Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CBS TV ratings 2025
Author Message
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #141
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 10:01 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.
Bullet you and Frank and both wrong. The SEC is playing the long game much better than the Big Ten which reminds me of chain store spread. The more locations you build in chain stores the more tax write off they have, so they keep spreading until one day there is no good reason to spread further and then what looked like the superior short term strategy of using your perks to your advantage collapses them.

The SEC is getting stronger regionally, it sacrifices more now for better exposure realizing that their brand is growing without having to overreach markets to make it appear stronger and realizing that less overhead means more profit. That's why all ledger lines favor the SEC so much more than just media money which you and Frank can't see but for different reasons. For Frank it's the only number he can spin for his conference and his natural audience for the blog.

You can't see it because you are focused on that one line in the ledger fully, until you look at the next. 2008 was aberrant. I was fortunate to work in non-profit at the time and see countless people with meager means acquiring home loans. The bell went off in my head that there was funny money being created in the system somewhere so I got the hell out of equities and into commodities. The vast majority of my buddies lost their butts in equities setting more than a few of them back in the retirement timeline.

My point? Neither the SEC nor ACC, nor the networks saw that coming. That little fiasco wasn't part of anyone's plan. You allude to that but don't make the connection to the fact it didn't alter the SEC's superior financial situation an iota. Why? Because it didn't alter its markets, its profitability across all lines of revenue, and it didn't cause it to make a knee jerk reaction by trying to outgrow its problem. The SEC's financial model was organic enough to ride out that mini global financial meltdown.

There's another coming and likely a world war along with it. That will touch us all. That's my free for today offering. Looking at what actually is and what was, is not the same thing as looking to the horizon to plan for tomorrow. The reason the SEC is where it is, is because it remained true to its branding as a regional conference by expanding only within that region and then by expanding from the other region most organically like it, the Southwest. We kept our culture.

The Big Ten's appeal was that it had just as strong of a culture, and while the Pacific West organically grew out of the Big Ten and Plains states' diaspora during the depression, Dust Bowl days, and to supply workers for West Coast industrialization, it grew its own culture which was alien to that of the more conservative (talking social mores not politics) of the Northern Midwest. Now their desire to expand into the Southeast will meet with more in the mouth vomit responses than it did when they went west. It simply isn't their identity. The SEC's identity has remained largely intact through expansion. The Big Ten is becoming unrecognizable to their own people. And the masses always vote with their feet and pocketbook, and apparently with their channel remote.

You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Look - I don’t think the SEC is going anywhere. The product is strong and the TV ratings reflect it. However, the media rights aren’t some tangential issue - it’s the very core of the financial value that the *conference* (not talking about individual school ticket sales and donations) brings to the table. The only reason why we’re talking about FSU, Clemson and UNC leaving the ACC is because they’re locked into an even longer and worse media rights deal with ESPN. The whole reason why the Pac-12 collapsed was literally the lack of a sufficient media rights deal.

As I’ve stated, I think Greg Sankey is a great leader for the SEC *now*. I would have full faith in his ability to negotiate the largest media rights deal in college sports history if/when he’s given the opportunity. That doesn’t detract that he’s handcuffed by the decisions of his predecessors to sign the 2014 long-term deal with ESPN, which means he has to squeeze out money from ESPN in other ways such as going to a 9-game conference schedule. I actually commend Sankey for being able to do that, but anyone giving him truth serum surely would rationally believe that he wishes he could go to the open market for the SEC rights far earlier than 2034. The NFL is going to opt out of its current TV deals that were signed right at the same time as the 2020 SEC-ESPN deal so that it’s back on the open market in 2029. Anyone that has premium sports rights to sell wants to be on the open market ASAP, which is why the Big Ten and anyone else that can be on the open market in the next few years is happy with the timing. This isn’t just a college football issue, but rather about the entire media ecosystem that wants premium sports rights wherever possible. The SEC simply can’t take advantage of it despite having the best viewership of any US sport property other than the NFL.

Frank everyone plays the hand they are dealt. The last contract signed isn't known to the public yet. The SEC's product remains the most organic in the industry. As I pointed out long ago when ESPN assembled the ACC and then underpaid them they were assembling a conference of product they could leverage and which wasn't paid full value, and why would they do that? To use those pieces as realignment progressed to get what they want. It was a brilliant chess game. And they paid the ACC enough and have propped them up enough so that they are the last largely unscathed set of undervalued properties left and they extended their contract beyond that of the SEC and Big Ten. They've set themselves up as the last broker of the last collections of valuable pieces, including having the last crown jewel in tow.

Now who are they going to benefit? Obviously themselves! But they have the most profitable of the college sports products signed 100%. They have a revenue model they will preserve. If they can land a piece of the Big Ten they will do it, but they won't do it at the expense of pissing off the SEC.

The SEC will stake its claim if the ACC breaks apart and inasmuch as what the SEC wants preserves the ESPN revenue model, they'll get it. And as far as what profits ESPN indirectly profits FOX there won't be any major war for bidding up the price of that product either. The most valuable pieces of the ACC are Florida State and Clemson, followed by North Carolina and Virginia as markets. Miami has value as well as does Louisville but due to factors beyond Louisville's control they aren't really in play for either of our conferences.

If the networks control the implosion of the ACC everyone will get something or most of what they want and FOX and ESPN will rebuild the Big 12 or ACC as a 50/50 interest for product to fill streaming services or lesser time slots. If ESPN wants to play the long game they will find a way to keep the most rebellious of the ACC product in the SEC, and provide enough to keep the rest in line with N.D. in tow and simply wait out the issues developing around inequity in the Big Ten.

But that isn't the likeliest outcome since both ESPN and FOX very likely want the centerpiece of their college football offering to be the CFP, and likely a new tournament for the basketball. That tells me compromise will be expected at the conference and network levels until an agreement is reached. And if that is what ESPN wants it is what they will get because they hold the final available product for the restructuring of the upper tier and for with which to fill some or all of the SEC's desires as they align with ESPN's objectives, or to augment the Big Ten in cooperation with FOX so that the runway is cleared to land the larger CFP and Tournament postseason revenues they covet.

Sankey has played his hand well. Warren sluffed some cards he should have held and likely jumped the shark by going West before waiting on the East. It was a stupid move only because the SEC was never going to go that far West. Warren's was a horrible read of the room in that regard. If Warren waits on the PAC schools, which weren't going to get the TV contract they wanted because their numbers were horrible and that due to lousy management more than market issues, they were still going to be available and desirous of a move later. Those apples were still on a tree and weren't going to rot if the Big Ten waits. The prizes were always to the East.

If ESPN keeps the ACC intact because they are profitable, they will likely cover their revenue model's vulnerability by removing 2 to 4 of the most valuable and keeping them in the SEC. Nothing has changed since I described that a few years back. Well here we are and the SEC has acquired all objects of interest to its West save perhaps Kansas, and now is dealing with as trusted a partner in these matters as they could have, over a product which shared the same historical roots as the SEC, has far more ties to the SEC than to the Big Ten, and if movement happened it would essentially be in house with distant family.

