Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Author Message
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1098
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #1
P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
For now I will assume 9-3 or worse is an automatic out.

SEC:
Texas A&M (8-0): Still have road games at Missouri and Texas but probably look to be favored in both of them and would probably make the Playoff even if they lost both of them anyway. Right now are probably thinking SEC Championship more than just getting in.

Alabama (7-1): Still have home games against LSU and Oklahoma who both lost home games. After South Carolina yesterday 'Bama probably would prefer LSU remain ranked as they do better vs. ranked teams than unranked but Alabama hasn't lost a home game in the Kalen DeBoer era anyway. They can still blow a game and make the Playoff anyway. Again, SEC Championship is the bigger goal now than just getting in.

Georgia (7-1): Has Texas at home and Georgia Tech in Atlanta. Texas barely beat Mississippi State away which probably isn't that bad since they've played every SEC tough in Starkville but also barely beat Kentucky in Lexington and that is bad. I can't see UT winning in Athens, they couldn't beat UGa in Austin last year. Then GT won't matter to their Playoff chances. It will be interesting when it comes to the SEC Championship. UGa and A&M don't play so who would play Bama if A&M loses a game? Georgia probably doesn't want to play if they lose to Tech, it could be their third loss although I imagine they'll get the benefit of the doubt by the Committee in that case.

Mississippi (7-1): Doesn't play a ranked opponent the rest of the way and won't have to leave the state. You can talk about Mississippi State playing everyone close or about them continually losing and in spectacular fashion. Even if Mississippi does blow the Egg Bowl they'll still finish 10-2. Problem is by the end of the season LSU and Oklahoma, their best wins could wind up not being ranked. If any SEC team gets left out at 10-2 it will be them.

Vanderbilt (7-1): They've got two road games, at Texas and at Tennessee. Win one and they're in the Playoff. Lose both and they're staying home. It's as simple as that. We're still waiting on Arch Manning, if he doesn't play next week that could really help Pimp Vandy.

Texas (6-2): They're not winning at Georgia. Could they essentially spoil Vanderbilt's Playoff chances next week?

Tennessee (6-2): Oklahoma next week is an eliminator between the two schools. They then have to go to Florida where they haven't won since 2003. Luckily for UT Billy Napier is no longer coaching for his job. If Vanderbilt loses at Texas and Tennessee beats Florida, you could have 9-2 Vanderbilt at 9-2 Tennessee in Knoxville essentially for a Playoff spot.

Missouri (6-2): They had a long winning streak in Columbia until Alabama popped it. They have the next opportunity to put out A&M's fire. Lose and their Playoff chances are over. Win and they still have to go to Oklahoma but Oklahoma will likely be out of the Playoff race by then. Longshot but not impossible.

Oklahoma (6-2): Couldn't beat Mississippi at home. Next two games are at Tennessee and at Alabama. Stick a fork in 'em, they're done!

SEC Outlook: Best scenario for them would be Vandy winning in Texas and then Tennessee beating Vandy. This would have them with Texas A&M, Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi, Vanderbilt, and Tennessee all 10-2 or better.

Big Ten:

Ohio State (7-0): They have to go to Michigan who they've lost four straight to including last year at home in their national championship season. They'll make the Playoff but don't lock them into Indy just yet.

Indiana (8-0): Lock them into Indy. Three of their remaining opponents are winless in the Big Ten, two of them haven't beaten a P4 opponent and it's late October.

Oregon (7-1): They have road games at a suddenly hot Iowa and at Washington to end the season plus a home game vs. USC. They lose both road games and/or trip up at home to USC and the Ducks won't be entertaining guests in Eugene this December.

Washington (6-2): Their only ranked opponent left is Oregon and they have to come to Seattle. They do have UCLA at the Rose Bowl the week before that. They have by far the most favorable remaining schedule of any 6-2 Big Ten team. If Oregon loses before UW, the Oregon-Washington game essentially becomes a Playoff game, otherwise there's a chance both of them make the Playoff with Oregon being Washington's quality win.

Nebraska (6-2): They have USC and Iowa but both games are at home. Their road games are at UCLA and Penn State. The problem is the Cornhuskers already lost to Michigan at home and at Minnesota, at team Iowa just blew out. Nebraska has the schedule to make the Playoff but they've got to prove it. When Matt Rhule comes to Penn State, the rumors of him being the next PSU coach will likely get louder.

Michigan (6-2): Obviously their Playoff will come down to beating OSU for the 5th time in a row but they can't afford to look past Northwestern "on the road" (will be at Wrigley). Is Northwestern legitimate or have just beaten a bunch of bad teams? If Michigan loses to NW, they won't make the Playoff even if they beat the Buckeyes. Don't forget one of their losses is to Oklahoma, if they run the tables the rest of the way Michigan could conceivably make the Big Ten Championship Game (other Big Ten teams could finish 7-1 and it could come down to a tiebreaker).

Iowa (6-2): Don't look now. Maybe Minnesota (and Wisconsin and Rutgers) just suck. Remember they only lost to Indiana 20-15 which looks really good after IU stomped all over UCLA. But Iowa's still has road games at USC and Nebraska (and UCLA at home). They're a longshot.

USC (6-2): The Trojans have failed their first two road tests vs. Illinois and Notre Dame and still have Nebraska and Oregon to go plus Iowa at home. Another longshot Playoff team.

