Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
ACC is having a bad year again.
Author Message
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #61
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-02-2026 01:32 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:44 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:10 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:44 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  Take away #1 Miami and the ACC is still the Big East of old. The only other ranked squad is going to be Wake Forest? If Miami leaves for the SEC/Big 10 with UNC, Clemson and Florida St does it maintain P4 status or does it become a G7 conference?

Ehh??

Miami and Wake Forest are both likely CFP teams. Duke, SMU and Virginia Tech should be ranked. Clemson and Louisville are solid.

Wake has only one loss, but they probably need to win out AND get some help to make the CFP. Not saying that it can't be done, but calling them a *likely* CFP team at this point in time is probably overselling their CFP chances just a bit.

WF only has 4 games left, and they've been blowing out schools for the past month. No way they're left out with 1 loss, or 2 losses if they lose the ACC CCG for that matter.

Wake could absolutely miss the field if they have no marquee wins.

If WF has only one loss going into the ACC CCG, they'll be in the top 10. Precedent from the 2 years of the current 12 team CFP makes it unlikely that a loss in the ACC CCG to a top 5, perhaps #1 Miami would drop them out. Perhaps if Miami blows them out by 50 and the QB and entire offensive line quit the team?

Now, COULD that happen if every single team in the current top 15 wins out? Sure, though in that scenario, if it's even possible which I doubt, WF wouldn't be in the top 10 going into the CCG, anyway. Far more likely, WF would be getting compared to a bunch of 3 loss SEC teams and still make the field.

FWIW, WF's current FPI on ESPN is 11, and their SOR is 11, and their SOS is 43. SMU in 2024 had an SOS of 75 GOING INTO THE CCG, which they lost but also moved their SOS up to a more respectable 55, and they still managed to turf out 3 loss Alabama, USCe and Ole Miss. WF's SOS would only go up with a CCG rematch with Miami. They'd be a far more deserving at-large CCG loser than SMU in 2024. Or can we forget last year, when Alabama didn't drop at all despite getting thrashed by Georgia in the SEC CCG?
11-03-2026 02:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #62
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:44 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:10 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:44 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  Take away #1 Miami and the ACC is still the Big East of old. The only other ranked squad is going to be Wake Forest? If Miami leaves for the SEC/Big 10 with UNC, Clemson and Florida St does it maintain P4 status or does it become a G7 conference?

Ehh??

Miami and Wake Forest are both likely CFP teams. Duke, SMU and Virginia Tech should be ranked. Clemson and Louisville are solid.

Wake has only one loss, but they probably need to win out AND get some help to make the CFP. Not saying that it can't be done, but calling them a *likely* CFP team at this point in time is probably overselling their CFP chances just a bit.

I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.

But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.

IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.

That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

The issue last year wasn't that Miami got in ahead of ND, it was that the CFP Committee wouldn't take the h2h into account unless they were ranked directly adjacent in the rankings, then they contorted themselves in all sorts of directions to make that happen so that the ACC didn't miss out on getting a single school into the CFP. If they'd correctly taken the h2h into account all along then Miami would have been ahead of ND all season long.
11-03-2026 02:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #63
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:44 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:10 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ehh??

Miami and Wake Forest are both likely CFP teams. Duke, SMU and Virginia Tech should be ranked. Clemson and Louisville are solid.

Wake has only one loss, but they probably need to win out AND get some help to make the CFP. Not saying that it can't be done, but calling them a *likely* CFP team at this point in time is probably overselling their CFP chances just a bit.

I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.

But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.

IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.

That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.

This is ridiculous, and I'm embarrassed to say that your SEC bias is showing again. SOS 43, SOR 11. With 4 games left to play that SOR will only go up if they keep winning, and with a rematch with Miami in the CCG, that SOS is likely to hold steady at worst or, more likely, end up in the 30s. It's ridiculous to claim "I don't see any tough teams on their schedule" as justification for keeping a 1 loss P4 team out of the CFP, something that didn't even happen to SMU and their terrible 75 SOS in 2024. And all of this assumes that Wake doesn't continue blitzing everybody by 40 points like they have in recent weeks.
11-03-2026 02:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TexanMark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,093
Joined: Jul 2003
Reputation: 1539
I Root For: Syracuse
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Post: #64
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-01-2026 08:08 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 10:49 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 10:11 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:46 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:44 AM)billybobby777 Wrote:  Take away #1 Miami and the ACC is still the Big East of old. The only other ranked squad is going to be Wake Forest? If Miami leaves for the SEC/Big 10 with UNC, Clemson and Florida St does it maintain P4 status or does it become a G7 conference?

Every school in the ACC could go 6-6 for the next decade and they'd still be a power conference. I can think of nearly 1 billion reasons why, just this year. All the troll threads in the world can't turn the American's $127m into $900m.

Agreed. They’d still get paid at least like the Big 12. The ACC could lose its top 8 schools in value and still have enough old money brands to survive with power status.

Hmmm... maybe but that assumes the ACC loses nobody else to the Big 12.

Let's say

Miami, ND, UNC, VA, Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT leave for the P2.

ACC now has following 10 schools leftover

GT, Duke, Wake,
Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
SMU, Cal, Stan

At that point I would guess at least Lou and Pitt would bale for the Big 12. And at that point, the ACC would no longer be a power conference.

He just said if they lose their top 8, not top 10 or more.

I’d say that the ACC losing just 2 is dead even with the Big 12, losing 4-8 they’d be behind, but perhaps not quite so far behind as many would believe. If all they had left was the schools you listed, they’d be just like the hateful 8 from the big 12, reloading and decimating the top of the g ranks. Perhaps they’d only get $30-40m per school on their next contract instead of $60m, but there would still be a yawning chasm between them and any g conference, and a small but noticeable gap between then and the Big 12 in the other direction.