That Frank is crappy position for the Big Ten to navigate on a good day. The ratings situation makes that day less optimal. Legally you will have a shot at some of those schools, but realistically the advantages are not with you. ESPN can make the transitions to the SEC much easier for all involved. ESPN will be looking after its own interests and to a significant degree those of a partner it would love to keep, the SEC. The distance and regional culture is similar to that of the SEC more so than the Big Ten and the travel and sports emphasis alignment sympathetic enough to also favor the SEC, especially with regards to diamond sports.

Had you committed less resources to attracting schools in the far West you would be in a better position to make offers to the East and the specter of coast-to-coast travel wouldn't be as haunting (it is Halloween).

Sankey figured out some time ago, and learned from Slive, that the most serious entity to do business with for sports broadcasting was ESPN. For CBS and NBC and FOX it was a department within a larger organization. For ESPN it was the organization and when Disney acquired ABC it overcame the need to have that OTA historical network affiliation. CBS and NBC have diminished in their college sports role since that acquisition was made, and ABC has benefitted even if they go their own way.

You see Frank, it was about the association/relationship and not the short term profit. The SEC found the best horse to ride in the derby and stuck with it. It turns out that it was also the best horse for the Preakness and Belmont. They can sprint and they can endure for distance and their business and ours are the only issue for the network instead of a department in a larger one.

Sankey outplayed Warren. Petitti is the one who inherited a crappy hand. And that's not just how I see it, it is the way it actually is. How do I know? The SEC is still what it defined itself to be. The Big Ten is the one which moved away from its core identity to try to survive.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 11:02 AM by JRsec.)
10-30-2025 10:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #142
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 09:09 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.

I get what you're saying, but 2008 was a long time ago. That's less relevant than what has been proposed thus far.

I'm not saying the SEC isn't interested in money, I'm simply saying it's possible that's not the only thing they're interested in. If it was their desire to take everything to market and get as much as possible then they would. My contention is I don't really see that as the pattern.

So we can either conclude SEC leadership is hamstrung, not as competent as needed, or is intentionally handling their affairs differently than what might be expected in an environment where everyone is focused on the prime figure of the media deal. Each of those are possible outcomes.

My contention with Frank is that he's not actually in a position to know which one it is. I'm not either, by the way. These are my opinions and not ironclad fact. Nonetheless, I think there's good circumstantial evidence for my perspective. it's not spin when I'm perfectly capable of admitting my outlook could be incorrect.

Or, it's just a pure matter of luck, that the SEC signed their deals in 2008 and 2020, probably the worst two years of the last quarter-century to sign a long term deal.
10-30-2025 11:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #143
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 11:06 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:09 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.

I get what you're saying, but 2008 was a long time ago. That's less relevant than what has been proposed thus far.

I'm not saying the SEC isn't interested in money, I'm simply saying it's possible that's not the only thing they're interested in. If it was their desire to take everything to market and get as much as possible then they would. My contention is I don't really see that as the pattern.

So we can either conclude SEC leadership is hamstrung, not as competent as needed, or is intentionally handling their affairs differently than what might be expected in an environment where everyone is focused on the prime figure of the media deal. Each of those are possible outcomes.

My contention with Frank is that he's not actually in a position to know which one it is. I'm not either, by the way. These are my opinions and not ironclad fact. Nonetheless, I think there's good circumstantial evidence for my perspective. it's not spin when I'm perfectly capable of admitting my outlook could be incorrect.

Or, it's just a pure matter of luck, that the SEC signed their deals in 2008 and 2020, probably the worst two years of the last quarter-century to sign a long term deal.

You sign your new deals when? When the old ones expire. The college football sports bubble is going to pop sometime after 2035. Why? Boomer's will be statistically gone as a driving force for the games, and their dollars saved will have been largely consumed by assisted living, nursing homes, and end of life care. There is a reason those three industries have been heavily invested in by very wealthy corporate groups. And hey, that's the upside. We may have a big damn war first. 07-coffee3
10-30-2025 11:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #144
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 06:36 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:21 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:29 AM)JRsec Wrote:  ....
Nope! And that's why you never have grasped the SEC mindset. CBS sealed its fate when it refused a pro rata share to Texas A&M and Missouri. ...
....
CBS knew two years before the contract was up how badly they screwed things up. ....

Here's my outlook in general response to the above sentiments.

The SEC is similar to Notre Dame in that they value things other than money.


I mean, if loyalty was the driver, then the SEC should have re-signed with CBS, a company that it had been with since 1994, the dawn of the conference-specific TV deals.

Loyalty isn't just about longevity, though. It's about a positive relationship, and after 2011 the SEC - CBS marriage was an unhappy one. JRsec, I know you very much dislike Clay Travis, but he is very good at "skating to where the puck is going". He was calling for CBS to sell the package to ESPN back in 2014. That's how ruptured the relationship was.

https://www.outkick.com/analysis/cbss-re...-its-games

CBS had a point in 2011-- they weren't getting any new content. The SEC GOTW package probably didn't get 17% better by adding Mizzou and Texas A&M. But there's such a thing as negotiating, and CBS could have reasonably asked to up the number of games they were showing.

I don't expect business people to have total clairvoyance 20 years down the road, so I don't blame the 2008 SEC leadership for locking in with ESPN. Especially adding the SEC Network a few years later, having all-but-one game on the ESPN family of networks has been very very good to the SEC.

A long contract also provided insurance against downside risks. If Alabama had hired Mack Brown and Texas had hired Nick Saban, maybe things work out differently.

If Larry Ellison decides between now and 2030 that his son is actually a fool, the media landscape looks a lot darker and colder and the Big Ten might envy the SEC's guaranteed money.

FWIW, I do well remember how the SEC responded (with a hissy fit) circa 2012-2013 to CBS not being willing to up the terms of the 2008 contract. IMO that was wrong thinking on the SEC's part, as CBS's position was simply to stick to the terms of the 2008, which they had every right to do. I mean, if around 2013 SEC ratings had been significantly lower than CBS expected when it signed that 2008 deal, would it have been OK for CBS to throw a hissy fit if it asked for the $55m a year amount to be lowered to $40m and the SEC said "no"? Not IMO.

To me, if you value loyalty when dealing with a partner who you go back to 1994, you don't take that kind of petulant stance with them, as IMO the SEC did with CBS.

That response, IMO, is one indicative of an overwhelming focus on the money involved, not loyalty-partnership factors as has been claimed by others here. That's why I mentioned it. I think it supports my view that going back to the 1990s, the SEC has made media deals with one primary goal, maximizing money. It just IMO hasn't been nearly as good as the B1G at it, not for the past 20 years.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 01:01 PM by quo vadis.)
10-30-2025 12:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #145
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

JR, if the numbers come out, and by which I assume we are talking about the tax filings, and it shows that the SEC with TX and OU are getting significantly more than I think it is getting - which for the record would mean equal to or more than the B1G is getting, as I have maintained that even with the 2020 deal the SEC will still be making less than the B1G, though the recent deal for a 9th game that pays about $5m more tightens that up, but still less - than I will certainly eat all the crow you choose to dish up and I will gladly acknowledge I was wrong about that. I don't think I've ever claimed I know for sure, I typically say "IMO".

