Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
Author Message
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #41
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 03:04 AM)Utgrizfan Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 12:01 AM)jrj84105 Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 10:43 PM)CardinalJim Wrote:  I believe who is safe and unsafe will likely take care of itself once The SEC and Big Ten start carving up The ACC.

Once that happens there will likely be serious meetings between The ACC and The Big 12. These meetings will be coordinated by their broadcast partners.

I say serious meetings because I know in Louisville’s case third party discussions have already happened. I have not heard the words “standing offer” but Pittsburgh, Virginia Tech, NC State and Louisville all have what could be described as that from The Big 12.

I am hopeful that The Big 12 has a spot for Syracuse as well.

If the 20 cap passes, I don’t think all 4 have a spot if Cal and/or Stanford are on the board. There is now a big enough western voting block to veto eastern-only expansion in the B12.

If the Big12 is smart they will avoid CAL and Stanford like the Plague, those 2 arguably did more damage in causing the PAC to lose Power status over the years by constantly refusing expansion options. They're a Cancer that deserves to wither and die off completely.

Cal and Stanford are in a weird spot. Sure, they helped kill off the Pac, but so did Utah and ASU. I think that the stink of their poor decisions in the Pac is more than countered by their otherworldly Academics and Olympics, to the point that they're improbably going to be evaluated just like everyone else. ie, how much value can your FB and mbb bring to a potential conference? Using that metric, they're pretty far down the Big 12's list, but a whole lot can happen, and I wouldn't say that they deserve to be sent out to pasture, especially when they're both spending money like crazy these days. I think that they screwed up royally, they know they did, and both are willing to spend what it takes to remain in the Power ranks. That's all that matters really.
10-27-2026 10:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Orangeman Rich Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 3
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 0
I Root For: Syracuse
Location:
Post: #42
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 09:55 AM)Blust3 Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 09:13 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:28 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Probably unsafe and lots of risk: Syracuse, Wake Forest, SMU, Boston College, West Virginia, Cincinnati & Central Florida

West Virginia will land somewhere. SMU will buy itself a landing. But four of these schools are fighting the headwinds of 1) small enrollments, 2) small or diminished fan bases, and 3) a lack of sustained national interest. In increasing order of risk:

4. Syracuse
3. Cincinnati
2. Boston College
1. Wake Forest

If P2 capped at 48 or higher, Syracuse and BC are safe as Syracuse represents New York and BC represents New England. Even the two programs have weak performance now. I think both are safer than duplicate schools in mid-sized states like Wake Forest and NC States.

Believe many miss this logic.
NY's a pretty important state from a media rights perspective.
Not to mention Syracuse's extensive history in football ('59 champs) & hoops ('03 champs).
There's a reason FSU wants them on their schedule rotation.
10-27-2026 10:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #43
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 05:51 AM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  All the talk has been about Pitt because they could make a good fit with West Virginia and Cincinnati.

But Virginia Tech and NC State would certainly prefer to move with Georgia Tech over Pitt, and Louisville might prefer that, too.

I think Pitt tends to get a little overvalued and GT a little undervalued in these discussions.

GT is a freaking ratings bonanza. Their game with Clemson pulled almost 5m last year on ESPN, and it was one of only 2 ESPN games to win the time slot over ABC and all the other OTA broadcasts on a Saturday last year. Plus, that 8-9m from the UGA-GT game is money in the bank, ESPN won't want to lose that, and they'd certainly make it one of their top 4 Big 12 picks every other year when the game is at GT. GT in an 8-9 win season is like Colorado when Deion has Shedeur and Travis Hunter posting win after win, there's no way the Big 12 would pass on that, plus a great presence in Atlanta, to go after a school like Pitt. Or just about any other ACC school for that matter. GT is the real deal.
10-27-2026 10:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #44
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 08:53 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  With the PCSA passing and even a cap of 22 in place, every school remains safe.

Why?

Because logic.

1) There is no incentive for the B1G nor SEC to expand to 22 outside perhaps the B1G brining in Carolina, Clemson, FSU, and Miami in one fell swoop and owning the SEC. This is a real threat, and I know many of you may poopoo it. The SEC really has no response to that, outside of ushering in performance based revenue sharing...