As long as the ACCN stays intact and there is hundreds of millions of dollars coming in, I'm not sure anyone leaves for the Big12
11-03-2026 03:07 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #65
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 01:16 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:58 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:50 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:31 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 08:04 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  [/b]

Classic subjective fandom statement without doing your homework.

The biggest errors by the CFP Selection Committee during the brief 12-team era has been the love affair with SEC programs. Even with home field advantages, the SEC record has been a disappointing 5 wins versus 8 losses. Compared to:

Big Ten - 11 wins v 5 losses
ACC - 3 wins v 3 losses

The CFP Selection Committee has a clear bias…to support ESPN’s interests which are currently fully engaged with the SEC.

Don't waste your time. He will never have an objective conversation.

Examples:

• Will die on his sword saying ND deserved the CFP last season, but cannot provide a noteworthy win. ND is shaping up the same way they did last year where they lose their only CFP-level games. But, throws shade at the ACC and Wake claiming no noteworthy wins. Hmmmm.

• Clamors about the Big East being the best hoops conference ever. I did my homework and provided him objective numbers in the form of conference win percentages, and it turned out the ACC was superior during the stretch he cited. Ignored it. Argues from a position of passion.

My conclusion: perhaps he was a closet ND fan in years past, and has some survivor's guilt due to the fact Notre Dame could have done more and saved the Big East (his fav conference) in years past. Instead he blames the ACC and will take any chance he can get to bash it.

Of course ND deserved the CFP last year. We were, by all the metrics, easily one of the 12 best teams.

That said, Miami deserved to be in, as they were too. The screw-job of ND happened because the CFP maneuvered Miami next to ND in the last poll with ZERO justification so they could claim H2H, and because of the stupid conference-champs and G5 inclusion rules.

ND had no CFP level wins last year. I just played your own hand.

Notre Dame was left out of the CFP last year because they were 0-2 against CFP at-large contenders and a helping of SEC bias. See also the 8-game SEC conference schedule.

This year, Notre Dame benefits from an absolutely silly and completely unfair rule that gives them PREFERENCE over other CFP at-large contenders. Notre Dame still has cushion to lose to Miami, even though the Irish may have another 0-fer against CFP contenders during the regular season.

I think ND was left out because of unjustifiable CFP maneuvering in the penultimate week of the rankings. The second to last rankings of the season, the CFP moved Alabama from 10 to 9 and Notre Dame fell from 9 to 10. This IMO was completely unjustifiable, as ND had just crushed a bad Stanford team while Alabama had barely squeaked by a mediocre Auburn team. Those results were functionally equal, so no justification for the flip - other than to position ND next to Miami in the final rankings so as to invoke "head to head".

The other thing that screwed the Irish was the absurd G5 inclusion and conference champs rule. By their own rankings, ND was in the final top 12, we were in fact #11. But we were bumped two places down, and out, to make room for two conference champs, one a G5, that were ranked much lower. That was IMO absurd.

Beyond that, don't fret about the Top 12 rule. It is IMO a rule that should apply to everyone, not just ND, as that would eliminate conference champ autobids. But if the CFP wants to keep ND out, they will merely find some excuse to rank them #13. The rule would only have teeth if it was tied to computer metrics that the CFP cannot manipulate, like "ND gets in if it is the top 12 of SOR (or FPI, or SP+, etc)". But it isn't. It is at the whim of the committee.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2026 08:01 AM by quo vadis.)
11-04-2026 08:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #66
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 02:50 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:44 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  Wake has only one loss, but they probably need to win out AND get some help to make the CFP. Not saying that it can't be done, but calling them a *likely* CFP team at this point in time is probably overselling their CFP chances just a bit.

I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.

But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.

IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.

That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.

This is ridiculous, and I'm embarrassed to say that your SEC bias is showing again. SOS 43, SOR 11. With 4 games left to play that SOR will only go up if they keep winning, and with a rematch with Miami in the CCG, that SOS is likely to hold steady at worst or, more likely, end up in the 30s. It's ridiculous to claim "I don't see any tough teams on their schedule" as justification for keeping a 1 loss P4 team out of the CFP, something that didn't even happen to SMU and their terrible 75 SOS in 2024. And all of this assumes that Wake doesn't continue blitzing everybody by 40 points like they have in recent weeks.

IDK ... IMO the disparity between SEC and ACC schedules is massive. E.g., Someone was complaining in the CFP thread that Texas and Kentucky are overrated. But in the Sagarin SOS ratings, they have played the #7 and #9 toughest schedules, and each STILL has to run a gauntlet of good teams as ranked in the Massey Composite. Texas still has to play top 20 LSU and top 20 Missouri both on the road! Kentucky still has to play top 20 Missouri, top 20 Tennessee, and top 25 Florida! They also play top 30 Louisville.

Wake on the other hand has the current #53 Sagarin schedule, and they play teams currently ranked #31, #40, #100 and unranked in the MC. That's absurdly easy, for a schedule already very easy. I mean, even regarding Texas, their game vs Texas AM, #38 in the MC, would be the second toughest game Wake has left to play in the regular season!

Wake would likely be about a 10-point dog if they played at LSU next week.

Really, if there was justice, Wake would play Kentucky's remaining schedule, or Texas's and Kentucky would play Wake's remaining schedule. There is an enormous disparity playing in the ACC - and against Wake's putrid OOC schedule - and playing in the SEC.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2026 08:15 AM by quo vadis.)
11-04-2026 08:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,065
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #67
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 08:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 01:16 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:58 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:50 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:31 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Don't waste your time. He will never have an objective conversation.

Examples:

• Will die on his sword saying ND deserved the CFP last season, but cannot provide a noteworthy win. ND is shaping up the same way they did last year where they lose their only CFP-level games. But, throws shade at the ACC and Wake claiming no noteworthy wins. Hmmmm.

