(12-04-2016 08:25 PM)MplsBison Wrote: They knocked the incumbent provider out of the competition with an unfair bid that they knew was unsustainable. That's what.
And saved consumers millions as a result. You think they KNEW they'd be losing money? What investor goes into a project KNOWING they will lose money?
For what purpose did they INTENTIONALLY do such a thing? You said 'the knew'. Prove it, or at least demonstrate 'why' they would do such a thing.
Quote:If there's one thing we can count on, it's that voters will blame the politicians currently in place for the pain they're feeling today, regardless if it was those politicians' fault.
And it won't matter how carefully or thoughtfully you explain to them that it wasn't their fault.
As I said, the average voter is a moron who doesn't care to become educated, but that wasn't the issue. When I told you about it, you blamed Republicans. Now that you know it was Democrats, you come back with this. I agree that Republicans will take blame for the democrats lies... which is a big part of why they can't just repeal it without being kicked out of office for the democrats lies. You've now been educated, but you continue to act as if you don't know better.
Quote:That's what I said. The MN state gov screwed up when it accepted the unfair, lowball bid.
You keep using that word... I don't think it means what you think it means
Quote: (12-03-2016 08:38 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: then all that means is that the insurers lost even more money.
Yeah we should definitely let illegal bribery go unchecked and sweep it under the rug. If that actually did happen, then BCBS MN and Medica MN CEO's should be in jail and MN govt officials that took the bribes should be banned from office.
Yeah, because that's what i said right? Of course not. They also might have parked illegally for the meetings and cheated on their spouses.
The point is that you keep saying they did this on purpose... yet you have never established what AT ALL they had to gain from it.
Quote: (12-03-2016 08:38 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: Where did those companies expanding their operations get many of their people from?
The utopian fantasy of the free market worshipers: perfect flexibility of resources and perfect information.
Doesn't work like that in reality.
So you can't answer it or know that the answer makes you look bad, so you come back with this. I never said it was 'perfect'. They probably got rid of lots of dead wood and some people changed careers.... as I said... Sucks for those people who may have been lost in the shuffle, great for those who were picked up in their place.... but the majority of laid off insurance workers would look for jobs being advertised for insurance workers.
Quote: (12-03-2016 08:38 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: the aca was completely unnecessary
The legacy of ACA will always be forcing the industry to cover people with pre-existing conditions.
Disgusting how it was before. And it's never going back. So "completely" unnecessary is wrong.
Since they admit that was stolen from Heritage and Romneycare, I'd say it was completely unnecessary. You're essentially arguing that concentration camps weren't completely unnecessary because we learned a lot about bone, muscle and nerve regeneration and hypothermia. My point is that PECs could have been solved otherwise... since even Democrats admit that that is only a question of insurance and not healthcare. There are a million ways that issue can be solved. None of them are cheap, but that doesn't mean this is the best way.
The ONLY positive thing of the ACA is what I've been saying for years now... the fact that there is now a whole lot more money being spent on healthcare. Republicans are trying to make sure democrats 'own' those tax increases, while Republicans 'own' the solutions.
Quote: (12-03-2016 08:38 PM)Hambone10 Wrote: They didn't INTEND to lose money
It's mind-boggling that you view this as an excuse for lowballing the bid and then running away when karma bites your a__.
"Your honor, you shouldn't punish my client for stealing the TV. After all, he didn't intend to get caught!"
It's more mind-boggling that you equate losing money on an investment as a crime similar to stealing a TV.
What reasonable purpose did they have in intentionally low-balling the bid? You keep acting like they had some other motive. What was it? Just to be jerks? Just to screw over the system? I'm doubting shareholders, many of whom are Democrats would sign on to lose millions for that purpose.
Quote:Too bad there are no more providers! The two that lowballed and won have turned yellow belly up, and the previous provider of 30 years was put out of business.
Demonstrably untrue. They aren't 'belly up'... They merely closed the money-losing project... They could easily stay open IF they were allowed to NOW charge enough to cover their costs.... and the previous provider is still in business... they just had LESS business.
you act as if they need to build a factory to build 'insurance'.