Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:24 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Meh. Regionalism in the B1G regarding football may be dead, but for Olympic sports it’s safe. The college basketball season has enough variety at the beginning of the year between media partners that conference expansion has hurt it without nearly the upside.
Football should be totally separate so go do your 20 team super conference and have fun. Consolidationists don’t seem to be aware a single super conference is how a capitalist driven enterprise “ends”.
But I don’t think football will end up being totally separate from at least basketball and likely Olympic sports overall. The “football will be separate” is the fantasy that a lot of people here keep telling themselves, which is why they are weirdly aren’t scared of what may happen *enough*.
Is a separation between football and other sports be what *should* happen? Probably. Is that what I think will happen? No, because I see firsthand how the same concept of elite conference status applies to the Olympic sports in the same way that it does to football and basketball. I’ve got kids with teammates and friends being recruited in Olympic sports *today* and being P4 means every bit as much to those sports as it does in football. You can reasonably surmise that it will continue to be the case if it goes down to a P2 or P1. That’s why Stanford and Cal send their Olympic sports athletes across the entire continent despite huge costs. Elite status is the one thing even more valuable than money in academia.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 12:38 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,375
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 10:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:47 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 09:02 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 08:01 AM)Crayton Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote: I don't like CCGs but they're no barrier to an expanded playoff. The barrier is Army-Navy week, which benefits two upper G5 programs and practically no-one else. Move it forward to CCG week or rivalry week and that can get you all the way up to 32 teams should you so choose.
You know a real barrier to 24 teams? Timeslots. 8 games all hosted by one network, presumably during a non-holiday week. Good luck.
I think the “barrier” here is the contracts the conferences have selling them. You can modify the contracts but you can’t unilaterally scrap them. One strategy may even be to turn them into defacto exhibitions to bring media partners to the table.
Adding Wild Card Games is simpler and maybe giving conferences the leeway to covert their CCG into a second WCG would be effective.
As I’ve said in other threads, give the A4 2 play-in games (WCG/CCG) and X bids (based on AQs and any at large spots after 12 games) and let them wrestle with themselves on how to deliver teams to the playoff. Do they use a spot on their CCG loser? Do they elevate a 7-5 Duke over a 10-2 Miami? Let them use/misuse their X spots.
We can put a direct price on the CCG barrier:
https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/2025/12...ip-amazon/
NBC is looking for $70 million from Amazon for the 2026 Big Ten Championship Game.
Add in how much Indianapolis is paying to host the game plus ticket and suite sales and sponsorships and you can see it would legitimately take $100 million or more in replacement revenue to the Big Ten and SEC for anything that replaces CCGs simply to break even… and it needs to be replacement revenue for the Big Ten and SEC specifically as opposed to simply shared amongst all of college football (e.g. $100 million for the B1G and SEC is meaningless if the Big 12 and ACC are also getting that same $100 million and thereby reducing the B1G/SEC revenue advantage).
That’s why these playoff expansion schemes that Petitti keeps proposing that would replace CCGs always include conference-only Wild Card Games that would solely be revenue generators for each individual conference as opposed to simply just making the CFP field bigger in and of itself. He’s not ever proposing to simply get rid of CCGs for the expanded playoff alone, but replacing them with even more conference-controlled WCGs on top of it. That $70 million B1G CCG figure (and the SEC CCG would be worth even more in the open market) needs to be replaced in a way that can’t be shared with anyone (and that last point of how that money can’t be shared is critical as, once again, just giving more money to *everyone* in college football with a bigger CFP isn’t the B1G/SEC goal).
It’s less of a contractual challenge and more of an economic challenge.
I have doubts these conference WCG would significantly beat a CCG.
Its sure a big gamble that you can get more money from these and put the regular season at risk.
I agree if I’m looking at it from a financial perspective. Could WCGs be worth more than a single CCG? Maybe. Will they be so much more valuable that it would be worth the *risk* to get rid of that single CCG where we clearly know the value? Maybe not. This is where we need to understand the risk-adjusted return (as opposed to simply the return itself).