Best scenario for the Big Ten would be Michigan and Washington running the tables with both picking up big wins to stand out over other 10-2 teams. We still in this scenario could have Oregon and Nebraska also finish 10-2 and if Cincinnati beats Utah and BYU it helps Nebraska's resume.

ACC:

Georgia Tech (8-0): Next two games are on the road with NC State up next. NC State did hand UVa their only loss of the season but UVa almost lost to UNC yesterday. After that it's BC. But Pittsburgh is next but that's in Atlanta. Then comes the biggie, UGa in Atlanta. We saw the footprint with SMU last year of an 11-2 ACC Championship Game loser so barring a complete collapse they should get in.

Miami (6-1): Three road games left, SMU, Virginia Tech, and Pittsburgh. SMU looks easier after they lost at Wake Forest but Virginia Tech looks tougher after they beat Cal. Pittsburgh at the end of the season is going to be tough, especially if it will be cold up north. Should Miami finish 10-2, that Notre Dame win should help them, especially if Notre Dame also finishes 10-2. Unfortunately for them South Florida lost although they're a quality win.

Virginia (7-1): Long road trip to Cal but they just lost at VT (then again UVa almost lost at UNC and at home vs WSU). If there's a team that's going to be out at 10-2 it'll be UVa having only played one ranked opponent all season and losing to two unranked opponents. On the other hand even if they blow an ACC game they still will have the tiebreaker over Louisville and will have a chance at GT in the ACC Championship and we all saw Clemson last year...

Louisville (7-1): Fairly decent chance to get to 11-1 with Virginia Tech and SMU the only road games on their schedule and California, Clemson, and Kentucky at home. They will need help to get to Charlotte with GT and UVa still unbeaten and UVa having beaten Louisville. They'll have the win at Miami in their pocket but they also lose to Virginia HTH.

Pittsburgh (6-2): Notre Dame, at Georgia Tech, Miami are their final three. Good luck. At least they can play spoiler. They're probably the SEC's, Big Ten's, and Big 12's best friend right now...

Wake Forest (5-2): Thank you Crayton for catching they do indeed have two losses. They have to go to Virginia (along with Florida State and Duke). Longshot.

Georgia Tech beating Georgia would help them and the ACC as a conference. Miami already took care of Notre Dame. Louisville beat Miami and Virginia beat Louisville. If the top teams keep winning it'll make for a very interesting conversation come Selection Sunday. It'll be a lot harder to keep out a one loss Virginia or Louisville than a two loss one.

Big 12:

BYU (8-0): Passed their first road test at Iowa State but still have games at Texas Tech and Cincinnati to go. Lose them both and they're staring at that same 10-2 record that kept them out of the Playoff last year.

Texas Tech (7-1): BYU at home, road games are Kansas State and West Virginia. Might even be able to lose the Big 12 Championship Game and still make the Playoff.

Houston (7-1): All their remaining games are winnable, so far only loss was at home to Texas Tech (although they got blown out). After getting Arizona State-Iowa State last year, the Big 12 Championship looks like Texas Tech vs. Houston, a way more popular game for Dallas.

Cincinnati (7-1): Will host BYU but will have to travel to Utah and TCU to end the season. Good story this year but tough road ahead.

Utah (6-2): Their season will be on the line vs. Cincinnati. All their remaining games are winnable but they are likely out of the Big 12 Championship having already lost to both Texas Tech and BYU and their best win is currently Arizona State that already has three losses. If it comes down to 10-2 Utah and 10-2 BYU the Cougars will have the tiebreaker.

TCU (6-2): Still hanging around. They have Cincinnati at home but will go to BYU (good luck there).

I don't think the Big 12 will get more than two bids, they should just try for seeding and hope their top teams win.

Independent:

Notre Dame (5-2): Still have undefeated Navy coming to South Bend and still has to go to Pittsburgh, neither game will be easy.

For the Irish, win out and they should be in, lose one and they're done.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2025 06:41 PM by schmolik.)
10-26-2025 07:03 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #2
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Excellent write up. Easy to forget but Wake also has only 2 losses. Not sure if Duke and SMU also deserve mention; 3 losses but only 1 in conference. All are long shots.

Agree on Ole Miss being in a precarious position with 2 losses. I’d put Vandy in that same boat as well as (cover your ears Aggie fans) A&M.
10-26-2025 12:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #3
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
For fun, here are the current chances I have for 9-3 at larges. Not sure if a human committee would look as kindly at a Gator team that wins out, but the fan in me says the below is legit.

30% Florida (at 8-4)
28% Texas
27% Oklahoma
27% Notre Dame
26% LSU
14% Alabama
12% Illinois
12% USC
11% Georgia
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2025 02:06 PM by Crayton.)
10-26-2025 01:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SouthEastAlaska Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,335
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 508
I Root For: UW
Location:
Post: #4
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Nice summation of the CFP race, well done 04-cheers
10-26-2025 02:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #5
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(10-26-2025 01:36 PM)Crayton Wrote:  For fun, here are the current chances I have for 9-3 at larges. Not sure if a human committee would look as kindly at a Gator team that wins out, but the fan in me says the below is legit.

