(12-05-2016 01:58 PM)200yrs2late Wrote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: You think they KNEW they'd be losing money?
I think they thought they'd get very little profit, no profit, or take a small hit in the first year.
Since you have to go to a competitive website (to get the subsidy) and sign up every year, to think that they were 'buying' business is silly.
Quote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: which is a big part of why they can't just repeal it without being kicked out of office
Well, that and they can't get rid of the good parts of ACA without keeping the bad parts. So whatever they "replace" it with, won't be that much different under the hood, even if they spray-paint the exterior.
With that argument, the ACA isn't that different under the hood from what we had before either. A Pinto isn't fundamentally different from a Ferrari. iirc, humans and dolphins share 90+% of DNA (or whatever it is)... so by MANY measures, we aren't that different.
Quote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: yet you have never established what AT ALL they had to gain from it.
The business, of course.
The business that cost them money? Ridiculous.
Quote:The point being that UCare can't just hire everyone back at the drop of a hat, contingent on re-winning the business. You know this.
Nor do they have to. You have to sign up by December 7th.... open enrollment was started weeks before that... and coverage doesn't start until the first. I suspect they have some metrics to approximate their 'success' thus far and have already interviewed the people.
Isn't that exactly what the other companies did LAST year? Except that they started with essentially zero people.
Quote:MN state govt might be so fed up that they decide to bring the thing in-house.
So now you're arguing that companies who do this for a living can't 'scale up' quickly, but politicians who don't can?
Quote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: My point is that PECs could have been solved otherwise
Maybe, but it will still be ACA's legacy.
Only to uninformed people. I agree the average American is stupid... the biggest problem is that this means that half of them are REALLY stupid.
Quote:Quote:the fact that there is now a whole lot more money being spent on healthcare.
I'm not sure I agree this is automatically a good thing. For example, it could just mean that more people are getting expensive, yet not necessarily effective, treatments.
BUT, if you generally accept that more spending = more people getting help, then the intention is good, and so I accept it.
I didn't mean automatically. I meant that the only positive thing is that there IS some 'new' money to be spent on fixing the mess that the ACA created. They didn't just deficit fund ALL of it.... just a bunch of it. Had they, it would have been almost impossible to fix.
Quote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: What reasonable purpose did they have in intentionally low-balling the bid?
To win the business. I'm not sure why this is difficult for you to understand.
Because winning unprofitable business is not a good long-term strategy. Your suggestion that people who have to go to the websites next year to keep the subsidies will 'pay more' is foolish... especially in light of the fact that the company won the business, and NOW they should be looking to 'cash in' as you suggest... and instead they're closing the doors.
Your argument makes zero sense.
Quote: (12-05-2016 12:00 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: They could easily stay open IF they were allowed to NOW charge enough to cover their costs
Yes, that was their plan. Lowball the bid, win the business, and then jack up the rates once they won it. Oldest trick in the book.
And illegal under the rules.
If that was the plan, why aren't they doing so now?
You need to become better informed on insurance. It is fundamentally different from anything else. The state has to approve rate increases.... and the OLD company would 'cap' the profit that the 'new' company could charge at their old rate... so once again, how is the consumer harmed?