(04-19-2022 12:10 PM)bill dazzle Wrote: * I agree with esayem that UMass would be a very solid addition to the Big East as a "partner" for UConn. It simply makes sense.
* Quo makes an important distinction between "status/prestige" on the one hand and "performance" on the other. I failed to differentiate in my recent posts comparing Big East and the current AAC in academics and athletics. Clearly, the Big East offers more prestige than the AAC given 1. the BE has existed for much longer and, as such, offers name recognition and "cache" 2. BE basketball is "power" and 3. most folks simply assume private schools have greater status than public universities (a misguided assumption, no less). So in the conference pecking order (as QV notes) and based on prestige/status, the Big East is generally a higher "ranked" league than the AAC. But in terms of performance both academically and athletically, the two leagues are basically equal in the conference pecking order based on all the metrics I presented.
That's a summary of the data that some would agree with and others would disagree with.
For example, most people who particularly value AAU and R1 doctoral research universities would tend to consider the AAC more prestigious, since the AAC has AAU universities and many more R1 doctoral research universities.
Football fans would also tend to consider the AAC more prestigious than the Big East as far as its football brand is concerned, since the AAC is an FBS conference, whereas the Big East only has 4 FCS schools.
Basketball fans would tend to consider the Big East more prestigious. Regarding undergraduate education, it's not clear whether the Big East schools are generally
considered more or less prestigious.
People who favor a private, religious school over a public university would probably consider the Big East more prestigious.
The Big East has a more well-known brand and more brand recognition, but the American has done a lot of catching up, and is now broadly recognized as one of the 10 major collegiate athletic conferences by most college sports fans.
The fact that the Big East no longer has a football conference has made them more of a niche conference, much like the WCC - great in basketball, but that's about it.
Thus, it may makes more sense to compare the Big East with the the Atlantic 10 and the West Coast Conference than it does to compare them with the AAC.
.