You surprise me Frank. The point of WCGs isn't to add extra games on CCG week, its to give more Big Ten teams something to play for in the regular season, keeping their large fanbases tuning in. The actual games themself are just a thing you then have to do to get down to 4 teams. And yeah, you will make money by selling them, but that isn't why the Big Ten is holding up CFP change to insist on their inclusion.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 12:40 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:59 AM)JRsec Wrote: Let's clarify that a tad. Will people tuning in to watch the two top schools of a conference play for a title ever be worth less than watching a play in game for a spot among the lowest seeds in a larger playoff? I have profound doubts that a WCG will mean more to the fans of either the Big Ten or SEC than a title game to determine their conference's championship. People put a premium on events which are ultimately determinative. BCS Championship game, CFP Championship Game, The Super Bowl. It is an annual event determining a champion, not a random game filling in a bracket.
To that point, maybe we should multiply the number of "Championships". Oklahoma vs. Texas A&M for the SEC-West "Championship Game"? Bring back the (or knockoffs of, the) SWC, BE, and Pac10 brands?
I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:23 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:24 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Meh. Regionalism in the B1G regarding football may be dead, but for Olympic sports it’s safe. The college basketball season has enough variety at the beginning of the year between media partners that conference expansion has hurt it without nearly the upside.
Football should be totally separate so go do your 20 team super conference and have fun. Consolidationists don’t seem to be aware a single super conference is how a capitalist driven enterprise “ends”.
But I don’t think football will end up being totally separate from at least basketball and likely Olympic sports overall. The “football will be separate” is the fantasy that a lot of people here keep telling themselves, which is why they are weirdly aren’t scared of what may happen *enough*.
Is a separation between football and other sports be what *should* happen? Probably. Is that what I think will happen? No, because I see firsthand how the same concept of elite conference status applies to the Olympic sports in the same way that it does to football and basketball. I’ve got kids with teammates and friends being recruited in Olympic sports *today* and being P4 means every bit as much to those sports as it does in football. You can reasonably surmise that it will continue to be the case if it goes down to a P2 or P1. That’s why Stanford and Cal send their Olympic sports athletes across the entire continent despite huge costs. Elite status is the one thing even more valuable than money in academia.
Yeah. They are separating themselves in Olympic sports. 3 Ivy League schools and New Mexico (at #49) were the only non P4 schools in the top 60 in the Director's Cup.
Its basketball only schools that want to separate football. The P4 have never been enthused about that. They know the money they are really leaving on the table is in basketball.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:28 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:40 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:47 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 09:02 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 08:01 AM)Crayton Wrote: I think the “barrier” here is the contracts the conferences have selling them. You can modify the contracts but you can’t unilaterally scrap them. One strategy may even be to turn them into defacto exhibitions to bring media partners to the table.
Adding Wild Card Games is simpler and maybe giving conferences the leeway to covert their CCG into a second WCG would be effective.
As I’ve said in other threads, give the A4 2 play-in games (WCG/CCG) and X bids (based on AQs and any at large spots after 12 games) and let them wrestle with themselves on how to deliver teams to the playoff. Do they use a spot on their CCG loser? Do they elevate a 7-5 Duke over a 10-2 Miami? Let them use/misuse their X spots.
We can put a direct price on the CCG barrier:
https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/2025/12...ip-amazon/
NBC is looking for $70 million from Amazon for the 2026 Big Ten Championship Game.
Add in how much Indianapolis is paying to host the game plus ticket and suite sales and sponsorships and you can see it would legitimately take $100 million or more in replacement revenue to the Big Ten and SEC for anything that replaces CCGs simply to break even… and it needs to be replacement revenue for the Big Ten and SEC specifically as opposed to simply shared amongst all of college football (e.g. $100 million for the B1G and SEC is meaningless if the Big 12 and ACC are also getting that same $100 million and thereby reducing the B1G/SEC revenue advantage).
That’s why these playoff expansion schemes that Petitti keeps proposing that would replace CCGs always include conference-only Wild Card Games that would solely be revenue generators for each individual conference as opposed to simply just making the CFP field bigger in and of itself. He’s not ever proposing to simply get rid of CCGs for the expanded playoff alone, but replacing them with even more conference-controlled WCGs on top of it. That $70 million B1G CCG figure (and the SEC CCG would be worth even more in the open market) needs to be replaced in a way that can’t be shared with anyone (and that last point of how that money can’t be shared is critical as, once again, just giving more money to *everyone* in college football with a bigger CFP isn’t the B1G/SEC goal).