30% Florida (at 8-4)
28% Texas
27% Oklahoma
27% Notre Dame
26% LSU
14% Alabama
12% Illinois
12% USC
11% Georgia

The SEC schools on that list would all have multiple ranked wins. Unlikely for ND, USC and Illinois. Florida at 8-4 could outpace a lot of 9-3 squads, perhaps most of them, but they’re unlikely to get in over 1 or 2 loss schools. They need a lot of help to even get into the conversation.
10-26-2025 04:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #6
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
I know Florida had the toughest schedule in the country but Texas's is no slouch either and featured a week 1 away journey to top ranked Ohio State. Surely they get the nod at 3 losses over Florida at 4. Obviously it depends on who the other losses are to but I'd put Georgia next after those two, assuming Georgia Tech runs the table outside of their rivalry game, followed by a three loss LSU who at least had the decency to lose to top ten teams and would have upset #4 Alabama in a redemption game. Notre Dame's losses to Miami and A&M are aging like fine wine but if they pick up a third loss it would be to an unranked team late in the year. Still probably make it in over the rest of the SEC due to "anti-regional" bias. Alabama and Oklahoma are similar to each and Oklahoma has H2H over Michigan (who, assuming their 3rd loss is to OSU, have no wins over ranked teams.) After Michigan come the two other Big Ten schools in that list, who have had nothing but disappointment this season. At 3 losses both probably lose out to 2 loss M2 programs.
10-26-2025 04:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Scoochpooch1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,779
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 255
I Root For: P4
Location:
Post: #7
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(10-26-2025 07:03 AM)schmolik Wrote:  For now I will assume 9-3 or worse is an automatic out.

SEC:
Texas A&M (8-0): Still have road games at Missouri and Texas but probably look to be favored in both of them and would probably make the Playoff even if they lost both of them anyway. Right now are probably thinking SEC Championship more than just getting in.

Alabama (7-1): Still have home games against LSU and Oklahoma who both lost home games. After South Carolina yesterday 'Bama probably would prefer LSU remain ranked as they do better vs. ranked teams than unranked but Alabama hasn't lost a home game in the Kalen DeBoer era anyway. They can still blow a game and make the Playoff anyway. Again, SEC Championship is the bigger goal now than just getting in.

Georgia (7-1): Has Texas at home and Georgia Tech in Atlanta. Texas barely beat Mississippi State away which probably isn't that bad since they've played every SEC tough in Starkville but also barely beat Kentucky in Lexington and that is bad. I can't see UT winning in Athens, they couldn't beat UGa in Austin last year. Then GT won't matter to their Playoff chances. It will be interesting when it comes to the SEC Championship. UGa and A&M don't play so who would play Bama if A&M loses a game? Georgia probably doesn't want to play if they lose to Tech, it could be their third loss although I imagine they'll get the benefit of the doubt by the Committee in that case.

Mississippi (7-1): Doesn't play a ranked opponent the rest of the way and won't have to leave the state. You can talk about Mississippi State playing everyone close or about them continually losing and in spectacular fashion. Even if Mississippi does blow the Egg Bowl they'll still finish 10-2. Problem is by the end of the season LSU and Oklahoma, their best wins could wind up not being ranked. If any SEC team gets left out at 10-2 it will be them.

Vanderbilt (7-1): They've got two road games, at Texas and at Tennessee. Win one and they're in the Playoff. Lose both and they're staying home. It's as simple as that. We're still waiting on Arch Manning, if he doesn't play next week that could really help Pimp Vandy.

Texas (6-2): They're not winning at Georgia. Could they essentially spoil Vanderbilt's Playoff chances next week?

Tennessee (6-2): Oklahoma next week is an eliminator between the two schools. They then have to go to Florida where they haven't won since 2003. Luckily for UT Billy Napier is no longer coaching for his job. If Vanderbilt loses at Texas and Tennessee beats Florida, you could have 9-2 Vanderbilt at 9-2 Tennessee in Knoxville essentially for a Playoff spot.

Missouri (6-2): They had a long winning streak in Columbia until Alabama popped it. They have the next opportunity to put out A&M's fire. Lose and their Playoff chances are over. Win and they still have to go to Oklahoma but Oklahoma will likely be out of the Playoff race by then. Longshot but not impossible.

Oklahoma (6-2): Couldn't beat Mississippi at home. Next two games are at Tennessee and at Alabama. Stick a fork in 'em, they're done!

SEC Outlook: Best scenario for them would be Vandy winning in Texas and then Tennessee beating Vandy. This would have them with Texas A&M, Alabama, Georgia, Mississippi, Vanderbilt, and Tennessee all 10-2 or better.

Big Ten:

Ohio State (7-0): They have to go to Michigan who they've lost four straight to including last year at home in their national championship season. They'll make the Playoff but don't lock them into Indy just yet.

Indiana (8-0): Lock them into Indy. Three of their remaining opponents are winless in the Big Ten, two of them haven't beaten a P4 opponent and it's late October.

Oregon (7-1): They have road games at a suddenly hot Iowa and at Washington to end the season plus a home game vs. USC. They lose both road games and/or trip up at home to USC and the Ducks won't be entertaining guests in Eugene this December.

Washington (6-2): Their only ranked opponent left is Oregon and they have to come to Seattle. They do have UCLA at the Rose Bowl the week before that. They have by far the most favorable remaining schedule of any 6-2 Big Ten team. If Oregon loses before UW, the Oregon-Washington game essentially becomes a Playoff game, otherwise there's a chance both of them make the Playoff with Oregon being Washington's quality win.

