team looking for an at-large bid, including Alabama's loss to Florida State. That was a Week One loss, and Florida State at least looks like it will get a bowl bid, and figures to be a favorite over Florida according to FPI.
FSU has played 2 teams who are currently ranked. Florida has played 3 of the top 5 and 2 more in the 2nd 10 with Tennessee to go and other than their FCS opponent hasn't played anyone with less than 5 wins already.
I respect what Florida had to go through this year but I cannot respect putting a 3 loss Texas in over 2 loss teams from the P2, including one or potentially two fellow SEC schools. Not only do they have an extra loss, they also didn't look particularly great in all of their wins. Squeaked by both UK and MSU in OT, beat Vandy by 3 at home (which, traditionally, means that the two would be viewed as evenly talented.) Yeah, no, I give it to the 'Dores easily.
11-17-2025 12:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #53
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-17-2025 12:40 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-17-2025 12:33 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-17-2025 09:28 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 04:07 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-16-2025 03:56 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  It is very hard to take account for upsets but if TTU wins out, including the CCG, I can't see a 10-2 SEC team (Vandy) being left out. They're in at the expense of whichever Utah school is the Big XII's second.

Things get a lot trickier if OSU and Oregon get upset by USC and Mich.

Up to 12 P2/ND teams will have 2 or fewer losses. That means at least 3 of those will be on the outside.

Not following your reasoning here. If 12 is the number, that means only one of those teams would get bounced (or two if the ACC champ has three losses, which is a distinct possibility with Pitt and SMU both still in contention with three losses apiece).

Quote:Michigan and the UO/USC loser may be bounced, but I think Vandy is also on the wrong side of the split and will probably be jumped by Texas if the Aggies lose their lone game against the top half of the SEC.

Agree with you on Vandy. But I think Texas is done, even with a win against A&M. They have three losses, including one (Florida) to an unranked team with only three wins to date. I think Texas has the worst loss of any team looking for an at-large bid, including Alabama's loss to Florida State. That was a Week One loss, and Florida State at least looks like it will get a bowl bid, and figures to be a favorite over Florida according to FPI.
FSU has played 2 teams who are currently ranked. Florida has played 3 of the top 5 and 2 more in the 2nd 10 with Tennessee to go and other than their FCS opponent hasn't played anyone with less than 5 wins already.
I respect what Florida had to go through this year but I cannot respect putting a 3 loss Texas in over 2 loss teams from the P2, including one or potentially two fellow SEC schools. Not only do they have an extra loss, they also didn't look particularly great in all of their wins. Squeaked by both UK and MSU in OT, beat Vandy by 3 at home (which, traditionally, means that the two would be viewed as evenly talented.) Yeah, no, I give it to the 'Dores easily.
If Vandy played Ohio St. ooc instead of Virginia Tech, Georgia State, Utah State and Charleston Southern, they would have 3 losses. Virtually all of the 2 loss schools would have 3 losses with the Texas ooc (a couple have lost to ND, so they wouldn't have an extra). Now, I've said its a long shot that Texas gets in even winning out, but they will get in over Vandy. Texas totally dominated Vandy until they got 3 TDs in the last 8 minutes, 2 in the last 3 with the last one with 30 seconds left.
11-17-2025 12:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Online
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #54
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Updated After Nov. 22 Games:

3rd loss, bye bye:
Big Ten: USC
Big 12: Houston

SEC:
#3 Texas A&M (11-0): Currently only has played two ranked opponents and #22 Missouri is in danger of falling out of next Tuesday's rankings having lost their fourth game. If Alabama dropped from #4 to #10 despite having beaten ranked teams, A&M probably will fall significantly if they lose at Texas next week.

#4 Georgia (10-1): I don't expect much of a problem from Georgia Tech. They're now hoping Texas can beat A&M (or maybe they're not, do they really want to lose to Alabama again?) They may have a better chance at a bye not playing the SEC Championship.

#6 Mississippi (10-1): Looking at Alabama I wouldn't think Mississippi is in with a loss and I have a feeling they're going to hit them way worse for losing to Mississippi State than they did Alabama for losing to Oklahoma, not to mention Mississippi doesn't have as many ranked wins as Alabama. They did beat Oklahoma (on the road no less).

#8 Oklahoma (9-2): Beat LSU and they're in and LSU beat Western Kentucky 13-10 in Death Valley at night.

#10 Alabama (9-2): They're an Iron Bowl win from the SEC Championship Game. If they win, where do they rank? If they lose the SEC Championship, what happens? One thing's for sure, lose to Auburn and they're out of the Playoff.

#14 Vanderbilt (9-2): They won but unfortunately so did practically everyone ahead of them. Even if they win at Tennessee, they'd need someone ahead of them to lose and would you penalize Alabama or BYU if they lost their conference championship (and could you keep Alabama out in favor of a Vanderbilt team that lost to Alabama anyway?) There's also Miami ahead of them as well.

SEC Outlook: Vanderbilt probably won't get in but the top five probably will. Last year they only had three.

Best Case scenario: Texas A&M wins the SEC undefeated. Michigan upsets Ohio State, Oregon sneaks into the Big Ten Championship and upsets Indiana, A&M is the #1 overall seed. On the other hand, I can see in this scenario Oregon, Indiana, and Ohio State all getting byes, squeezing out Georgia. Maybe the SEC would rather have 2 byes than the #1 overall seed.

Worst Case scenario: Texas A&M loses to Texas. Texas is blocked from getting in. Ohio State finally beats Michigan. Alabama wins the SEC Championship. The top three seeds are Ohio State/Indiana in either order followed by #3 Texas Tech with Alabama #4.

