Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFP to 24 next year
Author Message
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #141
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 09:32 AM)stever20 Wrote:  sorry but the bowl leaches are thankfully long gone. Too bad so sad.

It was always going to be straight seeding and not the conference bull**** game.

They're just going to manipulate the rankings to get the matchups they want. Rankings are subjective not objective. They did that last year when the Citrus Bowl wanted Texas vs. Michigan as their matchup and they casually moved the Longhorns ahead of Vanderbilt in a week where they didn't even play.

>Citrus Bowl has a contract where the highest-ranked Big Ten and SEC teams to miss the CFP go to that game
>November 25th comes around
>Texas is ranked 16th
>Vanderbilt is ranked 14th
>Texas beats Texas A&M 27-17 in Austin (A&M was -2.5)
>Vanderbilt beats Tennessee 45-24 in Knoxville (Tenn was -2.5)
>December 2nd comes around
>Texas is now ranked 13th
>Vanderbilt remains ranked 14th
11-10-2026 09:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bear Catlett Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 18,749
Joined: Jan 2020
Reputation: 2303
I Root For: UC
Location:
Post: #142
RE: CFP to 24 next year
Notre Dame made it a rule that if they’re ranked in the top 75 they’re guaranteed a spot.
11-10-2026 09:50 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SirSaint09 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 72
Joined: Jul 2016
Reputation: 23
I Root For: Alabama
Location:
Post: #143
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 09:23 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  I see a few problems with the suggestion of the G6 play-in tournament.

The G6 plays eight conference games before the tournament and then has a 16 team tournament on campus sites. What does everyone else do during the tournament? Do they have to throw together a four game schedule at the last minute? Same for the teams that are eliminated prior to the finals?

And a lower seed that goes on a run could only have four home games. Not good for revenue of fan involvement. You also lose a chance to play a P4 game for big bucks. You also can’t play an FCS for an easy win.

I was be fine with a G6 championship game between the top two on CCG Saturday but this idea just isn’t realistic.

It would certainly be a change but I did address the other teams in the idea. The other 54 teams that don’t make play-in would have their final 4 games set on selection day. 2 home and 2 away OOC. Schools could mostly set their schedule with opponent TBD.

The teams in play-in would have higher seed host in first round. In second round, higher seed hosts if both hosted week prior. If it’s a road team from week prior, they host to even out home games

Consolation bracket is set week to week and is scheduled to create good matchups and even out home games.

Perfect? No. But fits within the framework of the current calendar without adding games. With the P4 OOC game opportunities becoming more limited, this creates compelling G6 games and increased opportunities to build a resume for at large spots.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 09:53 AM by SirSaint09.)
11-10-2026 09:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
goofus Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,720
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 304
I Root For: Iowa
Location: chicago suburbs
Post: #144
RE: CFP to 24 next year
If I had to guess the broadcast schedule for the first 2 rounds

Round 1
Game 1: Tues 8PM EST (ABC)
Game 2: Wed 8PM EST (ESPN)
Game 3: Fri 6PM EST (Netflix)
Game 4: Fri 9PM EST (ABC)
Game 5: Sat 11AM EST (ESPN)
Game 6: Sat 2PM EST (TNT/CBS/Skydance)
Game 7: Sat 6PM EST (ABC)
Game 8: Sat 9PM EST (ESPN)

Round 2
Game 1: Thur 6PM EST (ESPN)
Game 2: Fri 3PM EST (Amazon)
Game 3: Fri 6PM EST (NBC)
Game 4: Fri 9PM EST (ABC)
Game 5: Sat 11AM EST (ABC)
Game 6: Sat 2PM EST (TNT/CBS/Skydance)
Game 7: Sat 6PM EST (ABC)
Game 8: Sat 9PM EST (ESPN)
11-10-2026 09:54 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #145
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 09:45 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:32 AM)stever20 Wrote:  sorry but the bowl leaches are thankfully long gone. Too bad so sad.

It was always going to be straight seeding and not the conference bull**** game.

They're just going to manipulate the rankings to get the matchups they want. Rankings are subjective not objective. They did that last year when the Citrus Bowl wanted Texas vs. Michigan as their matchup and they casually moved the Longhorns ahead of Vanderbilt in a week where they didn't even play.