• Clamors about the Big East being the best hoops conference ever. I did my homework and provided him objective numbers in the form of conference win percentages, and it turned out the ACC was superior during the stretch he cited. Ignored it. Argues from a position of passion.

My conclusion: perhaps he was a closet ND fan in years past, and has some survivor's guilt due to the fact Notre Dame could have done more and saved the Big East (his fav conference) in years past. Instead he blames the ACC and will take any chance he can get to bash it.

Of course ND deserved the CFP last year. We were, by all the metrics, easily one of the 12 best teams.

That said, Miami deserved to be in, as they were too. The screw-job of ND happened because the CFP maneuvered Miami next to ND in the last poll with ZERO justification so they could claim H2H, and because of the stupid conference-champs and G5 inclusion rules.

ND had no CFP level wins last year. I just played your own hand.

Notre Dame was left out of the CFP last year because they were 0-2 against CFP at-large contenders and a helping of SEC bias. See also the 8-game SEC conference schedule.

This year, Notre Dame benefits from an absolutely silly and completely unfair rule that gives them PREFERENCE over other CFP at-large contenders. Notre Dame still has cushion to lose to Miami, even though the Irish may have another 0-fer against CFP contenders during the regular season.

I think ND was left out because of unjustifiable CFP maneuvering in the penultimate week of the rankings. The second to last rankings of the season, the CFP moved Alabama from 10 to 9 and Notre Dame fell from 9 to 10. This IMO was completely unjustifiable, as ND had just crushed a bad Stanford team while Alabama had barely squeaked by a mediocre Auburn team. Those results were functionally equal, so no justification for the flip - other than to position ND next to Miami in the final rankings so as to invoke "head to head".

The other thing that screwed the Irish was the absurd G5 inclusion and conference champs rule. By their own rankings, ND was in the final top 12, we were in fact #11. But we were bumped two places down, and out, to make room for two conference champs, one a G5, that were ranked much lower. That was IMO absurd.

Beyond that, don't fret about the Top 12 rule. It is IMO a rule that should apply to everyone, not just ND, as that would eliminate conference champ autobids. But if the CFP wants to keep ND out, they will merely find some excuse to rank them #13. The rule would only have teeth if it was tied to computer metrics that the CFP cannot manipulate, like "ND gets in if it is the top 12 of SOR (or FPI, or SP+, etc)". But it isn't. It is at the whim of the committee.

They can vote however they want at any point. There is no law ruling a team can't drop two spots. The only poll that matters is the final poll, that's how it works.
11-04-2026 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,065
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #68
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 08:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 02:50 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.

But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.

IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.

That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.

This is ridiculous, and I'm embarrassed to say that your SEC bias is showing again. SOS 43, SOR 11. With 4 games left to play that SOR will only go up if they keep winning, and with a rematch with Miami in the CCG, that SOS is likely to hold steady at worst or, more likely, end up in the 30s. It's ridiculous to claim "I don't see any tough teams on their schedule" as justification for keeping a 1 loss P4 team out of the CFP, something that didn't even happen to SMU and their terrible 75 SOS in 2024. And all of this assumes that Wake doesn't continue blitzing everybody by 40 points like they have in recent weeks.

IDK ... IMO the disparity between SEC and ACC schedules is massive. E.g., Someone was complaining in the CFP thread that Texas and Kentucky are overrated. But in the Sagarin SOS ratings, they have played the #7 and #9 toughest schedules, and each STILL has to run a gauntlet of good teams as ranked in the Massey Composite. Texas still has to play top 20 LSU and top 20 Missouri both on the road! Kentucky still has to play top 20 Missouri, top 20 Tennessee, and top 25 Florida! They also play top 30 Louisville.

Wake on the other hand has the current #53 Sagarin schedule, and they play teams currently ranked #31, #40, #100 and unranked in the MC. That's absurdly easy, for a schedule already very easy. I mean, even regarding Texas, their game vs Texas AM, #38 in the MC, would be the second toughest game Wake has left to play in the regular season!

Wake would likely be about a 10-point dog if they played at LSU next week.

Really, if there was justice, Wake would play Kentucky's remaining schedule, or Texas's and Kentucky would play Wake's remaining schedule. There is an enormous disparity playing in the ACC - and against Wake's putrid OOC schedule - and playing in the SEC.

Wake is #13 in the Massey.

Cope.
11-04-2026 09:30 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #69
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 11:46 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 08:04 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 08:20 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  I don't think Wake should sniff the CFP no matter what they do, their schedules is way too soft.

But one thing I can say is that IMO, the CFP has been kinder to the ACC than any other conference since the expansion to twelve teams. Two years ago, it put two ACC teams - Clemson and SMU - in when the conference was even worse than this year and neither of those teams was top-12 material. Last year, it shamelessly maneuvered Miami - admittedly deserving but still - next to ND over the last two weeks to get them in to the playoffs when it looked like the ACC could be left out.

IMO, over 2024 and 2025, the ACC should have gotten at most two teams in total, and really deserved just one, and yet they got three in. So don't discount the CFP's ability to bend over backwards for them yet again.

That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.


Classic subjective fandom statement without doing your homework.

The biggest errors by the CFP Selection Committee during the brief 12-team era has been the love affair with SEC programs. Even with home field advantages, the SEC record has been a disappointing 5 wins versus 8 losses. Compared to:

Big Ten - 11 wins v 5 losses
ACC - 3 wins v 3 losses

The CFP Selection Committee has a clear bias…to support ESPN’s interests which are currently fully engaged with the SEC.

Performance in the playoffs is irrelevant as to who should be in. We have to decided based on the evidence at hand.

The ACC has been the worst of the A4 conferences in both 2024 and 2025. They were last in the MC both years. They are currently last in the MC this year as well.

IMO when you play in such a bad conference, an 11-1 record means next to nothing unless you proved something OOC. Wake Forest OOC opponents were Akron, Purdue and Merrimack. That is putrid.

