(11-05-2026 10:02 AM)Jhawkinva Wrote: The problem is the SEC gets the benefit of the doubt everywhere.
"Kentucky should be in because they beat LSU and South Carolina."
"Georgia might have the terrible home loss to Auburn, but what about the eye test?"
Record strength should matter or efficiency should matter or they should be balanced.
The problem is record strength is rewarded for the inefficient teams and record strength is sidestepped for the efficient teams.
No other conference gets to play by these "have it all" measures.
Interesting that you point to record strength and efficiency.
Strength of record?
Kentucky #2, Georgia #6, Ole Miss #7, Alabama #8, Texas #11, LSU #16, Tennessee #18.
Efficiency? Georgia #2, Alabama #4, LSU #5, Ole Miss #7, Texas #8, Tennessee #12, Kentucky #15.
Balance those out, and
Georgia #4
Alabama #6
Ole Miss #7
Kentucky #8.5
Texas #9.5
LSU #10.5
Tennessee #15
Not too far off from their CFP rankings. Then, factor in head-to-head, quality wins, and conference strength.
FWIW, here are the ratings for the other contenders:
SOR: #1 Miami, UCLA #3, Indiana #4, Utah #5, Ohio State #8, Wake Forest #10, BYU #12, Notre Dame #13
Efficiency: Notre Dame is #1, Miami is #3, Ohio State #6, Utah #9, Wake Forest #10, Indiana #11, BYU #13, UCLA #16
Combined:
Miami #2
Utah #7
Notre Dame #7
Ohio State #7
Indiana #7.5
UCLA #9.5
Wake Forest #10
BYU #12.5
So, based only on Strength of Record and Efficiencies ratings, the CFP rankings would be:
1) Miami
2) Georgia
3) Alabama
T4) Utah
T4) Ole Miss
T4) Notre Dame
T4) Ohio State
8) Indiana
9) Kentucky
T10) Texas
T10) UCLA
12) Wake Forest
13) LSU
14) BYU
15) Tennessee
Not too far off. Then, factor in:
- Alabama lost to #15
- Texas beat TWO of the teams tied for fourth
- Notre Dame lost to #14
- Ohio State lost to #10 and a team outside these contender ratings
- BYU beat #4
...and you get pretty close to the CFP rankings.
1) Miami
2) Georgia
3) Utah [+1 because undefeated?]
4) Indiana [+4 because reigning national champ?]
5) Alabama[-2 because loss to #15?]
6) Kentucky [+3 because win over #13?]
7) Texas [+3 because wins over #T4, #T4, and #15]
8) UCLA [+2 because undefeated?]
9) BYU [+3 because win over #T4]
10) Ole Miss [-6 because loss to #10 and Florida(who would be #16)?]
11) Notre Dame [-7 because no quality win and loss to #14?]
12) Ohio State [-8 because losses to #T10 and USC?]
13) Tennessee [+3 because win over #3?]
14) LSU [-1 because no quality win?]
....
16) Wake Forest (-4 because no quality win?]
FWIW, others' combined ratings:
Florida #18.5
Iowa #18.5
Houston #19
USC #19.5
Missouri #20.5
Northwestern #21
Texas Tech #22
Oregon #23.5
Boise State #25.5
South Carolina #25.5
Arizona #26.5