Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
Author Message
PlayBall! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,895
Joined: Jun 2012
Reputation: 203
I Root For: Kansas & Big XII
Location:
Post: #81
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 01:49 PM)Eichorst Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  ... Rutgers [has] access to tons of money but their boosters and fans don't care about football.

Rutgers attendance has been close to capacity every year since the pandemic, with attendance finally dropping off a bit this year because of how awful they've been. ...

So I don't think Rutgers fans don't care. They're just looking for some reason to be excited IMO.

What is the high school football culture like in NJ? Does that need a boost?

Having not one but two NFL teams playing in the state must hurt Rutgers. Saps away a lot of fan energy, especially if at least one is doing well each year.

Would officially changing the name (back?) to just "The University of New Jersey" help inspire loyalty over the long run?
11-12-2026 10:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
C2__ Offline
Caltex2
*

Posts: 24,292
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 609
I Root For: Houston, PVAMU
Location: League City, TX
Post: #82
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
I've always suggested they brand themselves as "Rutgers New Jersey."
11-12-2026 10:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,305
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #83
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 10:40 PM)PlayBall! Wrote:  What is the high school football culture like in NJ? Does that need a boost?

Having not one but two NFL teams playing in the state must hurt Rutgers. Saps away a lot of fan energy, especially if at least one is doing well each year.

Would officially changing the name (back?) to just "The University of New Jersey" help inspire loyalty over the long run?

1. NJ has some of the best HS football teams in the Northeast.

2. Don't confuse MetLife Stadium with the rest of the state. Areas south of Trenton are practically Philadelphia suburbs.

3. A NJ governor suggested the University of New Jersey. It was politically unpopular and subsequently shelved.
11-12-2026 10:57 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
tf8693 Online
All American
*

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
Post: #84
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
To be completely honest, the time to debate the question pondered by the OP was before Rutgers joined the B1G in 2014. At this point, the B1G has made its own bed on Rutgers. It should lie in it.

I'll confess to having never read any of the conference bylaws, but I strongly doubt that poor performance on the field (or court, as the case may be) is not grounds for expulsion from any conference, certainly not standing alone. In this day and age, when B1G members reportedly receive $80 million per year from media rights deals, expelling Rutgers from the conference over poor performance is tantamount to inviting a breach of contract lawsuit with nine or even ten figures in damages at stake. In addition to that, something often conveniently glossed over on this board is the fact that conference games, by their very nature, are zero sum. For every team that wins a conference game, there is another team that loses a conference game. Viewed in that light, teams that lose conference games, especially the cellar dwellers, are performing a valuable service for the conference as a whole.

I don't see any scenario where Rutgers gets kicked out of the B1G at this point based on the above. But that doesn't mean that I can't be wrong about that.
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 08:11 AM by tf8693.)
11-13-2026 08:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,635
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #85
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 12:27 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 12:10 PM)billybobby777 Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 11:36 AM)NWBearcat Wrote:  The answer is definitively no.

They haven’t been competitive in any sport. They are dead weight. It’s not like the still need Rutgers to access that market.

Adding them was a huge mistake that the Big 10 certainly regrets but wouldn’t say so publicly.

I wish someone in the big 10 office would admit that adding in Rutgers was a big mistake. Mike Aresco admitted that adding Charlotte and FAU to the AC was a mistake.

He did? Or was that written in Sharpie on a bathroom stall in Irving?

Both he said it and he wrote in the stall. When I was sitting on the toilet in Irving I read it. Unfortunately he also wrote something else on the stall about arriving at a certain time and I happened to be there. Aresco and Sea Bass have a strong resemblance.
11-13-2026 08:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,554
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #86
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 10:57 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 10:40 PM)PlayBall! Wrote:  What is the high school football culture like in NJ? Does that need a boost?

Having not one but two NFL teams playing in the state must hurt Rutgers. Saps away a lot of fan energy, especially if at least one is doing well each year.

Would officially changing the name (back?) to just "The University of New Jersey" help inspire loyalty over the long run?

1. NJ has some of the best HS football teams in the Northeast.

2. Don't confuse MetLife Stadium with the rest of the state. Areas south of Trenton are practically Philadelphia suburbs.

3. A NJ governor suggested the University of New Jersey. It was politically unpopular and subsequently shelved.

I think the football recruiting part was definitely an attraction for the Big Ten with respect to Rutgers. It wasn’t as big as the TV market part, but it was definitely a factor.