We will see.
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 07:45 AM by quo vadis.)
10-30-2025 12:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #146
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 09:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I admit quite often when I’m wrong. I also critique the Big Ten quite often. I’m an alum of a Big Ten school, but I actually acknowledge when they have a disadvantage against the SEC. And no, I don’t believe that if people actually read and understood my analysis on the GOR (that schools can’t just unilaterally break them and time reduces the damages and the ultimate settlement was still based on time) that I was wrong about it, but if you want to position it that way, then that’s fine. If you want to throw out a laundry list of where I’ve made a wrong prediction, then that’s fine, too. I have plenty of them and many are even on my own website that I can’t hide from.

However, on this issue, there is an actual scoreboard via years of tax filings: the Big Ten distributes more conference money than the SEC. Seeing that there is very little variance between the Big Ten and SEC on other types of conference revenue (and if anything, the SEC historically has more bowl revenue than the Big Ten), that difference is explained by the Big Ten having higher media rights revenue. Seeing that the most recent tax filings don’t fully take into account the Big Ten’s newest media deals that are even larger, that difference is almost certainly going to expand (although I will admit that is an educated prediction as opposed to historical data unlike prior tax filings).

Many SEC partisans (sorry that I didn’t make myself clear that this wasn’t Greg Sankey himself stating this) with few exceptions (such as quo) for whatever reason try to spin this a million different ways that have nothing to do with finances when the reality is simply that the SEC signed an undermarket long-term deal. There is little question in my own mind that the SEC would be getting more money in media rights than the Big Ten if they were able to go to the open market today. (Is that enough spin for you coming from a Big Ten fan?) I can readily admit that the Big Ten media rights advantage has to do with management and timing and calculated risks as opposed to only the on-the-field product… which is exactly what the *conference* is supposed to be doing beyond just letting the on-the-field results be the sole determinant of value. I don’t say that from the vantage point of the Big Ten being a superior collection of football teams, but rather the SEC actually *is* the superior collection of football teams yet has managed to not get paid what it’s worth due to multiple long-term mistakes. The fact that it can’t be rectified until 2034 *should* be a point that makes every SEC school angry as much as the ACC schools are angry at their own media rights deal, but as I’ve repeatedly stated, I do think Greg Sankey knows how to control his flock in the way that Jim Delany did for the Big Ten before and that makes a massive difference.

If we have seen anything in the past 20 years, it's that ANY very long term agreement has eventually come to be seen as "under market". Take out all the fluff, and that's the one thing I think all of us can agree on. The B1G has done the best job of keeping their agreements very short, and thus, they've been able to keep hitting the market before others. I'd like to see the SEC go with something shorter this next time.
10-30-2025 04:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #147
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.
10-31-2025 07:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #148
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 07:48 AM by quo vadis.)
10-31-2025 07:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #149
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3
10-31-2025 09:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #150
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

JR, I appreciate the point about total revenue. But IMO, that is not a conference issue, and usually these discussions are about conferences. Since within a conference, especially conferences like the SEC and B1G that do not have disparate revenue sharing, all members make the same media money, any differences in total revenue are a result of school-level factors. I mean we all know that within a conference, there are massive disparities in total revenue. Mississippi State doesn't have anywhere near Alabama's total revenue, Northwestern doesn't have anywhere near Michigan's total revenue, etc.

So media deals are regarded as measures of conference strength because they are negotiated by conferences and hence are conference revenue. Alabama making a ton more money than Indiana, or Ohio State making a ton more than Mississippi State, because they have far larger fan bases that buys tens of millions more in tickets and sponsorships and donations is a school vs school comparison, not a conference comparison.

And I think that my view is a pretty common one, I think in the media, there is a focus on conference media deals as being measuring sticks of conference power and strength, because it is a conference-level source of revenue. So that's why I focus on it, and not which conference has a higher average total revenue.

As for being a troll, whose chain am I trying to yank? Not anyone I am aware of. The media deal situation is a sore spot with me precisely because I like the SEC and want to see it thrive even more, not because I want to dump on the SEC.

Heck, if anything, like the recent leap in TV ratings, the fact that the SEC does have the best attendance, and the best total revenue average, makes the media situation even more irksome to me, as those facts just drive home the point that the SEC is the premier conference, #1 to the B1G's #1a within the P2, and should be paid as such by media.

Again, just MO.
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 09:26 AM by quo vadis.)
10-31-2025 09:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #151
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

JR, I appreciate the point about total revenue. But IMO, that is not a conference issue, and usually these discussions are about conferences. Since within a conference, especially conferences like the SEC and B1G that do not have disparate revenue sharing, all members make the same media money, any differences in total revenue are a result of school-level factors. I mean we all know that within a conference, there are massive disparities in total revenue. Mississippi State doesn't have anywhere near Alabama's total revenue, Northwestern doesn't have anywhere near Michigan's total revenue, etc.

So media deals are regarded as measures of conference strength because they are negotiated by conferences and hence are conference revenue. Alabama making a ton more money than Indiana, or Ohio State making a ton more than Mississippi State, because they have far larger fan bases that buys tens of millions more in tickets and sponsorships and donations is a school vs school comparison, not a conference comparison.

And I think that my view is a pretty common one, I think in the media, there is a focus on conference media deals as being measuring sticks of conference power and strength, because it is a conference-level source of revenue. So that's why I focus on it, and not which conference has a higher average total revenue.

As for being a troll, whose chain am I trying to yank? Not anyone I am aware of. The media deal situation is a sore spot with me precisely because I like the SEC and want to see it thrive even more, not because I want to dump on the SEC.

Heck, if anything, like the recent leap in TV ratings, the fact that the SEC does have the best attendance, and the best total revenue average, makes the media situation even more irksome to me, as those facts just drive home the point that the SEC is the premier conference, #1 to the B1G's #1a within the P2, and should be paid as such by media.

Again, just MO.

I think that we all need to get back to what really matters here: CBS bad.

2025:
Week 1: 2.24m PSU vs Nevada
Week 2: 2.32m Oregon vs Ok St
Week 3: 1.27m USC vs Purdue
Week 4: 5.30m Michigan vs Nebraska
Week 5: 5.22m OSU vs Washington
Week 6: 3.13m PSU vs UCLA
Week 7: 5.60m Indiana vs Oregon (!!!)
Week 8: 4.03m OSU vs Wisconsin
Week 9: 1.60m Minnesota vs Iowa

(2.24 + 2.32 + 1.27 + 5.30 + 5.22 + 3.13 + 5.60 + 4.03 + 1.60)/9 = 30.71
30.71/9 = 3.41m

CBS is now actually tracking to have worse numbers than last year, and they're dangerously close to falling behind the #1 ESPN (not ABC) game each week at this rate.

We can argue until we're blue in the face about what the SEC could have done differently, but, at the end of the day, we're still in the cat bird's seat, and our future is very bright. CBS looks more like Tugg Speedman, they're a White Dwarf heading to a black hole...it's physics, it's inevitable.
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 09:41 AM by bryanw1995.)
10-31-2025 09:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #152
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

I appreciate the point about total revenue - a point you make about as frequently as I make about media deals, I think. But IMO, that is not a conference issue, and usually these discussions are about conferences. I mean we all know that within a conference, there are massive disparities in total revenue. Mississippi State doesn't have anywhere near Alabama's total revenue, Northwestern doesn't have anywhere near Michigan's total revenue, etc.

