Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,065
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 11:46 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (11-03-2026 08:04 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote: I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.
But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.
IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.
That’s all wrong.
Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.
Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.
Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.
Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.
Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.
As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.
Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.
To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.
Classic subjective fandom statement without doing your homework.
The biggest errors by the CFP Selection Committee during the brief 12-team era has been the love affair with SEC programs. Even with home field advantages, the SEC record has been a disappointing 5 wins versus 8 losses. Compared to:
Big Ten - 11 wins v 5 losses
ACC - 3 wins v 3 losses
The CFP Selection Committee has a clear bias…to support ESPN’s interests which are currently fully engaged with the SEC.
Performance in the playoffs is irrelevant as to who should be in. We have to decided based on the evidence at hand.
The ACC has been the worst of the A4 conferences in both 2024 and 2025. They were last in the MC both years. They are currently last in the MC this year as well.
IMO when you play in such a bad conference, an 11-1 record means next to nothing unless you proved something OOC. Wake Forest OOC opponents were Akron, Purdue and Merrimack. That is putrid.
Nobody outside of ACC territory has any reason to respect wins against teams like Louisville, Duke, Pitt etc. These teams have beaten nobody.
The ACC's *best* win OOC vs another A4 conference is Duke barely beating Illinois 31-27. Illinois is #50 in the Massey Composite, which is 12th place in the B1G. And that's the ACC's best win. Everyone else they've beaten is ranked lower. That's awful.
That's not fanboyism, IMO, it's just the reality of what beating up an ACC schedule should mean this year - next to nothing. Wake should be treated like a G6 team when comparing to 9-3 SEC or B1G teams.
The ACC is not last, they're fourth. Nice spin.
Ranking systems begin with assumptions, and from there having multiple agree is consensus, not accuracy. Teams ranked higher in those systems benefit from playing one another, and it's a compounding effect built on subjective assumptions. So the B1G and now Monster XII playing in silos for the most part has helped them climb the rankings.
BUT
WAKE IS 13th IN THE MASSEY
|
|