It’s easy for people in the Southern half of the US to throw stones because pretty much the whole southeastern quadrant of the US from Texas to Florida and up through Georgia and the Carolinas all overindexes on elite football player production. So, sure, they can add a lot by just being regional within their footprint and contiguous.

The Big Ten was never in that position. It was identified over 20 years ago that with the way that demographic trends were going, the league was going to lose its dominant financial position if it didn’t act. Every other power league at the time - even the old football Big East - had a better demographic outlook than the Midwestern states in the Big Ten and that’s frankly still the case. Hence why the “natural fits” for a lot of fans, such as Missouri, weren’t going to move the needle or address the core long-term problem for the Big Ten.

Most of the Northeast is pretty terrible for producing FBS-level football players. The State of New York is particularly horrible at it - it is quite amazing how bad it is on a per capita basis.

However, New Jersey and Maryland are two massive exceptions to that general rule. Now, they don’t produce football players like Georgia or Florida, but they are at least producing them in line with what you would expect with their population… and those are both huge population states that are also adjacent to huge metro areas (NYC and DC).

So, this is what the Big Ten found: there were only two states in the entire Northern half of the US that produced football players at a material level that weren’t already in the Big Ten at that time: New Jersey and Maryland. Every other material football recruiting territory was either in the South or California (and expanding all of the way out to California for expansion was just a fever dream at that point in history).

Now, people can argue all about whether that expansion was worth it or not. However, the Big Ten simply didn’t have the option to be an insular and regionalized Midwestern league for expansion compared to the SEC. The Big Ten was going to HAVE to break out of its core footprint for long-term health and not just at the margins. The fact that New Jersey and Maryland were still contiguous states to the Big Ten footprint and in the Northern half of the US actually made it into a *conservative* expansion move by the league compared to other scenarios. I know a lot of people don’t see it that way and think regionality can rule, but once again, you have to look at it very differently when the core is the slow growth Midwest compared to leagues that have Florida, Texas, Georgia, etc.
11-13-2026 09:06 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Spaceball1 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 4
Joined: Nov 2026
Reputation: 3
I Root For: I love Uranus
Location:
Post: #87
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 02:17 PM)NWBearcat Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 12:12 PM)Spaceball1 Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 11:36 AM)NWBearcat Wrote:  The answer is definitively no.

They haven’t been competitive in any sport. They are dead weight. It’s not like the still need Rutgers to access that market.

Adding them was a huge mistake that the Big 10 certainly regrets but wouldn’t say so publicly.

The amount of money they have generated for the Big 10 network cannot be ignored. I don't think any of those school presidents are regretting all of that cash from the NYC market. Remember, BTN's rates for NYC went from $.10 a subscriber per month to over a $1 per subscriber per month.

Oh yeah? How is cable TV doing now?

The BTN still generates a TON of money. And BTN is still something you pay for through Fox One.
11-13-2026 10:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #88
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-11-2026 06:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO this is an example of the problem with making membership decisions based on money, like media deals. Fifteen years ago, the B1G (IMO) signed up Rutgers to get in-market rates for the BTN in the NYC area.

That worked, a gusher of money ensued, and IMO the impact on B1G competitiveness is underrated. Other than Ohio State catching a flyer in 2014, the top B1G schools were basically uncompetitive with the top SEC schools and the Clemson juggernaut. Then, once that money really started rolling in circa 2017, the top B1G schools got better. Ohio State almost beat Clemson in 2019, beat them in 2020, and then Michigan rose to playoff and national title level from 2021 on as well. That money helped bridge what had seemed like a huge gap in the mid-2010s.

It especially helped that the B1G IMO beggared Rutgers (and Maryland, who got them those same big rates in the lucrative DMV zone) while directing the vast majority of the new money to the legacy members.

But now ... that has pretty much run its course, BTN money in the DMV and NYC isn't the game changer it was a decade ago, and yet Rutgers is still in the B1G, dragging the league down. And they will continue to be.