Media deals are regarded as measures of conference strength because they are negotiated by conferences and hence are conference revenue. Alabama making a ton more money than Indiana, or Ohio State making a ton more than Mississippi State, because they have far larger fan bases that buys tens of millions more in tickets and sponsorships and donations is a school vs school comparison, not a conference comparison.

And I think that my view is a pretty common one, I think in the media, there is a focus on conference media deals as being measuring sticks of conference power and strength, because it is a conference-level source of revenue. So that's why I focus on it, and not which conference has a higher average total revenue.

As for being a troll, whose chain am I trying to yank? Not anyone I am aware of. It's a sore spot with me precisely because I like the SEC and want to see it thrive even more, not because I want to dump on the SEC.

Heck, if anything, like the recent leap in TV ratings, the fact that the SEC does have the best attendance, and the best total revenue average, makes the media situation even more irksome to me, as those facts remind me that the SEC is the premier conference and should be paid as such by media.

Again, just MO.
Attendance is part of business as it produces concessions sells signage rights, parking places, tailgating slots, and souvenirs, all in addition to tickets.

Ratings sell advertising.

Football, basketball, baseball, softball are all revenue sports at some or all of the SEC programs, with football and basketball being at all, and baseball at the majority of schools in the SEC, and softball at a number of them.

The conference is the collection of schools in its membership. The better the collection the more revenue you generate from attendance, from advertising, from signage, and the ones with the most viewership make the most.

At the vast majority of SEC schools donations eclipse media revenue and at most by double and at the top third by 3 times or more.

In any legitimate business that is taxed all lines of revenue are totaled, expenses to make that revenue subtracted, and the NET profit is taxed. They aren't taxed on one line only.

As a collection of individual schools no other collection of individual schools can touch those in the SEC in Gross Revenue production. They can't touch them in the number of customers going through the turnstiles, they can't touch them in revenue generated from all of the other points of commerce involved with the attendance at events, and they can't touch them on the basis for generating commercial revenue from events because they can't touch them in the total number of viewers.

Part of that popularity nationally stems from the number of winning programs in that particular collection of schools and the championships they have won in football (more than double that of all other collections of schools combined this century) and the one closest to it in revenue has not surpassed it in championships won this century in basketball, baseball, or softball.

As a collection of sports businesses, nobody can touch it. The fact that you pick one detail to keep any form of argument about it going makes you a troll. Good luck with that!
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 09:39 AM by JRsec.)
10-31-2025 09:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #153
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

No one is saying that the SEC isn’t doing well on other metrics.

The point is that the SEC is vastly underperforming what it ought to be receiving in media rights BECAUSE we see how well it’s doing on other metrics. The NFL dominates all non-media rights metrics in terms of engagement, profits, and team valuations, too… but that ALSO means they’re dominating media rights revenue on top of it because they have managed their TV deals exceedingly well. Non-media rights strength and media rights strength aren’t mutually exclusive and, in fact, are directly correlated with each other.

What I push back on is that media rights isn’t some type of side piece in the discussions here. It’s the centerpiece! The reason why we’re even communicating and debating on this forum dedicated to conference realignment is because of how media rights have directly impacted virtually every major realignment move for the past 30 years or even more (going back to Notre Dame signing its independent TV deal with NBC). If there is one single job requirement of the conference commissioner in today’s world, it’s to ensure that the conference gets the best media rights deal possible. That is what they are judged by and everything else is noise by comparison.

The fact that the SEC has so much value that it’s able to paper over its media rights revenue undervaluation in a way that the ACC can’t is totally acknowledged! Once again, no one here is saying that the SEC isn’t valuable or even #1 on a lot of metrics. The point is that the fact that the SEC has that much value elsewhere is proof positive that their media rights are vastly undervalued. And that wasn’t an intentional choice by the conference because of some supposedly high-minded non-financial choices about relationships or keeping Southern culture, but simply they signed a 20-year deal that they can’t get out of until 2034 that anyone with half a brain (including Greg Sankey) would have never ever signed even just 5 years later, much less over decade or two.

Like I’ve said, it’s not a permanent situation. But 9 years is also a long time in conference realignment. To pass it off as somehow minor is totally disingenuous. Heck, even your own theories about why the SEC is going to supposedly block out the Big Ten from any value from the ACC and the B1G will just get the minor leftovers is predicated on the SEC contract with ESPN. Half of what we talk about is media rights here… yet somehow it just has to be downplayed *only* when it comes to comparing the Big Ten and SEC revenue (but of course super important when it comes to every other leagues and aspect of conference realignment).

Saying that the SEC did all of these other things right but then somehow not make more money than the Big Ten for media rights is like saying that the SEC dominated time of possession but then the Big Ten made the big play in the 4th quarter to win the game. The media rights revenue IS the game when it comes to conference realignment. All of the other stuff is about how well schools sell tickets and get donations is rooted in their *individual* attributes. The job of the *conference* is to deliver additional value above and beyond just the sum of its individual school parts. The SEC has the parts and those parts are so valuable that they still add up to a huge figure, but the media rights revenue for them isn’t even reflective of the sum of those parts (much less adding more synergistic value). The reason why there’s a “P2” at all is because the Big Ten made up so much ground at the conference level on the media revenue metric.

This isn’t lacking a view of the total picture at all. It’s actually about seeing the total picture and acknowledging that a huge piece of that picture doesn’t align with the rest of that picture in the way that it should. It’s like seeing Business A beating Business B on quality, sales, and performance, but Business B is more profitable because Business A signed a bad deal 10 years ago while Business B took more risks. This isn’t some weird story - it happens in business all of the time where bad deals are made and that causes an underperformance for years. The SEC is just fortunate that everything else is strong to mitigate that underperformance unlike the ACC (and the Pac-12 and Big 12 before them).
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 09:50 AM by Frank the Tank.)
10-31-2025 09:39 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #154
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

No one is saying that the SEC is doing well on other metrics.

The point is that the SEC is vastly underperforming what it ought to be receiving in media rights BECAUSE we see how well it’s doing on other metrics. The NFL dominates all non-media rights metrics in terms of engagement, profits, and team valuations, too… but that ALSO means they’re dominating media rights revenue on top of it.

What I push back on is that media rights isn’t some type of side piece in the discussions here. It’s the centerpiece! The reason why we’re even communicating and debating on this forum dedicated to conference realignment is because of how media rights have directly impacted virtually every major realignment move for the past 30 years or even more (going back to Notre Dame signing its independent TV deal with NBC).

The fact that the SEC has so much value that it’s able to paper over its media rights revenue undervaluation in a way that the ACC can’t is totally acknowledged! Once again, no one here is saying that the SEC isn’t valuable on a lot of metrics. The point is that the fact that the SEC has that much value elsewhere is proof positive that their media rights are vastly undervalued. And that wasn’t an intentional choice by the conference because of some supposedly high-minded non-financial choices about relationships or keeping Southern culture, but simply they signed a 20-year deal that they can’t get out of until 2034 that anyone with half a brain (including Greg Sankey) would have never ever signed even just 5 years later, much less over decade or two.