Nebraska (6-2): They have USC and Iowa but both games are at home. Their road games are at UCLA and Penn State. The problem is the Cornhuskers already lost to Michigan at home and at Minnesota, at team Iowa just blew out. Nebraska has the schedule to make the Playoff but they've got to prove it. When Matt Rhule comes to Penn State, the rumors of him being the next PSU coach will likely get louder.

Michigan (6-2): Obviously their Playoff will come down to beating OSU for the 5th time in a row but they can't afford to look past Northwestern "on the road" (will be at Wrigley). Is Northwestern legitimate or have just beaten a bunch of bad teams? If Michigan loses to NW, they won't make the Playoff even if they beat the Buckeyes. Don't forget one of their losses is to Oklahoma, if they run the tables the rest of the way Michigan could conceivably make the Big Ten Championship Game (other Big Ten teams could finish 7-1 and it could come down to a tiebreaker).

Iowa (6-2): Don't look now. Maybe Minnesota (and Wisconsin and Rutgers) just suck. Remember they only lost to Indiana 20-15 which looks really good after IU stomped all over UCLA. But Iowa's still has road games at USC and Nebraska (and UCLA at home). They're a longshot.

USC (6-2): The Trojans have failed their first two road tests vs. Illinois and Notre Dame and still have Nebraska and Oregon to go plus Iowa at home. Another longshot Playoff team.

Best scenario for the Big Ten would be Michigan and Washington running the tables with both picking up big wins to stand out over other 10-2 teams. We still in this scenario could have Oregon and Nebraska also finish 10-2 and if Cincinnati beats Utah and BYU it helps Nebraska's resume.

ACC:

Georgia Tech (8-0): Next two games are on the road with NC State up next. NC State did hand UVa their only loss of the season but UVa almost lost to UNC yesterday. After that it's BC. But Pittsburgh is next but that's in Atlanta. Then comes the biggie, UGa in Atlanta. We saw the footprint with SMU last year of an 11-2 ACC Championship Game loser so barring a complete collapse they should get in.

Miami (6-1): Three road games left, SMU, Virginia Tech, and Pittsburgh. SMU looks easier after they lost at Wake Forest but Virginia Tech looks tougher after they beat Cal. Pittsburgh at the end of the season is going to be tough, especially if it will be cold up north. Should Miami finish 10-2, that Notre Dame win should help them, especially if Notre Dame also finishes 10-2. Unfortunately for them South Florida lost although they're a quality win.

Virginia (7-1): Long road trip to Cal but they just lost at VT (then again UVa almost lost at UNC and at home vs WSU). If there's a team that's going to be out at 10-2 it'll be UVa having only played one ranked opponent all season and losing to two unranked opponents. On the other hand even if they blow an ACC game they still will have the tiebreaker over Louisville and will have a chance at GT in the ACC Championship and we all saw Clemson last year...

Louisville (7-1): Fairly decent chance to get to 11-1 with Virginia Tech and SMU the only road games on their schedule and California, Clemson, and Kentucky at home. They will need help to get to Charlotte with GT and UVa still unbeaten and UVa having beaten Louisville. They'll have the win at Miami in their pocket but they also lose to Virginia HTH.

Pittsburgh (6-2): Notre Dame, at Georgia Tech, Miami are their final three. Good luck. At least they can play spoiler. They're probably the SEC's, Big Ten's, and Big 12's best friend right now...

Georgia Tech beating Georgia would help them and the ACC as a conference. Miami already took care of Notre Dame. Louisville beat Miami and Virginia beat Louisville. If the top teams keep winning it'll make for a very interesting conversation come Selection Sunday. It'll be a lot harder to keep out a one loss Virginia or Louisville than a two loss one.

Big 12:

BYU (8-0): Passed their first road test at Iowa State but still have games at Texas Tech and Cincinnati to go. Lose them both and they're staring at that same 10-2 record that kept them out of the Playoff last year.

Texas Tech (7-1): BYU at home, road games are Kansas State and West Virginia. Might even be able to lose the Big 12 Championship Game and still make the Playoff.

Houston (7-1): All their remaining games are winnable, so far only loss was at home to Texas Tech (although they got blown out). After getting Arizona State-Iowa State last year, the Big 12 Championship looks like Texas Tech vs. Houston, a way more popular game for Dallas.

Cincinnati (7-1): Will host BYU but will have to travel to Utah and TCU to end the season. Good story this year but tough road ahead.

Utah (6-2): Their season will be on the line vs. Cincinnati. All their remaining games are winnable but they are likely out of the Big 12 Championship having already lost to both Texas Tech and BYU and their best win is currently Arizona State that already has three losses. If it comes down to 10-2 Utah and 10-2 BYU the Cougars will have the tiebreaker.

TCU (6-2): Still hanging around. They have Cincinnati at home but will go to BYU (good luck there).

I don't think the Big 12 will get more than two bids, they should just try for seeding and hope their top teams win.

Independent:

Notre Dame (5-2): Still have undefeated Navy coming to South Bend and still has to go to Pittsburgh, neither game will be easy.

For the Irish, win out and they should be in, lose one and they're done.