It’s less of a contractual challenge and more of an economic challenge.
I have doubts these conference WCG would significantly beat a CCG.
Its sure a big gamble that you can get more money from these and put the regular season at risk.
I agree if I’m looking at it from a financial perspective. Could WCGs be worth more than a single CCG? Maybe. Will they be so much more valuable that it would be worth the *risk* to get rid of that single CCG where we clearly know the value? Maybe not. This is where we need to understand the risk-adjusted return (as opposed to simply the return itself).
You surprise me Frank. The point of WCGs isn't to add extra games on CCG week, its to give more Big Ten teams something to play for in the regular season, keeping their large fanbases tuning in. The actual games themself are just a thing you then have to do to get down to 4 teams. And yeah, you will make money by selling them, but that isn't why the Big Ten is holding up CFP change to insist on their inclusion.
That is to the detriment of Ohio St., Penn St., Michigan and a few other schools in the Big Ten. They will tune out until the playoffs, just like basketball.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:29 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,984
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:24 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Meh. Regionalism in the B1G regarding football may be dead, but for Olympic sports it’s safe. The college basketball season has enough variety at the beginning of the year between media partners that conference expansion has hurt it without nearly the upside.
Football should be totally separate so go do your 20 team super conference and have fun. Consolidationists don’t seem to be aware a single super conference is how a capitalist driven enterprise “ends”.
But I don’t think football will end up being totally separate from at least basketball and likely Olympic sports overall. The “football will be separate” is the fantasy that a lot of people here keep telling themselves, which is why they are weirdly aren’t scared of what may happen *enough*.
Is a separation between football and other sports be what *should* happen? Probably. Is that what I think will happen? No, because I see firsthand how the same concept of elite conference status applies to the Olympic sports in the same way that it does to football and basketball. I’ve got kids with teammates and friends being recruited in Olympic sports *today* and being P4 means every bit as much to those sports as it does in football. You can reasonably surmise that it will continue to be the case if it goes down to a P2 or P1. That’s why Stanford and Cal send their Olympic sports athletes across the entire continent despite huge costs. Elite status is the one thing even more valuable than money in academia.
Well, football is the revenue driver for most other sports in most places. So, if you were to separate football from other sports at a place like Alabama or OSU, they'd just dominate their regional "peers" in the other sports b/c instead of having twice as much money like they do in football, they'd have 10x as much money in every other sport. Prestige matters, sure, but for the schools that have been driving the crazy changes we've seen in the past few years, their only peers are other very large schools with $200m Athletic Budgets.
The way you talk about how Stanford only wants the best of the best of the best, as Will Smith said in Men in Black...that's how pretty much every school in the SEC and B1G, and many in the M2 operate now. And Ohio St doesn't get those kids if they're just going to beat up on Ohio U, Akron, Youngstown St, etc etc in their chosen sports. They get those kids when they're traveling all over the country fighting for B1G and National Titles.
Now, for schools that are not in the P4 and don't have the money to at least sometimes compete with P4 schools, the whole "disengage football from everything else" could make sense. But they won't be in the same division as the P4 if/when they do it.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:34 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,984
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:40 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:47 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 09:02 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 08:01 AM)Crayton Wrote: I think the “barrier” here is the contracts the conferences have selling them. You can modify the contracts but you can’t unilaterally scrap them. One strategy may even be to turn them into defacto exhibitions to bring media partners to the table.
Adding Wild Card Games is simpler and maybe giving conferences the leeway to covert their CCG into a second WCG would be effective.
As I’ve said in other threads, give the A4 2 play-in games (WCG/CCG) and X bids (based on AQs and any at large spots after 12 games) and let them wrestle with themselves on how to deliver teams to the playoff. Do they use a spot on their CCG loser? Do they elevate a 7-5 Duke over a 10-2 Miami? Let them use/misuse their X spots.
We can put a direct price on the CCG barrier:
https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/2025/12...ip-amazon/
NBC is looking for $70 million from Amazon for the 2026 Big Ten Championship Game.