2) Performance Based Revenue Sharing. If the B1G and SEC over-expand with schools that don't increase TOTAL VALUE per university, then they are literally voting in PBRS. Nobody wants that, although at some point Ohio State, Michigan, PSU etc. may demand it, and in turn Alabama and LSU etc. will demand it as well in order to keep up. Sorry, folks.

3) Per PCSA ruling, a conference cannot lose membership below EIGHT. This—in addition to time of withdrawal and exit penalties— helps both the ACC and Monster XII stay above the threshold.

4) Memphis and even UConn are arguably better candidates in the NIL era than current ACC and Monster XII members. Yep. I said it. Look at the money pouring into those schools. Give them an A4 tag (and paycheck), and watch your back, sweetheart.

5) Existing deals are grandfathered into the PCSA. So no double secret escape hatches some of you all seem so obsessed with atop your grassy knoll under the Denver Airport on the Flat Earth.

If the 16 school SEC is properly monetized in 2034, it would get paid the same amount in total dollars as that hypothetical 22 team B1G. Assuming both conferences get their true value out of the networks in 2030 and 2034, the only way the B1G is even close to the SEC is if they add ND + one or more others, and I don't think ND is interested.
10-27-2026 10:43 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Online
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,067
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #45
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 10:43 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 08:53 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  With the PCSA passing and even a cap of 22 in place, every school remains safe.

Why?

Because logic.

1) There is no incentive for the B1G nor SEC to expand to 22 outside perhaps the B1G brining in Carolina, Clemson, FSU, and Miami in one fell swoop and owning the SEC. This is a real threat, and I know many of you may poopoo it. The SEC really has no response to that, outside of ushering in performance based revenue sharing...

2) Performance Based Revenue Sharing. If the B1G and SEC over-expand with schools that don't increase TOTAL VALUE per university, then they are literally voting in PBRS. Nobody wants that, although at some point Ohio State, Michigan, PSU etc. may demand it, and in turn Alabama and LSU etc. will demand it as well in order to keep up. Sorry, folks.

3) Per PCSA ruling, a conference cannot lose membership below EIGHT. This—in addition to time of withdrawal and exit penalties— helps both the ACC and Monster XII stay above the threshold.

4) Memphis and even UConn are arguably better candidates in the NIL era than current ACC and Monster XII members. Yep. I said it. Look at the money pouring into those schools. Give them an A4 tag (and paycheck), and watch your back, sweetheart.

5) Existing deals are grandfathered into the PCSA. So no double secret escape hatches some of you all seem so obsessed with atop your grassy knoll under the Denver Airport on the Flat Earth.

If the 16 school SEC is properly monetized in 2034, it would get paid the same amount in total dollars as that hypothetical 22 team B1G. Assuming both conferences get their true value out of the networks in 2030 and 2034, the only way the B1G is even close to the SEC is if they add ND + one or more others, and I don't think ND is interested.

Eh, IDK. The B1G getting into FLA and the Carolinas is an absolute windfall compared to any SEC response. VaTech and NC State?

But going back to your post on the Big XII (pre-Monster) inking their deal before the 4C, I think you have a point. A point which when translated to the ancient ACC deal showcases why the ACC is undervalued in total dollars and why some members are upset.

If the four amigos leave the ACC, then Louisville, VaTech, GaTech, etc. all slide up the pecking order of PBRS as well. This is often overlooked.
10-27-2026 11:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BearcatJerry Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 13,286
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 551
I Root For: UC Bearcats
Location:
Post: #46
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 10:13 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 08:59 PM)BearcatJerry Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote:  If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members

UNC, VA, ND, Miami --> Big Ten
Flor St, Clem, VT, NCSU ---> SEC
Lou, Pitt, GT, Duke, Stan, Cal ---> Big 12
Wake, Cuse, SMU, BC ---> American

If the schools in Big 12 were suddenly forced to join an existing conference

Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col, Kan, Iowa St ---> ACC
BYU, TT, Ok St, Kan St, Bay, Hou, TCU --> Pac
UCF, WV, Cincy ---> American

Yeah, about that...
There is no way Cincinnati is going back to "the American."
Zero possibility of that happening.

Yeah. If the top 6 listed above went to the ACC, the remaining 10 would either stand pat, or more likely refill from some Pac/American/UConn schools that they wanted.

