Quote:Because you can't just "take". Maybe-- but iffy. IMO the long term WAC agreement will have a very small money penalty attached. Lawyers from every school signing will make sure "their" school is not put at a sizeable disadvantage. They don't have a million(s) to risk.
I think they can sign an agreement-- but still leave an "out" or reasonably small money penalty.
*** MY MAIN POINT-- a LARGE money penalty will not be included.
We don't know for sure either way, but you're only looking at half the issue.
You're only looking at what they *can* afford to do and not what they *can't* afford to not do. There would be a significant cost to being left behind. That's what I mean about this being an insurance policy. If we're serious about doing this, why wouldn't you sign an agreement that makes sure your compatriots aren't going to bail on you? If you don't do that then the plan might as well not exist.
And again...having an out is fine for the schools that need it. But for the ones that don't get the call, you'll be left there wondering why you didn't push for more of a commitment when you had the chance.
Good points (and I'm not just being patronizing).
But what about this aspect. What if there are not enough schools left behind to make it work. I still think a LARGE money penalty would be vetoed by some (enough) in the group for it not to be included. Some money-- yes.
UCAs AD says that all schools have committed to sticking this out since JSU, SHSU and KSU have left.
Don't know if it's monetary commitment, but he laughed when asked about others leaving.
Quote:Because you can't just "take". Maybe-- but iffy. IMO the long term WAC agreement will have a very small money penalty attached. Lawyers from every school signing will make sure "their" school is not put at a sizeable disadvantage. They don't have a million(s) to risk.
I think they can sign an agreement-- but still leave an "out" or reasonably small money penalty.
*** MY MAIN POINT-- a LARGE money penalty will not be included.
We don't know for sure either way, but you're only looking at half the issue.
You're only looking at what they *can* afford to do and not what they *can't* afford to not do. There would be a significant cost to being left behind. That's what I mean about this being an insurance policy. If we're serious about doing this, why wouldn't you sign an agreement that makes sure your compatriots aren't going to bail on you? If you don't do that then the plan might as well not exist.
And again...having an out is fine for the schools that need it. But for the ones that don't get the call, you'll be left there wondering why you didn't push for more of a commitment when you had the chance.
Good points (and I'm not just being patronizing).
But what about this aspect. What if there are not enough schools left behind to make it work. I still think a LARGE money penalty would be vetoed by some (enough) in the group for it not to be included. Some money-- yes.
UCAs AD says that all schools have committed to sticking this out since JSU, SHSU and KSU have left.
Don't know if it's monetary commitment, but he laughed when asked about others leaving.
Quote:Because you can't just "take". Maybe-- but iffy. IMO the long term WAC agreement will have a very small money penalty attached. Lawyers from every school signing will make sure "their" school is not put at a sizeable disadvantage. They don't have a million(s) to risk.
I think they can sign an agreement-- but still leave an "out" or reasonably small money penalty.
*** MY MAIN POINT-- a LARGE money penalty will not be included.
We don't know for sure either way, but you're only looking at half the issue.
You're only looking at what they *can* afford to do and not what they *can't* afford to not do. There would be a significant cost to being left behind. That's what I mean about this being an insurance policy. If we're serious about doing this, why wouldn't you sign an agreement that makes sure your compatriots aren't going to bail on you? If you don't do that then the plan might as well not exist.
And again...having an out is fine for the schools that need it. But for the ones that don't get the call, you'll be left there wondering why you didn't push for more of a commitment when you had the chance.
Good points (and I'm not just being patronizing).
But what about this aspect. What if there are not enough schools left behind to make it work. I still think a LARGE money penalty would be vetoed by some (enough) in the group for it not to be included. Some money-- yes.
UCAs AD says that all schools have committed to sticking this out since JSU, SHSU and KSU have left.
Don't know if it's monetary commitment, but he laughed when asked about others leaving.
(12-14-2022 02:55 PM)eku05 Wrote: We don't know for sure either way, but you're only looking at half the issue.
You're only looking at what they *can* afford to do and not what they *can't* afford to not do. There would be a significant cost to being left behind. That's what I mean about this being an insurance policy. If we're serious about doing this, why wouldn't you sign an agreement that makes sure your compatriots aren't going to bail on you? If you don't do that then the plan might as well not exist.
And again...having an out is fine for the schools that need it. But for the ones that don't get the call, you'll be left there wondering why you didn't push for more of a commitment when you had the chance.
Good points (and I'm not just being patronizing).
But what about this aspect. What if there are not enough schools left behind to make it work. I still think a LARGE money penalty would be vetoed by some (enough) in the group for it not to be included. Some money-- yes.
UCAs AD says that all schools have committed to sticking this out since JSU, SHSU and KSU have left.
Don't know if it's monetary commitment, but he laughed when asked about others leaving.
Where did you hear Dr. Teague?
