Supports all but two sports and one of those would move into a conference with App and the two GSUs. If that is the tipping point, well that's pretty silly.
(03-27-2014 08:32 AM)GoAppsGo92 Wrote: What he said was that UMASS might have changed the pecking order for JMU... meaning that UMASS might be seriously considered by the SBC and a full offer to NMSU as the solution to get to 12. He did NOT say JMU said "no thanks". No one with street cred with their info. said that.
That doesn't make alot of sense. If UMASS was concerned about travel expenses as an all-sports member of the MAC, why would they leave to be an all-sports member of the SBC?
Because it is just one sport... football. The SBC west teams would play there once every 5 years... Just like the east teams will do for Idaho. The SBC has transportation cost assistance for every travelling member to NMSU or Idaho... not hard to do it for UMASS too. UMASS was never going to leave a 6 bid basketball league for the MAC... that's the real reason it happened.
So a few days ago Sun Belt posters were saying that a football only invite will not be extended to anyone and now suddenly everyone thinks that's an option for UMass? A school thats as big of an outlier as Idaho?
UMASS is much more accessible than Moscow, ID. Its Boston for Pete's sake. UMASS is an existing FBS and is looking for a home, and they have called the SBC office. Of course we are going to consider them when we need one more in football and can bring NMSU in for all sports... its an easy choice if JMU blinks or balks and we are left to ponder Liberty... its possible it happens anyway even if JMU or Liberty get an invite.
If all SBC members can't agree to a 2-year, 14 school plan because they don't want to share the pot 14 ways... then its easy to see only one team getting an invite until there are further developments. Hello UMASS and NMSU.
I believe that UMass is in Amherst, which is not Boston. It is about a 1.5-2 hour drive depending on traffic
There is really nothing to lose going to SBC right now and a lot to gain. ...
This is precisely correct. Every word.
I can appreciate your opinion on this, but it seems like you're looking at it from a purely FBS football aspect. For better or worse, this is definitely not how the JMU administration sees it. They are looking at a much bigger picture. JMU offers 17 (I think) Div I sports. They are all going to be significantly impacted by a move to the Sunbelt. There are significant costs involved beyond adding additional football scholarships. I'm sure JMU is weighing all the pluses and minuses regarding a possible all sport move to the Sunbelt, but they have many variables that they will consider that most folks here aren't interested in.
One being that the SBC doesn't support several of JMU's sports meaning the SBC isn't really a home, it's a wing of a hotel.
Reading this "Conference Thread" is like living the Malaysia Airlines CNN Updates everyday for 12 months with their guest speaker experts that don't know what is really going on! We can only hope for some evidence soon from JMU!!!
(03-27-2014 08:37 AM)ODUBB35 Wrote: That doesn't make alot of sense. If UMASS was concerned about travel expenses as an all-sports member of the MAC, why would they leave to be an all-sports member of the SBC?
Because it is just one sport... football. The SBC west teams would play there once every 5 years... Just like the east teams will do for Idaho. The SBC has transportation cost assistance for every travelling member to NMSU or Idaho... not hard to do it for UMASS too. UMASS was never going to leave a 6 bid basketball league for the MAC... that's the real reason it happened.
So a few days ago Sun Belt posters were saying that a football only invite will not be extended to anyone and now suddenly everyone thinks that's an option for UMass? A school thats as big of an outlier as Idaho?
UMASS is much more accessible than Moscow, ID. Its Boston for Pete's sake. UMASS is an existing FBS and is looking for a home, and they have called the SBC office. Of course we are going to consider them when we need one more in football and can bring NMSU in for all sports... its an easy choice if JMU blinks or balks and we are left to ponder Liberty... its possible it happens anyway even if JMU or Liberty get an invite.
If all SBC members can't agree to a 2-year, 14 school plan because they don't want to share the pot 14 ways... then its easy to see only one team getting an invite until there are further developments. Hello UMASS and NMSU.
I believe that UMass is in Amherst, which is not Boston. It is about a 1.5-2 hour drive depending on traffic
The whole state is the size of a postage stamp. Much easier to fly in and get to than Idaho. Adding them would not be a problem.