People aren't getting this. The following list of schools was worth over $30m a year each to ESPN 4 years ago even though ESPN had 100% of the leverage, and media rights have only gone up since 2022:

BYU
Cincy
UH
UCF
Baylor
TCU
Texas Tech
Ok St
Ks St
Kansas
WVU
Iowa St

Take out Kansas and Iowa St from that group, and it's still worth the same on a per school basis. People seem to think that the 4c are some hot commodity, but they're no different than the other 12 in the Big 12...nobody wanted them in 2021 and 2022, so they joined the Big 12 as their only option. EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. That's bad in the sense that none of them are getting a P2 call, but it's good in the sense that every list of schools that the ACC might allegedly poach or attempt to poach from the Big 12 is different. Colorado? Utah? WVU? Cincy? TCU? Texas Tech? In fact, I bet we could run a poll of something like "what are the 6 most powerful/valuable schools in the Big 12" and every single school would get lots of votes from different people b/c there is no school that is clearly "bottom 6" in that conference.

So...you could literally use any metric you want, pick any 6 schools out of the Big 12, and they'd still rebuild/reload, UNLESS you took all 4 of the Texas schools at once. Good luck convincing the ACC to go to 5 schools in Texas unless they're also adding almost all the rest of the Big 12 while they're at it. Which, btw, is one of the most likely scenarios around the M2 in the coming years:

1. most likely - status quo or nearly so as the ACC loses 2-4 schools to the P2, nobody raids anybody else
2. full or nearly full merger of ACC and Big 12 after some schools join the P2, probably 4 ACC and 2 Big 12 departures at least gets everybody talking about combining resources.
3. a few schools leave one of the M2 for the other - least likely but not impossible

Either that, or, UC, UCF, and WVU (in the absolute worst case) stay together (like the PAC 2) and cobble together a replacement conference from whomever is available including the tops of "The American," the New PAC, etc...
10-27-2026 12:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bill dazzle Offline
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast
*

Posts: 18,670
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2038
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
Post: #47
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
I feel every current member of the Big 12 and ACC will still be a member of a very solid league once the SEC and Big Ten deliver their blows. There are at least 10 schools in the G leagues that can be called up and provide decent "reinforcements."

Obviously, if the ACC loses, say, six ... the conference won't be nearly as strong and nationally relevant. But it can remain competitive and reasonably respectable.
(This post was last modified: 10-27-2026 12:19 PM by bill dazzle.)
10-27-2026 12:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Claw Online
Legend
*

Posts: 27,563
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1566
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Orangeville HELP!
Post: #48
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
The amount of exit fees virtually guarantees the ACC will continue to exist.

The same may be true of the Big XII, but I don't remember their numbers.

Conference front offices don't dissolve themselves. They don't merge. They don't share their pie.

Whatever happens, the ACC and Big XII will continue to exist. There's too much money to walk away from either.
10-27-2026 12:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Jhawkinva Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 645
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation: 202
I Root For: Kansas
Location:
Post: #49
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
I don't think the Big 12 and ACC will both add G6 schools.

I think one will be adding from the other.
10-27-2026 03:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #50
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 03:48 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  I don't think the Big 12 and ACC will both add G6 schools.

I think one will be adding from the other.

Just look at the revenue figures and count the places.

If the upper tier forms with three conferences, which is what the OP insinuated, and if the cap is 20, you can make three strong conferences out of 60 schools.

The lowest earning school in the SEC is in 50th position.
The lowest earning school in the Big Ten is in 58th position.
The lowest earning school in the ACC is at 63rd position, Wake Forest.
The lowest earning schools are in the Big 12. They have 5 below 60th position: West Virginia at 62nd. Central Florida at 64th. Iowa State at 65th. Kansas State at 66th. And, Houston at 67th.

Now keep in mind that Central Florida and Houston are not making full shares for the last year reported. But West Virginia, Iowa State, and Kansas State are making full shares. Cincinnati without a full share for the reporting year is at 60th and should be safe.

But here's the problem. With the cap at 20 members for P conferences and with the SEC and Big Ten in position to add 4 and 2 respectively that means the ACC is subject to lose at least 5 and possibly 6 schools.

Let's say for the sake of discussion only that Duke, North Carolina, Virginia, Miami are taken. Stanford is a possible for the Big Ten but I have reservations regarding their value to FOX. I could absolutely see the Big Ten reconnecting its footprint by taking Colorado and an Arizona school. That's 15 million more in potential viewers to add to the market and it cuts down on travel overhead for their Western schools.