I think that 15 years of the B1G subsidizing Rutgers financially is fair compensation for 15 years of the B1G taking so much from Rutgers and making them even less competitive than they would have been with equal compensation. The real question is whether Rutgers in 2041 will have finally leveled up enough to be competitive long term, and their lack of significant fan and booster support leaves me skeptical.
11-13-2026 10:22 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
djsuperfly Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,616
Joined: Sep 2021
Reputation: 291
I Root For: UCF
Location:
Post: #89
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-13-2026 10:18 AM)Spaceball1 Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 02:17 PM)NWBearcat Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 12:12 PM)Spaceball1 Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 11:36 AM)NWBearcat Wrote:  The answer is definitively no.

They haven’t been competitive in any sport. They are dead weight. It’s not like the still need Rutgers to access that market.

Adding them was a huge mistake that the Big 10 certainly regrets but wouldn’t say so publicly.

The amount of money they have generated for the Big 10 network cannot be ignored. I don't think any of those school presidents are regretting all of that cash from the NYC market. Remember, BTN's rates for NYC went from $.10 a subscriber per month to over a $1 per subscriber per month.

Oh yeah? How is cable TV doing now?

The BTN still generates a TON of money. And BTN is still something you pay for through Fox One.

Yes, the BTN still generates a lot of money from cable subs. And, while cable subs are certainly down from their peak, cord cutting does appear to have mostly leveled off for now.

As to the second line, though: we know what BTN makes per cable sub under the cable contracts. BTN through DTC streaming like Fox One is far more nebulous, though.

From what a search says: The conference does not typically receive a direct, per-subscriber pay-per-view cut from individual streaming apps like Fox One; instead, Fox monetizes its total subscriber base, ad inventory, and bundle sign-ups (such as Fox One paired with ESPN Unlimited) to cover its fixed rights obligations.
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 10:32 AM by djsuperfly.)
11-13-2026 10:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Spaceball1 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 4
Joined: Nov 2026
Reputation: 3
I Root For: I love Uranus
Location:
Post: #90
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-13-2026 10:31 AM)djsuperfly Wrote:  Yes, the BTN still generates a lot of money from cable subs. And, while cable subs are certainly down from their peak, cord cutting does appear to have mostly leveled off for now.

As to the second line, though: we know what BTN makes per cable sub under the cable contracts. BTN through DTC streaming like Fox One is far more nebulous, though.

From what a search says: The conference does not typically receive a direct, per-subscriber pay-per-view cut from individual streaming apps like Fox One; instead, Fox monetizes its total subscriber base, ad inventory, and bundle sign-ups (such as Fox One paired with ESPN Unlimited) to cover its fixed rights obligations.

Yeah, it isn't clear how much they make of Fox One, but they still get a chunk of money from it (Fox owns 61% of BTN).

Quote:Conference Share: Even though Fox holds the controlling interest, the Big Ten Conference still retains a minority ownership stake (around 39%) in BTN, meaning subscription and ad revenues from cable, satellite, and digital platforms—including its inclusion on Fox Corporation's streaming service Fox One—continue to generate revenue shared with the conference and its member schools.
11-13-2026 10:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,616
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #91
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 08:08 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  Before someone mentions Temple, they were a football only member of the Big East. They sucked and weren’t putting anything into the program. But as a single sport member, it was a lot easier to kick them out.

They then joined the MAC for football and built the program up to where they got back in the Big East as a full member.

But if they had been a full member to begin with I doubt they are told to leave.

The Temple FB resume during the Big East years was really bad.

Non-conference
0-23 vs P5 opponents
13-21 vs G5 opponents
3-2 vs FCS
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 11:46 AM by PicksUp.)
11-13-2026 11:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoodOwl Offline
The 1 Hoo Knocks
*

Posts: 29,360
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 4935
I Root For: New Horizons
Location: Planiverse
Post: #92
Exclamation RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-11-2026 01:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 10:52 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 10:44 AM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.

I completely agree. The one thing I'll say is I wish Rutgers would find their "niche" sport and go all in trying to dominate it. Football is not in the cards for them. Maybe they could do that for men or women's basketball? Maybe volleyball or gymnastics? They don't have to win football, but they should contribute something athletically somewhere to the conference.

Rutgers women’s basketball was quite good for a long time up until the few years.

Somehow, Rutgers achieved the dubious feat of having 2 top 5 NBA Draft picks in 2025 and not only missed the NCAA Tournament, but also had a losing record overall.

I think Rutgers has tried - it’s not like they’re not spending money (as evidenced by their athletic deficits). They don’t seem to be spending money competently or efficiently.