(03-27-2014 08:48 AM)GoAppsGo92 Wrote: Because it is just one sport... football. The SBC west teams would play there once every 5 years... Just like the east teams will do for Idaho. The SBC has transportation cost assistance for every travelling member to NMSU or Idaho... not hard to do it for UMASS too. UMASS was never going to leave a 6 bid basketball league for the MAC... that's the real reason it happened.
So a few days ago Sun Belt posters were saying that a football only invite will not be extended to anyone and now suddenly everyone thinks that's an option for UMass? A school thats as big of an outlier as Idaho?
UMASS is much more accessible than Moscow, ID. Its Boston for Pete's sake. UMASS is an existing FBS and is looking for a home, and they have called the SBC office. Of course we are going to consider them when we need one more in football and can bring NMSU in for all sports... its an easy choice if JMU blinks or balks and we are left to ponder Liberty... its possible it happens anyway even if JMU or Liberty get an invite.
If all SBC members can't agree to a 2-year, 14 school plan because they don't want to share the pot 14 ways... then its easy to see only one team getting an invite until there are further developments. Hello UMASS and NMSU.
I believe that UMass is in Amherst, which is not Boston. It is about a 1.5-2 hour drive depending on traffic
The whole state is the size of a postage stamp. Much easier to fly in and get to than Idaho. Adding them would not be a problem.
I am driving across Massachusetts this weekend. Trust me, it's no postage stamp
(03-27-2014 09:04 AM)bridgeforthduke Wrote: So a few days ago Sun Belt posters were saying that a football only invite will not be extended to anyone and now suddenly everyone thinks that's an option for UMass? A school thats as big of an outlier as Idaho?
UMASS is much more accessible than Moscow, ID. Its Boston for Pete's sake. UMASS is an existing FBS and is looking for a home, and they have called the SBC office. Of course we are going to consider them when we need one more in football and can bring NMSU in for all sports... its an easy choice if JMU blinks or balks and we are left to ponder Liberty... its possible it happens anyway even if JMU or Liberty get an invite.
If all SBC members can't agree to a 2-year, 14 school plan because they don't want to share the pot 14 ways... then its easy to see only one team getting an invite until there are further developments. Hello UMASS and NMSU.
I believe that UMass is in Amherst, which is not Boston. It is about a 1.5-2 hour drive depending on traffic
The whole state is the size of a postage stamp. Much easier to fly in and get to than Idaho. Adding them would not be a problem.
I am driving across Massachusetts this weekend. Trust me, it's no postage stamp
I used to live in New England. While Massachusetts may not be as big as Idaho, the population in that small area is FAR more and traffic is always terrible.
And for those that think UMass gets the Boston market.. that's more ridiculous than claiming Georgia State gets the Atlanta market. Boston is not a college supporter. Ask Boston College about that. UMass is even less so.
(03-27-2014 10:07 AM)GoAppsGo92 Wrote: UMASS is much more accessible than Moscow, ID. Its Boston for Pete's sake. UMASS is an existing FBS and is looking for a home, and they have called the SBC office. Of course we are going to consider them when we need one more in football and can bring NMSU in for all sports... its an easy choice if JMU blinks or balks and we are left to ponder Liberty... its possible it happens anyway even if JMU or Liberty get an invite.
If all SBC members can't agree to a 2-year, 14 school plan because they don't want to share the pot 14 ways... then its easy to see only one team getting an invite until there are further developments. Hello UMASS and NMSU.
I believe that UMass is in Amherst, which is not Boston. It is about a 1.5-2 hour drive depending on traffic
The whole state is the size of a postage stamp. Much easier to fly in and get to than Idaho. Adding them would not be a problem.
I am driving across Massachusetts this weekend. Trust me, it's no postage stamp
I used to live in New England. While Massachusetts may not be as big as Idaho, the population in that small area is FAR more and traffic is always terrible.
And for those that think UMass gets the Boston market.. that's more ridiculous than claiming Georgia State gets the Atlanta market. Boston is not a college supporter. Ask Boston College about that. UMass is even less so.
Heck, they struggle with the Amherst market.
All you guys have to do is say "YES" and this whole thing goes away...
I don't think I ever really got the whole story of Linwood Rose and his apparently vehement opposition of FBS football. JMU probably wasn't ready for FBS before 2004, but I can't imagine the man was that pigheaded that he refused to even entertain the idea of FBS conference membership all while expanding the university exponentially during his tenure. Am I giving him too much credit here or is he just becoming our Emmanuel Goldstein per conference re-alignment.