>Citrus Bowl has a contract where the highest-ranked Big Ten and SEC teams to miss the CFP go to that game
>November 25th comes around
>Texas is ranked 16th
>Vanderbilt is ranked 14th
>Texas beats Texas A&M 27-17 in Austin (A&M was -2.5)
>Vanderbilt beats Tennessee 45-24 in Knoxville (Tenn was -2.5)
>December 2nd comes around
>Texas is now ranked 13th
>Vanderbilt remains ranked 14th

it was never going to be the conference bull**** game though.

Oh and the Citrus Bowl isn't just automatically hghest ranked teams. Just saw that 2 years ago when Alabama who was 11th went to Tampa, while South Carolina who was 15th went to the Citrus Bowl.
11-10-2026 09:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #146
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-09-2026 03:08 PM)otown Wrote:  So now everyone is down to no more than 1 G6 team on the schedule. There are 68 P4 teams outside of ND. ND eats 10 open slots. So there are only 58 open slots for P4-G6 games. However, there are 70 G6 teams. This means, there are going to be quite a few G6 teams without their yearly body bag game that brings in extra revenue.

On another note, I agree with JR, he is spot on with the boomer generation going away affecting ratings. I think the glory days of consistent huge college football ratings are in the rear view mirror.

The largest generation by population now is Millennials.

The second largest is Zoomers (Gen Z).

Life comes at ya fast. 03-wink

https://www.populationpyramids.org/gener...ted-states
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 10:53 AM by Gitanole.)
11-10-2026 09:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,567
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #147
RE: CFP to 24 next year
I could see using bowls for playoff games but unless you want to use the same bowl site more than once you’re going to be dipping pretty deep into the bowl pool to do it. The championship game isn’t considered a bowl so that would be 22 bowl games for the playoffs. What would the 22nd best bowl site be?

If you want to do all neutral sites for the early rounds just award them in advance like they do for basketball. Atlanta doesn’t have a secondary bowl so they would be a good host for the first or second round.
11-10-2026 10:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
e-parade Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
Post: #148
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-09-2026 11:27 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 11:05 PM)otown Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 10:43 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  So it will be something like this:
8 SEC
6 B10
8 B12/SEC
1 ND (even at 6-6)
1 G6

Thats a lot of bad teams in the playoff.

I got a lot of pushback when I thought the playoff was watered down with essentially top 25. There are gonna be a lot of blowouts first round........ and for what exactly?

There are blowouts now in a 12-team playoff. We will see how it plays out. The very edges of the bracket like the 9th seed versus 24th seed may have large spreads. However, even the 12th seed versus 21st seed may very well be a good matchup, particularly with the parity that we have seen. A 21st ranked team beating the 12th ranked team during the regular season is an upset, but it’s not exactly crazy.

There were blowouts in a 4 team playoff as well, including in championship games (OSU 42, Oregon 20; Clemson 44, Alabama 16; Georgia 65, TCU 7...).

The BCS National Championship game also had blowouts. USC beat Oklahoma 55-19. Florida beat Ohio State 41-14. Alabama, in back to back years, won 21-0 and then 42-14.


There will always be blowouts, and that's not a reason to keep it smaller.
11-10-2026 10:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #149
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 10:01 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  I could see using bowls for playoff games but unless you want to use the same bowl site more than once you’re going to be dipping pretty deep into the bowl pool to do it. The championship game isn’t considered a bowl so that would be 22 bowl games for the playoffs. What would the 22nd best bowl site be?

If you want to do all neutral sites for the early rounds just award them in advance like they do for basketball. Atlanta doesn’t have a secondary bowl so they would be a good host for the first or second round.

yeah sorry but that garbage is DOA- and it's already decided anyways- 1st 2 rounds are all at campus sites.. People just need to stop with the bowls bull****. That racket is gone gone long gone.
11-10-2026 10:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #150
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%

Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%

I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.

People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.

People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals

People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).

This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.

We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP field combined with a still scarce number of 12 regular season college football games.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level. This drives regular season interest in games even when teams are clearly in the playoff field… as simply playoff qualification in and of itself isn’t the sole goal.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and 25-plus teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 9th or 10th place finish for a play-in spot is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 10:39 AM by Frank the Tank.)
11-10-2026 10:32 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #151
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%

Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%

I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.

People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.

People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals

People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).