As I predicted, ND will be 10-2 as yes both Navy and Pitt will be easy wins. They can still lose one game either way, so they're in just like CFP planned in August.
10-26-2025 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,340
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 975
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #8
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
3x SEC (Georgia and Alabama are more or less locks)
3x B1G (Ohio State and Indiana are more or less locks)
3 total from ACC & B12
ND (they are ranked in the top 12 and will probably win out and wind up about #10)
G5 pick
12th team, either B1G or SEC (SEC has strong edge)

The Big 12 deserves 2 but may get jobbed again.
10-26-2025 08:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1098
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #9
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Updated after Week 9 Games:

3rd loss, bye bye:
SEC: Tennessee
Big Ten: Nebraska
ACC: Wake Forest

SEC:
Texas A&M (8-0): Still have the road games at Missouri and Texas with Texas looking tougher after they beat Vanderbilt yesterday.

Alabama (7-1): Oklahoma might not be a pushover but Alabama should be a bigger challenge for Oklahoma than Tennessee was and they'll want revenge after ending their Playoff hopes last season.

Georgia (8-1): That was a sweat vs. Florida. Texas looks like a tough game but they're a way different team on the road than at home. Georgia Tech looked really bad yesterday but if UGa played like they did yesterday that game could still be close. Last year they only went to 8 overtimes...

Mississippi (8-1): You know their schedule's easy when Mississippi State's the toughest game on their schedule. Oh wait, they actually won yesterday. You know you suck when you not only lose to Mississippi State but at home! Can they fire an interim head coach?

Texas (7-2): Well they're definitely a better team in the state of Texas (Dallas included) than they are outside of it (including Florida, Mississippi State, and Kentucky). Unfortunately for them they're not playing Georgia in the state of Texas.

Vanderbilt (7-2): Bad news is they lost. Good news is Tennessee lost at home to Oklahoma and that game in Knoxville looks winnable now.

Missouri (7-2): Next up is undefeated A&M. They'll play Oklahoma in Norman which looks a lot tougher now. Looks like a longshot.

Oklahoma (7-2): Well they got over the first hurdle but winning in Tuscaloosa will be a lot tougher.

SEC Outlook: They essentially lost Tennessee as a Playoff team. Now they have to hope UT doesn't ruin Vanderbilt's chances during Rivalry Week. The SEC also had to like both Georgia Tech and Miami tripping over themselves as that potentially could open up Playoff spots for them.

Big Ten:

Ohio State (8-0): Still counting down to Michigan.

Indiana (9-0): "The Bear" said on FOX that he wouldn't be surprised if IU was ranked #1 by the CFP Committee come Tuesday in the first CFP rankings.

Oregon (7-1): Tough road ahead of them (at Iowa, USC, at Washington) but also opportunities, enough to withstand a loss.

Washington (6-2): Barring an upset in the Rose Bowl to UCLA, it's beat Oregon at home to get to 10-2 and a potential Playoff spot.

Michigan (6-2): Just like Washington, they have a trap game at Wrigley Field vs. Northwestern and then Ohio State at home to get to 10-2 to make the Playoff.

USC (6-2): They won the pivotal game at Nebraska but they still have a game at Oregon plus a game at home vs. Iowa.

Iowa (6-2): Oregon next week, USC and Nebraska still on the road although Nebraska has now lost two home games.

Big 10 Outlook: The more 10-2 teams they get the better. On the other hand, they'd also like Ohio State to win out to make their path as easy as possible as opposed to last year's tough path (not to mention they'd prefer OSU and IU be on opposite sides of the draw in hopes of an OSU/IU national championship). The nightmare for the Big Ten is a whole bunch of 9-3 teams.

Big 12:

BYU (8-0): Still have Texas Tech and Cincinnati on the road to go. Not sure 10-2 gets them in after last year. They need to hope a lot of SEC and Big Ten teams get their third loss.

Texas Tech (8-1): Not sure how pathetic West Virginia won at Houston. Assuming Tech runs the table in the Big 12, 11-2 (losing in the Championship) is better than 10-2 as we saw last year with SMU (who lost to BYU in the regular season by the way). The game Saturday is big (even bigger as Houston's choke job means Tech can get to Arlington with Houston likely not joining them giving them a bigger home field advantage)

Cincinnati (7-2): Lost at Utah pretty badly but still ahead of them in the Big 12 standings since their other loss was a non conference game. They also host BYU later in the season. If Cincinnati wins out, they go to the Big 12 Championship Game (either BYU hands Texas Tech a second loss or Cincinnati hands BYU a second loss). Cincinnati though must go to TCU in the regular season finale and if they play like they did at Utah it won't matter.

Utah (7-2): Got a key win over Cincinnati. Still also trail both BYU and Texas Tech in the standings with both of them beating Utah. Making it to the Big 12 Championship Game is a longshot, both teams are likely ahead of Utah in the Big 12 Playoff pecking order, and three Big 12 Playoff teams is asking a lot.

Houston (7-2): Not eliminated from finishing 10-2 but if you're losing at home to West Virginia you're not finishing 10-2. Their schedule is winnable (at UCF, TCU, at Baylor) but West Virginia at home was winnable.

TCU (6-2): Their best win is over a 5-4 Baylor team and they still have road games at BYU and at Houston although West Virginia won at Houston.