I'm curious, also.
On one of the Arkansas sports podcasts, they posted it on. Twitter... I can't remember the name of it. I'll try to find again and post a link.
(12-14-2022 03:12 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Good points (and I'm not just being patronizing).
But what about this aspect. What if there are not enough schools left behind to make it work. I still think a LARGE money penalty would be vetoed by some (enough) in the group for it not to be included. Some money-- yes.
UCAs AD says that all schools have committed to sticking this out since JSU, SHSU and KSU have left.
Don't know if it's monetary commitment, but he laughed when asked about others leaving.
Where did you hear Dr. Teague?
I'm curious, also.
On one of the Arkansas sports podcasts, they posted it on. Twitter... I can't remember the name of it. I'll try to find again and post a link.
Thx
(This post was last modified: 12-14-2022 10:59 PM by EKUSteve.)
(12-14-2022 05:43 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Well-- he can laugh if he wants-- I think it would be a natural question-- that might not be able to be answered till it happens.
sidenote --Are there ever any UCA or AP posters here? Would like to hear their viewpoint.
I agree on that point TOPSTRAIGHT. Until we know what the actual terms are, it's impossible to say what a school would do if they got an offer from an established FBS conference (obviously it would most likely be C-USA if it happened).
Quote:3. This is football-only and all other UCA teams will remain in ASUN.
This does seem to be the unified message from the ADs. It may well be true, but I also am not entirely ruling out that they simply need to maintain some appearances right now either for their own purposes or as a favor to other non-football members in both conferences.
Quote:3. This is football-only and all other UCA teams will remain in ASUN.
This does seem to be the unified message from the ADs. It may well be true, but I also am not entirely ruling out that they simply need to maintain some appearances right now either for their own purposes or as a favor to other non-football members in both conferences.
I agree. Completely. But maybe we all are sticking in our regular conference and the NCAA isn’t pushing back on the football-only part of the FBS move. They have been in discussions with them already per your AD.
Heck, I’m still wondering if Gumbart will be announced as the commissioner of this new football conference. Lol.
Quote:3. This is football-only and all other UCA teams will remain in ASUN.
This does seem to be the unified message from the ADs. It may well be true, but I also am not entirely ruling out that they simply need to maintain some appearances right now either for their own purposes or as a favor to other non-football members in both conferences.
I agree. Completely. But maybe we all are sticking in our regular conference and the NCAA isn’t pushing back on the football-only part of the FBS move. They have been in discussions with them already per your AD.
Heck, I’m still wondering if Gumbart will be announced as the commissioner of this new football conference. Lol.
I mean…. Wow. Lions1983 shared this on the UNA forums.
So much was said here that I’ll need to listen again. So much information that could be interesting to proponents and naysayers of the move to FBS.
Things that stood out to me.
1. At the 15:19 point: "No current NCAA legislation that prevents the...
2. The ASUN has a much longer history to getting football going than many of us realize. Did I hear in this that Troy and Jax State were both members of the Trans America back in the day when starting football was such a focus 20 years ago ? Very interesting.
3. The ASUN is not willing to give up football as a selling point for the conference.
4. This ASUN/WAC Football league may have to live off of an untraditional revenue model. Is that sustainable? Who knows.
5. NDSU was specifically mentioned (19:13).
So many hard truths in rebuttal from the ETSU AD. But, he also acknowledges that if successful, others will jump on board.
Great listen.
(This post was last modified: 12-15-2022 11:17 PM by unalions.)
Quote:CUSA seems fine at 10. Doubt they add anymore unless their members are pulled to other conferences. Also, I hear there’s some bad blood and lots of burned bridges between several of the CUSA/WAC/ASUN schools now.
Well then this better work.
But don't you think they'd add members just to stop this from happening? If this works it really decreases C-USA's options if anything moves in the future.
If C-USA comes in and invites EKU, and SFA two years from now you think those schools would not take the invite? That leaves the WAC/ASUN with 2 less members. Again I don't see schools with below 12M budgets and half of the schools are D2 call ups that have not establish themselves as a D1 schools moving up as one to FBS even if those budgets increase to 15M or so. Being in a conference with established FBS schools and the best FCS schools in the southeast over the past 5 seasons is better. It is what it is. The schools will take an established FBS conference who has access to CFP revenue over a conference that is trying to be FBS. The reason why these schools are together because C-USA took schools away. I have no hard feelings but we cannot avoid the truth or we will live in non-reality. Just because I disagree does not mean I don't want the best for these schools. I think the WAC/ASUN should join together as a FB conference it is just the moving up as one to FBS I have questions about. The last time this was done was in 1998 with the Mountain West and those schools were already 1-A established schools.
Only half of CUSA is established FBS. And they all would take an invite to MWC or SunBelt to get out of the other half...