This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.

We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Yeah and I think byes are going to be worth something pretty positive now compared to with 12 teams with a lot less of a gap between games- and playing instead of a top 5-12 opponent, getting a team ranked 9-24. I do think the teams with byes going 1-7 in these 1st 2 years impacted things considerably.
11-10-2026 10:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #152
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-09-2026 09:56 PM)Alduflux Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 08:59 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 05:12 PM)goofus Wrote:  I wonder if the G6 conferences will go to some kind of flex scheduling system in the last week of the season to get their 2 best teams playing each other. This could maybe improve the ranking of their best team.

That's something I've been wondering and think all conferences (including the P4) should strongly consider. The SBC with 14 teams for example could play their 6 division games and use the last 2 games as flex to have their top 2 division teams play each other. American could look at 1-6/6 to rotate everyone and then flex 1 or 2 games (do they stay at 8 games or look to go to 9 games?) using defacto divisions for 2027, but will need to see what they do after expand settles. MWC, PAC, and CUSA probably use round robin scheduling, assuming they don't add or lose anyone, or close to it, but maybe the MWC and CUSA play X number of games and then flex a game or two. MAC is complicated currently with 13 teams, but ideally they get to an even number, though they also will be playing 9 conference games. Maybe they have an 6-8 game schedule for everyone, then play 1-3 flex game(s) that includes UCONN playing a MAC team for the 9 games, but probably needs defacto divisions for determining who hosts that weekend(s) ahead of time.

For the B12 and SEC, it's pretty simple, protect 3 rivals or go into pods of 4, rotate 4 teams or pods to create defacto divisions, then flex the final 2 games as defacto cross-division games like what was proposed for the SBC, though the SEC likely flexes after 6 games or so to ensure rivalry week games are maintained on Thanksgiving weekend. B1G I think keeps flex protect rivals annual, rotates 5 games, and then flex 2 games. I would also protect OSU-PSU and Minn-Neb. Then Iowa-Minn play each other annual + 1 flex game to guarantee their 3 rivalries are maintained annually, and the B1G also flexes their games after 6 games to ensure their rivalry week games are maintained on Thanksgiving weekend. They probably have to have defacto divisions (who plays 5 home and who plays 5 away games) for simplicity to ensure 9 teams host 1 week and the other 9 host the next week (same thing for the SEC and B12). ACC is in the same boat as the MAC that could probably have a 6-8 game schedule and then flex 1-3 game(s) that includes ND playing a flex game as part of their scheduling agreement though the 4 ACC-SEC games further complicates things unless the ACC reestablishes a rivalry weekend set of matchups like the B1G and SEC. Presumably those 8 ACC-SEC teams will have played 7 conference games in their conference while the rest sit at 6 games when the flex games are determined.

Expanding on this idea: Why do championship games have to go away? Just have it built into the regular season as game twelve. Using the B1G as an example, everyone plays four home and four road conference games. (This would move the current game 12 up to game 11 ie Mich/OSU). Then game twelve would be a flex game, with 1 vs 2 at a neutral site. Each other game would be 3 hosting 4, 5 hosting 6...etc. Considerations would be made to avoid rematches other then the championship.

The P4 CCGs lose value with expansion to 24 teams, that's why all 4 already bailed on it. G6 may opt to keep them, but it would likely come at the cost of a bye week to play their 13th game as it's been suggested by Dellenger and/or McMurphy that they would probably have to play them on Thanksgiving weekend with selection Sunday moved to after Rivalry Weekend. Maybe they would play the 1st weekend of December, but I doubt it would be allowed due to CFP logistics with getting games set with 10+ days notice.

As for using game #12 as the flex, I doubt the B1G wants to see their rivalries moved off of Thanksgiving weekend, and with using straight 1v2, 3v4, 5v6, etc., it runs the risk of teams losing their 7th home game so whatever format is used has to ensure teams keep their 7 home games, keeps everyone playing on a regular basis, and keeps rivalry week intact. That's why you'd see 7 games set (8 games for Iowa and Minnesota in my case) and flex the rest for a 9 game schedule to try to get the top teams playing each other and determine a true champion on the field. You could use the schedule format to assign the 9 teams with 5 conference home games scheduled as the home team in a defacto division and have the 9 teams with 5 conference away games in the other defacto division and assign matchups that way, but I see that as game #11 as rivalry week wouldn't be touched