(03-27-2014 01:06 PM)All Dukes_All Day Wrote: I don't think I ever really got the whole story of Linwood Rose and his apparently vehement opposition of FBS football. JMU probably wasn't ready for FBS before 2004, but I can't imagine the man was that pigheaded that he refused to even entertain the idea of FBS conference membership all while expanding the university exponentially during his tenure. Am I giving him too much credit here or is he just becoming our Emmanuel Goldstein per conference re-alignment.
probably the same reasons Merten held back GMU football.
some prez's just aren't on board for those kind of athletics decisions.
(03-27-2014 01:06 PM)All Dukes_All Day Wrote: I don't think I ever really got the whole story of Linwood Rose and his apparently vehement opposition of FBS football. JMU probably wasn't ready for FBS before 2004, but I can't imagine the man was that pigheaded that he refused to even entertain the idea of FBS conference membership all while expanding the university exponentially during his tenure. Am I giving him too much credit here or is he just becoming our Emmanuel Goldstein per conference re-alignment.
probably the same reasons Merten held back GMU football.
some prez's just aren't on board for those kind of athletics decisions.
and yet now Rose is on the board at UVA, certainly UVA is not dropping FBS football, and definitely UVA has not had its academic reputation damaged by FBS football
(03-27-2014 01:06 PM)All Dukes_All Day Wrote: I don't think I ever really got the whole story of Linwood Rose and his apparently vehement opposition of FBS football. JMU probably wasn't ready for FBS before 2004, but I can't imagine the man was that pigheaded that he refused to even entertain the idea of FBS conference membership all while expanding the university exponentially during his tenure. Am I giving him too much credit here or is he just becoming our Emmanuel Goldstein per conference re-alignment.
probably the same reasons Merten held back GMU football.
some prez's just aren't on board for those kind of athletics decisions.
and yet now Rose is on the board at UVA, certainly UVA is not dropping FBS football, and definitely UVA has not had its academic reputation damaged by FBS football
They don't seem to be taking FBS football that seriously though.
What I believe is that Rose doesn't mind FBS if its a P5 conference since that is a real money maker with a lot of exposure. Rose likely didn't think JMU moving to a lower level conference was a good idea. This is backed up by Mike Barber once saying that he had heard that JMU would only move if a BCS conference like the ACC came calling.
There are still a lot of moving parts. I don't think UMass to the MAC in all sports is still impossible. In my opinion, they have 2 years to try for the AAC, while playing in the A10 and MAC, and can possibly change their position on the MAC if nothing materializes.
(03-27-2014 11:56 AM)Saint3333 Wrote: Supports all but two sports and one of those would move into a conference with App and the two GSUs. If that is the tipping point, well that's pretty silly.
I think it's 4 - men's soccer, field hockey, women's lacrosse and women's swimming. Please correct me if I'm wrong on any of those.
I agree that it's not THE issue, but still...that's quite a bit of scrambling JMU will have to do to find a home for all those sports if they go Sunbelt.
(03-27-2014 11:56 AM)Saint3333 Wrote: Supports all but two sports and one of those would move into a conference with App and the two GSUs. If that is the tipping point, well that's pretty silly.
I think it's 4 - men's soccer, field hockey, women's lacrosse and women's swimming. Please correct me if I'm wrong on any of those.
I agree that it's not THE issue, but still...that's quite a bit of scrambling JMU will have to do to find a home for all those sports if they go Sunbelt.
I don't think it's that uncommon. Oduh is big east in field hockey, MAC in wrestling etc
Sun Belt now has Men's Soccer. It starts next year. Ga. Southern. Ga. State. App. St. and 3 northern schools. The Sun Belt put this together as Ga. Southern. Ga. State and App. St. had no conference for men's soccer.
(03-27-2014 01:38 PM)GaSoEagle Wrote: Sun Belt now has Men's Soccer. It starts next year. Ga. Southern. Ga. State. App. St. and 3 northern schools. The Sun Belt put this together as Ga. Southern. Ga. State and App. St. had no conference for men's soccer.
Still not the greatest solution for a soccer program that is frequently ranked in the top 20.