Big Ten:

#1 Ohio State (11-0): If this was any other school, they'd be sitting pretty with a Playoff bid locked up and if they lose they won't have to play in the Big Ten Championship Game. But this is OSU and losing to TTUN is inexcusable.

#2 Indiana (11-0): Don't know if IU will call for Cignetti's head if they lose at Purdue but, nah, like that would happen?

#7 Oregon (10-1): There's a lot of teams waiting in the wings if Oregon loses, I wouldn't recommend it. On the other hand, a win and a Michigan win and they can go to the Big Ten Championship Game.

#18 Michigan (9-2): Are they too low even if they beat Ohio State? Consider that they're still behind three loss Texas.

Big 10 Outlook: Probably not going to help themselves much. Hope Oregon wins.

Best Case Scenario: Ohio State beats Michigan, Alabama wins the SEC Championship Game, OSU and IU are the top two seeds. 1 and 3 wouldn't be too bad as long as they are on opposite sides.

Worst Case Scenario: Oregon loses and doesn't make the Playoff. On top of that, Ohio State loses to Michigan. In this scenario, Michigan would go to the Big Ten Championship. Assuming Indiana wins, the Big Ten is a two team conference. Vanderbilt somehow sneaks in, giving them six teams.

Big 12:

#5 Texas Tech (10-1): Win next week (at West Virginia) and they should go, even if they lose in the Big 12 Championship Game. The Big 12 wants TTU to lose but Tech wants the bye or at the very least the #5 seed. Chances are good that no one in the top 3 would choose to go to the Cotton Bowl so if Tech is the #5 seed they'll still play in the Cotton Bowl vs. the #4 seed.

#11 BYU (10-1): Big win at Cincinnati to get them into a likely Big 12 Championship appearance. The problem is looking at the current standings they're out and it would be unlikely they can jump anyone other than winning the Big 12. If both Alabama and BYU lose their conference championships, how can BYU jump Alabama? And other than that, what opening would BYU have?

#12 Utah (9-2): The good news is they survived. The bad news is BYU won and their chance at the Big 12 Championship closed and BYU would have priority over them if it came to the two Utah schools and BYU probably isn't getting in either.

Big 12 Outlook: I'm not seeing BYU getting in unless they win the Big 12 Championship ... in Dallas.

Best Case Scenario: They want two teams but if they get them Texas Tech's seed gets hurt and they likely have to play away from Dallas in the QF round. It's a question of getting BYU in or giving TTU a better chance. Tech has a small chance to win a national championship. Does the Big 12 really want to hurt that so BYU loses in the first round to say Mississippi?

ACC:

#13 Miami (8-2): They weren't helped by BYU winning at Cincinnati nor by Vanderbilt. They did get some help by Pittsburgh beating Georgia Tech. It's likely Miami's only chance of getting in is via the ACC Championship and the window, while narrow, is still open, and had Georgia Tech won it would have closed completely.

#19 Virginia (9-2), With GT losing, they have to be a fairly big favorite for the ACC Championship and an automatic bid for the Playoff now. They probably don't want to see Miami make it to Charlotte so root for SMU!

#16, loss, Georgia Tech (9-2): Still here by record. Might still be in the ACC Championship race. Have to play UGa in Atlanta.

ACC Outlook: Don't ask.

Best case scenario: By some miracle enough teams ahead of Miami lose and they sneak in as an at large. At this rate, the ACC would take Miami being the ACC Champion, at least they'd have a better chance to actually win a game than Virginia.

Worst case scenario: SMU winning the ACC with 3 losses.

#9 Notre Dame (9-2): Only 70-7. They don't really have the schedule and USC losing yesterday doesn't help but the CFP Committee has been giving them the doubt all season, especially over Miami, and I don't see that changing.

I think our Playoff field will be:

SEC: Texas A&M, Georgia, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Alabama
Big Ten: Ohio State, Indiana, Oregon
Big 12: Texas Tech
Notre Dame
ACC Champion
G6 Champion

I don't think Texas beating Texas A&M or Michigan beating Ohio State will do a damn thing. The chaos will happen if BYU wins the Big 12 and then someone will be out. It will be very interesting between Alabama and Notre Dame then assuming Alabama loses the SEC Championship. If Alabama wins the SEC Championship, Notre Dame's gone. I can only see the SEC if Alabama gets left out again in this scenario.
11-23-2025 08:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Online
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #55
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Summarizing:
https://www.offtackleempire.com/post/LtvAiVKADHZv

Using the AP/Coaches polls,

Alabama should be in unless they lose and BYU wins.
Notre Dame should be in unless both Alabama and BYU win.
BYU needs to win.

Of course the CFP Committee isn't governed by the polls and a close loss certainly can move Alabama and/or BYU above Notre Dame. Who knows, maybe the campaigning moves Miami above Notre Dame?

I would say with all the combinations I could come up with I think the Big 12 and SEC champions have to have byes. If Alabama wins, how are they not the top SEC team? They have two losses? They'll have beaten Georgia twice who also has two losses. You're not going to rank Alabama behind one loss Mississippi or Texas A&M who played much weaker SEC schedules. If BYU beats Texas Tech, you have a 12-1 BYU who avenged their loss to Texas Tech. Even if you say Tech's QB didn't play in their loss to Arizona State, if you compare BYU to Tech head to head, BYU's win was in a neutral field vs. Tech at home.
11-30-2025 08:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.