I'm growing more than tired of these "kick so and so out" topics. Rutgers and Maryland aren't that great at football. But that's a good thing for the Big Ten not a bad one. If they love being in the conference and having them on a contender's schedule gives them a little bit of a break in conference play, then the pair is actually boosting the top of the Big Ten by occupying the bottom.

That job fell to Vanderbilt in the SEC and Northwestern in the Big Ten until both got serious about competing. And what has that done for our two conferences? It's provided an extra conference loss for some middling and occasionally contending programs.

People deride UNC and UVa or Duke as poor adds because of football. They are great adds because of football. They are stellar in basketball, stellar in academics and they don't screw up your front runners though they'll all beat some of the middle every year.

Conferences want programs that strengthen their weaknesses, protect their strengths, and add academically and in innumerable other ways. The SEC loves Mississippi State. Their fans a great. They travel well. And until the untimely death of Mike Leach they were what they had always been, an uncertain win and potential loss on anyone's schedule. IOW they were competitive. Make them AAU and there isn't even a concern over them. What the ignorant masses don't know is that like West Virginia their state tasked them with maintaining disciplines which served the work force needs of the state in management and middle management. What the vast majority of this forum has never acknowledged is that states like Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia kept their reconstruction constitutions longer than states like Virginia, and North Carolina. Those constitutions deliberately separated Engineering and Agricultural schools from Medical and Law schools. The idea during reconstruction was that by imposing these constitutions on the states it would impair the ability of a future generation of Southern leaders from knowing and associating with each other across all disciplines necessary to build a resistance. Because of this and the tardiness of several states to do anything but amend those constitutions, many schools were impaired from having the collection of disciplines which would later be considered for AAU status.

My point is that there are State needs which are given as tasks to certain schools to fulfill, historical and state constitutional reasons why some schools only have some of the disciplines sought by those entities which acknowledge the spread of them and excellence in them, and there is no reason for the SEC or Big Ten to want these schools dismissed from their ranks.

Nobody is getting kicked out. And I seriously doubt that Michigan, Ohio State and Penn State or any others decide to go independent. There's too much investment and history and tradition they have with their conference mates to make such shortsighted decisions.

I'm all for wild speculation about realignment because there is a possibility that some of it will happen. I see no such basis for speculation in who gets tossed out threads. Left behind threads? Yep, they are real. Founding member tossed out for underperformance threads are not.

Edit: If it ever happens I might change my mind. The only way any school leaves the SEC or Big Ten will be voluntarily and I don't see that happening as being likely either. But if it did it would be because the school decided to utilize its revenue and available land for their educational mission and so their internal priorities will have changed.

I want smaller, regional conferences. A big fish or two and then others in each. Every champ gets a playoff spot. Easier travel and lower costs for all. But that would make too much sense.
11-13-2026 11:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,988
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #93
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-13-2026 11:49 AM)GoodOwl Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 01:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 10:52 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 10:44 AM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.

I completely agree. The one thing I'll say is I wish Rutgers would find their "niche" sport and go all in trying to dominate it. Football is not in the cards for them. Maybe they could do that for men or women's basketball? Maybe volleyball or gymnastics? They don't have to win football, but they should contribute something athletically somewhere to the conference.

Rutgers women’s basketball was quite good for a long time up until the few years.

Somehow, Rutgers achieved the dubious feat of having 2 top 5 NBA Draft picks in 2025 and not only missed the NCAA Tournament, but also had a losing record overall.

I think Rutgers has tried - it’s not like they’re not spending money (as evidenced by their athletic deficits). They don’t seem to be spending money competently or efficiently.

I'm growing more than tired of these "kick so and so out" topics. Rutgers and Maryland aren't that great at football. But that's a good thing for the Big Ten not a bad one. If they love being in the conference and having them on a contender's schedule gives them a little bit of a break in conference play, then the pair is actually boosting the top of the Big Ten by occupying the bottom.

That job fell to Vanderbilt in the SEC and Northwestern in the Big Ten until both got serious about competing. And what has that done for our two conferences? It's provided an extra conference loss for some middling and occasionally contending programs.

People deride UNC and UVa or Duke as poor adds because of football. They are great adds because of football. They are stellar in basketball, stellar in academics and they don't screw up your front runners though they'll all beat some of the middle every year.