Add in how much Indianapolis is paying to host the game plus ticket and suite sales and sponsorships and you can see it would legitimately take $100 million or more in replacement revenue to the Big Ten and SEC for anything that replaces CCGs simply to break even… and it needs to be replacement revenue for the Big Ten and SEC specifically as opposed to simply shared amongst all of college football (e.g. $100 million for the B1G and SEC is meaningless if the Big 12 and ACC are also getting that same $100 million and thereby reducing the B1G/SEC revenue advantage).
That’s why these playoff expansion schemes that Petitti keeps proposing that would replace CCGs always include conference-only Wild Card Games that would solely be revenue generators for each individual conference as opposed to simply just making the CFP field bigger in and of itself. He’s not ever proposing to simply get rid of CCGs for the expanded playoff alone, but replacing them with even more conference-controlled WCGs on top of it. That $70 million B1G CCG figure (and the SEC CCG would be worth even more in the open market) needs to be replaced in a way that can’t be shared with anyone (and that last point of how that money can’t be shared is critical as, once again, just giving more money to *everyone* in college football with a bigger CFP isn’t the B1G/SEC goal).
It’s less of a contractual challenge and more of an economic challenge.
I have doubts these conference WCG would significantly beat a CCG.
Its sure a big gamble that you can get more money from these and put the regular season at risk.
I agree if I’m looking at it from a financial perspective. Could WCGs be worth more than a single CCG? Maybe. Will they be so much more valuable that it would be worth the *risk* to get rid of that single CCG where we clearly know the value? Maybe not. This is where we need to understand the risk-adjusted return (as opposed to simply the return itself).
You surprise me Frank. The point of WCGs isn't to add extra games on CCG week, its to give more Big Ten teams something to play for in the regular season, keeping their large fanbases tuning in. The actual games themself are just a thing you then have to do to get down to 4 teams. And yeah, you will make money by selling them, but that isn't why the Big Ten is holding up CFP change to insist on their inclusion.
I think that the money from WCGs is most of the reason they're pushing it so hard. Michigan and USC blocked the PE move, but the B1G have-nots still need money. A bunch of 7-10m games would generate a whole lot of money. That's probably how the 7-7-5-5-2-2 proposal came about, if 2 WCGs are worth a bit of money, imagine how much more 5 such games would be worth!
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:36 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,984
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote: To that point, maybe we should multiply the number of "Championships". Oklahoma vs. Texas A&M for the SEC-West "Championship Game"? Bring back the (or knockoffs of, the) SWC, BE, and Pac10 brands?
I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I didn't hate divisions, but there was a significant power gap between the SECW and SECE, and we never built up any history with the SECE schools other than USC. We've still never hosted Georgia in football as an SEC school, we've been in the Conference almost as long as we were in the Big 12, and we are YET AGAIN NOT PLAYING GEORGIA IN 2026. It's almost comical at this point. Why are we playing Alabama yet again in 2026 instead of Georgia?
Ok, maybe I did kinda hate divisions, but only b/c it delayed our full acceptance into the SEC, with many of the old SECE schools still considering us interlopers.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:41 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote: To that point, maybe we should multiply the number of "Championships". Oklahoma vs. Texas A&M for the SEC-West "Championship Game"? Bring back the (or knockoffs of, the) SWC, BE, and Pac10 brands?
I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 02:38 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 01:41 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I didn't hate divisions, but there was a significant power gap between the SECW and SECE, and we never built up any history with the SECE schools other than USC. We've still never hosted Georgia in football as an SEC school, we've been in the Conference almost as long as we were in the Big 12, and we are YET AGAIN NOT PLAYING GEORGIA IN 2026. It's almost comical at this point. Why are we playing Alabama yet again in 2026 instead of Georgia?
Ok, maybe I did kinda hate divisions, but only b/c it delayed our full acceptance into the SEC, with many of the old SECE schools still considering us interlopers.
It won't change. Those in the Deep South don't consider Texas part of the South!
My wife says she just wishes we (Texas, OU, A&M, Missouri, Arkansas) would just go back where we came from. I think South Carolina is the only one of the expansion schools that has been fully embraced by the fan bases and they already played Georgia and some of the others pretty regularly and they recruit the same areas.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 02:45 PM |
|
GoBuckeyes1047
All American

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 10:51 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 10:47 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 09:02 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 08:01 AM)Crayton Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote: I don't like CCGs but they're no barrier to an expanded playoff. The barrier is Army-Navy week, which benefits two upper G5 programs and practically no-one else. Move it forward to CCG week or rivalry week and that can get you all the way up to 32 teams should you so choose.