I will say thinking about it my idea logistically, I could see the B1G, if implemented, set the 1st set of flex games about 13 days prior to ensure plenty of time after 5 conference games completed (9 teams can be preassigned the home game and you'd probably see Iowa-Minn played on this week to maintain their 3 annual rivals with adding OSU-PSU and Minn-Neb to protected rivalries for simplicity) and then again the following week for the 2nd set of flex games after 6 conference games completed (other 9 teams preassigned the home team), but I would prefer an extra game played before assigning flex matchups, which would only leave about 6 days notice, but since it's conference matchups and we've seen kickoffs assigned with 6 days notice by media partners, I think the 6 days notice may be possible. Obviously rivalry week would remain and be untouched.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 10:49 AM by GoBuckeyes1047.)
11-10-2026 10:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,949
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #153
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%

Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%

I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.

People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.

People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals

People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).

This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.

We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Well I would say the NCAA hasn't paid off. The tourney is very valuable, but the regular season is not. Texas had a 16,540 seat arena they built in 1977. The recently opened Moody Center seats 10,673 for basketball. Attendance has fallen as now about half the schools in the power conferences make the tourney each year. Texas isn't in the very top tier of basketball schools and has only made the final 4 three times, once since 1947, but has made the tourney 31 of the last 37 years.

I was looking at New Mexico's basketball attendance the other day. While they were regular 16 and 17k in the 70s, they have fallen to around 12k.

The season really starts in March.

Going from 16% of the power teams (11/68) to 32% (probably 22/68) is a big jump. But its still not basketball level. Last year 35 of the 68 P4 (51%) and 38 of the 79 P5 (48% counting the BE) made the tourney. Two years ago 14 of the 16 SEC teams made the tourney!

As I said before, why bet the ranch? This isn't something that can be undone. Incremental expansion as everyone else has done was logical. First 16 for a few years. See how that works and then move to 20.

They had success tripling it, but they knew 4 was hurting the sport. They needed a broader field. And its still pretty tough getting in at 12. Nobody with 3 regular season (ie not counting CCG) losses has made it yet and some 2 loss teams didn't.
11-10-2026 10:57 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #154
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 10:57 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%

Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%

I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.

People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.

People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals

People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).

This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.

We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Well I would say the NCAA hasn't paid off. The tourney is very valuable, but the regular season is not. Texas had a 16,540 seat arena they built in 1977. The recently opened Moody Center seats 10,673 for basketball. Attendance has fallen as now about half the schools in the power conferences make the tourney each year. Texas isn't in the very top tier of basketball schools and has only made the final 4 three times, once since 1947, but has made the tourney 31 of the last 37 years.

I was looking at New Mexico's basketball attendance the other day. While they were regular 16 and 17k in the 70s, they have fallen to around 12k.

The season really starts in March.

Going from 16% of the power teams (11/68) to 32% (probably 22/68) is a big jump. But its still not basketball level. Last year 35 of the 68 P4 (51%) and 38 of the 79 P5 (48% counting the BE) made the tourney. Two years ago 14 of the 16 SEC teams made the tourney!

As I said before, why bet the ranch? This isn't something that can be undone. Incremental expansion as everyone else has done was logical. First 16 for a few years. See how that works and then move to 20.

They had success tripling it, but they knew 4 was hurting the sport. They needed a broader field. And its still pretty tough getting in at 12. Nobody with 3 regular season (ie not counting CCG) losses has made it yet and some 2 loss teams didn't.

I think a lot of bb attendance is a lot of the OOC games are neutral site and not really home and homes. Looking at Texas this year- they have 1 quality home OOC game, with Memphis. They play neutral sites with Baylor and Miami, and have a tourney where they open with Georgetown. They have 7 other home OOC games and the best rated KP opponent of those 7 is East Texas A&M. at #223 in KP. That's gonna depress attendance considerably.
11-10-2026 11:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,320
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #155
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 09:26 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  Imagine you're Minnesota. You manage to go 8-4 (6-3) in the regular season, which is your best year in almost a decade. Instead of celebrating your season with a trip to Indy, or a Florida vacation, you're tasked with beating Alabama in Tuscaloosa.