I'll say Duke, North Carolina and Virginia for the SEC with possibly Miami. They add academically and bolster the only part of the SEC's sports offering that needs enhancement, basketball. They also do not severely rob value from the ACC where ESPN will likely choose to sculpt a new football product out of the Big 12, possibly even splitting the cost of it with FOX getting 50% of T1 and T2 rights.

The question is what might a rebuilt ACC look like?

East:
Boston College, Louisville, Pittsburgh, Syracuse, Virginia Tech

South:
Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, N.C. State, Wake Forest (there's the rub for some unlucky Big 12 school.)

Southwest:
Baylor, Kansas, Oklahoma State, S.M.U., T.C.U.

West:
An Arizona school, Brigham Young, California, Utah, Stanford

Now if the Big Ten goes for academics and old friends and takes Cal and Stanford then the other Arizona school and Colorado go into the West for the Big 12.

On the outs? Houston, Iowa State, Kansas State, West Virginia for sure. Perhaps Cincinnati if Wake gets the wink and it becomes pure addition to the remaining ACC. Remember now South Florida outearns all of those schools and has a 55,000 enrollment.

That said Cincinnati is competing quite well on the field and those kinds of performances looking back over a fairly consistent history will count as well.

I started with the money because that's where most start, but it isn't the only factor. Geography, cultural fit, and success count.
10-27-2026 04:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #51
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 04:37 PM)JRsec Wrote:  I started with the money because that's where most start, but it isn't the only factor. Geography, cultural fit, and success count.

Cultural fit is a big deal in the SEC. They missed with Missouri, but all of the others have been reasonably good fits.

The Big Ten really missed the cultural fit issue. Nothing says Big Ten football like Rutgers-Oregon or Maryland-UCLA.
10-27-2026 05:08 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jrj84105 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,185
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 352
I Root For: Utes
Location:
Post: #52
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 04:37 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 03:48 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  I don't think the Big 12 and ACC will both add G6 schools.

I think one will be adding from the other.

Just look at the revenue figures and count the places.

If the upper tier forms with three conferences, which is what the OP insinuated, and if the cap is 20, you can make three strong conferences out of 60 schools.

The lowest earning school in the SEC is in 50th position.
The lowest earning school in the Big Ten is in 58th position.
The lowest earning school in the ACC is at 63rd position, Wake Forest.
The lowest earning schools are in the Big 12. They have 5 below 60th position: West Virginia at 62nd. Central Florida at 64th. Iowa State at 65th. Kansas State at 66th. And, Houston at 67th.

Now keep in mind that Central Florida and Houston are not making full shares for the last year reported. But West Virginia, Iowa State, and Kansas State are making full shares. Cincinnati without a full share for the reporting year is at 60th and should be safe.

But here's the problem. With the cap at 20 members for P conferences and with the SEC and Big Ten in position to add 4 and 2 respectively that means the ACC is subject to lose at least 5 and possibly 6 schools.

Let's say for the sake of discussion only that Duke, North Carolina, Virginia, Miami are taken. Stanford is a possible for the Big Ten but I have reservations regarding their value to FOX. I could absolutely see the Big Ten reconnecting its footprint by taking Colorado and an Arizona school. That's 15 million more in potential viewers to add to the market and it cuts down on travel overhead for their Western schools.

I'll say Duke, North Carolina and Virginia for the SEC with possibly Miami. They add academically and bolster the only part of the SEC's sports offering that needs enhancement, basketball. They also do not severely rob value from the ACC where ESPN will likely choose to sculpt a new football product out of the Big 12, possibly even splitting the cost of it with FOX getting 50% of T1 and T2 rights.

The question is what might a rebuilt ACC look like?

East:
Boston College, Louisville, Pittsburgh, Syracuse, Virginia Tech

South:
Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, N.C. State, Wake Forest (there's the rub for some unlucky Big 12 school.)

Southwest:
Baylor, Kansas, Oklahoma State, S.M.U., T.C.U.

West:
An Arizona school, Brigham Young, California, Utah, Stanford

Now if the Big Ten goes for academics and old friends and takes Cal and Stanford then the other Arizona school and Colorado go into the West for the Big 12.

