bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-17-2026 02:31 PM)JRsec Wrote: (06-17-2026 01:55 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-17-2026 11:56 AM)JRsec Wrote: (06-17-2026 11:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I always come back to K.I.S.S.
Keep It Simple Stupid.
If you can’t explain the playoff system to a 4th grader, then it’s too complicated. I’ve always firmly believed that since I first started writing about different playoff proposals over 20 years ago.
There was some justification for multiple AQs in a 16-team CFP. Even if you disagreed with the multiple AQ concept, the whole rationale was that it tied to a relative scarcity of playoff spots and that created stakes for, say, the distinction between a 4th place team in the Big Ten or SEC compared to the 5th place team. In essence, the fact that teams could be shut out of the playoffs due to their place in the standings in their conference is what would hypothetically create more interest in regular season conference races. The “value” of multiple AQs from a TV perspective would only come from effectively eliminating many or any at-large berths (e.g. “the regular season conference standings ARE the first part of the playoff”).
In contrast, once you get beyond 16 teams, the multiple AQ concept is very superficial unless you provide so many AQs to the various conferences (e.g. 6 or 7 AQs each to the Big Ten and SEC) that there a few to no at-large spots and it starts shutting out otherwise top 20 or 24 ranked teams from other conferences, which inherently makes the playoff field worse and less competitive. The Big Ten also wanted multiple AQs specifically to show the *difference* in power between the B1G/SEC compared to the Big 12/ACC by giving more AQs to the B1G/SEC, so you can see why the B1G decided to back off completely from multiple AQs and went to an at-large format (where the B1G and SEC can “meritocratically” show their superiority) rather than a system that structurally treated the Big 12 and ACC as equals to the P2 by granting all P4 leagues with the same number of AQs.
I don’t see why it has to be that difficult. Each of the P4 champs plus the top G6 champ (or team or however you want to define it) gets into the playoff and then everyone else is an at-large for the rest of the field (regardless of the size of the playoff). (I know that even granting a berth to each P4 champ might also seem superficial in a 24-team playoff… although as in Jurassic Park, “Life finds a way” as we saw with the ACC last year.) The whole issue with the SEC Championship Game largely comes down to money, which is totally fair from the SEC. However, we shouldn’t mistake the SEC wanting to keep a CCG as something as a matter of *principle*. This is all about being compensated if they’re giving up a valuable asset (which once again, I think is the right of every conference). The SEC doesn’t care about this system format or who gets AQs or anything beyond that if you’re eliminating or devaluing their CCG, then they need to get compensated for it and then some. The Big Ten isn’t stupid, either - they aren’t proposing to eliminate their CCG out of the goodness of their hearts, but rather whatever revenue sharing that comes from a larger playoff needs to provide the B1G was as much or more of a revenue advantage over everyone else other than the SEC as before.
Simple would be creating 4 regionally constructed divisions within each of the SEC and Big Ten with each of their divisions comprised of either 6 or 7 teams (meaning a conference of either 24 or 28 schools each) and having each division champion participate in a 4-school playoff for the conference championship with the champion of the Big Ten and the champion of the SEC meeting for the collegiate version of the Super Bowl. I only suggest 28 because it would allow for 6 division games, 3 games created from 1 school in the other three divisions with 3 crossover games with the other conference, or if we keep the schools and all of the conference game money in house, they would play their six division opponents and 2 each from the other 3 conference divisions.
56 schools would cover almost if not all of the schools with history of past championships (plural on purpose) and those earning enough revenue to be competitive in the NIL era.
The SEC and Big Ten would keep all of the assets for the regular season by playing all 12 games as conference games and with 4 seven school divisions that provides ample rotation to keep fresh faces on the schedule. The internal 4 division champs could play it off or if you want more revenue each division champ could play the 2nd place school of another division to start the conference playoffs. Having almost 1/3rd of your schools involved in your post season easily replaces minor bowl revenue and the Semifinals and Finals would very easily match larger bowl payouts.
Options like these are why I see a new upper tier as likely. It would be one way to either have something like this or forego a much larger expansion by simply keeping the same P4 structure but adding conference semis, retaining the conference CCGs and ending up with a 4-school championship. That maximizes revenue for the conferences and still gives our media partners their payday at the end.
My reticence over expanding the CFP is not only would the SEC lose a 100 million plus game with the CCG, but the conferences would not be maximizing their own potential and the only ones making more money off the new arrangement would be the networks.