I'd rather not make the playoff. I would save my school the 4-hour embarrassment. I already know I'm out-resourced. At least the players get a chance to celebrate their season in a bowl game.

There is something to having a bit more of a ladder bracket. It eases the discrepancy at the cutoff line and forces any charity bid teams to have at least 1 decent win. I do think they could go to 26 and have a mini play-in round adjacent to Army-Navy.

As a Gator fan of a team aspiring for an 8-4 finish I would absolutely relish one more chance at a National Title, even if it means traveling to Tuscaloosa with a 5% win chance.

As a fan of the sport, I think the G6 should have gotten at least 2 spots or even a commitment to an objective ranking system. They are going to expand the rankings to Top 40 and we’ll all see 5 G teams flirting with the 24 rank while only 1 makes the field.
11-10-2026 11:19 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,949
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #156
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 11:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:57 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Well I would say the NCAA hasn't paid off. The tourney is very valuable, but the regular season is not. Texas had a 16,540 seat arena they built in 1977. The recently opened Moody Center seats 10,673 for basketball. Attendance has fallen as now about half the schools in the power conferences make the tourney each year. Texas isn't in the very top tier of basketball schools and has only made the final 4 three times, once since 1947, but has made the tourney 31 of the last 37 years.

I was looking at New Mexico's basketball attendance the other day. While they were regular 16 and 17k in the 70s, they have fallen to around 12k.

The season really starts in March.

Going from 16% of the power teams (11/68) to 32% (probably 22/68) is a big jump. But its still not basketball level. Last year 35 of the 68 P4 (51%) and 38 of the 79 P5 (48% counting the BE) made the tourney. Two years ago 14 of the 16 SEC teams made the tourney!

As I said before, why bet the ranch? This isn't something that can be undone. Incremental expansion as everyone else has done was logical. First 16 for a few years. See how that works and then move to 20.

They had success tripling it, but they knew 4 was hurting the sport. They needed a broader field. And its still pretty tough getting in at 12. Nobody with 3 regular season (ie not counting CCG) losses has made it yet and some 2 loss teams didn't.

I think a lot of bb attendance is a lot of the OOC games are neutral site and not really home and homes. Looking at Texas this year- they have 1 quality home OOC game, with Memphis. They play neutral sites with Baylor and Miami, and have a tourney where they open with Georgetown. They have 7 other home OOC games and the best rated KP opponent of those 7 is East Texas A&M. at #223 in KP. That's gonna depress attendance considerably.

But regular season conference games used to matter. Now UT's peak capacity is 60% of what it was.
11-10-2026 11:22 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #157
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 10:57 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 01:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Over/under on the percentage of people online that will claim that this is destroying the sport that they love: 99%

Over/under on the percentage of those same people that will want to inject this playoff directly into their veins when they get served with 8 elimination playoff games over the course of 3 days and then another 8 games a week later: 99%

I have long stated that the powers that be care about what people *do* as opposed to what they *say*. This isn’t just a matter of college football: every single sport everywhere that has a playoff expansion gets crushed by fans online about how it’s diluting the sport, a money-grab, etc… and then they all watch it more than ever when that expanded playoff actually gets implemented.

People complained for years upon years about FIFA expanding the number of qualifying countries for this past year’s World Cup. It then became the most successful World Cup from a financial perspective ever.

People complained about the NBA Play-In Tournament… yet those games then continuously draw viewers in line with the conference finals

People complained about the NFL adding 2 more playoff teams… and then fans love when they get 6 wild card games over the course of 3 days (including a tripleheader on Sunday).

This will happen for college football, too. Oh sure - we’ve got a population of truly principled old school fans on this forum that may legitimately not watch these playoff games. But for 99% of you, if you’re telling me that you’re not watching at least *some* of 16 elimination 1st and 2nd round playoff games over the course over the course of two December weekends, I don’t believe you. You will be hooked when this playoff is a reality and no longer a hypothetical. It is inevitable.

We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Well I would say the NCAA hasn't paid off. The tourney is very valuable, but the regular season is not. Texas had a 16,540 seat arena they built in 1977. The recently opened Moody Center seats 10,673 for basketball. Attendance has fallen as now about half the schools in the power conferences make the tourney each year. Texas isn't in the very top tier of basketball schools and has only made the final 4 three times, once since 1947, but has made the tourney 31 of the last 37 years.