You know a real barrier to 24 teams? Timeslots. 8 games all hosted by one network, presumably during a non-holiday week. Good luck.
I think the “barrier” here is the contracts the conferences have selling them. You can modify the contracts but you can’t unilaterally scrap them. One strategy may even be to turn them into defacto exhibitions to bring media partners to the table.
Adding Wild Card Games is simpler and maybe giving conferences the leeway to covert their CCG into a second WCG would be effective.
As I’ve said in other threads, give the A4 2 play-in games (WCG/CCG) and X bids (based on AQs and any at large spots after 12 games) and let them wrestle with themselves on how to deliver teams to the playoff. Do they use a spot on their CCG loser? Do they elevate a 7-5 Duke over a 10-2 Miami? Let them use/misuse their X spots.
We can put a direct price on the CCG barrier:
https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/2025/12...ip-amazon/
NBC is looking for $70 million from Amazon for the 2026 Big Ten Championship Game.
Add in how much Indianapolis is paying to host the game plus ticket and suite sales and sponsorships and you can see it would legitimately take $100 million or more in replacement revenue to the Big Ten and SEC for anything that replaces CCGs simply to break even… and it needs to be replacement revenue for the Big Ten and SEC specifically as opposed to simply shared amongst all of college football (e.g. $100 million for the B1G and SEC is meaningless if the Big 12 and ACC are also getting that same $100 million and thereby reducing the B1G/SEC revenue advantage).
That’s why these playoff expansion schemes that Petitti keeps proposing that would replace CCGs always include conference-only Wild Card Games that would solely be revenue generators for each individual conference as opposed to simply just making the CFP field bigger in and of itself. He’s not ever proposing to simply get rid of CCGs for the expanded playoff alone, but replacing them with even more conference-controlled WCGs on top of it. That $70 million B1G CCG figure (and the SEC CCG would be worth even more in the open market) needs to be replaced in a way that can’t be shared with anyone (and that last point of how that money can’t be shared is critical as, once again, just giving more money to *everyone* in college football with a bigger CFP isn’t the B1G/SEC goal).
It’s less of a contractual challenge and more of an economic challenge.
I have doubts these conference WCG would significantly beat a CCG.
Its sure a big gamble that you can get more money from these and put the regular season at risk.
I agree if I’m looking at it from a financial perspective. Could WCGs be worth more than a single CCG? Maybe. Will they be so much more valuable that it would be worth the *risk* to get rid of that single CCG where we clearly know the value? Maybe not. This is where we need to understand the risk-adjusted return (as opposed to simply the return itself).
Here's another question at least for the B1G & SEC. What's more valuable for their conference race and championship weekend? 3 WCGs (#1 in, 2-4 host 5-7) or 2 WCGs + CCG (top 2 in and play in CCG, 3-4 host 5-6)? If the CFP does indeed expand, presumably to around 16 teams give or take a couple, and puts games on Army-Navy weekend, then WCGs are likely going to be on CCG Weekend, assuming the regular season ends on Thanksgiving weekend.
The CFB regular schedule, if any changes are made, would only start sooner with the 2nd bye week while giving conferences the opportunity to move a conference game sooner in the season to give their media partners better quality options for their top games.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 02:54 PM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
The irony is that your previous post was essentially saying that the SEC isn’t like the NFL, but then are proposing almost exactly what the NFL does with respect to divisions.
We obviously just fundamentally disagree about this issue. The national viewer is king - believe me that ABC/ESPN wants the SEC to increase its viewers in the valuable markets *outside* of the South. That’s the “hockey stick” growth opportunity as opposed to just trying to squeeze out some more viewers in the home Southern market.
At the same time, what’s different between the NFL and college football is that the NFL actually *can* sell an AFC North divisional race amongst mediocre teams nationally with great effectiveness in a way that college football really can’t. The big brands still matter much more in college football by comparison and drive extraordinarily more value. To bullet’s point, the SEC scrapped divisions (so there’s little sanctimony justified there) and when you look at virtually every single business proposal about how to drive more revenue in college football (whether people like these P/E firms or not), they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 03:08 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 03:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
The irony is that your previous post was essentially saying that the SEC isn’t like the NFL, but then are proposing almost exactly what the NFL does with respect to divisions.
