JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-31-2025 10:42 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-31-2025 10:11 AM)JRsec Wrote: (10-31-2025 09:39 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-31-2025 09:05 AM)JRsec Wrote: (10-31-2025 07:42 AM)quo vadis Wrote: Winning the national title is awesome and everyone wants to do it, but it doesn't say much about conference strength. Heck in 2018, Clemson won the national title with one of the five or six best teams ever, absolutely destroyed the SEC champ in the national title game, and yet the ACC was terrible, easily the worst of the five power conferences while the SEC had maybe the strongest year of any conference during the 2010s, was far better. No real relationship there. In hoops, I have been an ardent Big East partisan since 1980, but the two years UConn won the national title recently, we were not the best conference either of those years, we were very good, but just not the best. The past two years, the SEC has easily been the best conference on the football field, even though B1G teams have won the title (the B1G has been very good, btw, second best both years, but not the best). Might well be the same again this year.
That said, I disagree with the idea voiced by someone else that the the SEC is dominating in business, if by that we mean media deals. Yes, with the caveat that none of us has yet seen the actual payouts of the recent B1G and SEC media deals, I think it likely that the B1G is still making a bit more than the SEC despite the SEC having far better ratings since adding TX and OU. If so, that IMO is a massive win for the B1G. But again, I acknowledge that we have to see the actual numbers, and I could be wrong.
Quo, when a conference has dominated every statistic from attendance to total revenue for well over a decade, and is now sweeping the ratings, no other conference can touch those numbers, and the only thing that can be touted by the opposition is only one line for media revenue from the whole ledger of income, and the only victories they can claim are a few championships in the last quarter century and those by only 2 schools out of 18, and that in only one revenue sport, that's an ass kicking. And only a troll would continue to argue otherwise! It hasn't even been close! 
No one is saying that the SEC is doing well on other metrics.
The point is that the SEC is vastly underperforming what it ought to be receiving in media rights BECAUSE we see how well it’s doing on other metrics. The NFL dominates all non-media rights metrics in terms of engagement, profits, and team valuations, too… but that ALSO means they’re dominating media rights revenue on top of it.
What I push back on is that media rights isn’t some type of side piece in the discussions here. It’s the centerpiece! The reason why we’re even communicating and debating on this forum dedicated to conference realignment is because of how media rights have directly impacted virtually every major realignment move for the past 30 years or even more (going back to Notre Dame signing its independent TV deal with NBC).
The fact that the SEC has so much value that it’s able to paper over its media rights revenue undervaluation in a way that the ACC can’t is totally acknowledged! Once again, no one here is saying that the SEC isn’t valuable on a lot of metrics. The point is that the fact that the SEC has that much value elsewhere is proof positive that their media rights are vastly undervalued. And that wasn’t an intentional choice by the conference because of some supposedly high-minded non-financial choices about relationships or keeping Southern culture, but simply they signed a 20-year deal that they can’t get out of until 2034 that anyone with half a brain (including Greg Sankey) would have never ever signed even just 5 years later, much less over decade or two.
Like I’ve said, it’s not a permanent situation. But 9 years is also a long time in conference realignment. To pass it off as somehow minor is totally disingenuous. Heck, even your own theories about why the SEC is going to supposedly block out the Big Ten from any value from the ACC and the B1G will just get the minor leftovers is predicated on the SEC contract with ESPN. Half of what we talk about is media rights here… yet somehow it just has to be downplayed *only* when it comes to comparing the Big Ten and SEC revenue (but of course super important when it comes to every other leagues and aspect of conference realignment).
Saying that the SEC did all of these other things right but then somehow not make more money than the Big Ten for media rights is like saying that the SEC dominated time of possession but then the Big Ten made the big play in the 4th quarter to win the game. The media rights revenue IS the game when it comes to conference realignment. All of the other stuff is about how well schools sell tickets and get donations is rooted in their *individual* attributes. The job of the *conference* is to deliver additional value above and beyond just the sum of its individual school parts. The SEC has the parts and those parts are so valuable that they still add up to a huge figure, but the media rights revenue for them isn’t even reflective of the sum of those parts (much less adding more synergistic value). The reason why there’s a “P2” at all is because the Big Ten made up so much ground at the conference level on the media revenue metric.
This isn’t lacking a view of the total picture at all. It’s actually about seeing the total picture and acknowledging that a huge piece of that picture doesn’t align with the rest of that picture in the way that it should. It’s like seeing Business A beating Business B on quality, sales, and performance, but Business B is more profitable because Business A signed a bad deal 10 years ago while Business B took more risks. This isn’t some weird story - it happens in business all of the time where bad deals are made and that causes an underperformance for years. The SEC is just fortunate that everything else is strong to mitigate that underperformance unlike the ACC (and the Pac-12 and Big 12 before them).
Frank, stick a sock in it! Your own people are finally realizing how important all lines of revenue are. And your media revenue advantage lasted only because of a lousy CBS deal. That's over! We'll all see that we are right back where we've always been next year too. The SEC will dominate total revenue, and you'll still be thumping your chest on media revenue if you are fortunate to have a lead there at all.
This is no longer the NCAA which has limited overhead due to amateurism. It's totally business now and all lines of revenue matter at every school. Is it a fact that the Big Ten made more in media revenue last year? Yes! Is it a fact that the average SEC school made over 5 million more in all forms of revenue than a Big Ten school? Yes!
Good luck moving forward and keeping up in a world where expenses mean you need every penny you earn no matter what ledger line you place it on to remain viable.
I've seen business with good profits from sales fold because they were losing too much money in other places, and usually due to poor expansions of their enterprise. Damn that sounds familiar!