I was looking at New Mexico's basketball attendance the other day. While they were regular 16 and 17k in the 70s, they have fallen to around 12k.

The season really starts in March.

Going from 16% of the power teams (11/68) to 32% (probably 22/68) is a big jump. But its still not basketball level. Last year 35 of the 68 P4 (51%) and 38 of the 79 P5 (48% counting the BE) made the tourney. Two years ago 14 of the 16 SEC teams made the tourney!

As I said before, why bet the ranch? This isn't something that can be undone. Incremental expansion as everyone else has done was logical. First 16 for a few years. See how that works and then move to 20.

They had success tripling it, but they knew 4 was hurting the sport. They needed a broader field. And its still pretty tough getting in at 12. Nobody with 3 regular season (ie not counting CCG) losses has made it yet and some 2 loss teams didn't.

Sure - I think those are fair concerns.

For expanding to 16 as opposed to 24, I personally would have been perfectly fine with it.

From a TV value perspective, though, I think most people would have had a 16-team playoff as a flat straight bracket with no byes, so while that adds more playoff games, it wouldn’t have necessarily added an entirely new round. Plus, the CFP was in a bit of a bind since their contract was so favorable towards ESPN where expanding to 16 wouldn’t have created enough additional revenue and/or enough leverage to at least threaten to take the media rights to the open market (even if they didn’t choose to use that threat in the end). So, it was effectively a “go big or go home” situation - the incremental change was a sufficient enough driver for additional revenue. The value wasn’t in just adding some more games, but now having 2 rounds of the playoff in December (with the first round not conflicting with the NFL on Friday and Saturday) as opposed to just a larger first round on the current first round weekend with even more NFL conflicts compared to now (as Thursday playoff games would have happened). Under the 24-team CFP, the NFL conflicts are still happening for what will now be the second round, but the first round being free from NFL conflicts except on Thursday is where ESPN and other media networks saw a ton of additional value.

Now, the leagues probably could have kept their CCGs in a 16-team playoff, but if the top 4 didn’t have any bye at all in a 16-team playoff, then the CCGs would have truly been competitively useless (to the extent that they weren’t already).
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 11:30 AM by Frank the Tank.)
11-10-2026 11:29 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhidbeyWolf Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,603
Joined: Jul 2025
Reputation: 242
I Root For: Wolfpack
Location: Olympic Shadow
Post: #158
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-09-2026 11:08 AM)b2b Wrote:  Gross. So much to dislike about this. It's a shame the conference title games are going away. They were a lot of fun to watch.

Yeah, they are exciting, but at least there won't be more Championship game re-matches. Like AL/GA last year, which was a blowout win that was kinda expected.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 12:15 PM by WhidbeyWolf.)
11-10-2026 11:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,555
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #159
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 11:19 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:26 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  Imagine you're Minnesota. You manage to go 8-4 (6-3) in the regular season, which is your best year in almost a decade. Instead of celebrating your season with a trip to Indy, or a Florida vacation, you're tasked with beating Alabama in Tuscaloosa.

I'd rather not make the playoff. I would save my school the 4-hour embarrassment. I already know I'm out-resourced. At least the players get a chance to celebrate their season in a bowl game.

There is something to having a bit more of a ladder bracket. It eases the discrepancy at the cutoff line and forces any charity bid teams to have at least 1 decent win. I do think they could go to 26 and have a mini play-in round adjacent to Army-Navy.

As a Gator fan of a team aspiring for an 8-4 finish I would absolutely relish one more chance at a National Title, even if it means traveling to Tuscaloosa with a 5% win chance.

As a fan of the sport, I think the G6 should have gotten at least 2 spots or even a commitment to an objective ranking system. They are going to expand the rankings to Top 40 and we’ll all see 5 G teams flirting with the 24 rank while only 1 makes the field.

The other part is this notion that any fan would rather go to a consolation bowl compared to the playoff. Minnesota fans would 100% rather go to the playoff in the PP’s scenario even if it means getting waxed by Alabama. No one would rather win the NIT over getting the last NCAA Tournament bid and losing in the first round.

