(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote: (11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%
Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%
I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.
People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.
People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals
People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).
This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.
We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.
I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).
Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.
I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP field combined with a still scarce number of 12 regular season college football games.
I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.
It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.
Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.
That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.
The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level. This drives regular season interest in games even when teams are clearly in the playoff field… as simply playoff qualification in and of itself isn’t the sole goal.
The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and 25-plus teams would just play their minor league call-ups.
The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 9th or 10th place finish for a play-in spot is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.
This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.
The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.