We obviously just fundamentally disagree about this issue. The national viewer is king - believe me that ABC/ESPN wants the SEC to increase its viewers in the valuable markets *outside* of the South. That’s the “hockey stick” growth opportunity as opposed to just trying to squeeze out some more viewers in the home Southern market.
At the same time, what’s different between the NFL and college football is that the NFL actually *can* sell an AFC North divisional race amongst mediocre teams nationally with great effectiveness in a way that college football really can’t. The big brands still matter much more in college football by comparison and drive extraordinarily more value. To bullet’s point, the SEC scrapped divisions (so there’s little sanctimony justified there) and when you look at virtually every single business proposal about how to drive more revenue in college football (whether people like these P/E firms or not), they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.
There is no irony at all Frank. The NFL's divisions are really regional but rather pan regional for market purposes. In 1992 the divisions in the SEC were organized to preserve local rivalries. At Twenty with 5 to a division they can be regional and preserve those rivalries and by rotating each of the other 5 team divisions annually you play all of the schools every three years and the flip the home games to away games in the rotation. More rivalries are protected and should the Conference have semi-finals and then finals all four regions have a reason to watch the semis and they usually watch the finals anyway.
The point here is not to turn the monetary control of those over to the networks. The networks wouldn't have to worry about AQs as the 4 resulting champs could play it off seeded by perceived strength due to whatever priorities the network chooses. They'll make plenty of money from that and still fill the two weeks in between the bowl season and the CFP with some great games they buy. The CCG is extremely valuable to the SEC for a one off event and they could easily increase the value of 3 games X another .5 to .7 for the semis.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 03:48 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,100
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 12:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:24 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Meh. Regionalism in the B1G regarding football may be dead, but for Olympic sports it’s safe. The college basketball season has enough variety at the beginning of the year between media partners that conference expansion has hurt it without nearly the upside.
Football should be totally separate so go do your 20 team super conference and have fun. Consolidationists don’t seem to be aware a single super conference is how a capitalist driven enterprise “ends”.
But I don’t think football will end up being totally separate from at least basketball and likely Olympic sports overall. The “football will be separate” is the fantasy that a lot of people here keep telling themselves, which is why they are weirdly aren’t scared of what may happen *enough*.
Is a separation between football and other sports be what *should* happen? Probably. Is that what I think will happen? No, because I see firsthand how the same concept of elite conference status applies to the Olympic sports in the same way that it does to football and basketball. I’ve got kids with teammates and friends being recruited in Olympic sports *today* and being P4 means every bit as much to those sports as it does in football. You can reasonably surmise that it will continue to be the case if it goes down to a P2 or P1. That’s why Stanford and Cal send their Olympic sports athletes across the entire continent despite huge costs. Elite status is the one thing even more valuable than money in academia.
I said it should happen in the post you quoted so I'm not sure what you're going on about. When the vast majority of revenue is brought in for a single sport, then it just makes sense to isolate that single sport and maximize it. It is negatively affecting other sports, athletes, and coaches. I am not making this up...
Did you see the NYT is now publishing articles about the strained B1G, which is losing its identity?
Had the four West Coast schools moved to the B1G for football, and the rest moved for only football as well, the Pac 12 would have remained an elite Olympic power conference just as it was before the B1G decided to kill it. The Big East doesn't even sponsor football and does just fine, look at UConn in men's and women's hoops.
Essentially your argument falls apart if Olympic sports conferences are regionally constructed in a sensible and competitively balanced manner.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 03:54 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,100
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
I always seem to forget NFL franchises also sponsor hockey, softball, women's basketball, lacrosse, and all those other sports plus they are many times government entities employing thousands of educators and staff.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 03:56 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 11:51 AM)JRsec Wrote: I think it is pretty clear that more consolidation will happen and that conference size will grow again. Whether that is 20 or 24 schools there is and was importance in winning your division. If divisions are regional within larger conferences for the sake of travel costs and to assist non revenue sports competition, then bringing back the divisions and having division champions will be a good thing. For one the fans liked it, the coaches benefitted from being able to attain good goals even if it wasn't the ultimate goal, and players understood and bought into that format.
