quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 11:15 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: (10-28-2025 11:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote: My belief is based on a vague feeling derived from statements by SEC officials and talking heads in the media, but it is a belief that there is a strong sentiment in the SEC that Disney is the SEC's "partner", whereas I think the B1G takes a more "strictly business" view of their media partners, even with FOX.
And IMO it has served them well.
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.
It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade style offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.
(10-28-2025 11:29 AM)JRsec Wrote: Nope! And that's why you never have grasped the SEC mindset. CBS sealed its fate when it refused a pro rata share to Texas A&M and Missouri. Hard to believe from a business perspective that CBS was so short sighted. The SEC understood its ability to draw a large audience for CBS. It wasn't worried about its exposure moving forward because they recognized it as an inferior platform to that of ESPN/ABC.
CBS knew two years before the contract was up how badly they screwed things up. In most cases Frank I would agree that a higher bid would have made the difference, but for Mike Slive and Greg Sankey who worked for Slive when the snub of pro rata happened, they saw CBS as a bad business partner. They would not have renewed with CBS unless all other bidders lowballed them. A competitive bid from CBS was going to be rejected on the grounds of the inability to trust them as a partner. Most times it is only about business. Sometimes it is personal. Now we are all seeing what CBS is worth without the SEC and how much of a solid partner ESPN/ABC is. OTA CBS and NBC are floundering. I'm glad they are with your guys and not our guys!
Here's my outlook in general response to the above sentiments.
The SEC is similar to Notre Dame in that they value things other than money.
Sure, the SEC could have squeezed things in certain situations and made more money. The Big Ten technically did a "better job" from that perspective, but the SEC has a different outlook and that approach is why CBS never had much of a chance. In fact, to my understanding the SEC never even opened up the negotiations to Fox the last time around. The partnership with Disney, in other words, is about more than simply cash.
It makes sense actually when you study culture and psychology. Especially if you've studied Southern culture and its touchstones. The people that run the SEC are the type that value loyalty and other intangible aspects of the notion of partnership.
They also value assets beyond the monetary. Exhibit A is the additions of Texas and Oklahoma to the league and I believe you'll see other very strong additions in the not too distant future. Liquid assets are great, but that's not the only thing people trade in. Exposure is exhibit B..the coverage that the SEC gets on ESPN is unmatched. There's value in that beyond up front money.
Famously, the Masters was broadcast on CBS for many years with no ads. Even now, there's only 4 minutes of ads per hour of broadcast and no ads allowed on the course itself. The concessions were outright cheap, not just affordable. I'm not a golf fan, but it's not hard to see the people that ran Augusta National didn't need the money and valued the experience. With the people that run the SEC, you're dealing with a similar mindset and cultural outlook.
As Frank mentioned, the deal between Fox and the Big Ten is a partnership...sure...but it's a business partnership in the contractual sense. They are tied at the hip legally and thus base their decisions on that formal relationship. Obviously they both see profit in this approach or they wouldn't have entered into it, but this is a different dynamic than what we see in the SEC with its media deals.
Although to be fair, the Big Ten probably threw in that hard with Fox because they wanted a company that would promote them with the same gusto that ESPN promotes the SEC. Fox was basically the only other game in town, the only realistic option to get that sort of coverage. The Big Ten had a personal issue with ESPN, and was willing to pare down the relationship over time. Fox probably demanded more as well to make good on their endeavors.
All in all, this informs where we are with the corporate involvement in college sports. The two biggest dogs on the block(SEC and Big Ten) value certain things and nature took its course from there.
I appreciate your POV and admit mine has no more evidence supporting it than does yours.
Nevertheless, IMO you are being too kind to SEC leadership, basically explaining as a conscious choice (the decisions that have led to marriage with Disney and less $$$ than the ratings would command) what IMO was just poor negotiating. I just do not believe the SEC has media values that differ from maximizing revenue. I think it thought the deals it signed beginning in 2008 did just that, but they just messed up and turned out to be wrong, whereas the B1G has made smarter choices pursuing the same goal.
I mean, if loyalty was the driver, then the SEC should have re-signed with CBS, a company that it had been with since 1994, the dawn of the conference-specific TV deals. IIRC that was the deal that broke up the old CFA agreement that dated from the 1984 SCOTUS decision that liberated conference media rights. So the SEC had a much longer relationship with CBS than ESPN. And IMO, the SEC had no right to feel that CBS had been disloyal about not doing a 2011 pro-rata, as CBS was just abiding by the terms of the contract. But the SEC broke off that relationship in 2020.
Also, IIRC, when the 2008 deal was announced the amount of $$$ included was a prominent part of all the stories that came out. It is a monetary deal, after all so IMO it stands to reason that money would matter most.
Again, your POV is at least as good as mine, but that is how I see it.
|
|