Like I’ve said, it’s not a permanent situation. But 9 years is also a long time in conference realignment. To pass it off as somehow minor is totally disingenuous. Heck, even your own theories about why the SEC is going to supposedly block out the Big Ten from any value from the ACC and the B1G will just get the minor leftovers is predicated on the SEC contract with ESPN. Half of what we talk about is media rights here… yet somehow it just has to be downplayed *only* when it comes to comparing the Big Ten and SEC revenue (but of course super important when it comes to every other leagues and aspect of conference realignment).

Saying that the SEC did all of these other things right but then somehow not make more money than the Big Ten for media rights is like saying that the SEC dominated time of possession but then the Big Ten made the big play in the 4th quarter to win the game. The media rights revenue IS the game when it comes to conference realignment. All of the other stuff is about how well schools sell tickets and get donations is rooted in their *individual* attributes. The job of the *conference* is to deliver additional value above and beyond just the sum of its individual school parts. The SEC has the parts and those parts are so valuable that they still add up to a huge figure, but the media rights revenue for them isn’t even reflective of the sum of those parts (much less adding more synergistic value). The reason why there’s a “P2” at all is because the Big Ten made up so much ground at the conference level on the media revenue metric.

This isn’t lacking a view of the total picture at all. It’s actually about seeing the total picture and acknowledging that a huge piece of that picture doesn’t align with the rest of that picture in the way that it should. It’s like seeing Business A beating Business B on quality, sales, and performance, but Business B is more profitable because Business A signed a bad deal 10 years ago while Business B took more risks. This isn’t some weird story - it happens in business all of the time where bad deals are made and that causes an underperformance for years. The SEC is just fortunate that everything else is strong to mitigate that underperformance unlike the ACC (and the Pac-12 and Big 12 before them).

Frank, stick a sock in it! Your own people are finally realizing how important all lines of revenue are. And your media revenue advantage lasted only because of a lousy CBS deal. That's over! We'll all see that we are right back where we've always been next year too. The SEC will dominate total revenue, and you'll still be thumping your chest on media revenue if you are fortunate to have a lead there at all.

This is no longer the NCAA which has limited overhead due to amateurism. It's totally business now and all lines of revenue matter at every school. Is it a fact that the Big Ten made more in media revenue last year? Yes! Is it a fact that the average SEC school made over 5 million more in all forms of revenue than a Big Ten school? Yes!

Good luck moving forward and keeping up in a world where expenses mean you need every penny you earn no matter what ledger line you place it on to remain viable.

I've seen businesses with good profits from sales fold because they were losing too much money in other places, and usually due to poor expansions of their enterprise. Damn that sounds familiar!

Tell you what, when you are right about something important, I'll listen more attentively to what you say. But so far, I can't find what that is. It wasn't about realignment, wasn't about the status of amateurism being secure with the NCAA, or most anything related to the NCAA, and it is still in serious doubt that anyone will remain with them from the upper tier as all of this moves forward. GORs? I believe I was the one who said they had only been used in the recording industry and entertainment and were untested for government supported entities like universities and likely subject to sovereign immunity. When contracts got big enough to be worth the cost of the court case they didn't hold up too well did they.

What I have found on this board is how little business sense most of the board has. I suppose that is due to the fact that most simply draw a paycheck from some corporation and never had to run a business. That's why they can't grasp that one line of revenue does not a business make. Would the SEC like to earn the most in that line too? Sure! Is it essential to its overall success? Not in the least! Will it be sufficient to address all of the Big Ten's concerns? No!

Now in the era of baby bust declines in total enrollment at universities sports branding is widely recognized as the big front porch of the institution in garnering interest from prospective students. Tell me Frank what helps there? Your media money or the ratings? Affordability has students from all over the North headed South. Our campuses are undergoing massive apartment building and increased enrollment. I think they are overbuilding, and that's this whole system has lost its mind, but it's happening.

AAU and STEM should matter because that is where the research dollars are and where the lucrative jobs will be found. But for undergraduate diplomas, which to be very honest are little more indicative of an education than a high school diploma was circa 1964 in terms of what they actually know, they are going where the cost of education is the cheapest. I think like everything else what they are paying to get is as hyperinflated as a 2025 SUV filled with chips from China that don't last and are hard to resupply. Most of these kids are going to go so deeply in debt to get that paper credentialing called a diploma that they won't live as well as we did and won't go as far, hence the reference to the modern SUV.

Why the diversion in the narrative? In business every line of revenue counts toward overall success. I've never argued that media money isn't relevant. I've always argued that it is only one line in the ledger, because Frank that's exactly all it is or ever will be! It's only debated here to save face for the those to which it represents their "only" measure of success. And all the time wasted in that debate hasn't addressed any of the real issues. And the real issue is that players will now be paid, overhead has skyrocketed in the college sports business mostly due to the NCAA's recalcitrance on any form of remuneration and now everyone, but the damned NCAA is having to pick up the tab. And because of that all of those other ledger lines now matter more than ever!

What's more is that now the border between winning and losing is going to be more lethal than ever to the interests of those involved. An upper tier may form with as many as 72 or more schools. But the rate of dropping out of major sports due to the cost of them is now going to spike. Not this year, not the next, but over the next decade to two, the number of major universities offering high profile sports is going to drop faster than at any point in our past. And the reason will be costs, and those which maintain those programs are going to focus on all of those ledger lines and not just one. And that's going to happen because that's how business is managed, and I'm sorry to say most university presidents are not accustomed to maintaining the revenue line. They rely on COLAs from their state's taxpayers to accomplish that and those taxpayers are under economic duress as well.
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2025 10:25 AM by JRsec.)
10-31-2025 10:11 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Claw Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,563
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1566
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Orangeville HELP!
Post: #155
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
The SEC has always prioritized exposure and fan engagement over financials. It's how they built the conference. It's why they made the TV deal. It works, and they know it.
10-31-2025 10:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #156
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 09:36 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  (Stuff)
Agree with JRsec on everything above this point
....
As a collection of sports businesses, nobody can touch it. The fact that you pick one detail to keep any form of argument about it going makes you a troll. Good luck with that!

You're mostly right, but "that one detail" is one of the few things that is actually the responsibility of the conference office. We tend to overstate the impact of the commissioner and the league office (remember when the C7 got their ducks in a row, got a league and a media deal without having a commissioner at all, and then rented league office space from a law firm for like $1 a month for a while?).

IF you're wang-measuring the SEC vs the Big Ten (and that definitely one of the major topics on this board) then everything you listed (summarized here as: the program power of the individual SEC schools) is absolutely true, and if you stack up the 16 SEC schools school-for-school against the 18 Big Ten schools, you get the results you get.

The SEC media revenue, from everything we can tell, lags the Big Ten media revenue. Now maybe the leaks are wrong, and when we get the 2024-25 tax forms, maybe the SEC numbers are higher than we're led to believe and the Big Ten lower. But that would run counter to all of the reporting.

There is something to be said for being inside the ESPN ecosystem. Having your games talked about on College Gameday is better than having them talked about on Big Noon Kickoff, etc etc. Quo is unimpressed by that argument, consistently. He's equally unimpressed when American Conference fans bring it up. (no idea if you're following those discussions, JRsec, because why would you, you have no dogs in that fight and you're not just here for the media contract drama.) He values that at roughly $0, and I disagree with him on that -- it's worth something, maybe 10%, maybe 15%.