Nobody outside of ACC territory has any reason to respect wins against teams like Louisville, Duke, Pitt etc. These teams have beaten nobody.

The ACC's *best* win OOC vs another A4 conference is Duke barely beating Illinois 31-27. Illinois is #50 in the Massey Composite, which is 12th place in the B1G. And that's the ACC's best win. Everyone else they've beaten is ranked lower. That's awful.

That's not fanboyism, IMO, it's just the reality of what beating up an ACC schedule should mean this year - next to nothing. Wake should be treated like a G6 team when comparing to 9-3 SEC or B1G teams.

The bolded is wrong.

First, the CFP Selection Committee is using a specified criteria to select teams…if the Committee keeps selecting lots of SEC teams that lose in their first CFP game, then the Committee’s criteria needs to be changed. SEC teams are not definitionally the ‘best’ or ‘deserving’. The evidence at hand is always bound by the selection criteria, which is constantly being reevaluated/tweaked by each selection Committee.

Second, last year’s CFP results proved that the last team selected (Miami) was actually better than three higher ranked teams (TAMU, Ole Miss and Ohio State). In other words, the most impactful decision of the Committee was the inclusion/exclusion of Miami v Notre Dame. We’ll never definitively know whether the Committee made the right selections (other than Indiana and Miami being the two best from amongst the chosen 12 teams). Given the quandary, FBS commissioners quickly expanded the CFP to 24 teams.

Finally, conference membership is now being used to advantage teams in the SEC. To most Notre Dame and BYU fans, Alabama and Oklahoma were selected last year more for their pedigree than on-field accomplishments. Alabama was completely outclassed in the SEC CCG, yet the CFP Committee was unwilling to even alter their ranking.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2026 02:52 PM by Wahoowa84.)
11-04-2026 02:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Hokie Mark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,875
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 2008
I Root For: VT, ACC teams
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #70
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 11:50 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Of course ND deserved the CFP last year. We were, by all the metrics, easily one of the 12 best teams.

That said, Miami deserved to be in, as they were too. The screw-job of ND happened because the CFP maneuvered Miami next to ND in the last poll with ZERO justification so they could claim H2H, and because of the stupid conference-champs and G5 inclusion rules.

If both ND and Miami deserved to be in last year (which I agree with), then including Miami is NOT any injustice to ND. You need to identify which teams were NOT worthy of inclusion.

If you want to blame the ACC's tiebreaker rules for allowing Duke to win the ACC CG, I think you're on solid ground. That had the side effect of bringing a 2nd G6 champ into the playoffs, thus eating another spot.

That said, I also think both ND and Miami were better than some SEC at-large teams, Alabama and Oklahoma in particular. The CFP love affair with Alabama has been a major problem for years, yet most fans seem afraid to call them out.
11-04-2026 03:07 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #71
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 02:50 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:46 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 08:04 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.


Classic subjective fandom statement without doing your homework.

The biggest errors by the CFP Selection Committee during the brief 12-team era has been the love affair with SEC programs. Even with home field advantages, the SEC record has been a disappointing 5 wins versus 8 losses. Compared to:

Big Ten - 11 wins v 5 losses
ACC - 3 wins v 3 losses

The CFP Selection Committee has a clear bias…to support ESPN’s interests which are currently fully engaged with the SEC.

Performance in the playoffs is irrelevant as to who should be in. We have to decided based on the evidence at hand.

The ACC has been the worst of the A4 conferences in both 2024 and 2025. They were last in the MC both years. They are currently last in the MC this year as well.

IMO when you play in such a bad conference, an 11-1 record means next to nothing unless you proved something OOC. Wake Forest OOC opponents were Akron, Purdue and Merrimack. That is putrid.

Nobody outside of ACC territory has any reason to respect wins against teams like Louisville, Duke, Pitt etc. These teams have beaten nobody.

The ACC's *best* win OOC vs another A4 conference is Duke barely beating Illinois 31-27. Illinois is #50 in the Massey Composite, which is 12th place in the B1G. And that's the ACC's best win. Everyone else they've beaten is ranked lower. That's awful.

That's not fanboyism, IMO, it's just the reality of what beating up an ACC schedule should mean this year - next to nothing. Wake should be treated like a G6 team when comparing to 9-3 SEC or B1G teams.

The bolded is wrong.

First, the CFP Selection Committee is using a specified criteria to select teams…if the Committee keeps selecting lots of SEC teams that lose in their first CFP game, then the Committee’s criteria needs to be changed. SEC teams are not definitionally the ‘best’ or ‘deserving’. The evidence at hand is always bound by the selection criteria, which is constantly being reevaluated/tweaked by each selection Committee.

Second, last year’s CFP results proved that the last team selected (Miami) was actually better than three higher ranked teams (TAMU, Ole Miss and Ohio State). In other words, the most impactful decision of the Committee was the inclusion/exclusion of Miami v Notre Dame. We’ll never definitively know whether the Committee made the right selections (other than Indiana and Miami being the two best from amongst the chosen 12 teams). Given the quandary, FBS commissioners quickly expanded the CFP to 24 teams.

Finally, conference membership is now being used to advantage teams in the SEC. To most Notre Dame and BYU fans, Alabama and Oklahoma were selected last year more for their pedigree than on-field accomplishments. Alabama was completely outclassed in the SEC CCG, yet the CFP Committee was unwilling to even alter their ranking.

No, IMO the bolded from my previous post is correct. We don't have a crystal ball we can only go on the evidence we have at the time. As I said, I think Miami deserved to be in the playoffs based on that evidence as all the metrics had them as a top 12 team. Also, even if we do look back retrospectively, the result of a game doesn't "prove" anything. Anyone can win a given game. NIU beat Notre Dame in 2024, but they weren't a better team.