Conferences want programs that strengthen their weaknesses, protect their strengths, and add academically and in innumerable other ways. The SEC loves Mississippi State. Their fans a great. They travel well. And until the untimely death of Mike Leach they were what they had always been, an uncertain win and potential loss on anyone's schedule. IOW they were competitive. Make them AAU and there isn't even a concern over them. What the ignorant masses don't know is that like West Virginia their state tasked them with maintaining disciplines which served the work force needs of the state in management and middle management. What the vast majority of this forum has never acknowledged is that states like Alabama, Mississippi, and Georgia kept their reconstruction constitutions longer than states like Virginia, and North Carolina. Those constitutions deliberately separated Engineering and Agricultural schools from Medical and Law schools. The idea during reconstruction was that by imposing these constitutions on the states it would impair the ability of a future generation of Southern leaders from knowing and associating with each other across all disciplines necessary to build a resistance. Because of this and the tardiness of several states to do anything but amend those constitutions, many schools were impaired from having the collection of disciplines which would later be considered for AAU status.

My point is that there are State needs which are given as tasks to certain schools to fulfill, historical and state constitutional reasons why some schools only have some of the disciplines sought by those entities which acknowledge the spread of them and excellence in them, and there is no reason for the SEC or Big Ten to want these schools dismissed from their ranks.

Nobody is getting kicked out. And I seriously doubt that Michigan, Ohio State and Penn State or any others decide to go independent. There's too much investment and history and tradition they have with their conference mates to make such shortsighted decisions.

I'm all for wild speculation about realignment because there is a possibility that some of it will happen. I see no such basis for speculation in who gets tossed out threads. Left behind threads? Yep, they are real. Founding member tossed out for underperformance threads are not.

Edit: If it ever happens I might change my mind. The only way any school leaves the SEC or Big Ten will be voluntarily and I don't see that happening as being likely either. But if it did it would be because the school decided to utilize its revenue and available land for their educational mission and so their internal priorities will have changed.

I want smaller, regional conferences. A big fish or two and then others in each. Every champ gets a playoff spot. Easier travel and lower costs for all. But that would make too much sense.

Yes, those were the halcyon days of regional conferences. Days before the rise of the Disney Empire. They claimed that the sum of our parts didn't equal the value of the whole and so realignment began. Since then, consolidation (product placement) has been all that mattered. They didn't want all of the parts that created the sum total. They wanted only the most valuable parts, which of course ultimately will be worth less than they were when their enhanced value stemmed in part from their regional dominance over those other regional schools the networks don't want as much. The networks don't want the whole to be worth the same as the sum of the parts, they want it to cost less than the sum of the parts, and they only want the icing and cherries from the top of each cake. The end they seek is the diminishment of top brands as they cannibalize one another down to a dominant few to create a spectacle for the masses, not the fans. Like the stupor bowl where celebrities go to be seen at the final event of each season, likely knowing little of the sport, but being there to be seen basking in the sacrifice of others. The sport itself is reduced to being the backdrop of the spectacle. And they say the Hunger Games was science fiction. It was merely a stylized representation of what we already do whether that is the Super Bowl, the CFP finals, the Olympics, or any other event that celebrities and politicians cluster to attend so they can be elevated above the beloved spectacle. It is their way of reminding us of who rules. And in the dystopian Rollerball, the sport exists to remind us of the futility of individual achievement in order that we might better serve some collective.

Sports need only stand to highlight the achievement of athletes dedicated to being the best in their chosen discipline. If they are anything but that celebration of personal excellence, then they have been corrupted. Team sports existed only to teach the necessity of communication, performance of assigned task, and how when we each pursues excellence in our position and we do it in concert with others skilled differently than we are that we can attain anything. Team sports represent the best of human cooperation. If they become more than a tool for teaching life skills and the benefits of cooperation they have been corrupted.

If sports help our youth to become better people, then they have achieved their purpose.

Again, form follows function. If the function is to create better young adults, then the sport itself is worthwhile as an instrument for learning (an amateur concept). If the function is to help the participant to make a living or give the public entertainment, then it becomes a profession. What the Supreme Court determined was that once the schools made millions from a sport and it served as entertainment for the masses, it indeed ceased to be a form of instruction and became a profession. Because of that college sports are the genie that is never going back into the bottle. They are for profit, and the days of a couple of brands in a conference of around 10 will lose out for whatever generates more revenue, even if that eventually kills the demand. Entropy has begun.
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 01:04 PM by JRsec.)
11-13-2026 12:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #94
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-12-2026 10:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 05:32 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 02:17 PM)NWBearcat Wrote:  Oh yeah? How is cable TV doing now?