JRsec, I respect what you say about the culture of the SEC, and about how handshake deals are binding there. But I'm skeptical, because those unwritten handshake deals are only binding on the hand that shakes, not on the institution. And the counterparty, ESPN, doesn't have that kind of culture at all. I don't think anyone in Bristol cares one little bit what Jimmy Pitaro did or didn't promise Mike Slive fifteen years ago.

Quo has an argument that, if the SEC office had followed his line of thinking, they would not have signed any TV deal at all for the SEC GOTW in 2020. They would have put the deal up for auction much closer to the end of the deal, and caught the height of the "let's spend billions of dollars on building a streaming service and be the next Netflix" mania that burned up all of PAramount's and WBD's cash.

The other side of that is, you can't predict when that kind of bubble will peak and when it will pop. the SEC chose a very lucrative deal with long term security, even if it meant leaving up to a billion possible but not at all guaranteed money on the table. (Sure, the SEC GOTW could have hit the market and gotten the same sort of overvalued deal that the Big Ten got from CBS or NBC. But it's also possible that the SEC would have hit at exactly the wrong six-month window and gotten an undervalued deal. It's not as guaranteed as Quo thinks)

I don't think disagreeing, even at length and repetitively, is trolling. (Obviously, given my post history)
10-31-2025 10:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #157
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 10:26 AM)Claw Wrote:  The SEC has always prioritized exposure and fan engagement over financials. It's how they built the conference. It's why they made the TV deal. It works, and they know it.

That sort of mentality works until it doesn't. It's worked thus far, and I have no complaints about where we stand here today. However, as I stated above, just one little change will make all the difference for us in the future. We can stick with ESPN, split the contract again, move to another company or companies, whatever, but we should go for a shorter contract length next time, and we shouldn't renew 4 years before the contract ends. ie, don't panic and renew years and years before we have to b/c the B1G is going 4 years before we are. Let it drag out close to the end of the current deal, put it up for auction, and see where things end up. If ESPN is on top, well that's easy, we just stick with them. If ESPN is far from the top, also an easy decision. If CBS, Netflix or someone else comes in and offers stupid money for our gotw or 2 or 3 games each week, that's also an easy decision. But we need to factor in that longer deals need to have a lot more money in them and a much higher AAV than shorter deals.
10-31-2025 10:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #158
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 10:34 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 10:26 AM)Claw Wrote:  The SEC has always prioritized exposure and fan engagement over financials. It's how they built the conference. It's why they made the TV deal. It works, and they know it.

That sort of mentality works until it doesn't. It's worked thus far, and I have no complaints about where we stand here today. However, as I stated above, just one little change will make all the difference for us in the future. We can stick with ESPN, split the contract again, move to another company or companies, whatever, but we should go for a shorter contract length next time, and we shouldn't renew 4 years before the contract ends. ie, don't panic and renew years and years before we have to b/c the B1G is going 4 years before we are. Let it drag out close to the end of the current deal, put it up for auction, and see where things end up. If ESPN is on top, well that's easy, we just stick with them. If ESPN is far from the top, also an easy decision. If CBS, Netflix or someone else comes in and offers stupid money for our gotw or 2 or 3 games each week, that's also an easy decision. But we need to factor in that longer deals need to have a lot more money in them and a much higher AAV than shorter deals.

The first immutable law of a successful business: If it ain't broke don't fix it!

The Big Ten has a lot more to fix than the SEC. And how do you know it hasn't already been addressed?
10-31-2025 10:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #159
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 10:11 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:18 AM)schmolik Wrote:  Right because we all know who's winning in championship sports play ... at least the last two years in college football.

Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

No one is saying that the SEC is doing well on other metrics.

The point is that the SEC is vastly underperforming what it ought to be receiving in media rights BECAUSE we see how well it’s doing on other metrics. The NFL dominates all non-media rights metrics in terms of engagement, profits, and team valuations, too… but that ALSO means they’re dominating media rights revenue on top of it.

What I push back on is that media rights isn’t some type of side piece in the discussions here. It’s the centerpiece! The reason why we’re even communicating and debating on this forum dedicated to conference realignment is because of how media rights have directly impacted virtually every major realignment move for the past 30 years or even more (going back to Notre Dame signing its independent TV deal with NBC).

The fact that the SEC has so much value that it’s able to paper over its media rights revenue undervaluation in a way that the ACC can’t is totally acknowledged! Once again, no one here is saying that the SEC isn’t valuable on a lot of metrics. The point is that the fact that the SEC has that much value elsewhere is proof positive that their media rights are vastly undervalued. And that wasn’t an intentional choice by the conference because of some supposedly high-minded non-financial choices about relationships or keeping Southern culture, but simply they signed a 20-year deal that they can’t get out of until 2034 that anyone with half a brain (including Greg Sankey) would have never ever signed even just 5 years later, much less over decade or two.

Like I’ve said, it’s not a permanent situation. But 9 years is also a long time in conference realignment. To pass it off as somehow minor is totally disingenuous. Heck, even your own theories about why the SEC is going to supposedly block out the Big Ten from any value from the ACC and the B1G will just get the minor leftovers is predicated on the SEC contract with ESPN. Half of what we talk about is media rights here… yet somehow it just has to be downplayed *only* when it comes to comparing the Big Ten and SEC revenue (but of course super important when it comes to every other leagues and aspect of conference realignment).

Saying that the SEC did all of these other things right but then somehow not make more money than the Big Ten for media rights is like saying that the SEC dominated time of possession but then the Big Ten made the big play in the 4th quarter to win the game. The media rights revenue IS the game when it comes to conference realignment. All of the other stuff is about how well schools sell tickets and get donations is rooted in their *individual* attributes. The job of the *conference* is to deliver additional value above and beyond just the sum of its individual school parts. The SEC has the parts and those parts are so valuable that they still add up to a huge figure, but the media rights revenue for them isn’t even reflective of the sum of those parts (much less adding more synergistic value). The reason why there’s a “P2” at all is because the Big Ten made up so much ground at the conference level on the media revenue metric.

This isn’t lacking a view of the total picture at all. It’s actually about seeing the total picture and acknowledging that a huge piece of that picture doesn’t align with the rest of that picture in the way that it should. It’s like seeing Business A beating Business B on quality, sales, and performance, but Business B is more profitable because Business A signed a bad deal 10 years ago while Business B took more risks. This isn’t some weird story - it happens in business all of the time where bad deals are made and that causes an underperformance for years. The SEC is just fortunate that everything else is strong to mitigate that underperformance unlike the ACC (and the Pac-12 and Big 12 before them).

Frank, stick a sock in it! Your own people are finally realizing how important all lines of revenue are. And your media revenue advantage lasted only because of a lousy CBS deal. That's over! We'll all see that we are right back where we've always been next year too. The SEC will dominate total revenue, and you'll still be thumping your chest on media revenue if you are fortunate to have a lead there at all.

