CSNbbs
is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? (/thread-1035549.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - murrdcu - 11-10-2026 08:43 PM

If whatever the new form of the bill is in the future has the same provision, how long until conferences do what was once unthinkable and kick schools out to bring new ones in?

Rutgers bringing back Schiano for at least one more season seems to be the financially prudent thing for the athletic department, and Rutgers' first priority should always be to do what's best for Rutgers. But is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? That's a question likely to come up at Big Ten headquarters, if it hasn't already, and Rutgers would be wise to close out the 2020s with a better sense of the moment.


https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/greg-schiano-is-staying-but-rutgers-bigger-problem-is-the-cost-of-keeping-up-in-the-big-ten/

We’ve entered the era of kicking schools out? SEC is fighting LSU in court over circumventing the rules while also establishing the legal right to punish or expel its members for not following the organization’s rules regardless of state laws. Three different leaders in Lincoln, Nebraska have publicly said they need to increase research and obtain AAU or risk getting left behind. Could Rutgers be facing a similar issue from a competitive and athletic spending issue now that the cable subscriptions aren’t as valuable to the conference?


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - billybobby777 - 11-10-2026 10:20 PM

I would like Rutgers to be ousted from the Big 10.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - IWokeUpLikeThis - 11-10-2026 10:21 PM

My goodness, that article looked like it was written by a high school student.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - Todor - 11-10-2026 10:24 PM

As an athletics department? Who cares.

As part of their money making strategy? Absolutely.

The Big Ten gets closer to the nations biggest market of eyeballs.

And eyeballs are only that matters to college sports.

Looking at things from any other perspective is pointless.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - ArmoredUpKnight - 11-10-2026 10:27 PM

Good luck kicking someone out. Not worth the headache


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - XLance - 11-11-2026 05:37 AM

The Rutgers/Big Ten association doesn't seem to have been profitable for Rutgers. You would have to wonder if the school could operate more profitably in another league where the cost of competition was not so great.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - goofus - 11-11-2026 08:28 AM

Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.


is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - curtis0620 - 11-11-2026 08:37 AM

(11-11-2026 05:37 AM)XLance Wrote:  The Rutgers/Big Ten association doesn't seem to have been profitable for Rutgers. You would have to wonder if the school could operate more profitably in another league where the cost of competition was not so great.


They should have brought in Pitt


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - thrill_house - 11-11-2026 08:52 AM

(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - AssKickingChicken - 11-11-2026 09:01 AM

(11-11-2026 05:37 AM)XLance Wrote:  The Rutgers/Big Ten association doesn't seem to have been profitable for Rutgers. You would have to wonder if the school could operate more profitably in another league where the cost of competition was not so great.

They would probably be better off in the American on the field but not at the bank.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - Bear Catlett - 11-11-2026 09:07 AM

Yeah I’ve never understood the “access” argument in deciding whether or not to take a certain school into a conference.

Do you need Rutgers’ approval to recruit a kid from New Jersey???


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - goofus - 11-11-2026 09:15 AM

(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

See what I mean. That only took 5 seconds and now you want to go after Iowa.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - b2b - 11-11-2026 09:16 AM

(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Wanting to keep Rutgers over Iowa. That's a wild take.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - Frank the Tank - 11-11-2026 09:23 AM

(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - bullet - 11-11-2026 09:26 AM

(11-11-2026 09:07 AM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  Yeah I’ve never understood the “access” argument in deciding whether or not to take a certain school into a conference.

Do you need Rutgers’ approval to recruit a kid from New Jersey???

You get visibility. You also get events to host with your rich alumni in NYC, which increases donations, not just to athletics.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - bullet - 11-11-2026 09:30 AM

Its like with Houston in the Big 12 after Texas left. TCU might as well have been Washington St. for the visibility they got in Houston before they joined the Big 12. UofH was essential for the Big 12. Having Rutgers in the conference increases media visibility for the Big Ten.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - Frank the Tank - 11-11-2026 09:30 AM

(11-11-2026 09:07 AM)Bear Catlett Wrote:  Yeah I’ve never understood the “access” argument in deciding whether or not to take a certain school into a conference.

Do you need Rutgers’ approval to recruit a kid from New Jersey???

The athletic recruiting angle is a little overstated, although New Jersey is a good football recruiting territory in a way that most of the Northeast as not. (See the vast difference just across the river in New York State despite NYS having over twice the population.)

However, I think the “normal” student recruiting angle is underrated. The State of New Jersey is the largest net exporter of college students to other states and these are families with higher incomes on average that can afford the higher tuition. The East Coast is quite provincial when it comes to college name brand recognition, so getting the names of schools like Purdue, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota, etc. in front of NYC market audiences for college applications is actually quite important. It’s not the *only* lever that schools have for name brand recognition, but it’s definitely part of the overall marketing package.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - thrill_house - 11-11-2026 09:54 AM

(11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.

Rutgers makes every school in this conference better. The useless eaters from the flyover states west of Interstate 69 don't, unless they're feeding wins to the Big 3 (Michigan, OSU, PSU).

They have no recruits, no television markets, and very few non-resident alums outside of Chicago (which they can get access to by playing Northwestern).

I would gladly trade the Big Ten West for a half dozen or so ACC schools. The Big Ten West schools have been propped up by their conference affiliation for a century. They all belong in the Middle 2.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - bryanw1995 - 11-11-2026 10:43 AM

(11-10-2026 10:21 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  My goodness, that article looked like it was written by a high school student.

Not many high school students would use the word "exorbitant" in a sentence. Maybe he had AI write it for him? I hear that AI is smarter than most hs students nowadays.

So much Rutgers hate from so many places these days. I'm gonna laugh when they win the B1G in the 2030s. It doesn't matter how they come up with the money for their athletics, it only matters that they do it. And a school like Rutgers can cover a while lot more than a $78m deficit.


RE: is Rutgers what's best for the Big Ten? - stechs02 - 11-11-2026 10:44 AM

(11-11-2026 09:23 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:52 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-11-2026 08:28 AM)goofus Wrote:  Sure, every Big Ten member would like to get rid of Rutgers, but they are afraid of the precedent it would set. Once you establish you can kick a school out, its only a matter of time before they go after you next.

Rutgers gives us access to NY/NJ recruits, gives our our alums in NYC a chance to see their schools play, and gives each school a much needed conference win in football.

I'd much rather keep Rutgers and kick out Iowa.

Yeah - I know people absolutely love to pile on Rutgers.

However, *someone* in every conference is going to finish last.

If the team finishing last is located in the NYC market for TV households, major recruiting territory (both for athletics and “normal” students as New Jersey is the largest out-of-state exporter of college students), and access to alums (my analysis of where Big Ten alums actually live a few years ago showed that, outside of the largest in-state markets for each respective school, NYC had a stronger concentration of alums from every Big Ten school than every Midwestern metro area except for Chicago), that’s actually exactly what you want out of your last place team.

No one has ever expected for Rutgers to be like Michigan or Ohio State. Instead, they’re in the equivalent of the Mississippi State position in the SEC. On that front, any rational conference office would take Rutgers for that position because, even in a declining cable industry, that market alone still throws off a ton of BTN revenue.

I completely agree. The one thing I'll say is I wish Rutgers would find their "niche" sport and go all in trying to dominate it. Football is not in the cards for them. Maybe they could do that for men or women's basketball? Maybe volleyball or gymnastics? They don't have to win football, but they should contribute something athletically somewhere to the conference.