Big 12 Outlook: Hope Texas Tech and BYU win out. There's a path for Cincinnati. Just hope no more West Virginia's happen.

ACC:

Virginia (8-1): Another close win for UVa. At least Florida State won yesterday. Chances are Louisville will be ranked higher than Miami and Georgia Tech also lost to the same NC State team UVa lost to earlier in the season. Virginia's now a game up in the ACC with a tiebreaker over Louisville and winning the ACC Championship would practically lock them into the Playoff.

Georgia Tech (8-1): The loss doesn't eliminate GT but it certainly takes a lot of leeway away from them and makes their in state clash with UGa more important. The CFP Committee put an 11-2 SMU in last year's Playoff but would they give the same leeway to a three loss GT which doesn't have a signature win? If they don't beat Pittsburgh at home, they very well might not even make the ACC Championship.

Louisville (7-1): The bad news is Miami's loss to SMU makes the Cardinals' win over Miami not look as good (not to mention Louisville themselves still has to go to Dallas later in the season). The good news is with Georgia Tech losing there is a path to Charlotte if Georgia Tech and Louisville tie behind Virginia (or better yet if Pittsburgh beats Georgia Tech and Louisville and Pittsburgh tie behind Virginia, Louisville would win the tiebreaker). Maybe better yet would be Louisville just finishing 11-1 and being left out of the ACC Championship, I'd love to see the CFP Committee leave an 11-1 Louisville out, especially if their one loss is to ACC Champion Virginia.

Pittsburgh (7-2): Bad news? One loss and they're out and they've got Notre Dame, at Georgia Tech, and Miami. Good news? Win them all and they'll have an impressive resume.

Miami (6-2): That loss hurts. Win out (including beating Pittsburgh) and they'll still have that win over Notre Dame in their favor. All of a sudden NC State isn't a gimme after beating both Virginia and Georgia Tech but at least that game is in Miami.

ACC Outlook: I don't think 10-2 is good for ACC teams, especially since Virginia and Georgia Tech already have losses to 5-4 NC State.

Notre Dame (6-2): Navy and then at Pittsburgh. Have no margin of error.
11-02-2025 08:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,123
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #10
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
It's going to be very entertaining to see how the committee ranks Miami-FL and Notre Dame on Tuesday and to hear their justification for doing so.
11-02-2025 12:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1098
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #11
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)
11-02-2025 12:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #12
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(10-26-2025 04:51 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  I know Florida had the toughest schedule in the country but Texas's is no slouch either and featured a week 1 away journey to top ranked Ohio State. Surely they get the nod at 3 losses over Florida at 4. Obviously it depends on who the other losses are to but I'd put Georgia next after those two, assuming Georgia Tech runs the table outside of their rivalry game, followed by a three loss LSU who at least had the decency to lose to top ten teams and would have upset #4 Alabama in a redemption game. Notre Dame's losses to Miami and A&M are aging like fine wine but if they pick up a third loss it would be to an unranked team late in the year. Still probably make it in over the rest of the SEC due to "anti-regional" bias. Alabama and Oklahoma are similar to each and Oklahoma has H2H over Michigan (who, assuming their 3rd loss is to OSU, have no wins over ranked teams.) After Michigan come the two other Big Ten schools in that list, who have had nothing but disappointment this season. At 3 losses both probably lose out to 2 loss M2 programs.

Yeah, as much as it grinds my gears to say it, Texas is looking better today. It's interesting to see how the Committee considers all of those squeakers against weaker opponents vs having such an extremely difficult schedule. Last year, I think the squeakers disqualify them. This year, there's a decent chance that extremely difficult SOS gets them the nod. If they finish at 9-3 with a top 10 SOS and several excellent wins, then that should get them in ahead of a whole lot of 10-2 schools from the P4 or even P2. Perhaps they're even in over another 10-2 SEC school like, say, Vanderbilt who had an easier overall schedule and lost the h2h with Texas. Ofc, OU's schedule is even tougher than Texas', so no chance to jump ahead of a 10-2 OU.

I'm starting to get optimistic about 5 SEC teams in the CFP now:

A&M
Alabama
Georgia
Ole Miss
All 4 of the above have one or perhaps even 2 games to give.

Texas
OU
Vanderbilt
Missouri
Vandy and Missouri probably need to win out, OUT might each have a game to spare, depending on what happens elsewhere.

Obviously a lot can and will change in these last few weeks, but the picture right now is encouraging for Birmingham.

On the B1G side, things are looking pretty encouraging, too. With all the carnage in the M2 over the past couple of weeks, and with ND's schedule taking such a hit, there's a very real chance that there are 9 bids spread out amongst the P2. Assuming the SEC schools all beat each other other and we end up with 5, that leaves 4 for the B1G:

Indiana
OSU
-pretty close to locks for both with 2 games to give and only 4 left to play