This is no longer the NCAA which has limited overhead due to amateurism. It's totally business now and all lines of revenue matter at every school. Is it a fact that the Big Ten made more in media revenue last year? Yes! Is it a fact that the average SEC school made over 5 million more in all forms of revenue than a Big Ten school? Yes!

Good luck moving forward and keeping up in a world where expenses mean you need every penny you earn no matter what ledger line you place it on to remain viable.

I've seen business with good profits from sales fold because they were losing too much money in other places, and usually due to poor expansions of their enterprise. Damn that sounds familiar!

Tell you what, when you are right about something important I'll listen more attentively to what you say. But so far I can't find what that is. It wasn't about realignment, wasn't about the status of amateurism, or most anything related to the NCAA and it is still in serious doubt that anyone will remain with them from the upper tier as all of this moves forward. GORs? I believe I was the one who said they had only been used in the recording industry and entertainment and were untested for government supported entities like universities and likely subject to sovereign immunity. When contracts got big enough to be worth the cost of the court case they didn't hold up too well did they.

What I have found on this board is how little business sense most of the board has. I suppose that is due to the fact that most simply draw a paycheck from some corporation and never had to run a business. That's why they can't grasp that one line of revenue does not a business make. Would the SEC like to earn the most in that line too? Sure! Is it essential to its overall success? Not in the least! Will it be sufficient to address all of the Big Ten's concerns? No!

Now in the era of baby bust declines in total enrollment at universities sports branding is widely recognized as the big front porch of the institution in garnering interest from prospective students. Tell me Frank what helps there? Your media money or the ratings? Affordability has students from all over the North headed South. Our campuses are undergoing massive apartment building and increased enrollment. I think they are overbuilding, and that's this whole system has lost its mind, but it's happening.

AAU and STEM should matter because that is where the research dollars are and where the lucrative jobs will be found. But for undergraduate diplomas, which to be very honest are little more indicative of an education than high school diploma was circa 1964 in terms of what they actually know, they are going where the cost of education is the cheapest. I think like everything else what they are paying to get is as hyperinflated as a 2025 SUV filled with chips from China that don't last and are hard to resupply. Most of these kids are going to go so deeply in debt to get that paper credentialing called a diploma that they won't live as well as we did and won't go as far, hence the reference to the modern SUV.

Why the diversion in the narrative? In business every line of revenue counts toward overall success. I've never argued that media money isn't relevant. I've always argued that it is only one line in the ledger, because Frank that's exactly all it is or ever will be! It's only debated here to save face for the those to which it represents their "only" measure of success. And all the time wasted in that debate hasn't addressed any of the real issues. And the real issue is that players will now be paid, overhead has skyrocketed in the college sports business mostly due to the NCAA's recalcitrance on any form of remuneration and now everyone, but the damned NCAA is having to pick up the tab. And because of that all of those other ledger lines no matter more than ever!

We’re just going around in circles here again.

I will point out only the following:

If you want to critique my predictions about realignment or even GORs, that’s fine. Like I’ve said, I have made a lot of wrong predictions over the years and quite publicly so. If you want to base your opinion of me based on those predictions as opposed to the rigor of analysis, go ahead, too. I made a prediction on my blog once that Texas A&M wouldn’t get into the SEC due to ESPN’s interest in the Longhorn Network, and boy oh boy that post got circulated every few months on TexAgs for at least 10 years and boy oh boy there were some stellar opinions about me. (Thanks for the blog traffic, Aggies!) Saying my prediction is wrong doesn’t bother me. What I do attempt is to apply a rigorous analysis of the whole picture - business, entertainment, academic, culture, legal, etc. - and while I wear my fandom on my sleeve, I do believe that I also acknowledge the weaknesses of the Big Ten and others that I support as opposed to blindly believing that they are impervious to mistakes or problems.

However, I still have zero idea where you’ve gotten the impression that I didn’t think that amateurism in college sports would crumble or am some type of defender of the NCAA. You have mentioned this before and I legitimately don’t get it. I have been writing about NIL (before most people here likely even heard of the term) and how players were going to need to get paid (and *deserved* to get paid) and the courts were going to break it all open and that the NCAA was a walking antitrust violation for many, many, many years… and long before it was popular to say so and long before the Alston case. I got attacked by the readers of my own blog when I wrote that players should get paid well over 10 years ago in the wake of the Ed O’Bannon litigation. I don’t know why you keep saying that I was somehow wrong on amateurism when I have been an open believer in players getting paid long before now. Maybe you believe that this is just a “blind squirrel finds a nut” prediction from me, but at least don’t tell me that I didn’t find that particular nut at all. I apologize for the tangent, but this one really irks me because I’m a long-time and unabashed public supporter of player rights on both financial and legal grounds and very openly criticized the Big Ten’s statements on it during the 2010s (e.g. “We’d rather go down to Division III than pay players”) whenever the subject arose.
10-31-2025 10:42 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #160
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 10:42 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 10:11 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.

That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 07-coffee3

No one is saying that the SEC is doing well on other metrics.

The point is that the SEC is vastly underperforming what it ought to be receiving in media rights BECAUSE we see how well it’s doing on other metrics. The NFL dominates all non-media rights metrics in terms of engagement, profits, and team valuations, too… but that ALSO means they’re dominating media rights revenue on top of it.

What I push back on is that media rights isn’t some type of side piece in the discussions here. It’s the centerpiece! The reason why we’re even communicating and debating on this forum dedicated to conference realignment is because of how media rights have directly impacted virtually every major realignment move for the past 30 years or even more (going back to Notre Dame signing its independent TV deal with NBC).

The fact that the SEC has so much value that it’s able to paper over its media rights revenue undervaluation in a way that the ACC can’t is totally acknowledged! Once again, no one here is saying that the SEC isn’t valuable on a lot of metrics. The point is that the fact that the SEC has that much value elsewhere is proof positive that their media rights are vastly undervalued. And that wasn’t an intentional choice by the conference because of some supposedly high-minded non-financial choices about relationships or keeping Southern culture, but simply they signed a 20-year deal that they can’t get out of until 2034 that anyone with half a brain (including Greg Sankey) would have never ever signed even just 5 years later, much less over decade or two.

Like I’ve said, it’s not a permanent situation. But 9 years is also a long time in conference realignment. To pass it off as somehow minor is totally disingenuous. Heck, even your own theories about why the SEC is going to supposedly block out the Big Ten from any value from the ACC and the B1G will just get the minor leftovers is predicated on the SEC contract with ESPN. Half of what we talk about is media rights here… yet somehow it just has to be downplayed *only* when it comes to comparing the Big Ten and SEC revenue (but of course super important when it comes to every other leagues and aspect of conference realignment).

Saying that the SEC did all of these other things right but then somehow not make more money than the Big Ten for media rights is like saying that the SEC dominated time of possession but then the Big Ten made the big play in the 4th quarter to win the game. The media rights revenue IS the game when it comes to conference realignment. All of the other stuff is about how well schools sell tickets and get donations is rooted in their *individual* attributes. The job of the *conference* is to deliver additional value above and beyond just the sum of its individual school parts. The SEC has the parts and those parts are so valuable that they still add up to a huge figure, but the media rights revenue for them isn’t even reflective of the sum of those parts (much less adding more synergistic value). The reason why there’s a “P2” at all is because the Big Ten made up so much ground at the conference level on the media revenue metric.