On the outs? Houston, Iowa State, Kansas State, West Virginia for sure. Perhaps Cincinnati if Wake gets the wink and it becomes pure addition to the remaining ACC. Remember now South Florida outearns all of those schools and has a 55,000 enrollment.

That said Cincinnati is competing quite well on the field and those kinds of performances looking back over a fairly consistent history will count as well.

I started with the money because that's where most start, but it isn't the only factor. Geography, cultural fit, and success count.

The ACCN still monetizes markets, and TCU duplicates an already covered DFW market. Waco is somewhere down in the 80s market-wise, even below WVU while IRC Cincinnati is ~35 ish.

A top 10 Houston market is in well ahead of both TCU and Baylor with Cincinnati also higher on the pecking order.

TTU is spending their way into relevance, but as expected the Hateful 8 is otherwise settling to the bottom of the BXII while the newcomers are migrating to the top. The longer this takes to sort out, the more clear it will be that a BigEast/WAC “best of” is better than the B12 leftovers.
10-27-2026 05:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #53
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 05:37 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 04:37 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 03:48 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  I don't think the Big 12 and ACC will both add G6 schools.

I think one will be adding from the other.

Just look at the revenue figures and count the places.

If the upper tier forms with three conferences, which is what the OP insinuated, and if the cap is 20, you can make three strong conferences out of 60 schools.

The lowest earning school in the SEC is in 50th position.
The lowest earning school in the Big Ten is in 58th position.
The lowest earning school in the ACC is at 63rd position, Wake Forest.
The lowest earning schools are in the Big 12. They have 5 below 60th position: West Virginia at 62nd. Central Florida at 64th. Iowa State at 65th. Kansas State at 66th. And, Houston at 67th.

Now keep in mind that Central Florida and Houston are not making full shares for the last year reported. But West Virginia, Iowa State, and Kansas State are making full shares. Cincinnati without a full share for the reporting year is at 60th and should be safe.

But here's the problem. With the cap at 20 members for P conferences and with the SEC and Big Ten in position to add 4 and 2 respectively that means the ACC is subject to lose at least 5 and possibly 6 schools.

Let's say for the sake of discussion only that Duke, North Carolina, Virginia, Miami are taken. Stanford is a possible for the Big Ten but I have reservations regarding their value to FOX. I could absolutely see the Big Ten reconnecting its footprint by taking Colorado and an Arizona school. That's 15 million more in potential viewers to add to the market and it cuts down on travel overhead for their Western schools.

I'll say Duke, North Carolina and Virginia for the SEC with possibly Miami. They add academically and bolster the only part of the SEC's sports offering that needs enhancement, basketball. They also do not severely rob value from the ACC where ESPN will likely choose to sculpt a new football product out of the Big 12, possibly even splitting the cost of it with FOX getting 50% of T1 and T2 rights.

The question is what might a rebuilt ACC look like?

East:
Boston College, Louisville, Pittsburgh, Syracuse, Virginia Tech

South:
Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, N.C. State, Wake Forest (there's the rub for some unlucky Big 12 school.)

Southwest:
Baylor, Kansas, Oklahoma State, S.M.U., T.C.U.

West:
An Arizona school, Brigham Young, California, Utah, Stanford

Now if the Big Ten goes for academics and old friends and takes Cal and Stanford then the other Arizona school and Colorado go into the West for the Big 12.

On the outs? Houston, Iowa State, Kansas State, West Virginia for sure. Perhaps Cincinnati if Wake gets the wink and it becomes pure addition to the remaining ACC. Remember now South Florida outearns all of those schools and has a 55,000 enrollment.

That said Cincinnati is competing quite well on the field and those kinds of performances looking back over a fairly consistent history will count as well.

I started with the money because that's where most start, but it isn't the only factor. Geography, cultural fit, and success count.

The ACCN still monetizes markets, and TCU duplicates an already covered DFW market. Waco is somewhere down in the 80s market-wise, even below WVU while IRC Cincinnati is ~35 ish.

A top 10 Houston market is in well ahead of both TCU and Baylor with Cincinnati also higher on the pecking order.

TTU is spending their way into relevance, but as expected the Hateful 8 is otherwise settling to the bottom of the BXII while the newcomers are migrating to the top. The longer this takes to sort out, the more clear it will be that a BigEast/WAC “best of” is better than the B12 leftovers.