Oregon
USC
Iowa
Michigan
Washington
-2 of the above, lots of games between the top 7 overall should eliminate some but boost resume for others. Iowa, Oregon and USC each plays the other 2, Washington plays Oregon and Michigan ofc has their easy W against OSU. Worst possible outcome is Oregon smokes out everyone else and Michigan loses to OSU, in that case it's almost certainly only 3 bids. In most other outcomes, 4 is a very real possibility.
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025 01:01 PM by bryanw1995.)
11-02-2025 12:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #13
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
After Michigan and PSU flamed out early on (Illinois too, but Indiana filled their slot) I've been on the 3 Big Ten teams train for nearly a month now. Between the three of them they'll be handing all of those other schools at least one loss each. Then there are a load of 9-3 SEC schools ready to fight it out with 1 loss ACC and Big XII schools for the last AL spots. Take all those "second tier" Big Ten schools, there isn't a signature win to be had from the lot of them.
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025 01:18 PM by The Beaver.)
11-02-2025 01:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
CardinalJim Online
Welcome to The New Age
*

Posts: 22,188
Joined: Apr 2004
Reputation: 4795
I Root For: Louisville
Location: Rocky Knob, KY
Post: #14
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 12:42 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)

Texas is the worst 7-2 team in the country. Manning is highly overrated.
11-02-2025 02:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1098
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #15
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 02:04 PM)CardinalJim Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:42 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)

Texas is the worst 7-2 team in the country. Manning is highly overrated.

They have wins over Oklahoma and Vanderbilt and one of their losses is to undefeated Ohio State.
11-02-2025 02:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TrojanCampaign Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,086
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 335
I Root For: USC, AAMU,
Location: Huntsville
Post: #16
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 02:04 PM)CardinalJim Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:42 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)

Texas is the worst 7-2 team in the country. Manning is highly overrated.

I would say Texas is the most underperforming team in the country. Texas SHOULD be undefeated right now. But the fact that they have lost two games despite having so much talent is baffling.

If Manning did not have such a poor performance against Ohio State they would have won that game.
11-02-2025 02:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


CardinalJim Online
Welcome to The New Age
*

Posts: 22,188
Joined: Apr 2004
Reputation: 4795
I Root For: Louisville
Location: Rocky Knob, KY
Post: #17
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
I watched the Texas Kentucky game. I saw how bad UK made Manning and Texas look. Might well be the ugliest football game of the year.

Just painful to watch.
11-03-2025 01:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,872
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #18
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 02:22 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 02:04 PM)CardinalJim Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:42 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)

Texas is the worst 7-2 team in the country. Manning is highly overrated.

They have wins over Oklahoma and Vanderbilt and one of their losses is to undefeated Ohio State.

And in Columbus, the only team to get closer than 18 to Ohio St.
11-03-2025 01:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,872
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #19
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 02:29 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 02:04 PM)CardinalJim Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:42 PM)schmolik Wrote:  Here's my first top 10:

10. Texas (7-2)
9. Oregon (7-1)
8. Texas Tech (8-1)
7. BYU (8-0)
6. Mississippi (8-1)
5. Georgia (7-1)
4. Alabama (7-1)
3. Texas A&M (8-0)
2. Ohio State (8-0)
1. Indiana (9-0)

Texas is the worst 7-2 team in the country. Manning is highly overrated.

I would say Texas is the most underperforming team in the country. Texas SHOULD be undefeated right now. But the fact that they have lost two games despite having so much talent is baffling.

If Manning did not have such a poor performance against Ohio State they would have won that game.

Its not really Manning. Its the offensive line that is the weakness. They looked really good against Vanderbilt.
11-03-2025 01:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TerryD Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 16,979
Joined: Feb 2006
Reputation: 1269
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location: Grayson Highlands
Post: #20
RE: P4 College Football Playoff Outlook
(11-02-2025 08:06 AM)schmolik Wrote:  Updated after Week 9 Games:

3rd loss, bye bye:
SEC: Tennessee
Big Ten: Nebraska
ACC: Wake Forest

SEC:
Texas A&M (8-0): Still have the road games at Missouri and Texas with Texas looking tougher after they beat Vanderbilt yesterday.

Alabama (7-1): Oklahoma might not be a pushover but Alabama should be a bigger challenge for Oklahoma than Tennessee was and they'll want revenge after ending their Playoff hopes last season.

Georgia (8-1): That was a sweat vs. Florida. Texas looks like a tough game but they're a way different team on the road than at home. Georgia Tech looked really bad yesterday but if UGa played like they did yesterday that game could still be close. Last year they only went to 8 overtimes...

Mississippi (8-1): You know their schedule's easy when Mississippi State's the toughest game on their schedule. Oh wait, they actually won yesterday. You know you suck when you not only lose to Mississippi State but at home! Can they fire an interim head coach?

Texas (7-2): Well they're definitely a better team in the state of Texas (Dallas included) than they are outside of it (including Florida, Mississippi State, and Kentucky). Unfortunately for them they're not playing Georgia in the state of Texas.

Vanderbilt (7-2): Bad news is they lost. Good news is Tennessee lost at home to Oklahoma and that game in Knoxville looks winnable now.

Missouri (7-2): Next up is undefeated A&M. They'll play Oklahoma in Norman which looks a lot tougher now. Looks like a longshot.

Oklahoma (7-2): Well they got over the first hurdle but winning in Tuscaloosa will be a lot tougher.

SEC Outlook: They essentially lost Tennessee as a Playoff team. Now they have to hope UT doesn't ruin Vanderbilt's chances during Rivalry Week. The SEC also had to like both Georgia Tech and Miami tripping over themselves as that potentially could open up Playoff spots for them.

Big Ten:

Ohio State (8-0): Still counting down to Michigan.