Tell you what, when you are right about something important I'll listen more attentively to what you say. But so far I can't find what that is. It wasn't about realignment, wasn't about the status of amateurism, or most anything related to the NCAA and it is still in serious doubt that anyone will remain with them from the upper tier as all of this moves forward. GORs? I believe I was the one who said they had only been used in the recording industry and entertainment and were untested for government supported entities like universities and likely subject to sovereign immunity. When contracts got big enough to be worth the cost of the court case they didn't hold up too well did they.
What I have found on this board is how little business sense most of the board has. I suppose that is due to the fact that most simply draw a paycheck from some corporation and never had to run a business. That's why they can't grasp that one line of revenue does not a business make. Would the SEC like to earn the most in that line too? Sure! Is it essential to its overall success? Not in the least! Will it be sufficient to address all of the Big Ten's concerns? No!
Now in the era of baby bust declines in total enrollment at universities sports branding is widely recognized as the big front porch of the institution in garnering interest from prospective students. Tell me Frank what helps there? Your media money or the ratings? Affordability has students from all over the North headed South. Our campuses are undergoing massive apartment building and increased enrollment. I think they are overbuilding, and that's this whole system has lost its mind, but it's happening.
AAU and STEM should matter because that is where the research dollars are and where the lucrative jobs will be found. But for undergraduate diplomas, which to be very honest are little more indicative of an education than high school diploma was circa 1964 in terms of what they actually know, they are going where the cost of education is the cheapest. I think like everything else what they are paying to get is as hyperinflated as a 2025 SUV filled with chips from China that don't last and are hard to resupply. Most of these kids are going to go so deeply in debt to get that paper credentialing called a diploma that they won't live as well as we did and won't go as far, hence the reference to the modern SUV.
Why the diversion in the narrative? In business every line of revenue counts toward overall success. I've never argued that media money isn't relevant. I've always argued that it is only one line in the ledger, because Frank that's exactly all it is or ever will be! It's only debated here to save face for the those to which it represents their "only" measure of success. And all the time wasted in that debate hasn't addressed any of the real issues. And the real issue is that players will now be paid, overhead has skyrocketed in the college sports business mostly due to the NCAA's recalcitrance on any form of remuneration and now everyone, but the damned NCAA is having to pick up the tab. And because of that all of those other ledger lines no matter more than ever!
We’re just going around in circles here again.
I will point out only the following:
If you want to critique my predictions about realignment or even GORs, that’s fine. Like I’ve said, I have made a lot of wrong predictions over the years and quite publicly so. If you want to base your opinion of me based on those predictions as opposed to the rigor of analysis, go ahead, too. I made a prediction on my blog once that Texas A&M wouldn’t get into the SEC due to ESPN’s interest in the Longhorn Network, and boy oh boy that post got circulated every few months on TexAgs for at least 10 years and boy oh boy there were some stellar opinions about me. (Thanks for the blog traffic, Aggies!) Saying my prediction is wrong doesn’t bother me. What I do attempt is to apply a rigorous analysis of the whole picture - business, entertainment, academic, culture, legal, etc. - and while I wear my fandom on my sleeve, I do believe that I also acknowledge the weaknesses of the Big Ten and others that I support as opposed to blindly believing that they are impervious to mistakes or problems.
However, I still have zero idea where you’ve gotten the impression that I didn’t think that amateurism in college sports would crumble or am some type of defender of the NCAA. You have mentioned this before and I legitimately don’t get it. I have been writing about NIL (before most people here likely even heard of the term) and how players were going to need to get paid (and *deserved* to get paid) and the courts were going to break it all open and that the NCAA was a walking antitrust violation for many, many, many years… and long before it was popular to say so and long before the Alston case. I got attacked by the readers of my own blog when I wrote that players should get paid well over 10 years ago in the wake of the Ed O’Bannon litigation. I don’t know why you keep saying that I was somehow wrong on amateurism when I have been an open believer in players getting paid long before now. Maybe you believe that this is just a “blind squirrel finds a nut” prediction from me, but at least don’t tell me that I didn’t find that particular nut at all. I apologize for the tangent, but this one really irks me because I’m a long-time and unabashed public supporter of player rights on both financial and legal grounds and very openly criticized the Big Ten’s statements on it during the 2010s (e.g. “We’d rather go down to Division III than pay players”) whenever the subject arose.
You said as much in a defense of the NCAA a few years back. Since I'm likely old enough to be you dad's age you will find, when you get here, that decades run together, let alone years. But you essentially defended the NCAA model and didn't think it was vulnerable because "It does too much for the institutions (schools)."
And the only reason for the sock reference was it was obvious this was going back into that circle.
I spent 20 years in corporate life setting up businesses, helping them to run, and prior to that I ran one myself out of necessity when I lost a grandfather. All details matter. Unless you've run one you wouldn't have a clue as to how integral every line of that ledger is with overall success. College sports is absolutely a business, the SCOTUS was spot on to see it that way, the NCAA is grossly outdated and bureaucratized, and we need to move on because the model no longer works for us.
My last 20 years of work were in non-profit endeavors. Ledger lines mattered there too! All of life is a form of business whether the government is capitalistic, socialistic, or communistic. Business abides. It's personal liberty that is in the balance. Whether you barter or buy and sell, details matter. What even most free people, like us, fail to grasp is that we don't actually own anything. The government just agrees to let us believe that we do, until we can't pay our taxes. I'll let that sobering reality sink in, not on you because you know, but upon the rest. And the right to privacy exists until there is a dispute over the amount of taxes due. The invasion of privacy is called an audit. And the real irony is your congressman (no taxation without representation) is actually supposed to represent you, not major corporations in the congressional district, not the government, but you. Good luck to us all!
|
|