ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
A modest CFP compromise proposal
The P2 seem to have two quite distinct preferences for what a future CFP should look like. The B1G wants 24, and the SEC is OK with 16. The ACC and Big 12 want to be seen as quasi-equals with the P2. The SEC doesn't want to give up its lucrative CFP. The G6 doesn't want to be excluded, and Notre Dame wants to be assured it will have a path to the CFP as an independent.
I propose a compromise: a 20 team CFP.
Each of the A4 conferences get 3 autobids, based only on their conference standings. First tiebreaker is total W-L record, second tiebreaker if needed is CFP ranking. The 2 highest ranked G6 teams and the 6 highest ranked teams not already in the field play at large at neutral sites in Round 1 in Week 1 of the postseason. That same week, the first and second place teams from each A4 conference play in their CCG, also at neutral sites.
In Week 2, the 4 CCG losers host the 4 at large winners. In Week 3, the 4 CCG winners host the 4 third place A4 finishers.
The Quarterfinals are played at the Rose, Sugar, Fiesta, and Orange Bowls at New Years, and the Semis roughly a week later in Atlanta and Dallas. Finals are played at a site TBD by bid.
In 2025, the field would have looked like this:
Week 1
CCGs
#12 Miami (10-2) vs #16 Virginia (10-2)
#5 Texas Tech (11-1) vs #11 BYU (11-1)
#1 Ohio State (12-0) vs #2 Indiana (12-0)
#3 Georgia (11-1) vs #6 Ole Miss (11-1)
At-large
#8 Oklahoma (10-2) vs #20 North Texas (11-1)
#9 Notre Dame (10-2) vs #19 James Madison (11-1)
#10 Alabama (10-2) vs #17 USC (9-3)
#13 Texas (9-3) vs #14 Vanderbilt (10-2)
Week 2
#13 Texas (10-3) @ #1 Ohio State (12-1)
#10 Alabama (11-2) @ #6 Ole Miss (11-2)
#9 Notre Dame 11-2) @ #11 BYU (11-2)
#8 Oklahoma (11-2) @ #16 Virginia (10-3)
Week 3
#24 Georgia Tech (9-3) @ #2 Indiana (13-0)
#15 Utah (10-2) @ #3 Georgia (12-1)
#7 Texas A&M (11-1) @ #5 Texas Tech (12-1)
#4 Oregon (11-1) @ #12 Miami (11-2)
First Five left out:
#18 Michigan (9-3)
#21 Tulane (10-2)
#22 Arizona (9-3)
#23 Navy (9-2)
#25 Missouri (8-4)
|
|
| 06-15-2026 05:20 PM |
|
Fighting Muskie
Senior Chief Realignmentologist

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
This looks awfully similar to my own 24-team, 2 autobids for each P2/M2 model.
I like this, but I’d cap things at 2 autobids per league. You’re not trying to squeeze 8 playoff games over 1 weekend and the bye is pretty attractive to the CCG winners.
|
|
| 06-15-2026 06:08 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
They're dumping anything but the G5/6 autobid in a 24 team. I don't know why they would pursue any autobids in 20. 19 at large and 1 G5/6.
|
|
| 06-15-2026 06:12 PM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-15-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: This looks awfully similar to my own 24-team, 2 autobids for each P2/M2 model.
I like this, but I’d cap things at 2 autobids per league. You’re not trying to squeeze 8 playoff games over 1 weekend and the bye is pretty attractive to the CCG winners.
The biggest reason for the third autobid is to increase the importance of conference games throughout November. Each conference would likely have as many as six teams in contention for a playoff spot, even if some of those teams aren't as highly ranked as they need to be in the current format.
The only weekend with 8 games is the one that currently would have 10 CCGs, many of which have little bearing on the CFP.
|
|
| 06-15-2026 09:29 PM |
|
Fighting Muskie
Senior Chief Realignmentologist

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-15-2026 09:29 PM)ken d Wrote: (06-15-2026 06:08 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: This looks awfully similar to my own 24-team, 2 autobids for each P2/M2 model.
I like this, but I’d cap things at 2 autobids per league. You’re not trying to squeeze 8 playoff games over 1 weekend and the bye is pretty attractive to the CCG winners.
The biggest reason for the third autobid is to increase the importance of conference games throughout November. Each conference would likely have as many as six teams in contention for a playoff spot, even if some of those teams aren't as highly ranked as they need to be in the current format.
The only weekend with 8 games is the one that currently would have 10 CCGs, many of which have little bearing on the CFP.