Indiana (9-0): "The Bear" said on FOX that he wouldn't be surprised if IU was ranked #1 by the CFP Committee come Tuesday in the first CFP rankings.

Oregon (7-1): Tough road ahead of them (at Iowa, USC, at Washington) but also opportunities, enough to withstand a loss.

Washington (6-2): Barring an upset in the Rose Bowl to UCLA, it's beat Oregon at home to get to 10-2 and a potential Playoff spot.

Michigan (6-2): Just like Washington, they have a trap game at Wrigley Field vs. Northwestern and then Ohio State at home to get to 10-2 to make the Playoff.

USC (6-2): They won the pivotal game at Nebraska but they still have a game at Oregon plus a game at home vs. Iowa.

Iowa (6-2): Oregon next week, USC and Nebraska still on the road although Nebraska has now lost two home games.

Big 10 Outlook: The more 10-2 teams they get the better. On the other hand, they'd also like Ohio State to win out to make their path as easy as possible as opposed to last year's tough path (not to mention they'd prefer OSU and IU be on opposite sides of the draw in hopes of an OSU/IU national championship). The nightmare for the Big Ten is a whole bunch of 9-3 teams.

Big 12:

BYU (8-0): Still have Texas Tech and Cincinnati on the road to go. Not sure 10-2 gets them in after last year. They need to hope a lot of SEC and Big Ten teams get their third loss.

Texas Tech (8-1): Not sure how pathetic West Virginia won at Houston. Assuming Tech runs the table in the Big 12, 11-2 (losing in the Championship) is better than 10-2 as we saw last year with SMU (who lost to BYU in the regular season by the way). The game Saturday is big (even bigger as Houston's choke job means Tech can get to Arlington with Houston likely not joining them giving them a bigger home field advantage)

Cincinnati (7-2): Lost at Utah pretty badly but still ahead of them in the Big 12 standings since their other loss was a non conference game. They also host BYU later in the season. If Cincinnati wins out, they go to the Big 12 Championship Game (either BYU hands Texas Tech a second loss or Cincinnati hands BYU a second loss). Cincinnati though must go to TCU in the regular season finale and if they play like they did at Utah it won't matter.

Utah (7-2): Got a key win over Cincinnati. Still also trail both BYU and Texas Tech in the standings with both of them beating Utah. Making it to the Big 12 Championship Game is a longshot, both teams are likely ahead of Utah in the Big 12 Playoff pecking order, and three Big 12 Playoff teams is asking a lot.

Houston (7-2): Not eliminated from finishing 10-2 but if you're losing at home to West Virginia you're not finishing 10-2. Their schedule is winnable (at UCF, TCU, at Baylor) but West Virginia at home was winnable.

TCU (6-2): Their best win is over a 5-4 Baylor team and they still have road games at BYU and at Houston although West Virginia won at Houston.

Big 12 Outlook: Hope Texas Tech and BYU win out. There's a path for Cincinnati. Just hope no more West Virginia's happen.

ACC:

Virginia (8-1): Another close win for UVa. At least Florida State won yesterday. Chances are Louisville will be ranked higher than Miami and Georgia Tech also lost to the same NC State team UVa lost to earlier in the season. Virginia's now a game up in the ACC with a tiebreaker over Louisville and winning the ACC Championship would practically lock them into the Playoff.

Georgia Tech (8-1): The loss doesn't eliminate GT but it certainly takes a lot of leeway away from them and makes their in state clash with UGa more important. The CFP Committee put an 11-2 SMU in last year's Playoff but would they give the same leeway to a three loss GT which doesn't have a signature win? If they don't beat Pittsburgh at home, they very well might not even make the ACC Championship.

Louisville (7-1): The bad news is Miami's loss to SMU makes the Cardinals' win over Miami not look as good (not to mention Louisville themselves still has to go to Dallas later in the season). The good news is with Georgia Tech losing there is a path to Charlotte if Georgia Tech and Louisville tie behind Virginia (or better yet if Pittsburgh beats Georgia Tech and Louisville and Pittsburgh tie behind Virginia, Louisville would win the tiebreaker). Maybe better yet would be Louisville just finishing 11-1 and being left out of the ACC Championship, I'd love to see the CFP Committee leave an 11-1 Louisville out, especially if their one loss is to ACC Champion Virginia.

Pittsburgh (7-2): Bad news? One loss and they're out and they've got Notre Dame, at Georgia Tech, and Miami. Good news? Win them all and they'll have an impressive resume.

Miami (6-2): That loss hurts. Win out (including beating Pittsburgh) and they'll still have that win over Notre Dame in their favor. All of a sudden NC State isn't a gimme after beating both Virginia and Georgia Tech but at least that game is in Miami.

ACC Outlook: I don't think 10-2 is good for ACC teams, especially since Virginia and Georgia Tech already have losses to 5-4 NC State.

Notre Dame (6-2): Navy and then at Pittsburgh. Have no margin of error.


ND has had no margin of error since week 2.

Very similar to last season's playoff chances after week 2.

ND reeled off 10 straight wins to make the playoff last year.

The Irish have won 6 in a row this year. It needs to win the next 4 games to repeat history from last year.
(This post was last modified: 11-03-2025 01:42 PM by TerryD.)
11-03-2025 01:40 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.