(04-03-2014 02:54 PM)jmu-fan-1981 Wrote: The college sports world will explode if news comes out that JMU bluffed its way to an AAC invite by colluding with UMASS. I would take back every negative thing I've ever thought or said about JB and the admin and triple my yearly donation today.
I would be very, very, very surprised if JMU got an AAC bid.
Here's where the AAC is right now.
1) They just lost their big boy ticket. And Louisville, their best program.
2) They now have to fight for scraps with everyone else in the G5.
3) Their basketball will take a hit with the departure of Louisville (and Tulsa and Tulane coming in aren't going to help).
4) The money shares fall per team as you rise above 12.
5) Their basketball product is fighting off the A-10, and is below the Big East.
6) Every CUSA, MAC, and Sun Belt team would join the AAC if asked.
So, lets take the UMass to the AAC thing first. Ok, they have a longstanding rival with Uconn and Temple. Uconn might be too close (stadiums 30 miles apart). Their football is an utter dumpster fire. Why would the AAC expand to add a team that isn't going to do much as far as market addition that would harm their football product? They have 12 teams. And MTSU, USM (y'all probably forgot about them - they're bad now, but that wont last) are both still on the table. Both have good basketball and much better football. MTSU is in a major urban center. USM is a flagship school. I'd be surprised if UMass got an AAC bid. Not shocked, but surprised. It'd be a great move for the Belt (because it would mean that there would be no cascade). Heck, ARMY would be a better get because they have a national following that the conference can sell to the networks.
Now, lets move on to the (unlikely scenario) that the AAC has lost its damn mind and decides to go over 12 to take UMass. Now who to pair them with. Okay, here's the list of possibles
Army
Northern Illinois
Middle Tennessee State
Ohio
Marshall
Southern Mississippi
Louisiana Lafayette
UTSA
UTEP
Arkansas State
Old Dominion
-----and-----
James Madison
If the AAC took JMU out of that list, I'd be shocked. Rank them in football. JMU is either the last place program or close to it. Rank them in football facilities and attendance. JMU is not in last place but its pretty low on the list. Rank them in basketball, and you'll find JMU near the bottom. Rank them in location (which is subjective) and you'll find that the most likely "market pick" would be UTSA, followed by NIU, followed by MTSU, and ODU and ..... Why would they go with JMU over ODU in that case? ODU is already further along in its transition. And they're in a better recruiting area.
I suppose that so long as they don't want Ohio or Marshall, you guys are sort of close to Cincinnati. It also gives ECU a closer rival to travel to (although Navy and Temple aren't much further than JMU - if they were looking to go that route, I'd think that ODU would be the obvious choice).
Yea, if you get an AAC bid, then triple the donations to your AD. And enjoy going to the ODU board and trolling for all its worth. But guys, pass up NIU to take JMU? UTSA (Have you seen their attendance records)?