What many posters fail to grasp, and I'm not referring to you Frank, is that the CCGs are owned by the conference and the network pays for the right to broadcast them. This would be the case for playoff structures internal to any conference championship. The inventory would be produced and it would be good inventory, but each conference would be selling their rights to those games and all of the money received would be their money. When we have a CFP the networks buy the rights to the event but then pay shares to the participating teams and a share to the conferences. Those shares do not equal what the conference's would earn with their own internal playoff yielding a champion for National semis and finals. We all would be better off marketing conference playoff for the championship. It would ensure that all of our conferences got equal numbers of teams into the postseason, but the postseason begins in your conference. If the Big Ten and SEC earn more for their internal playoffs then it is fair for them to keep it. And this isn't a bug but a feature because it eliminates a lot of the wrangling over the CFP because some pairings are worth more than others. But it would be inclusive of a 4 conference upper tier and their champions would have equal access to the National semis.
Let's say hypothetically that the SEC found 4 schools it wanted to move to 20, the Big 10 got two to move to 20, the ACC backfilled to 20 as did the Big 12 if need be, otherwise just moved to 20. Eighty schools exceeds by a about a dozen any so called upper tier conference's past representation allowing for top G programs to move up and stay in the show. It would allow for 4 divisions of 5 within each of the 4 conferences. That would mean that 1/5th of every conference would be involved in the postseason. If you allow divisional runners up to face off against the other division champs and make 8 of your schools postseason eligible then you have accommodated 32 of the 80 schools in the upper tier.
What does this accomplish? Every conference would have meaningful and determinative late season regular games more frequently as schools jockeyed to be one of their division's top two. They would start each season with a 2 in 5 chance of being in the postseason. It enhances the post season games for the two networks. Each conference expands their revenue base and increases the interest and value in their CCG all of which they own. The 4 conference champs make the National Semis almost as valuable as the finals. Then networks have added inventory, the conferences have more money to distribute, and the people have a champion decided by the play of the regular season and then the post season with no damn committee involved anywhere, just conference tie breaking rules by which all conference members agreed to abide. It doesn't get any simpler or more reasonable than that.
We may end up here where the Big Ten is like the NFC and the SEC is like the AFC in a college football version of the NFL.
However, I think the inertia is still greater than you may believe. As with a lot of items, we may largely agree on the end point, but the debate is more about how quickly we will get there.
The more that I’ve learned about the actual machinations of realignment over the past decade in speaking with people that have actually been in the room for these decisions, it’s that such decisions are so often made in the context of a plane falling out of the sky than it is about calculated moves. That is, for all of the strategy and deep analysis that is deployed (and believe me that I’m all about strategic planning almost to a fault), people just scramble for survival when a plane is about to crash. And for a lot of athletic departments - even ones in the wealthiest places like the Big Ten and SEC - they’re in the equivalent of a plane in free fall when it comes to rising costs and expenses. So, they can’t look at things of how they might be 10 or 20 or 30 years from now, but rather how they’re going to figure out their NIL and revenue sharing budgets for the next 6 months.
If an expanded CFP means an immediate cash infusion of $X for schools, then it’s *really* hard for them to pass that up in this environment. They’d rather be getting more revenue in that manner than, say, selling off parts of their future athletic revenue streams to private equity. Either way, so many places (and that includes schools in the P2) need money *now*. We always need to look at it in that context.
I don't disagree. I simply am noting that owning your own internal playoff structure will produce more revenue than playing in someone else's.
And if our two conferences work together, especially through any further expansion, we would be remiss not to grasp the advantages of owning our own internal structure whether we are indeed a P2, or still a P4. Any system which pays in shares by withholding 50% or some other % of the funds will never payoff like owning your own and bidding them out. Great decisions, as you know, are never made while under duress. Expediency is never efficient.
I think it generates less than an intersectional match. Especially since there is a decent chance it is a repeat.
Now they may prefer it because it offers more control, but probably less money. Just more relative to everyone else.
It also creates a weaker playoff field. Conference playoffs based on conference standings in a conference where you are only playing 1/3 to 1/2 of the teams are going to give you things like Duke near the top. So that also hurts revenue.
And I don't think anyone likes multiple AQs except for the Big Ten. The SEC wants more at large and the Big 12 and ACC don't want to have fewer slots and be officially designated as "lesser." Money is one thing. Playoff disadvantage is something else.
(This post was last modified: 06-17-2026 07:10 PM by bullet.)
|
|