Also, we have to look at seedings. It's like the NCAA tournament. Maybe a conference gets four teams in, but in the tourney they are all facing higher-seeded teams and are underdogs. If they go 0-4, that doesn't mean they didn't belong and the conference got too many teams in, it means they lost like they were supposed to. If you think too many SEC teams got in last year, you have to explain who you think should have gotten in instead, and why, not just point at them losing, IMO. BYU was also completely smashed in their CCG, so IMO no reason to think they would have done better than Alabama in the playoffs. Alabama actually did win a road playoff game last year before getting wiped by the #1 team. The SEC has IMO deserved the most teams in the playoffs, but in 2024 and 2025 they have tended to be 8/9/10/11/12 type teams, thus not the type of teams that will go far.

As for Alabama specifically, I think they were a top 12 team and should have been in the playoffs last year too. What I think was completely unjustified was the way the CFP put Alabama over ND in the penultimate rankings so as to put Miami in position to pass ND in the final rankings based on H2H. IMO that is an example of human chicanery you don't find in computers.

I checked Vegas hypothetical, and if Wake played at LSU this week like Alabama has to, Wake would be a 10-point underdog. There is nothing IMO about them to believe they are a playoff team. And sadly, unlike say Notre Dame, they have no opportunity coming up to prove they are. Their schedule, save for Miami, is just very soft.
11-05-2026 07:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #72
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 03:07 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:50 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Of course ND deserved the CFP last year. We were, by all the metrics, easily one of the 12 best teams.

That said, Miami deserved to be in, as they were too. The screw-job of ND happened because the CFP maneuvered Miami next to ND in the last poll with ZERO justification so they could claim H2H, and because of the stupid conference-champs and G5 inclusion rules.

If both ND and Miami deserved to be in last year (which I agree with), then including Miami is NOT any injustice to ND. You need to identify which teams were NOT worthy of inclusion.

If you want to blame the ACC's tiebreaker rules for allowing Duke to win the ACC CG, I think you're on solid ground. That had the side effect of bringing a 2nd G6 champ into the playoffs, thus eating another spot.

That said, I also think both ND and Miami were better than some SEC at-large teams, Alabama and Oklahoma in particular. The CFP love affair with Alabama has been a major problem for years, yet most fans seem afraid to call them out.

IMO Notre Dame was screwed by two things, neither of which was Miami's fault: First, the CFP pulled IMO a fast one by moving Alabama ahead of ND in the penultimate rankings for no good reason, that put Miami in a position to bump ND based on H2H and them otherwise being next to each other in the rankings. That did enable them to put one deserving team (Miami) in, but at the expense of another (ND).

And second, the silly G5-inclusion and five conference champs get in rules, which put James Madison and Tulane, two teams that clearly were not as good as ND or BYU, in the playoffs. I mean, the CFP literally admitted this, as they ranked ND #11 and BYU #12, meaning they felt they were two of the top 12 teams.

As for Alabama, IMO these current Alabama teams are obviously not the dominant Saban-era teams. But last year they (and Oklahoma) were the 10th or 11th best teams. Rank them ahead or behind Notre Dame if you want (and I would have put them behind us), they deserved to be in too. They also were better than James Madison or Tulane. It's just that when you are the 11th best team in a 12 team playoff, you obviously are likely to lose early. That doesn't mean you didn't belong.
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2026 08:05 AM by quo vadis.)
11-05-2026 08:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #73
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 09:30 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-04-2026 08:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 02:50 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.

This is ridiculous, and I'm embarrassed to say that your SEC bias is showing again. SOS 43, SOR 11. With 4 games left to play that SOR will only go up if they keep winning, and with a rematch with Miami in the CCG, that SOS is likely to hold steady at worst or, more likely, end up in the 30s. It's ridiculous to claim "I don't see any tough teams on their schedule" as justification for keeping a 1 loss P4 team out of the CFP, something that didn't even happen to SMU and their terrible 75 SOS in 2024. And all of this assumes that Wake doesn't continue blitzing everybody by 40 points like they have in recent weeks.

IDK ... IMO the disparity between SEC and ACC schedules is massive. E.g., Someone was complaining in the CFP thread that Texas and Kentucky are overrated. But in the Sagarin SOS ratings, they have played the #7 and #9 toughest schedules, and each STILL has to run a gauntlet of good teams as ranked in the Massey Composite. Texas still has to play top 20 LSU and top 20 Missouri both on the road! Kentucky still has to play top 20 Missouri, top 20 Tennessee, and top 25 Florida! They also play top 30 Louisville.

Wake on the other hand has the current #53 Sagarin schedule, and they play teams currently ranked #31, #40, #100 and unranked in the MC. That's absurdly easy, for a schedule already very easy. I mean, even regarding Texas, their game vs Texas AM, #38 in the MC, would be the second toughest game Wake has left to play in the regular season!

Wake would likely be about a 10-point dog if they played at LSU next week.

Really, if there was justice, Wake would play Kentucky's remaining schedule, or Texas's and Kentucky would play Wake's remaining schedule. There is an enormous disparity playing in the ACC - and against Wake's putrid OOC schedule - and playing in the SEC.

Wake is #13 in the Massey.

Cope.

... and Kentucky and Texas are both ahead of them. So why is Wake playing Merrimack, Duke, SMU and Georgia Tech, two of which are literally outside the top 100 in the Massey, while Kentucky has to play Tennessee, Florida, Missouri and Louisville, all of whom are ranked *ahead* of all four teams that Wake Forest plays?

Makes zero sense IMO for Wake/ACC fans to expect that if Wake has a better record going forward against their soft-shell schedule that they should move ahead of Kentucky, who already has played a far tougher schedule (#9 vs #53 in Sagarin) and has a far tougher one ahead?

Sadly, if that does happen, they will likely be ranked higher in the MC as well, as one flaw in computers is they tend to overrate W/L records too, just not as badly as people do.