The appeal of the WAC/ASUN deal (just one aspect) is they are all similar in budget. And they can grow together and not have to worry about competing in conference with schools that can name their own budgets (Liberty).
Speaking of Liberty, they will be in the AAC before long.
And how come when people talk about CUSA expansion, everyone says, no no no, we will stay at 10... but this comes up, and half of these schools are about to be picked up by CUSA???...
A lot of BS talk to me...
Dont believe the SBC is as desirable as you think. Yes some moved this last round but more out of the fear of being left in a dead conference. Similar to JSU and KSU leaving the ASUN, afraid the move to FBS would not happen.
MWC move by UTEP or NMSU would be understandable but the geography isnt great in either conference but are those schools western or eastern based?
Now that UCLA is cleared to move who knows how the shack up will end. Marshall could end up in the PAC as even in my limited time keeping up with G5 those guys are unhappy everywhere in a small amount of time.
Revenue stream in CUSA will end up being greater per school than SBC. Cant speak much on MWC. This create little desire to move.
Quote:CUSA seems fine at 10. Doubt they add anymore unless their members are pulled to other conferences. Also, I hear there’s some bad blood and lots of burned bridges between several of the CUSA/WAC/ASUN schools now.
Well then this better work.
But don't you think they'd add members just to stop this from happening? If this works it really decreases C-USA's options if anything moves in the future.
If C-USA comes in and invites EKU, and SFA two years from now you think those schools would not take the invite? That leaves the WAC/ASUN with 2 less members. Again I don't see schools with below 12M budgets and half of the schools are D2 call ups that have not establish themselves as a D1 schools moving up as one to FBS even if those budgets increase to 15M or so. Being in a conference with established FBS schools and the best FCS schools in the southeast over the past 5 seasons is better. It is what it is. The schools will take an established FBS conference who has access to CFP revenue over a conference that is trying to be FBS. The reason why these schools are together because C-USA took schools away. I have no hard feelings but we cannot avoid the truth or we will live in non-reality. Just because I disagree does not mean I don't want the best for these schools. I think the WAC/ASUN should join together as a FB conference it is just the moving up as one to FBS I have questions about. The last time this was done was in 1998 with the Mountain West and those schools were already 1-A established schools.
Only half of CUSA is established FBS. And they all would take an invite to MWC or SunBelt to get out of the other half...
The appeal of the WAC/ASUN deal (just one aspect) is they are all similar in budget. And they can grow together and not have to worry about competing in conference with schools that can name their own budgets (Liberty).
Speaking of Liberty, they will be in the AAC before long.
And how come when people talk about CUSA expansion, everyone says, no no no, we will stay at 10... but this comes up, and half of these schools are about to be picked up by CUSA???...
A lot of BS talk to me...
Dont believe the SBC is as desirable as you think. Yes some moved this last round but more out of the fear of being left in a dead conference. Similar to JSU and KSU leaving the ASUN, afraid the move to FBS would not happen.
MWC move by UTEP or NMSU would be understandable but the geography isnt great in either conference but are those schools western or eastern based?
Now that UCLA is cleared to move who knows how the shack up will end. Marshall could end up in the PAC as even in my limited time keeping up with G5 those guys are unhappy everywhere in a small amount of time.
Revenue stream in CUSA will end up being greater per school than SBC. Cant speak much on MWC. This create little desire to move.
How? I do agree that the SBC is overrated. There are 8 teams in that conference that are not that good overall at sports. Georgia State, Georgia Southern, ASU, USA, ULM, Texas State, USM. These teams are only good at one sport and KSU beats Georgia State and Southern all the time in sports. SBC fans are become annoying and make up every excuse in the book if your team beats them.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2022 08:49 AM by jones682.)
The SBC is more desirable to the general football fan in the south because of the decent rivalries and the southern geographical region.
The Sun Belt needs just to add teams from TN and north AL/Miss to fill out the map a bit. Could produce some great travel opportunities for fans with a much closer geographic footprint than these other spread-out conferences.
(12-15-2022 11:05 PM)unalions Wrote: I mean…. Wow. Lions1983 shared this on the UNA forums.
So much was said here that I’ll need to listen again. So much information that could be interesting to proponents and naysayers of the move to FBS.
Things that stood out to me.
1. At the 15:19 point: "No current NCAA legislation that prevents the...
2. The ASUN has a much longer history to getting football going than many of us realize. Did I hear in this that Troy and Jax State were both members of the Trans America back in the day when starting football was such a focus 20 years ago ? Very interesting.
3. The ASUN is not willing to give up football as a selling point for the conference.
4. This ASUN/WAC Football league may have to live off of an untraditional revenue model. Is that sustainable? Who knows.
5. NDSU was specifically mentioned (19:13).
So many hard truths in rebuttal from the ETSU AD. But, he also acknowledges that if successful, others will jump on board.
Great listen.