I find it highly unlikely that the P2 would give the M2 a 3rd autobid
|
|
| 06-15-2026 09:32 PM |
|
goofus
Heisman

Posts: 5,718
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 304
I Root For: Iowa
Location: chicago suburbs
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
Perhaps an 18-team CFP could work.
|
|
| 06-15-2026 09:48 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
For the SEC and B1G the #3 spot is the preferred spot. #3 has to play a single opponent in the 10-16 range to make New Years. To advance that far from the #1 or #2 spot you have to either beat a Top 5 team AND a team in the 15-25 range or take a beating against that Top 5 teams and still have to beat the 10-16 team that #3 lines up against. A single game against 10-16 is much easier.
If we incorporate CCG the stakes cannot be inverted and they cannot be for seeding alone. Each win needs to get you one step closer to the National Title.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 06:14 AM |
|
Hokie Mark
Legend

Posts: 26,875
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 2011
I Root For: VT, ACC teams
Location: Greensboro, NC
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-15-2026 05:20 PM)ken d Wrote: The P2 seem to have two quite distinct preferences for what a future CFP should look like. The B1G wants 24, and the SEC is OK with 16. The ACC and Big 12 want to be seen as quasi-equals with the P2. The SEC doesn't want to give up its lucrative CFP. The G6 doesn't want to be excluded, and Notre Dame wants to be assured it will have a path to the CFP as an independent.
I propose a compromise: a 20 team CFP.
Each of the A4 conferences get 3 autobids, based only on their conference standings. First tiebreaker is total W-L record, second tiebreaker if needed is CFP ranking. The 2 highest ranked G6 teams and the 6 highest ranked teams not already in the field play at large at neutral sites in Round 1 in Week 1 of the postseason. That same week, the first and second place teams from each A4 conference play in their CCG, also at neutral sites.
In Week 2, the 4 CCG losers host the 4 at large winners. In Week 3, the 4 CCG winners host the 4 third place A4 finishers.
The Quarterfinals are played at the Rose, Sugar, Fiesta, and Orange Bowls at New Years, and the Semis roughly a week later in Atlanta and Dallas. Finals are played at a site TBD by bid.
In 2025, the field would have looked like this:
Week 1
CCGs
#12 Miami (10-2) vs #16 Virginia (10-2)
#5 Texas Tech (11-1) vs #11 BYU (11-1)
#1 Ohio State (12-0) vs #2 Indiana (12-0)
#3 Georgia (11-1) vs #6 Ole Miss (11-1)
At-large
#8 Oklahoma (10-2) vs #20 North Texas (11-1)
#9 Notre Dame (10-2) vs #19 James Madison (11-1)
#10 Alabama (10-2) vs #17 USC (9-3)
#13 Texas (9-3) vs #14 Vanderbilt (10-2)
Week 2
#13 Texas (10-3) @ #1 Ohio State (12-1)
#10 Alabama (11-2) @ #6 Ole Miss (11-2)
#9 Notre Dame 11-2) @ #11 BYU (11-2)
#8 Oklahoma (11-2) @ #16 Virginia (10-3)
Week 3
#24 Georgia Tech (9-3) @ #2 Indiana (13-0)
#15 Utah (10-2) @ #3 Georgia (12-1)
#7 Texas A&M (11-1) @ #5 Texas Tech (12-1)
#4 Oregon (11-1) @ #12 Miami (11-2)
First Five left out:
#18 Michigan (9-3)
#21 Tulane (10-2)
#22 Arizona (9-3)
#23 Navy (9-2)
#25 Missouri (8-4)
1. I don't like using total W-L as a tiebreaker, because it incentivizes teams to play an all-cupcake OOC schedule.
2. The problem with 20 teams is you likely end up with a double-bye for 4 teams.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 06:15 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
And the winner advances to the 16 team field, hosts a game, gets a week off before their next game, and may or may not have an easier opponent than the loser.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 09:45 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 06:15 AM)Hokie Mark Wrote: (06-15-2026 05:20 PM)ken d Wrote: The P2 seem to have two quite distinct preferences for what a future CFP should look like. The B1G wants 24, and the SEC is OK with 16. The ACC and Big 12 want to be seen as quasi-equals with the P2. The SEC doesn't want to give up its lucrative CFP. The G6 doesn't want to be excluded, and Notre Dame wants to be assured it will have a path to the CFP as an independent.
I propose a compromise: a 20 team CFP.
Each of the A4 conferences get 3 autobids, based only on their conference standings. First tiebreaker is total W-L record, second tiebreaker if needed is CFP ranking. The 2 highest ranked G6 teams and the 6 highest ranked teams not already in the field play at large at neutral sites in Round 1 in Week 1 of the postseason. That same week, the first and second place teams from each A4 conference play in their CCG, also at neutral sites.