I always like to say that college football fans have the worst Stockholm Syndrome of any sports fans because we so many of us grew up with such a bastardized postseason and national title naming system for most of our lives that we don’t even know any better. Minnesota getting a pat on the head for a nice season with a bowl game doesn’t override the desire to make a playoff even if it means a loss. Most of us watch sports other than college football. The notion that any fan would rather have their team miss the playoffs to compete for the championship so that they can win a consolation game would be totally bonkers in every other sport, yet it’s like tie Stockholm Syndrome of the absolutely ridiculous way that we determined the national championship frankly up until the 12-team CFP has warped our brains.

As an Illinois fan, yes, I would rather make the playoff and lose by 50 to Alabama on the road in the playoff than going to the Citrus Bowl (as lovely Florida is during that time of year). This isn’t even a debate. You watch your team for a chance to win it all.

People have talked about in thread about young people and whether they watch college football. You know what is totally asinine to have to explain to a young person (as I have done with my kids)? How college football used to a determine a national champion before the CFP and even how it was done in the 4-team playoff era by committee. They will look at you like you have 5 eyeballs on your forehead. They absolutely do not get a sport that *doesn’t* have a comprehensive playoff system. And they’re right - it’s quite amazing how we spent the last 100-plus years with such a ridiculous way of determining a champion. It’s so obvious to these kids that it was stupid in a way that long-time fans are blinded by.
11-10-2026 11:45 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,949
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #160
RE: CFP to 24 next year
(11-10-2026 11:29 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:57 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:34 AM)ohio1317 Wrote:  We'll see. I am very open to being wrong (have been plenty), but my prediction is playoff ratings are great. I also predict lower ratings until at least November within a few years (it won't be year 1 most likely though). It won't be extreme and it won't be enough they backpedal, but it will be enough to see the top level games are getting less viewers. It will probably be lost in the noise of everything else (inflation, cost effectiveness of constellation of brands, changing TV market, etc), but that will also effect the next round of TV contracts for the conferences. I really think college football had a unique setup that artificially helped those games and that has been lost.

I am open to being wrong on all that, but regardless of how it effects anyone else though, I will probably be watching less. I love watching the conferences races and counting down the national title contenders. Maybe I overestimating other sports here, but, for me, I just struggle to care about the league standings in baseball, the NFL, NHL, or college basketball until late outside of my own teams, because they don't seem particularly important until late. If you are remotely good, you'll make the playoff. If two top teams are playing, it might be interesting, but only if nothing else is going on. College football is the only one I feel the need to check top scores regularly for and the limited setup is a significant part of that (although admittedly not the only part).

Well its still not quite as high as MLB or NFL and a lot less than college basketball.
It may not have hit that tipping point yet.

I think there’s a medium between the very large field of the NCAA Tournament that is also combined with a very large number of college basketball regular season games and the current 12-team CFP.

I do think a lot of fans concentrate on the total number of teams in the playoff and the binary “in or out” determination and just flatly state that certain teams like Georgia, Alabama, Ohio State, etc. will now always make the playoff and therefore their regular season games aren’t important, but aren’t taking in that there is still a clear ladder in this bracket where there are multiple races within the overall playoff race.

It’s a pretty massive deal to be in the top 8 in this playoff. That gets you a first round bye *and* a home playoff game. This still creates quite great stakes to the best regular season games between top-ranked teams - it’s not just about getting into the top 24. This is a massive benefit compared to the top teams in college basketball where there isn’t anywhere near as much of a direct advantage from regular season success beyond the pure seeding.

Similarly, the race to be in the top 16 is another level to the regular season as that gets you a home playoff game in the first round. After that, it’s all of the other teams just trying to get a playoff spot at all in the top 24.

That’s where we need to understand how our mindsets will shift and I think sports fans are actually quite good at doing this as quite literally *every* playoff expansion in *every* sport this century has been successful (even while old school fans might still complain online), even in terms of enhancing regular season interest.

The NFL regular season has that multi-tiered playoff race where there is the race to get the first round bye for the #1 seed at one level, the division races at another level, and then the wild card race at a third level.

The additional wild card team added to each league in MLB this decade has added two other dimensions to the regular season where (a) the division leaders can’t just coast into the playoffs since the 3rd ranked division winner in each league has to play the Wild Card Series as opposed to getting a first round bye and (b) the extra playoff spot in each league keeps FAR more teams in the playoff race until often the last week or even series of the season. I love baseball, but as much as people romanticize the much more limited postseason qualification standards of the past, for every great pennant race that came down to the wire, there were 10 Septembers where the entire last month of the season was useless and teams would just play their minor league call-ups.