I still have the same concerns that I had before watching this. I have mentioned them, Matt Brown have mention them, and the guys on this podcast have mentioned them. 8 Million a year even if the budget grow is not going to cut it in FBS. You cannot be low major in FBS. Most of these schools are D2 call-ups. Even if the members in your conference are all on the same level budget wise (which they are not), when it comes to bowl tie ends it will hurt the conference. As a G5 team, you have to make a bowl game and you have to be in a conference that is apart of the CFP. Look at the schools budgets that C-USA got vs the budgets in this conference. Plus you cannot have a FBS football only conference. Again most of these schools have not seen a FCS playoff let alone played in one and they want to be in FBS? The ones that have are well above the rest and will be in C-USA within 3 years.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2022 06:34 PM by jones682.)
(12-15-2022 11:05 PM)unalions Wrote: I mean…. Wow. Lions1983 shared this on the UNA forums.
So much was said here that I’ll need to listen again. So much information that could be interesting to proponents and naysayers of the move to FBS.
Things that stood out to me.
1. At the 15:19 point: "No current NCAA legislation that prevents the...
2. The ASUN has a much longer history to getting football going than many of us realize. Did I hear in this that Troy and Jax State were both members of the Trans America back in the day when starting football was such a focus 20 years ago ? Very interesting.
3. The ASUN is not willing to give up football as a selling point for the conference.
4. This ASUN/WAC Football league may have to live off of an untraditional revenue model. Is that sustainable? Who knows.
5. NDSU was specifically mentioned (19:13).
So many hard truths in rebuttal from the ETSU AD. But, he also acknowledges that if successful, others will jump on board.
Great listen.
I still have the same concerns that I had before watching this. I have mentioned it, Matt Brown has mention it, and the guys on this podcast have mentioned it. 8 Million a year even if the budget grow is not going to cut it in FBS. You cannot be low major in FBS. Most of these schools are D2 call-ups. Even if the members in your conference are all on the same level budget wise (which they are not), when it comes to bowl tie ends it will hurt the conference. As a G5 team, you have to make a bowl game and you have to be in a conference that is apart of the CFP. Look at the schools budgets that C-USA got vs the budgets in this conference. Pulse you cannot have a FBS football only conference. Again most of these schools have not seen a FCS playoff let alone played in one and there want to be in FBS? The ones that have are well above the rest and will be in C-USA within 3 years.
I stopped reading at 8M. Even UNA has a budget high than that right now. You’re just trying to argue a point with incorrect data.
If you think these teams are going to stick with their current FCS budgets, you’re delusional. Budgets will increase and they will increase steadily as a group instead of being at a disadvantage by joining an established G5. A point Matt Brown said was an advantage of this plan.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2022 06:36 PM by unalions.)
(12-15-2022 11:05 PM)unalions Wrote: I mean…. Wow. Lions1983 shared this on the UNA forums.
So much was said here that I’ll need to listen again. So much information that could be interesting to proponents and naysayers of the move to FBS.
Things that stood out to me.
1. At the 15:19 point: "No current NCAA legislation that prevents the...
2. The ASUN has a much longer history to getting football going than many of us realize. Did I hear in this that Troy and Jax State were both members of the Trans America back in the day when starting football was such a focus 20 years ago ? Very interesting.
3. The ASUN is not willing to give up football as a selling point for the conference.
4. This ASUN/WAC Football league may have to live off of an untraditional revenue model. Is that sustainable? Who knows.
5. NDSU was specifically mentioned (19:13).
So many hard truths in rebuttal from the ETSU AD. But, he also acknowledges that if successful, others will jump on board.
Great listen.
I still have the same concerns that I had before watching this. I have mentioned it, Matt Brown has mention it, and the guys on this podcast have mentioned it. 8 Million a year even if the budget grow is not going to cut it in FBS. You cannot be low major in FBS. Most of these schools are D2 call-ups. Even if the members in your conference are all on the same level budget wise (which they are not), when it comes to bowl tie ends it will hurt the conference. As a G5 team, you have to make a bowl game and you have to be in a conference that is apart of the CFP. Look at the schools budgets that C-USA got vs the budgets in this conference. Pulse you cannot have a FBS football only conference. Again most of these schools have not seen a FCS playoff let alone played in one and there want to be in FBS? The ones that have are well above the rest and will be in C-USA within 3 years.
I stopped reading at 8M. Even UNA has a budget high than that right now. You’re just trying to argue a point with incorrect data.
If you think these teams are going to stick with their current FCS budgets, you’re delusional. Budgets will increase and they will increase steadily as a group instead of being at a disadvantage by joining an established G5. A point Matt Brown said was an advantage of this plan.
I am not talking about UNA, I know that UNA budget is 13M. Even if they increased, there budgets will not increase to 25M.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2022 08:24 PM by jones682.)