In Week 2, the 4 CCG losers host the 4 at large winners. In Week 3, the 4 CCG winners host the 4 third place A4 finishers.
The Quarterfinals are played at the Rose, Sugar, Fiesta, and Orange Bowls at New Years, and the Semis roughly a week later in Atlanta and Dallas. Finals are played at a site TBD by bid.
In 2025, the field would have looked like this:
Week 1
CCGs
#12 Miami (10-2) vs #16 Virginia (10-2)
#5 Texas Tech (11-1) vs #11 BYU (11-1)
#1 Ohio State (12-0) vs #2 Indiana (12-0)
#3 Georgia (11-1) vs #6 Ole Miss (11-1)
At-large
#8 Oklahoma (10-2) vs #20 North Texas (11-1)
#9 Notre Dame (10-2) vs #19 James Madison (11-1)
#10 Alabama (10-2) vs #17 USC (9-3)
#13 Texas (9-3) vs #14 Vanderbilt (10-2)
Week 2
#13 Texas (10-3) @ #1 Ohio State (12-1)
#10 Alabama (11-2) @ #6 Ole Miss (11-2)
#9 Notre Dame 11-2) @ #11 BYU (11-2)
#8 Oklahoma (11-2) @ #16 Virginia (10-3)
Week 3
#24 Georgia Tech (9-3) @ #2 Indiana (13-0)
#15 Utah (10-2) @ #3 Georgia (12-1)
#7 Texas A&M (11-1) @ #5 Texas Tech (12-1)
#4 Oregon (11-1) @ #12 Miami (11-2)
First Five left out:
#18 Michigan (9-3)
#21 Tulane (10-2)
#22 Arizona (9-3)
#23 Navy (9-2)
#25 Missouri (8-4)
1. I don't like using total W-L as a tiebreaker, because it incentivizes teams to play an all-cupcake OOC schedule.
2. The problem with 20 teams is you likely end up with a double-bye for 4 teams.
With the results of the byes (1-7), I doubt anyone is thinking of double byes anymore.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 09:47 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: For the SEC and B1G the #3 spot is the preferred spot. #3 has to play a single opponent in the 10-16 range to make New Years. To advance that far from the #1 or #2 spot you have to either beat a Top 5 team AND a team in the 15-25 range or take a beating against that Top 5 teams and still have to beat the 10-16 team that #3 lines up against. A single game against 10-16 is much easier.
#3 has to play an A4 conference champion on their home field. Who that will be and where they will be ranked can't be determined in advance.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 10:10 AM |
|
Fighting Muskie
Senior Chief Realignmentologist

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
CFP proposals are tricky.
You want to adequately award the P2 CCG winners but at the same time want to avoid overly rewarding the M2 CCG winners.
You also don’t want the reward to result in teams being rusty from a lengthy wait between games.
Then there’s the tv windows—most of the time, broadcasters really utilize 4 windows a weekend— 8:00pm Fri, 12:00pm Sat, 3:30pm Sat, & 8:00pm Sat. If you want a round to feature more than 4 games you either have air games simultaneously and competing with each other, or get creative with the times—potentially bumping that number to 6 with a Friday double header and a 4th Saturday game by starting the first game at 11am or earlier.
You also don’t want an over complicated formula for qualifying.
It’s no easy task.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 11:31 AM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 09:45 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
And the winner advances to the 16 team field, hosts a game, gets a week off before their next game, and may or may not have an easier opponent than the loser.
By winning the CG you get an extra week to prepare for the round-of-16 and ‘maybe’ an easier opponent? Those stakes are zilch. Who’d want to waste their energy and risk injury by competing in that game; who’d want to air a game of two-hand touch?
Give both teams the extra week, and skip the game in its entirety. You have 8 games that weekend; you won’t miss any good time slots (ie. no financial loss) by trimming to 6. The top ranked team is awarded the easier opponent by virtue of 12 games of hard work rather than a powderpuff exhibition.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 12:54 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 11:31 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: CFP proposals are tricky.
You want to adequately award the P2 CCG winners but at the same time want to avoid overly rewarding the M2 CCG winners.
You also don’t want the reward to result in teams being rusty from a lengthy wait between games.
Then there’s the tv windows—most of the time, broadcasters really utilize 4 windows a weekend— 8:00pm Fri, 12:00pm Sat, 3:30pm Sat, & 8:00pm Sat. If you want a round to feature more than 4 games you either have air games simultaneously and competing with each other, or get creative with the times—potentially bumping that number to 6 with a Friday double header and a 4th Saturday game by starting the first game at 11am or earlier.
