Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
Author Message
mturn017 Offline
ODU Homer
*

Posts: 18,901
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1828
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Roanoke, VA
Post: #41
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
I think the cap on revenue sharing will likely get shot down as anti trust but I'm not sure about the clearing house. Seems like there's a legitimate interest to know that competitors aren't being paid by third parties with no clear economic interest. That sounds like cheating on it's face so the burden should be on them to show that the money they receive does have an economic interest.

But then again there's a legitimate interest to put a cap on revenue sharing. Hopefully if nothing else this can be the straw that broke the camel's back and gets all parties to come together and figure it out. Federal legislation is needed and players should have a voice in negotiating. Both.
06-10-2026 02:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #42
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
Maybe just cap revenue sharing at cost of attendance and see how that goes over for the happy little litigators.

*In reality, I believe there is a direct formula one can derive from revenue generation. Of course, the BRAND is above all else, the COACH formulates the team, and the PLAYERS are fairly transient.
(This post was last modified: 06-10-2026 02:46 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-10-2026 02:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #43
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
(06-10-2026 12:27 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(06-10-2026 09:05 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-10-2026 06:11 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(06-09-2026 08:22 PM)Maize Wrote:  Here is the link
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-sports/...41425.html

While IANAL, from my layman POV I am not sure this will succeed. IIRC, the cap on revenue sharing was approved by the House federal judge, it is part of that settlement, as was the CSC on the grounds that a cap is useless without an enforcement mechanism.

Of course, just because one federal judge rules one way, that doesn't mean another judge won't rule another way. But IIRC, that typically happens in cases with a strong left-right ideological split, like abortion, Trump executive orders, religion, stuff like that. To my knowledge, these NCAA antitrust and pay for play issues do not have that quality, so I think another judge will hesitate to challenge the House settlement.

We'll see.

There have been a ton of Congressional reps come out against the idea that pay can be capped. Surely there are many judges who would agree with them.

Without antitrust legislation, I don't see how any cap will ever be enforceable in the long run. If this makes it to court, the plaintiffs will win again.

In the end----there are only 2 ways to have revenue sharing with a salary cap. Either through collective bargaining with a players union or via a limited anti-trust exemption granted by Congress. Frankly, given that the players have been handed complete and total free agency (something even pro players have been unable to get) by the courts, I dont see much of a motivation for the players to form a union (they have already won). That pretty much leaves a congressional limited anti-trust exemption as the only option for the schools to get the kind of college sports landscape defined by the House/Alston settlement.

I'm afraid that you're right. Unionization would raise the salary floor, but it would also dramatically limit the ceiling while curtailing mobility for all athletes. This feels like an insurmountable hurdle. I also don't see Congress handing antitrust exemptions to the P4 structure, codifying their anti-competitive advantages either. It's certainly a difficult situation to resolve.
06-10-2026 02:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,517
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #44
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
(06-10-2026 02:39 PM)mturn017 Wrote:  I think the cap on revenue sharing will likely get shot down as anti trust but I'm not sure about the clearing house. Seems like there's a legitimate interest to know that competitors aren't being paid by third parties with no clear economic interest. That sounds like cheating on it's face so the burden should be on them to show that the money they receive does have an economic interest.

But then again there's a legitimate interest to put a cap on revenue sharing. Hopefully if nothing else this can be the straw that broke the camel's back and gets all parties to come together and figure it out. Federal legislation is needed and players should have a voice in negotiating. Both.

Is it cheating though? What right does the NCAA or the P4 cartel have to artificially limit wages through collusion? College sports are a business now, and the amateurism shield no longer holds -- the only factor that prevented this mess in the past. This is a textbook antitrust violation and it will be easily defeated in court. As Kavanaugh noted in Alston, "The NCAA’s business model would be flatly illegal in almost any other industry in America... The NCAA is not above the law."
06-10-2026 02:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,340
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 975
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #45
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
The salary cap is more important than the transfers to the universities. I think the SEC and B1G will each create captive unions that will agree to that/

What they want is 5-year eligibility cap and a salary/NIL cap for teams rather than specifically for players. If a school wants to spend $35m of its $40m on a single player that is fine. Players will probably agree.

Limiting transfers, and it will have to be a number greater than one to get the players to agree. Note, CBAs will almost certainly be by conference, so transfer rules would only apply within them. They would have no force if you jumped from a G6 or FCS to a one of the A4 conferences, or from one A4 conference to another. Only an A4 wide union agreement would have any power on transfer. And for that the number must be higher than one, even before exceptions (inevitable).

Honestly, transfers have worked in the A4 favor, as they strip out the G6 and FCS of good players. This is actually more of an issue for G6 schools than A4.

The number of years eligible is more critical. The likely concession to get this will be more walk on space.
06-10-2026 03:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #46
RE: Yahoo: Class-action lawsuit filed against NCAA, P4, CSC & over House Settlement
(06-10-2026 06:11 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(06-09-2026 08:22 PM)Maize Wrote:  Here is the link
https://sports.yahoo.com/college-sports/...41425.html

While IANAL, from my layman POV I am not sure this will succeed. IIRC, the cap on revenue sharing was approved by the House federal judge, it is part of that settlement, as was the CSC on the grounds that a cap is useless without an enforcement mechanism.

The argument that the plaintiffs are making is that state laws override the settlement. The state laws do not set a cap, and they do not have restrictions on 3rd Party (fake) NIL deals.

The CSC not only screens NIL deals it monitors the cap. The plaintiff's lawyers (e.g., Jeffrey Kessler, et al) get a 1% commission. When there were various challenges to the original settlement, Kessler was a vigorous proponent that the deal was fair and negotiated at arms length (i.e, it was not a sweetheart deal between the NCAA and the lawyers that was not to the benefit of athletes.). He might be expected to advocate for the settlement, unless there was just some modification.

The two named plaintiffs are interesting. Charlie Mirer is the son of Notre Dame QB Rick Mirer. His first two seasons at Stanford he was non-scholarship, but received a NIL from the Stanford collective. Last season (after the House Settlement went into effect), he received a scholarship, and the NIL deal with the collective disappeared, and he appeared in one game. Troy Taylor when he was coach had indicated the intent for all Stanford football players to be on scholarship, but historically Stanford had used a combination of academic and need-based scholarships (and probably NIL money) so there were few true walk-ons that you might have had at a state school.

Tanaloa Ili is a highly touted freshman for USC. He originally committed to USC last June, graduated early from high school, and began classes at USC in January. He claims promised NIL money disappeared after the House settlement.

To receive damage payments under the House Settlement, athletes had to waive their right to sue. But this could not be used for new athletes under the 10-year injunction period (e.g. freshmen in 2034-35 were 9 years old and in grade school). So new players each season have to sign a waiver. I suspect that neither Mirer or Ili have signed waivers.

This could be a problem for a class-action lawsuit when many have waived their right to sue. It is also limited to the 17 States that have NIL laws. They may be subject to interpretation as whether they permit limits to NIL money or screening.
06-18-2026 05:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.