If we are to offer more than a bid to the champion of a conference divisions have a place. But if we are to increase the amount of games which the conference totally has as their right to sell to the highest bidder, then increasing the size of the internal playoffs for the Big Ten and SEC make sense for both of them. Let their champions meet those of the ACC and Big 12 and retain the old 4 team championship series.
This would end the bickering over inclusion, without excluding the ACC or Big 12 from having the benefit of their own post season championships which would include schools likely passed up by the current proposed system.
What the networks are trying to attain is control over the expanded post season for a pittance of what could be earned internal each conference. Pay a school 5 million plus or minus for participation in a Post Season Playoff and ESPN / FOX profit from it.
Let the 4 conferences have 4 divisions each and let the divisional champs play it off for the Conference Championship and then go to a 4 champ post season playoff and the conferences benefit the most from their own championship series and the networks still get the best 3 games for their championship.
Determining how to expand the CFP ultimately benefits the networks more than the conferences.
The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.
With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 04:41 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 03:48 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 03:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
The irony is that your previous post was essentially saying that the SEC isn’t like the NFL, but then are proposing almost exactly what the NFL does with respect to divisions.
We obviously just fundamentally disagree about this issue. The national viewer is king - believe me that ABC/ESPN wants the SEC to increase its viewers in the valuable markets *outside* of the South. That’s the “hockey stick” growth opportunity as opposed to just trying to squeeze out some more viewers in the home Southern market.
At the same time, what’s different between the NFL and college football is that the NFL actually *can* sell an AFC North divisional race amongst mediocre teams nationally with great effectiveness in a way that college football really can’t. The big brands still matter much more in college football by comparison and drive extraordinarily more value. To bullet’s point, the SEC scrapped divisions (so there’s little sanctimony justified there) and when you look at virtually every single business proposal about how to drive more revenue in college football (whether people like these P/E firms or not), they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.
There is no irony at all Frank. The NFL's divisions are really regional but rather pan regional for market purposes. In 1992 the divisions in the SEC were organized to preserve local rivalries. At Twenty with 5 to a division they can be regional and preserve those rivalries and by rotating each of the other 5 team divisions annually you play all of the schools every three years and the flip the home games to away games in the rotation. More rivalries are protected and should the Conference have semi-finals and then finals all four regions have a reason to watch the semis and they usually watch the finals anyway.
The point here is not to turn the monetary control of those over to the networks. The networks wouldn't have to worry about AQs as the 4 resulting champs could play it off seeded by perceived strength due to whatever priorities the network chooses. They'll make plenty of money from that and still fill the two weeks in between the bowl season and the CFP with some great games they buy. The CCG is extremely valuable to the SEC for a one off event and they could easily increase the value of 3 games X another .5 to .7 for the semis.
And divisions, especially smaller divisions, means the CCG doesn't get 1 vs. 2, but may get 1 vs. 5. CCGs without divisions are just better TV.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 04:44 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 04:41 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: The challenge is that the marketplace clearly does *not* want divisions at the expense of losing Ohio State-Oregon or Texas-Georgia level games. If the biggest threat to both the current states of the Big Ten and SEC is a 20-team Super League consisting solely of the elite brands - and I personally believe that’s their biggest threat by far because the money for they setup is being dangled daily in front of the Ohio States and Alabamas of the world - then the leagues realistically can’t ever go backwards on the number of top brand vs. top brand matchups. Instead, those top brand vs. top brand matchups need to be increased even more. Regionalism in that sense is totally dead - it’s about national brand power. Even outside of the P2, you can see the ACC altering who gets to play Notre Dame more because they similarly need a greater inventory of top brand name matchups and the other leagues are getting rid of divisions to optimize playoff chances.
The other challenge is that the format that you point to - a multi-round conference intra-conference playoff - only really works if the end result playoff is the Big Ten vs. SEC champ. The P2 aren’t going to go to a 4-team playoff with the ACC and Big 12 champs and treating them as equals. They just killed giving them first round byes in the current playoff system because of how imbalanced that they see their power positions! I think the Big Ten and SEC want their proverbial cake and eat it, too, where they believe that their 2nd/3rd/4th place teams are also superior to the champs of other leagues and they want everyone to know it both competitively and financially. They’re never going to even pretend the ACC and Big 12 are equals ever again.