That's why the SEC deserves more autobids for the playoffs, IMO.
11-05-2026 08:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,065
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #74
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-05-2026 08:12 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-04-2026 09:30 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-04-2026 08:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 02:50 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.

This is ridiculous, and I'm embarrassed to say that your SEC bias is showing again. SOS 43, SOR 11. With 4 games left to play that SOR will only go up if they keep winning, and with a rematch with Miami in the CCG, that SOS is likely to hold steady at worst or, more likely, end up in the 30s. It's ridiculous to claim "I don't see any tough teams on their schedule" as justification for keeping a 1 loss P4 team out of the CFP, something that didn't even happen to SMU and their terrible 75 SOS in 2024. And all of this assumes that Wake doesn't continue blitzing everybody by 40 points like they have in recent weeks.

IDK ... IMO the disparity between SEC and ACC schedules is massive. E.g., Someone was complaining in the CFP thread that Texas and Kentucky are overrated. But in the Sagarin SOS ratings, they have played the #7 and #9 toughest schedules, and each STILL has to run a gauntlet of good teams as ranked in the Massey Composite. Texas still has to play top 20 LSU and top 20 Missouri both on the road! Kentucky still has to play top 20 Missouri, top 20 Tennessee, and top 25 Florida! They also play top 30 Louisville.

Wake on the other hand has the current #53 Sagarin schedule, and they play teams currently ranked #31, #40, #100 and unranked in the MC. That's absurdly easy, for a schedule already very easy. I mean, even regarding Texas, their game vs Texas AM, #38 in the MC, would be the second toughest game Wake has left to play in the regular season!

Wake would likely be about a 10-point dog if they played at LSU next week.

Really, if there was justice, Wake would play Kentucky's remaining schedule, or Texas's and Kentucky would play Wake's remaining schedule. There is an enormous disparity playing in the ACC - and against Wake's putrid OOC schedule - and playing in the SEC.

Wake is #13 in the Massey.

Cope.

... and Kentucky and Texas are both ahead of them. So why is Wake playing Merrimack, Duke, SMU and Georgia Tech, two of which are literally outside the top 100 in the Massey, while Kentucky has to play Tennessee, Florida, Missouri and Louisville, all of whom are ranked *ahead* of all four teams that Wake Forest plays?

Makes zero sense IMO for Wake/ACC fans to expect that if Wake has a better record going forward against their soft-shell schedule that they should move ahead of Kentucky, who already has played a far tougher schedule (#9 vs #53 in Sagarin) and has a far tougher one ahead?

Sadly, if that does happen, they will likely be ranked higher in the MC as well, as one flaw in computers is they tend to overrate W/L records too, just not as badly as people do.

That's why the SEC deserves more autobids for the playoffs, IMO.

Kentucky makes more money. Boohoo. Wake would love that opportunity. Can you arrange it for them? Put in a good word with Sankey?

The Massey includes people's polls. It's just an aggregate system.

Just admit the foundation of your arguments rely heavily on your own subjective eye test, and from there you manipulate various ranking systems to support your POV when it is convenient.
11-05-2026 09:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Jhawkinva Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 645
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation: 202
I Root For: Kansas
Location:
Post: #75
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
The problem is the SEC gets the benefit of the doubt everywhere.

"Kentucky should be in because they beat LSU and South Carolina."

"Georgia might have the terrible home loss to Auburn, but what about the eye test?"

Record strength should matter or efficiency should matter or they should be balanced.

The problem is record strength is rewarded for the inefficient teams and record strength is sidestepped for the efficient teams.

No other conference gets to play by these "have it all" measures.
11-05-2026 10:02 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #76
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 02:50 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:46 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 08:04 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 07:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-02-2026 01:35 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  That’s all wrong.

Wake has played a better SOS than many of the current CFP contenders…per ESPN, Wake’s SOS is better than Miami, UCLA, Utah, BYU and Notre Dame.

Even with the usual SEC bias, ESPN advanced metrics currently have Wake’s FPI as #11 and strength-of-record #11. Although there’s many games left to play, this bodes well for Wake’s CFP candidacy in a 12-team CFP.

Finally, continuing to whine about Miami’s CFP selection last year proves your lack of reasonable thought. Miami actually defeated Notre Dame on the field in the regular season, then beat TAMU in College Station in the playoffs, and beat Ohio State & Ole Miss en route to the championship game. You’re merely advocating for an SEC + B1G + ND invitational tournament…without any interest in a true playoff based on actual merit and performance.

Well regarding Wake, I just looked at their schedule and strained to find any quality. Yes, they've played Miami, obviously a good team. Other than that? Their OOC schedule is Akron, Purdue, and this week "Merrimack". That's a terrible OOC schedule. They needed double-OT to beat an awful Purdue team.

Other than that, just a big pile of mediocre to bad ACC teams (Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia). Nothing worth mentioning there.

As for ND last year, my issue isn't that Miami got in. They were one of the 12 best teams after the regular season (can't look at how they did in the playoffs as that info wasn't known then). Miami last year is the IMO indisputable ACC team that deserved to be in the last two years.

Nevertheless, I also think the CFP engaged in unjustifiable rankings the last two weeks to maneuver Miami into a position where they could invoke H2H to put Miami in. Especially, when Miami beat ND on their home field on an at-the-buzzer FG. That's not even a H2H win worth giving weight to, given the HFA. ND was also one of the 12 best teams, and should have been in as well.

To me, the CFP has bent over backwards to get ACC teams in, despite the ACC being terrible on the field the last three years of the 12 team CFP.


Classic subjective fandom statement without doing your homework.

The biggest errors by the CFP Selection Committee during the brief 12-team era has been the love affair with SEC programs. Even with home field advantages, the SEC record has been a disappointing 5 wins versus 8 losses. Compared to:

Big Ten - 11 wins v 5 losses
ACC - 3 wins v 3 losses

The CFP Selection Committee has a clear bias…to support ESPN’s interests which are currently fully engaged with the SEC.

