JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,987
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-13-2026 11:49 AM)GoodOwl Wrote: (11-11-2026 01:45 PM)JRsec Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:52 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:44 AM)stechs02 Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.
However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.
If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.
No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.
I completely agree. The one thing I'll say is I wish Rutgers would find their "niche" sport and go all in trying to dominate it. Football is not in the cards for them. Maybe they could do that for men or women's basketball? Maybe volleyball or gymnastics? They don't have to win football, but they should contribute something athletically somewhere to the conference.
Rutgers women’s basketball was quite good for a long time up until the few years.
Somehow, Rutgers achieved the dubious feat of having 2 top 5 NBA Draft picks in 2025 and not only missed the NCAA Tournament, but also had a losing record overall.
I think Rutgers has tried - it’s not like they’re not spending money (as evidenced by their athletic deficits). They don’t seem to be spending money competently or efficiently.
I'm growing more than tired of these "kick so and so out" topics. Rutgers and Maryland aren't that great at football. But that's a good thing for the Big Ten not a bad one. If they love being in the conference and having them on a contender's schedule gives them a little bit of a break in conference play, then the pair is actually boosting the top of the Big Ten by occupying the bottom.
That job fell to Vanderbilt in the SEC and Northwestern in the Big Ten until both got serious about competing. And what has that done for our two conferences? It's provided an extra conference loss for some middling and occasionally contending programs.
People deride UNC and UVa or Duke as poor adds because of football. They are great adds because of football. They are stellar in basketball, stellar in academics and they don't screw up your front runners though they'll all beat some of the middle every year.
Conferences want programs that strengthen their weaknesses, protect their strengths, and add academically and in innumerable other ways. The SEC loves Mississippi State. Their fans a great. They travel well. And until the untimely death of Mike Leach they were what they had always been, an uncertain win and potential loss on anyone's schedule. IOW they were competitive. Make them AAU and there isn't even a concern over them. What the ignorant masses don't know is that like West Virginia their state tasked them with maintaining disciplines which served the work force needs of the state in management and middle management. What the vast majority of this forum has never acknowledged is that states like Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia kept their reconstruction constitutions longer than states like Virginia, and North Carolina. Those constitutions deliberately separated Engineering and Agricultural schools from Medical and Law schools. The idea during reconstruction was that by imposing these constitutions on the states it would impair the ability of a future generation of Southern leaders from knowing and associating with each other across all disciplines necessary to build a resistance. Because of this and the tardiness of several states to do anything but amend those constitutions, many schools were impaired from having the collection of disciplines which would later be considered for AAU status.
My point is that there are State needs which are given as tasks to certain schools to fulfill, historical and state constitutional reasons why some schools only have some of the disciplines sought by those entities which acknowledge the spread of them and excellence in them, and there is no reason for the SEC or Big Ten to want these schools dismissed from their ranks.
Nobody is getting kicked out. And I seriously doubt that Michigan, Ohio State and Penn State or any others decide to go independent. There's too much investment and history and tradition they have with their conference mates to make such shortsighted decisions.
I'm all for wild speculation about realignment because there is a possibility that some of it will happen. I see no such basis for speculation in who gets tossed out threads. Left behind threads? Yep, they are real. Founding member tossed out for underperformance threads are not.
Edit: If it ever happens I might change my mind. The only way any school leaves the SEC or Big Ten will be voluntarily and I don't see that happening as being likely either. But if it did it would be because the school decided to utilize its revenue and available land for their educational mission and so their internal priorities will have changed.
I want smaller, regional conferences. A big fish or two and then others in each. Every champ gets a playoff spot. Easier travel and lower costs for all. But that would make too much sense.
Yes, those were the halcyon days of regional conferences. Days before the rise of the Disney Empire. They claimed that the sum of our parts didn't equal the value of the whole and so realignment began. Since then, consolidation (product placement) has been all that mattered. They didn't want all of the parts that created the sum total. They wanted only the most valuable parts, which of course ultimately will be worth less than they were when their enhanced value stemmed in part from their regional dominance over those other regional schools the networks don't want as much. The networks don't want the whole to be worth the same as the sum of the parts, they want it to cost less than the sum of the parts, and they only want the icing and cherries from the top of each cake. The end they seek is the diminishment of top brands as they cannibalize one another down to a dominant few to create a spectacle for the masses, not the fans. Like the stupor bowl where celebrities go to be seen at the final event of each season, likely knowing little of the sport, but being there to be seen basking in the sacrifice of others. The sport itself is reduced to being the backdrop of the spectacle. And they say the Hunger Games was science fiction. It was merely a stylized representation of what we already do whether that is the Super Bowl, the CFP finals, the Olympics, or any other event that celebrities and politicians cluster to attend so they can be elevated above the beloved spectacle. It is their way of reminding us of who rules. And in the dystopian Rollerball, the sport exists to remind us of the futility of individual achievement in order that we might better serve some collective.
Sports need only stand to highlight the achievement of athletes dedicated to being the best in their chosen discipline. If they are anything but that celebration of personal excellence, then they have been corrupted. Team sports existed only to teach the necessity of communication, performance of assigned task, and how when we each pursues excellence in our position and we do it in concert with others skilled differently than we are that we can attain anything. Team sports represent the best of human cooperation. If they become more than a tool for teaching life skills and the benefits of cooperation they have been corrupted.
If sports help our youth to become better people, then they have achieved their purpose.
Again, form follows function. If the function is to create better young adults, then the sport itself is worthwhile as an instrument for learning (an amateur concept). If the function is to help the participant to make a living or give the public entertainment, then it becomes a profession. What the Supreme Court determined was that once the schools made millions from a sport and it served as entertainment for the masses, it indeed ceased to be a form of instruction and became a profession. Because of that college sports are the genie that is never going back into the bottle. They are for profit, and the days of a couple of brands in a conference of around 10 will lose out for whatever generates more revenue, even if that eventually kills the demand. Entropy has begun.
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 01:04 PM by JRsec.)
|
|