atsKnight
Banned
Posts: 937
Joined: Jan 2012
I Root For: UCF
Location:
|
RE: The Magnificent Orange Emperor tweets
(10-30-2018 10:06 AM)ODU BBALL Wrote: (10-30-2018 01:13 AM)atsKnight Wrote: (10-30-2018 12:54 AM)ODU BBALL Wrote: (10-29-2018 10:58 PM)atsKnight Wrote: So are there any Republicans on here that think that Trump's rhetoric about the media has been been unnecessary at best, dangerous at worst?
Or is the consensus that calling the press "the enemy of the people" is a good thing?
He called "Fake News" coming from the press the enemy of the people. He didn't call out the press in general terms the enemy of the people.
In that same vein your post above is fake news because of its slanted and biased position by ignoring that important aspect of his press related commentary.
First of all, can we stop calling things "Fake News"? Saying that my opinion post on a message board is fake news is the way a child learning to speak would make broad characterizations with simple words. Trying to emulate children in speech does not make discussions between adults more nuanced.
Secondly, you're right. He has never called sympathetic media outlets fake news, so he has not vilified the entire press. My posts in this thread have referenced Trump's rhetoric towards political opponents. My points and questions still stand. Would America be better off as a country if more people on both sides matched Trump's tone and rhetoric?
No! First of all, we can only stop calling things "Fake News" when the news outlets that are constantly pumping out fake or misleading news in spite of knowing differently stop. A classic example is NBC sitting on news - actually some key and pertinent facts that one of their interviewed witnesses stated - that they knew would be a big help to Kavanaugh till after the Senate hearings instead of reporting it. Why? Because they aren't just reporting news anymore. They are also backing a political group (Democrats). Sure, guys like you who are backing the Liberal/Socialist side that is putting out the vast majority of the fake news don't like the fact that their news outlets are being labeled with that negative connotation. Also, all of that "child learning to speak" BS in your post is nothing more than your own bullying tactic to try to shut down being called out on it yourself. If you either don't know the difference between news "facts" and fake news "facts", or you just conveniently left some facts out (as you did) to present a better point of view for your argument then yes, you did your own version of "Fake News".
I'm not sure how you are construing what I said as bullying. Could you explain for me how you define bullying?
If you disagree with someone's post on a message board, there are many options for stating your disagreement. You did a great job of pointing out that you felt like I was conveniently leaving facts out to present a better point of view for my argument. Now I can take that expression of thought and ask you to list what facts were left out. Maybe I didn't feel like the facts were left out, but disagree on the objective truth of the facts. But we can have a discussion about it like adults.
When all you say is, Fake News!!, you don't come across like someone who wants to hear, but someone who only wants to be heard. And the oversimplification devolves the argument. You could say that Kim Jong-Un is a 'meany-pants', and most would agree, but there are better descriptors to use than that.
(10-30-2018 10:06 AM)ODU BBALL Wrote: Secondly, there is no reasonable argument to be made that the mainstream news outlets (including ABC, CBS, CNN, MSNBC, and NBC) have not regularly, routinely, daily, and hourly pumped out stories with the main intent of being negative towards President Trump and Republicans. Anything bad happens .... it's Trump's (or the Republicans fault) even if they had noting to do with it. Anything good happens ... they frequently don't even say a word about it, or at least don't report it as they would if Obama were still "giving them a thrill up their leg".
I would disagree with this and most people consider me reasonable. NBC, CBS, and ABC aren't trying to be partisan outlets. I think the problem that many conservatives run into is that they myopically believe they are right on every issue. If you're right on every issue, then of course everyone else will be wrong, and the only reasons why are that they are stupid or evil. Again, because of my Christian faith, I try to start my evaluation of people assuming that there is a possibility that I'm wrong. So, I try to make as few judgments about people's motivations as I can. Do you have a faith tradition that informs your beliefs on how to treat others?
(10-30-2018 10:06 AM)ODU BBALL Wrote: As for your question about "matching Trump's tone and rhetoric" ... it is a fair question, however it is very one sided the way it is presented. Trump's "rhetoric" pales in comparison to what the Democrats have been doing to stir up the hatred. Keep in mind what the Democrats did before he was even sworn in. They first tried to get the Electoral College to change the way the individuals representing each state presented their votes to the Electoral College - i.e., if Trump won North Carolina for example to get their 17 electoral votes (as he did), they attempted to coerce the people that actually present the votes representing North Carolina to change some or all of those votes to Hillary Clinton in an attempt to lower Trumps Electoral College score and deprive him of his duly elected win. Since that point in time all the way up until today they have been shouting "impeach Trump, impeach 45" and make no mistake .... if they take back control of the House they will probably start down that road. They sat on his cabinet nominations without confirming them an unusually long time in an attempt to keep him from being able to do much early on. They have shown that they will resort to anything to stop a Supreme Court nomination (Kavanaugh). Recently, several of their representatives have actively and openly preached to their followers to "get in the faces" of Conservatives anywhere you encounter them which has led to Conservatives at times not even being able to have a quiet dinner in a restaurant with their families, or go on a date to a movie theater. If you want to paint Trump calling out certain news outlets for doing "Fake News" as being somehow similar to the things I have just listed then knock yourself out, but I for one am not buying it, because it isn't anywhere close to being similar.
Instead of childish terminology, I would characterize this as a childish argument. "Did you do something wrong?" "So and so did it first!"
I try to teach my kids that even though if other kids do things that are wrong, they are responsible for their own actions.
If other people doing bad things were a justification for my actions, I could be a very pious serial killer if I wanted to be.
|
|