(11-30-2025 11:10 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (11-30-2025 10:59 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-30-2025 10:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote: On the other hand, if ND and Alabama lost yesterday they'd be looking taking an AL with Miami and getting another slot set aside for one of their lesser teams. No, I don't think it behooves them to ensure their strongest team is wasted in a CCG slot.
The highest-ranked team in the Big Ten is playing in the CCG.
The highest-ranked team in the Big XII is playing in the CCG.
The highest-ranked team in the SEC will be playing in the CCG (assuming Texas A&M falls below Georgia following its loss to Texas, and no one else leapfrogs Georgia)
Notice a pattern here?
If the ACC wants to try to game the system, fine. But then they shouldn't be heard to complain if their conference champion misses the CFP.
They stole a bid they didn't deserve last year with a weak CCG winner, will likely do so again this year (though, its not really stealing since they aren't sneaking an AL at the same time.) They break the pattern alright but I don't think they're making a mistake to do so.
I'm going to ignore sensitivities for a moment and simply be frank about this matter. Whether the CFP is 14 or 16 or 12 they simply just need to take the Champion of the Big Ten and SEC and make all other slots at large. When the next realignment comes this will be a moot point anyway as the SEC and Big Ten will take the best remaining schools from the ACC and Big 12. Maybe a third conference forms and then their champ can get an automatic bid too. But until that time comes, we have two conferences that have grown stronger at the expense of the others. And the biggest issue is that nobody wants to ackowledge that gorilla's presence in the room. It's way past time to have serious discussions about the new reality in college sports about what that means if an upper tier forms, and how to best include as many as possible, and do it fully grasping the reality and needs of all concerned.
The Big Ten and SEC now disproportionately represent the top brands of the sport. And frankly James Madison, Tulane, and others will never have a budget that can compete with that of Texas, Michigan, Ohio State, Alabama, Notre Dame and others all making 200 million plus a year and getting the fattest media checks to boot. Now toss in NIL and the Portal and the gulf separating the ability to compete has become the Atlantic Ocean.
The days of full inclusion of 136 schools in the FBS are shot to hell and back. This ends in an upper tier either still under the auspices of the NCAA or more likely not. And it ends if we are lucky with 72 or so schools in an upper tier of 3 conferences of about 24 to 20 each. And pay and TV time slots will all favor this new entity and it will not be the greed of these schools that drives it but the reshaping of college football for the benefit of television and gambling that puts us there.
There are seven levels of High School Football in Alabama and each crowns a champion. It's only logical that a school in a county of 5,000 can't compete with a school in one district of Birmingham or Huntsville when the enrollment of that high school is several thousand greater than the whole county of the other. Common sense dictated the dividing of the football teams into groups of similar sizes and means.
Well that same logic will drive the division of the FBS into two, maybe three tiers if most FCS schools want inclusion. It simply is what it is and it isn't any school's or president's, or commssioner's or conference's fault. It's time that common sense prevailed and young men at smaller schools didn't have to lineup against purchased behemoths at the top brand schools. There will be fewer injuries, better games, and each tier will get to crown a champ and that honor will be better spread among all athletes than it is now.
Perhaps the Downtown Athletic Club could award a Heisman Trophy at each tier.
But the reality is the CFP is going to be dominated by the SEC and Big Ten and quite possibly by a third conference comprised of PAC 12, ACC and Big 12 schools. And that new tier will play 12 games among themselves, invite 16 teams to a playoff, and will pay a boatload of athletes outside of football with their eanrings.
If we sincerely believe that all conferences will get an AQ or that there isn't a gob smack of difference between the advantages Texas, N.D., OSU, and Alabama have over La Tech, Tulane, San Diego State, or the academies then we are insane. I vote for sanity and common sense. I liked college football BCS and before. But both Toto, Dorothy and I realize we aren't in Kansas anymore. And there be witches on committees and phony wizards at the networks. And until we find our ruby slippers this is the new reality. Toss in the bluefaced flying monkeys of gambling and my favorite sport has taken a huge knock. But pining for the past isn't going to change a thing. We have to accpet the cards dealt us by the courts, and the professionalization of our game. Let's get on with it. Griping about it doesn't accomplish a thing.