Performance in the playoffs is irrelevant as to who should be in. We have to decided based on the evidence at hand.

The ACC has been the worst of the A4 conferences in both 2024 and 2025. They were last in the MC both years. They are currently last in the MC this year as well.

IMO when you play in such a bad conference, an 11-1 record means next to nothing unless you proved something OOC. Wake Forest OOC opponents were Akron, Purdue and Merrimack. That is putrid.

Nobody outside of ACC territory has any reason to respect wins against teams like Louisville, Duke, Pitt etc. These teams have beaten nobody.

The ACC's *best* win OOC vs another A4 conference is Duke barely beating Illinois 31-27. Illinois is #50 in the Massey Composite, which is 12th place in the B1G. And that's the ACC's best win. Everyone else they've beaten is ranked lower. That's awful.

That's not fanboyism, IMO, it's just the reality of what beating up an ACC schedule should mean this year - next to nothing. Wake should be treated like a G6 team when comparing to 9-3 SEC or B1G teams.

The bolded is wrong.

First, the CFP Selection Committee is using a specified criteria to select teams…if the Committee keeps selecting lots of SEC teams that lose in their first CFP game, then the Committee’s criteria needs to be changed. SEC teams are not definitionally the ‘best’ or ‘deserving’. The evidence at hand is always bound by the selection criteria, which is constantly being reevaluated/tweaked by each selection Committee.

Second, last year’s CFP results proved that the last team selected (Miami) was actually better than three higher ranked teams (TAMU, Ole Miss and Ohio State). In other words, the most impactful decision of the Committee was the inclusion/exclusion of Miami v Notre Dame. We’ll never definitively know whether the Committee made the right selections (other than Indiana and Miami being the two best from amongst the chosen 12 teams). Given the quandary, FBS commissioners quickly expanded the CFP to 24 teams.

Finally, conference membership is now being used to advantage teams in the SEC. To most Notre Dame and BYU fans, Alabama and Oklahoma were selected last year more for their pedigree than on-field accomplishments. Alabama was completely outclassed in the SEC CCG, yet the CFP Committee was unwilling to even alter their ranking.

Nonsense. Alabama beat the #2 team and handed them their only loss of the season before losing the rematch. You are focusing on one game. Do you think because Ohio St. destroyed Oregon the year before in the playoffs that Oregon didn't deserve #1? Of course, Oregon deserved it. Now Ohio St. was ranked too low, but a bunch of us agreed that they were. Now the committee makes the same mistake. Boise was not better than Clemson in 2024. They screwed up the whole bracket with that mistake. They focused on Boise giving Oregon fits in one game and didn't pay attention that horrible Wyoming and Nevada teams nearly beat Boise. And then they ignored that SMU got beat head to head by BYU at home and Clemson at a neutral site, but rated them ahead because they had fewer losses even though they played a much weaker schedule.

Their mistake last year was JMU. I saw them play. They did not have the speed to belong in the playoffs. Duke was a better team, even though they were a fluke because of tiebreaks and an unpset in the CCG.
11-05-2026 10:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #77
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-05-2026 10:02 AM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  The problem is the SEC gets the benefit of the doubt everywhere.

"Kentucky should be in because they beat LSU and South Carolina."

"Georgia might have the terrible home loss to Auburn, but what about the eye test?"

Record strength should matter or efficiency should matter or they should be balanced.

The problem is record strength is rewarded for the inefficient teams and record strength is sidestepped for the efficient teams.

No other conference gets to play by these "have it all" measures.

Interesting that you point to record strength and efficiency.

Strength of record?
Kentucky #2, Georgia #6, Ole Miss #7, Alabama #8, Texas #11, LSU #16, Tennessee #18.

Efficiency? Georgia #2, Alabama #4, LSU #5, Ole Miss #7, Texas #8, Tennessee #12, Kentucky #15.

Balance those out, and
Georgia #4
Alabama #6
Ole Miss #7
Kentucky #8.5
Texas #9.5
LSU #10.5
Tennessee #15

Not too far off from their CFP rankings. Then, factor in head-to-head, quality wins, and conference strength.

FWIW, here are the ratings for the other contenders:

SOR: #1 Miami, UCLA #3, Indiana #4, Utah #5, Ohio State #8, Wake Forest #10, BYU #12, Notre Dame #13

Efficiency: Notre Dame is #1, Miami is #3, Ohio State #6, Utah #9, Wake Forest #10, Indiana #11, BYU #13, UCLA #16

Combined:
Miami #2
Utah #7
Notre Dame #7
Ohio State #7
Indiana #7.5
UCLA #9.5
Wake Forest #10
BYU #12.5

So, based only on Strength of Record and Efficiencies ratings, the CFP rankings would be:

1) Miami
2) Georgia
3) Alabama
T4) Utah
T4) Ole Miss
T4) Notre Dame
T4) Ohio State
8) Indiana
9) Kentucky
T10) Texas
T10) UCLA
12) Wake Forest
13) LSU
14) BYU
15) Tennessee

Not too far off. Then, factor in:
- Alabama lost to #15
- Texas beat TWO of the teams tied for fourth
- Notre Dame lost to #14
- Ohio State lost to #10 and a team outside these contender ratings
- BYU beat #4
...and you get pretty close to the CFP rankings.

1) Miami
2) Georgia
3) Utah [+1 because undefeated?]
4) Indiana [+4 because reigning national champ?]
5) Alabama[-2 because loss to #15?]
6) Kentucky [+3 because win over #13?]
7) Texas [+3 because wins over #T4, #T4, and #15]
8) UCLA [+2 because undefeated?]
9) BYU [+3 because win over #T4]
10) Ole Miss [-6 because loss to #10 and Florida(who would be #16)?]
11) Notre Dame [-7 because no quality win and loss to #14?]
12) Ohio State [-8 because losses to #T10 and USC?]
13) Tennessee [+3 because win over #3?]
14) LSU [-1 because no quality win?]
....
16) Wake Forest (-4 because no quality win?]