...and this is what dates the membership offer in a way that just doesn't age well. At least UMD helped to broker JHU joining for lacrosse to help the B1G get AQ and instant near-the-top billing in the sport, for whatever sliver of a share for its worth (I guess for some BTN content). Rutgers feels like it could be just any school rounding out the bunch were it not for its location.

There were worse offers made in other conferences to incoming schools...Hofstra and Northeastern to CAA for football that both schools then dropped, CUSA doubling down in FL with both FIU and FAU, AAC with Charlotte, etc.. But, you're looking at non-major conference moves. The closest to just how "unfit" Rutgers is to its conference surroundings for a major conference may be BC in the ACC or DePaul in the Big East? Those two private schools don't have to broadcast their finances, but, I don't get the impression they're sinking in the same way Rutgers is.
Actually, both Rutgers and Maryland were needed to get the B1G that automatic lacrosse birth to attract JHU. Though you could say that Syracuse could have filled that slot just as well while having a better lacrosse team to boot. Or Virginia, setting aside that Virginia was seemingly not interested in joining the Big Ten back then.

With some of the talk out of JHU about the decision to join a conference, imagine if the ACC returned the calls? What might it have been had the B1G taken both UMD and Rutgers to then swing and miss with JHU? Who's the affiliate then?
11-14-2026 11:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,374
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #95
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-14-2026 11:53 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 10:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 05:32 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 02:17 PM)NWBearcat Wrote:  Oh yeah? How is cable TV doing now?

...and this is what dates the membership offer in a way that just doesn't age well. At least UMD helped to broker JHU joining for lacrosse to help the B1G get AQ and instant near-the-top billing in the sport, for whatever sliver of a share for its worth (I guess for some BTN content). Rutgers feels like it could be just any school rounding out the bunch were it not for its location.

There were worse offers made in other conferences to incoming schools...Hofstra and Northeastern to CAA for football that both schools then dropped, CUSA doubling down in FL with both FIU and FAU, AAC with Charlotte, etc.. But, you're looking at non-major conference moves. The closest to just how "unfit" Rutgers is to its conference surroundings for a major conference may be BC in the ACC or DePaul in the Big East? Those two private schools don't have to broadcast their finances, but, I don't get the impression they're sinking in the same way Rutgers is.
Actually, both Rutgers and Maryland were needed to get the B1G that automatic lacrosse birth to attract JHU. Though you could say that Syracuse could have filled that slot just as well while having a better lacrosse team to boot. Or Virginia, setting aside that Virginia was seemingly not interested in joining the Big Ten back then.

With some of the talk out of JHU about the decision to join a conference, imagine if the ACC returned the calls? What might it have been had the B1G taken both UMD and Rutgers to then swing and miss with JHU? Who's the affiliate then?
It only takes 6 teams to get an automatic berth. We would have had one even without JHU. They were added as an affiliate, instead,because they're elite in both lacrosse and academics.

Fun fact, the ACC will finally get an automatic bid of their own in a year when SMU adds lacrosse. That was announced two weeks ago but no-one here noticed. I was gonna make a thread on it but forgot.
11-14-2026 03:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #96
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-14-2026 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-14-2026 11:53 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 10:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 05:32 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 02:17 PM)NWBearcat Wrote:  Oh yeah? How is cable TV doing now?

...and this is what dates the membership offer in a way that just doesn't age well. At least UMD helped to broker JHU joining for lacrosse to help the B1G get AQ and instant near-the-top billing in the sport, for whatever sliver of a share for its worth (I guess for some BTN content). Rutgers feels like it could be just any school rounding out the bunch were it not for its location.

There were worse offers made in other conferences to incoming schools...Hofstra and Northeastern to CAA for football that both schools then dropped, CUSA doubling down in FL with both FIU and FAU, AAC with Charlotte, etc.. But, you're looking at non-major conference moves. The closest to just how "unfit" Rutgers is to its conference surroundings for a major conference may be BC in the ACC or DePaul in the Big East? Those two private schools don't have to broadcast their finances, but, I don't get the impression they're sinking in the same way Rutgers is.
Actually, both Rutgers and Maryland were needed to get the B1G that automatic lacrosse birth to attract JHU. Though you could say that Syracuse could have filled that slot just as well while having a better lacrosse team to boot. Or Virginia, setting aside that Virginia was seemingly not interested in joining the Big Ten back then.