And look - maybe a Big Ten vs. SEC Super Bowl to the exclusion of everyone else is the eventual goal or end game. However, I still think there are too many schools and markets with material value that they can’t possibly all fit into the Big Ten and SEC, which is another challenge for the overall system.
The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.
With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.
That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.
The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.
What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.
Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.
The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 04:58 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 04:58 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 04:41 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 12:33 PM)JRsec Wrote: The SEC did marvelously with them. We are poised to lose enthusiasm the longer we refuse to return to them. We were never the NFL and our fans didn't want us to be. What we are is Southern College Football, and that is what they want to see and why we dominated the time slots on ABC. Our true rivalries are geographic. Auburn not playing Georgia every year now is going to be resented. Georgia and Auburn fans will never care that Auburn plays Oklahoma or Georgia plays Texas. They would be happy to see those in the conference playoffs but Georgia fans want to play Florida and Auburn and Auburn fans want to play Georgia and Alabama. Trying to fit what the national mold wants will be ultimately destructive to what the SEC has already.
If folks up North want an NFL model then have one, but count us out. And don't preach to anyone in the SEC about brand on brand matchups. That's not our problem, it's yours.
And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.
With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.
That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.
The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.
What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.
Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.
The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.
I'm not trying to agitate you. You are just getting agitated! I just don't think you are right on some of these things and so am disagreeing. Its a message board. You are convinced 100% you are right and take any debate as a personal attack.
Even if its someone like you or Frank who I both respect, if I think you are making incongruent arguments, I will point it out.
I didn't think the pay for play would go this far and I don't like it, but I have accepted it. The presidents still haven't accepted that athletes being employees is inevitable without Congressional action, but its obvious its coming. And divisions aren't coming back.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 05:11 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 04:58 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 04:41 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:23 PM)bullet Wrote: And the SEC dumped that. Because the powers weren't playing enough and ABC didn't like that. It wanted more Alabama-Georgia. Auburn wanted more games vs. Florida. It didn't want teams playing only every 12 years (at least not the good ones). When it comes to divisions, JR, you are stuck in the past. I liked divisions. I liked amateurism. But I'm not pretending either are coming back. I imagine after this year, even the Sun Belt will kill formal divisions.
The only possibility anything like divisions comes back is if the Big Ten and SEC get big enough to split into two conferences under one umbrella. Maybe each goes to 24 and splits into two 12 team leagues (without divisions). And then they would only have 7 or 8 games vs. their own conference so they could have more games against the other conference in their group.
I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.
At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.
The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.
Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.
Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.
With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.
That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.
The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.
What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.
Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.
The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.
I'm not trying to agitate you. You are just getting agitated! I just don't think you are right on some of these things and so am disagreeing. Its a message board. You are convinced 100% you are right and take any debate as a personal attack.
Even if its someone like you or Frank who I both respect, if I think you are making incongruent arguments, I will point it out.
I didn't think the pay for play would go this far and I don't like it, but I have accepted it. The presidents still haven't accepted that athletes being employees is inevitable without Congressional action, but its obvious its coming. And divisions aren't coming back.
Your last statement is true. The sooner we move to an employee relationship the sooner we can clean up the portal. The schools should be compensated when someone takes one of their players in the portal. IOW, the raiding party needs to pay a buyout. With a contract you can do that.
I do think I'm right, and I expect some disagreements and/or argumentation, just not accusation. Disagree with my argument and it is discussion. Attack my motives and it becomes personal. I prefer things as they were with the BCS. I could live with the 4 school CFP. The arguments now are needless. Take the top 4 schools and play it off. Usually, one of those didn't belong and most years there were only 3 with a real shot at winning it all, sometimes just 2. Now all the hogwash is over the 11th and 12th team in. Take it to 16 and they'll be fussing over #17. Wasted breath and wasted time is all that is.
If the ACC and Big 12 survive the next consolidation and rebuild, I'd be in great favor of each holding their own playoff for champion and those 4 schools would advance and be seeded and play it off. To hell with a committee! Let each conference make what it can from its own championship format and let the Networks manage the final 4. Then the SEC and Big Ten could do what is best for each of them as the formats that benefit the one do not suit the other.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 05:36 PM |
|