You also don’t want an over complicated formula for qualifying.
It’s no easy task.
It is no easy task. And, ken d, kudos for working through it. I read myself coming across as passionately opposed, but really I think any proposal can be worked into a realistic format with “few/er” gaps.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 12:57 PM |
|
GoBuckeyes1047
All American

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 11:31 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: CFP proposals are tricky.
You want to adequately award the P2 CCG winners but at the same time want to avoid overly rewarding the M2 CCG winners.
You also don’t want the reward to result in teams being rusty from a lengthy wait between games.
Then there’s the tv windows—most of the time, broadcasters really utilize 4 windows a weekend— 8:00pm Fri, 12:00pm Sat, 3:30pm Sat, & 8:00pm Sat. If you want a round to feature more than 4 games you either have air games simultaneously and competing with each other, or get creative with the times—potentially bumping that number to 6 with a Friday double header and a 4th Saturday game by starting the first game at 11am or earlier.
You also don’t want an over complicated formula for qualifying.
It’s no easy task.
You could arguably fit 6 games into a weekend with 2 Friday (4:30-5, 8-8:30) and 4 Saturday (11, 2:30, 5:45, 9:15) using ESPN's existing bowl game TV schedule, but 6 games in 1 weekend would be my max unless you try to add a couple Thursday evening games, which 1 of those is definitely going up against TNF in NFL. Realistically, you have 18 windows at most for standalone games the first 3 weekends of December, but 2 of those go against the NFL the 3rd weekend, and you probably need another for Army-Navy so that leaves 15 standalone slots at most. I agree it's tricky. There's also the debate of whether you want the QFs on the 3rd weekend of December or on New Years, which is probably dependent on if CCGs stay or go, which depends on whether an expanded CFP beyond 16 teams makes enough to satisfy the P2 dropping their CCGs.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 12:57 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,313
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 10:10 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: For the SEC and B1G the #3 spot is the preferred spot. #3 has to play a single opponent in the 10-16 range to make New Years. To advance that far from the #1 or #2 spot you have to either beat a Top 5 team AND a team in the 15-25 range or take a beating against that Top 5 teams and still have to beat the 10-16 team that #3 lines up against. A single game against 10-16 is much easier.
#3 has to play an A4 conference champion on their home field. Who that will be and where they will be ranked can't be determined in advance.
My complaint here may be overfitting the particulars of 2025. But the real travesty with P2CGs in this setup is that beating a Top 5 team fails to get you any closer to the National Title; it, again, is a seeding exercise.
Every win should get a team closer to the National Title.
Winning a battle between Top 5 teams should accord a bye. Stage the CG a week later if we’re concerned about ‘too much’ rest. But just like the M2 CGs, if the reward is merely a different flavor of non Top 10 team (and the play-in does add a randomizer), teams will play conservative, fans will disengage, and money will leave the system.
////////
If we want to keep CGs, every team should have different risk/reward. One way is to assign different rewards to different games (P2CGs get byes, M2CG losers are eliminated). Another way is to flex those rewards (2 best champs get byes, 2 lowest losers are eliminated).
Being ‘more’ generous is better than ‘less’ at keeping any “unfairness” localized (which is probably why Ken gave home field to all 8 CG participants). Giving a third bye therefore avoids those times when 13-0 Florida State has to play an extra game while allowing those times when 11-2 ASU gets a bye. But more byes and more losers means less access down-bracket.
The Big Ten may be right that eliminating all CCGs grants “full” access to lower-ranked teams; but I think keeping the P2CGs is still workable toward that end.
(This post was last modified: 06-16-2026 04:00 PM by Crayton.)
|
|
| 06-16-2026 03:55 PM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 12:54 PM)Crayton Wrote: (06-16-2026 09:45 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
And the winner advances to the 16 team field, hosts a game, gets a week off before their next game, and may or may not have an easier opponent than the loser.
By winning the CG you get an extra week to prepare for the round-of-16 and ‘maybe’ an easier opponent? Those stakes are zilch. Who’d want to waste their energy and risk injury by competing in that game; who’d want to air a game of two-hand touch?
Give both teams the extra week, and skip the game in its entirety. You have 8 games that weekend; you won’t miss any good time slots (ie. no financial loss) by trimming to 6. The top ranked team is awarded the easier opponent by virtue of 12 games of hard work rather than a powderpuff exhibition.