With some of the talk out of JHU about the decision to join a conference, imagine if the ACC returned the calls? What might it have been had the B1G taken both UMD and Rutgers to then swing and miss with JHU? Who's the affiliate then?
It only takes 6 teams to get an automatic berth. We would have had one even without JHU. They were added as an affiliate, instead,because they're elite in both lacrosse and academics.

Fun fact, the ACC will finally get an automatic bid of their own in a year when SMU adds lacrosse. That was announced two weeks ago but no-one here noticed. I was gonna make a thread on it but forgot.

I don't know if the Big Ten could pull off what the ACC has been doing with just five men's teams and no AQ. Maybe get a waiver, but, there's a big difference between a conference with the likes of Duke, Virginia, UNC, Syracuse, and Notre Dame to what existed at the time with the Big Ten. Maryland and Hopkins certainly helped develop the others quickly.
11-14-2026 03:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,374
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #97
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-14-2026 03:42 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-14-2026 03:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-14-2026 11:53 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 10:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-12-2026 05:32 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  ...and this is what dates the membership offer in a way that just doesn't age well. At least UMD helped to broker JHU joining for lacrosse to help the B1G get AQ and instant near-the-top billing in the sport, for whatever sliver of a share for its worth (I guess for some BTN content). Rutgers feels like it could be just any school rounding out the bunch were it not for its location.

There were worse offers made in other conferences to incoming schools...Hofstra and Northeastern to CAA for football that both schools then dropped, CUSA doubling down in FL with both FIU and FAU, AAC with Charlotte, etc.. But, you're looking at non-major conference moves. The closest to just how "unfit" Rutgers is to its conference surroundings for a major conference may be BC in the ACC or DePaul in the Big East? Those two private schools don't have to broadcast their finances, but, I don't get the impression they're sinking in the same way Rutgers is.
Actually, both Rutgers and Maryland were needed to get the B1G that automatic lacrosse birth to attract JHU. Though you could say that Syracuse could have filled that slot just as well while having a better lacrosse team to boot. Or Virginia, setting aside that Virginia was seemingly not interested in joining the Big Ten back then.

With some of the talk out of JHU about the decision to join a conference, imagine if the ACC returned the calls? What might it have been had the B1G taken both UMD and Rutgers to then swing and miss with JHU? Who's the affiliate then?
It only takes 6 teams to get an automatic berth. We would have had one even without JHU. They were added as an affiliate, instead,because they're elite in both lacrosse and academics.

Fun fact, the ACC will finally get an automatic bid of their own in a year when SMU adds lacrosse. That was announced two weeks ago but no-one here noticed. I was gonna make a thread on it but forgot.

I don't know if the Big Ten could pull off what the ACC has been doing with just five men's teams and no AQ. Maybe get a waiver, but, there's a big difference between a conference with the likes of Duke, Virginia, UNC, Syracuse, and Notre Dame to what existed at the time with the Big Ten. Maryland and Hopkins certainly helped develop the others quickly.
While clearly less elite than the ACC schools back then its not like the Big Ten schools were bad. I think they would have been getting at least one AL a year anyway. But I say that without checking stats. The conference bid would have thus been more useful in getting an extra slot if an upset happened in the conference championship game.
11-14-2026 03:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,946
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #98
RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten?
(11-11-2026 10:52 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 10:44 AM)stechs02 Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.

I completely agree. The one thing I'll say is I wish Rutgers would find their "niche" sport and go all in trying to dominate it. Football is not in the cards for them. Maybe they could do that for men or women's basketball? Maybe volleyball or gymnastics? They don't have to win football, but they should contribute something athletically somewhere to the conference.

Rutgers women’s basketball was quite good for a long time up until the few years.

Somehow, Rutgers achieved the dubious feat of having 2 top 5 NBA Draft picks in 2025 and not only missed the NCAA Tournament, but also had a losing record overall.

I think Rutgers has tried - it’s not like they’re not spending money (as evidenced by their athletic deficits). They don’t seem to be spending money competently or efficiently.

Sure.

Rutgers is in. They are doing for the conference what they were expected to do. Anything more is gravy.
11-14-2026 05:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.