This isn’t lacking a view of the total picture at all. It’s actually about seeing the total picture and acknowledging that a huge piece of that picture doesn’t align with the rest of that picture in the way that it should. It’s like seeing Business A beating Business B on quality, sales, and performance, but Business B is more profitable because Business A signed a bad deal 10 years ago while Business B took more risks. This isn’t some weird story - it happens in business all of the time where bad deals are made and that causes an underperformance for years. The SEC is just fortunate that everything else is strong to mitigate that underperformance unlike the ACC (and the Pac-12 and Big 12 before them).

Frank, stick a sock in it! Your own people are finally realizing how important all lines of revenue are. And your media revenue advantage lasted only because of a lousy CBS deal. That's over! We'll all see that we are right back where we've always been next year too. The SEC will dominate total revenue, and you'll still be thumping your chest on media revenue if you are fortunate to have a lead there at all.

This is no longer the NCAA which has limited overhead due to amateurism. It's totally business now and all lines of revenue matter at every school. Is it a fact that the Big Ten made more in media revenue last year? Yes! Is it a fact that the average SEC school made over 5 million more in all forms of revenue than a Big Ten school? Yes!

Good luck moving forward and keeping up in a world where expenses mean you need every penny you earn no matter what ledger line you place it on to remain viable.

I've seen business with good profits from sales fold because they were losing too much money in other places, and usually due to poor expansions of their enterprise. Damn that sounds familiar!

Tell you what, when you are right about something important I'll listen more attentively to what you say. But so far I can't find what that is. It wasn't about realignment, wasn't about the status of amateurism, or most anything related to the NCAA and it is still in serious doubt that anyone will remain with them from the upper tier as all of this moves forward. GORs? I believe I was the one who said they had only been used in the recording industry and entertainment and were untested for government supported entities like universities and likely subject to sovereign immunity. When contracts got big enough to be worth the cost of the court case they didn't hold up too well did they.

What I have found on this board is how little business sense most of the board has. I suppose that is due to the fact that most simply draw a paycheck from some corporation and never had to run a business. That's why they can't grasp that one line of revenue does not a business make. Would the SEC like to earn the most in that line too? Sure! Is it essential to its overall success? Not in the least! Will it be sufficient to address all of the Big Ten's concerns? No!

Now in the era of baby bust declines in total enrollment at universities sports branding is widely recognized as the big front porch of the institution in garnering interest from prospective students. Tell me Frank what helps there? Your media money or the ratings? Affordability has students from all over the North headed South. Our campuses are undergoing massive apartment building and increased enrollment. I think they are overbuilding, and that's this whole system has lost its mind, but it's happening.

AAU and STEM should matter because that is where the research dollars are and where the lucrative jobs will be found. But for undergraduate diplomas, which to be very honest are little more indicative of an education than high school diploma was circa 1964 in terms of what they actually know, they are going where the cost of education is the cheapest. I think like everything else what they are paying to get is as hyperinflated as a 2025 SUV filled with chips from China that don't last and are hard to resupply. Most of these kids are going to go so deeply in debt to get that paper credentialing called a diploma that they won't live as well as we did and won't go as far, hence the reference to the modern SUV.

Why the diversion in the narrative? In business every line of revenue counts toward overall success. I've never argued that media money isn't relevant. I've always argued that it is only one line in the ledger, because Frank that's exactly all it is or ever will be! It's only debated here to save face for the those to which it represents their "only" measure of success. And all the time wasted in that debate hasn't addressed any of the real issues. And the real issue is that players will now be paid, overhead has skyrocketed in the college sports business mostly due to the NCAA's recalcitrance on any form of remuneration and now everyone, but the damned NCAA is having to pick up the tab. And because of that all of those other ledger lines no matter more than ever!

We’re just going around in circles here again.

I will point out only the following:

If you want to critique my predictions about realignment or even GORs, that’s fine. Like I’ve said, I have made a lot of wrong predictions over the years and quite publicly so. If you want to base your opinion of me based on those predictions as opposed to the rigor of analysis, go ahead, too. I made a prediction on my blog once that Texas A&M wouldn’t get into the SEC due to ESPN’s interest in the Longhorn Network, and boy oh boy that post got circulated every few months on TexAgs for at least 10 years and boy oh boy there were some stellar opinions about me. (Thanks for the blog traffic, Aggies!) Saying my prediction is wrong doesn’t bother me. What I do attempt is to apply a rigorous analysis of the whole picture - business, entertainment, academic, culture, legal, etc. - and while I wear my fandom on my sleeve, I do believe that I also acknowledge the weaknesses of the Big Ten and others that I support as opposed to blindly believing that they are impervious to mistakes or problems.

However, I still have zero idea where you’ve gotten the impression that I didn’t think that amateurism in college sports would crumble or am some type of defender of the NCAA. You have mentioned this before and I legitimately don’t get it. I have been writing about NIL (before most people here likely even heard of the term) and how players were going to need to get paid (and *deserved* to get paid) and the courts were going to break it all open and that the NCAA was a walking antitrust violation for many, many, many years… and long before it was popular to say so and long before the Alston case. I got attacked by the readers of my own blog when I wrote that players should get paid well over 10 years ago in the wake of the Ed O’Bannon litigation. I don’t know why you keep saying that I was somehow wrong on amateurism when I have been an open believer in players getting paid long before now. Maybe you believe that this is just a “blind squirrel finds a nut” prediction from me, but at least don’t tell me that I didn’t find that particular nut at all. I apologize for the tangent, but this one really irks me because I’m a long-time and unabashed public supporter of player rights on both financial and legal grounds and very openly criticized the Big Ten’s statements on it during the 2010s (e.g. “We’d rather go down to Division III than pay players”) whenever the subject arose.

You said as much in a defense of the NCAA a few years back. Since I'm likely old enough to be you dad's age you will find, when you get here, that decades run together, let alone years. But you essentially defended the NCAA model and didn't think it was vulnerable because "It does too much for the institutions (schools)."

And the only reason for the sock reference was it was obvious this was going back into that circle.

I spent 20 years in corporate life setting up businesses, helping them to run, and prior to that I ran one myself out of necessity when I lost a grandfather. All details matter. Unless you've run one you wouldn't have a clue as to how integral every line of that ledger is with overall success. College sports is absolutely a business, the SCOTUS was spot on to see it that way, the NCAA is grossly outdated and bureaucratized, and we need to move on because the model no longer works for us.

My last 20 years of work were in non-profit endeavors. Ledger lines mattered there too! All of life is a form of business whether the government is capitalistic, socialistic, or communistic. Business abides. It's personal liberty that is in the balance. Whether you barter or buy and sell, details matter. What even most free people, like us, fail to grasp is that we don't actually own anything. The government just agrees to let us believe that we do, until we can't pay our taxes. I'll let that sobering reality sink in, not on you because you know, but upon the rest. And the right to privacy exists until there is a dispute over the amount of taxes due. The invasion of privacy is called an audit. And the real irony is your congressman (no taxation without representation) is actually supposed to represent you, not major corporations in the congressional district, not the government, but you. Good luck to us all!07-coffee3
10-31-2025 10:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.