This is all predicated on the need for a compromise, in which the SEC appears determined to keep their lucrative CCG. Personally, I would be fine with doing away with all CCGs, but I can't see a path to letting the SEC keep their CCG while still participating in a CFP on equal terms with the B1G, unless they also kept their CCG. And they would no doubt both insist that all four of their participants get special treatment from the CFP, probably a bye into the second round of the playoff.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 04:00 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 04:00 PM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 12:54 PM)Crayton Wrote: (06-16-2026 09:45 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
And the winner advances to the 16 team field, hosts a game, gets a week off before their next game, and may or may not have an easier opponent than the loser.
By winning the CG you get an extra week to prepare for the round-of-16 and ‘maybe’ an easier opponent? Those stakes are zilch. Who’d want to waste their energy and risk injury by competing in that game; who’d want to air a game of two-hand touch?
Give both teams the extra week, and skip the game in its entirety. You have 8 games that weekend; you won’t miss any good time slots (ie. no financial loss) by trimming to 6. The top ranked team is awarded the easier opponent by virtue of 12 games of hard work rather than a powderpuff exhibition.
This is all predicated on the need for a compromise, in which the SEC appears determined to keep their lucrative CCG. Personally, I would be fine with doing away with all CCGs, but I can't see a path to letting the SEC keep their CCG while still participating in a CFP on equal terms with the B1G, unless they also kept their CCG. And they would no doubt both insist that all four of their participants get special treatment from the CFP, probably a bye into the second round of the playoff.
The CFP argument is just a big stall to allow time for other factors to become clear including but not limited to any further expansion, some kind of consensus on rules pertaining to NIL and the viability of breaking away to form their own League of 2 conferences. It also allows both the Big Ten and SEC to get on the same page with FOX and ESPN as it pertains to the CCG's and CFP. Therefore they will keep up the discord until each gets what it wants. If both figure they can make more money with internal playoffs in an expanded conference as opposed to external playoffs without as much expansion that's another reason to wait. The disgreement here is a device, not a rift.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 04:12 PM |
|
Fighting Muskie
Senior Chief Realignmentologist

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
I’m an advocate for internal conference playoffs too (a huge fan in fact). But there seems to be a contingent out there that seems to think that a +1 national title game after the fact is some giant antitrust no go.
I think that’s hog wash but I’m curious what others thought.
(I like the idea of playing the CCGs NYD/E in the traditional tie bowl sites. We could even preserve some of the major bowls by letting conference quarter-final and semifinal losers to participate.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 05:03 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-16-2026 04:12 PM)JRsec Wrote: (06-16-2026 04:00 PM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 12:54 PM)Crayton Wrote: (06-16-2026 09:45 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-16-2026 06:14 AM)Crayton Wrote: This really perverts the rewards of Conference Championship Games.
For the XII and ACC, the loser not only advances into the 16-team field but they also host a gane AND get an easier opponent than the winner. The injury report at gametime in Arlington and Charlotte will be a mile long.
And the winner advances to the 16 team field, hosts a game, gets a week off before their next game, and may or may not have an easier opponent than the loser.
By winning the CG you get an extra week to prepare for the round-of-16 and ‘maybe’ an easier opponent? Those stakes are zilch. Who’d want to waste their energy and risk injury by competing in that game; who’d want to air a game of two-hand touch?
Give both teams the extra week, and skip the game in its entirety. You have 8 games that weekend; you won’t miss any good time slots (ie. no financial loss) by trimming to 6. The top ranked team is awarded the easier opponent by virtue of 12 games of hard work rather than a powderpuff exhibition.
This is all predicated on the need for a compromise, in which the SEC appears determined to keep their lucrative CCG. Personally, I would be fine with doing away with all CCGs, but I can't see a path to letting the SEC keep their CCG while still participating in a CFP on equal terms with the B1G, unless they also kept their CCG. And they would no doubt both insist that all four of their participants get special treatment from the CFP, probably a bye into the second round of the playoff.
The CFP argument is just a big stall to allow time for other factors to become clear including but not limited to any further expansion, some kind of consensus on rules pertaining to NIL and the viability of breaking away to form their own League of 2 conferences. It also allows both the Big Ten and SEC to get on the same page with FOX and ESPN as it pertains to the CCG's and CFP. Therefore they will keep up the discord until each gets what it wants. If both figure they can make more money with internal playoffs in an expanded conference as opposed to external playoffs without as much expansion that's another reason to wait. The disgreement here is a device, not a rift.
I think the SEC is happy to do away with their CCG. But 1) they need to be paid for it; and 2) they don't want an over-expansion of the playoffs that hurts their regular season.
I think the biggest objection if figuring out whether the networks will pay enough to make it worthwhile giving up the CCGs which are worth about $200 million, half of that SEC. They do want to look at whether 24 over-expands, but don't seem real concerned.
|
|
| 06-16-2026 06:00 PM |
|