FWIW, others' combined ratings:
Florida #18.5
Iowa #18.5
Houston #19
USC #19.5
Missouri #20.5
Northwestern #21
Texas Tech #22
Oregon #23.5
Boise State #25.5
South Carolina #25.5
Arizona #26.5
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2026 12:38 PM by YNot.)
11-05-2026 12:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ProfessorBooty Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 72
Joined: Feb 2026
Reputation: 18
I Root For: Miami U
Location:
Post: #78
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
The only way the ACC gets a team other than their champion into the CFP would be if that champion isn't Miami. If they put 2 ACC teams in, they couldn't get 5 SEC teams in again. Come on, guys, use your heads.
11-05-2026 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #79
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-03-2026 03:07 PM)TexanMark Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 08:08 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 10:49 AM)goofus Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 10:11 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:46 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Every school in the ACC could go 6-6 for the next decade and they'd still be a power conference. I can think of nearly 1 billion reasons why, just this year. All the troll threads in the world can't turn the American's $127m into $900m.

Agreed. They’d still get paid at least like the Big 12. The ACC could lose its top 8 schools in value and still have enough old money brands to survive with power status.

Hmmm... maybe but that assumes the ACC loses nobody else to the Big 12.

Let's say

Miami, ND, UNC, VA, Flor St, Clem, NCSU, VT leave for the P2.

ACC now has following 10 schools leftover

GT, Duke, Wake,
Lou, Pitt, Cuse, BC,
SMU, Cal, Stan

At that point I would guess at least Lou and Pitt would bale for the Big 12. And at that point, the ACC would no longer be a power conference.

He just said if they lose their top 8, not top 10 or more.

I’d say that the ACC losing just 2 is dead even with the Big 12, losing 4-8 they’d be behind, but perhaps not quite so far behind as many would believe. If all they had left was the schools you listed, they’d be just like the hateful 8 from the big 12, reloading and decimating the top of the g ranks. Perhaps they’d only get $30-40m per school on their next contract instead of $60m, but there would still be a yawning chasm between them and any g conference, and a small but noticeable gap between then and the Big 12 in the other direction.

As long as the ACCN stays intact and there is hundreds of millions of dollars coming in, I'm not sure anyone leaves for the Big12

Well, their next contract isn't until 2036, when the ACCN will likely be a much smaller % of their overall media agreement. It's hard to put an exact number on the dollar amount, but a seat of the pants guesstimate would be it pays about 1/3, maybe 1/2 in 2036-2045 that it pays from 2026-2035. However, as media rights agreements are still climbing aggressively, that will translate to something more like, I dunno, 20% or so of the total media rights income? Certainly something significantly less than it is today.
11-05-2026 05:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #80
RE: ACC is having a bad year again.
(11-04-2026 08:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 01:16 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:58 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:50 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-03-2026 11:31 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Don't waste your time. He will never have an objective conversation.

Examples:

• Will die on his sword saying ND deserved the CFP last season, but cannot provide a noteworthy win. ND is shaping up the same way they did last year where they lose their only CFP-level games. But, throws shade at the ACC and Wake claiming no noteworthy wins. Hmmmm.

• Clamors about the Big East being the best hoops conference ever. I did my homework and provided him objective numbers in the form of conference win percentages, and it turned out the ACC was superior during the stretch he cited. Ignored it. Argues from a position of passion.

My conclusion: perhaps he was a closet ND fan in years past, and has some survivor's guilt due to the fact Notre Dame could have done more and saved the Big East (his fav conference) in years past. Instead he blames the ACC and will take any chance he can get to bash it.

Of course ND deserved the CFP last year. We were, by all the metrics, easily one of the 12 best teams.

That said, Miami deserved to be in, as they were too. The screw-job of ND happened because the CFP maneuvered Miami next to ND in the last poll with ZERO justification so they could claim H2H, and because of the stupid conference-champs and G5 inclusion rules.

ND had no CFP level wins last year. I just played your own hand.

Notre Dame was left out of the CFP last year because they were 0-2 against CFP at-large contenders and a helping of SEC bias. See also the 8-game SEC conference schedule.

This year, Notre Dame benefits from an absolutely silly and completely unfair rule that gives them PREFERENCE over other CFP at-large contenders. Notre Dame still has cushion to lose to Miami, even though the Irish may have another 0-fer against CFP contenders during the regular season.

I think ND was left out because of unjustifiable CFP maneuvering in the penultimate week of the rankings. The second to last rankings of the season, the CFP moved Alabama from 10 to 9 and Notre Dame fell from 9 to 10. This IMO was completely unjustifiable, as ND had just crushed a bad Stanford team while Alabama had barely squeaked by a mediocre Auburn team. Those results were functionally equal, so no justification for the flip - other than to position ND next to Miami in the final rankings so as to invoke "head to head".

The other thing that screwed the Irish was the absurd G5 inclusion and conference champs rule. By their own rankings, ND was in the final top 12, we were in fact #11. But we were bumped two places down, and out, to make room for two conference champs, one a G5, that were ranked much lower. That was IMO absurd.

Beyond that, don't fret about the Top 12 rule. It is IMO a rule that should apply to everyone, not just ND, as that would eliminate conference champ autobids. But if the CFP wants to keep ND out, they will merely find some excuse to rank them #13. The rule would only have teeth if it was tied to computer metrics that the CFP cannot manipulate, like "ND gets in if it is the top 12 of SOR (or FPI, or SP+, etc)". But it isn't. It is at the whim of the committee.

Funny how you think SEC teams are always the best, unless that conflicts with one of your other rooting interests like, I dunno...ND?
11-05-2026 05:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.