The NBA play-in totally changed regular season incentives, too. Being in the top 6 of the conference is a massive difference since you avoid the Play-In Tournament. As a result, the top teams can’t coast after the All-Star Break at the top end, the teams in the middle part of the standings are fighting hard because the difference between being ranked 6th versus 7th is so glaring, and the bottom end is still engaged since a 10th place finish is still in reach for most teams heading into the last month of the season where they still have a shot at the playoffs.

This is the educated bet of the 24-team playoff, and once again, it’s an educated one (not a total shot in the dark) as *every* playoff expansion this century has worked in every major North American sport despite the whining of fans about “participation trophies”. Every. Single. One.

The worry from fans is constantly about how a #1 vs. #2 regular season game will become “meaningless”, but they still aren’t getting how 95% of games are totally meaningless from a national perspective by November in a way that’s radically changed by playoff expansion. This is the much greater potential upside for a far greater inventory of games. That’s the educated bet. I think it will pay off.

Well I would say the NCAA hasn't paid off. The tourney is very valuable, but the regular season is not. Texas had a 16,540 seat arena they built in 1977. The recently opened Moody Center seats 10,673 for basketball. Attendance has fallen as now about half the schools in the power conferences make the tourney each year. Texas isn't in the very top tier of basketball schools and has only made the final 4 three times, once since 1947, but has made the tourney 31 of the last 37 years.

I was looking at New Mexico's basketball attendance the other day. While they were regular 16 and 17k in the 70s, they have fallen to around 12k.

The season really starts in March.

Going from 16% of the power teams (11/68) to 32% (probably 22/68) is a big jump. But its still not basketball level. Last year 35 of the 68 P4 (51%) and 38 of the 79 P5 (48% counting the BE) made the tourney. Two years ago 14 of the 16 SEC teams made the tourney!

As I said before, why bet the ranch? This isn't something that can be undone. Incremental expansion as everyone else has done was logical. First 16 for a few years. See how that works and then move to 20.

They had success tripling it, but they knew 4 was hurting the sport. They needed a broader field. And its still pretty tough getting in at 12. Nobody with 3 regular season (ie not counting CCG) losses has made it yet and some 2 loss teams didn't.

Sure - I think those are fair concerns.

For expanding to 16 as opposed to 24, I personally would have been perfectly fine with it.

From a TV value perspective, though, I think most people would have had a 16-team playoff as a flat straight bracket with no byes, so while that adds more playoff games, it wouldn’t have necessarily added an entirely new round. Plus, the CFP was in a bit of a bind since their contract was so favorable towards ESPN where expanding to 16 wouldn’t have created enough additional revenue and/or enough leverage to at least threaten to take the media rights to the open market (even if they didn’t choose to use that threat in the end). So, it was effectively a “go big or go home” situation - the incremental change was a sufficient enough driver for additional revenue. The value wasn’t in just adding some more games, but now having 2 rounds of the playoff in December (with the first round not conflicting with the NFL on Friday and Saturday) as opposed to just a larger first round on the current first round weekend with even more NFL conflicts compared to now (as Thursday playoff games would have happened). Under the 24-team CFP, the NFL conflicts are still happening for what will now be the second round, but the first round being free from NFL conflicts except on Thursday is where ESPN and other media networks saw a ton of additional value.

Now, the leagues probably could have kept their CCGs in a 16-team playoff, but if the top 4 didn’t have any bye at all in a 16-team playoff, then the CCGs would have truly been competitively useless (to the extent that they weren’t already).

Doing nothing is always an option. They could have waited until 2032. Or go to 16 with CCGs and a minimal increase. I think it was reckless to make that decision based on a short term contract.

Maybe it will work. But it was unnecessarily risky. It simply isn't a high enough return for the risk involved.

Maybe a factor was that the Big Ten (and ACC and Big 12) saw interest in the CCGs fading (even though last year's 1 vs. 2 was huge)? I think the fan interest in the SEC CCG was as big as ever. But I do know that coaches weren't that enthused about it and the wear and tear before the playoff.
11-10-2026 11:46 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.