If you are going to look at markets that way there's no point in taking anyone but Houston. Markets don't make the difference. Earnings and ratings help tremendously. And ratings and market size are of course two entirely different things. Texas and A&M carry DFW. Baylor wins at more than one sport, is an old private university and has a following and makes money. Baylor was 51st in total revenue production, your Utes were 59th. Maybe that's why in this exercise you shy away from earning potential and talk about markets. Either way Utah is AAU, the more preferable way to access the state for institutions shying away from religious institutions, and you likely don't have much to worry about. Plus, they look pretty good on the field to me. Revenue generation ability is a key indicator of strength. But there are others and success certainly generates interest.
10-27-2026 06:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Jhawkinva Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 645
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation: 202
I Root For: Kansas
Location:
Post: #54
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
I just don't see where it makes sense for Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, etc. to keep Boston College, Wake, Syracuse, SMU, etc., unless they're willing to stay on for heavily reduced shares in perpetuity. If they are, then raiding the Big 12 makes sense.

If those schools want to be heavily subsidized, then cutting bait is really the only reasonable option.

At that point, there's options.

First off, you see what the Big 12 offers. The Big 12 can effectively remove the ACC from power conference status if they steal Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, and Louisville or NC State. This is where RedBird Capital, Monster, or some other partner could make a big move.

You can also start a league with no dead weight, going trim like the Pac-12 did. Something like this:

Florida State
Clemson
Virginia Tech
Louisville
NC State
Georgia Tech
Kansas
Arizona St
Colorado
Utah
Texas Tech
BYU


I think Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, etc. are simply tired of playing games in half empty stadiums. They don't want to play Boston College more often. They'd rather not have them on the schedule at all.

Whatever happens, the ACC's top football brands will decide it.
10-27-2026 06:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #55
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 06:42 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  I just don't see where it makes sense for Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, etc. to keep Boston College, Wake, Syracuse, SMU, etc., unless they're willing to stay on for heavily reduced shares in perpetuity. If they are, then raiding the Big 12 makes sense.

If those schools want to be heavily subsidized, then cutting bait is really the only reasonable option.

At that point, there's options.

First off, you see what the Big 12 offers. The Big 12 can effectively remove the ACC from power conference status if they steal Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, and Louisville or NC State. This is where RedBird Capital, Monster, or some other partner could make a big move.

You can also start a league with no dead weight, going trim like the Pac-12 did. Something like this:

Florida State
Clemson
Virginia Tech
Louisville
NC State
Georgia Tech
Kansas
Arizona St
Colorado
Utah
Texas Tech
BYU


I think Clemson, Florida State, Virginia Tech, etc. are simply tired of playing games in half empty stadiums. They don't want to play Boston College more often. They'd rather not have them on the schedule at all.

Whatever happens, the ACC's top football brands will decide it.

I agree. But going small lean and mean wasn't the OP's condition. The OP wanted to speculate about who gets left out. It doesn't have to be 20 members but if the conference replacing members is the ACC, and the conference being picked over is the Big 12, I don't see the ACC members leaving by notification because none of them want to pay the exit fee. They'd keep Wake Forest and the others rather than spend the money and frankly other than Wake the rest make money at a competitive level, not great, but competitive.
10-27-2026 06:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Jhawkinva Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 645
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation: 202
I Root For: Kansas
Location:
Post: #56
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
That's fair.

It makes a lot of sense to me that leagues start moving to independent in-conference scheduling in the future.

In that world, and if revenues are doled out accordingly, the ACC could find Florida State, Clemson, Virginia Tech, Louisville, Georgia Tech, NC State, etc. happier than they are now because they could just play each other while adding big cross continent games like Utah and Texas Tech.
10-27-2026 07:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #57
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-26-2026 05:32 PM)Jhawkinva Wrote:  I think the new Big 12 has one big advantage on the previous version of the Pac-12.

Pac-12 leadership was rightfully concerned their fanbases might not sign up for streaming at a significant enough rate to deliver big money incentives.

But you think Texas Tech, BYU, Kansas, Kansas State, Iowa State, West Virginia, etc. fans are just going to accept not having their teams available?

They'll drop cable and sign up for streaming to make sure their team is on the air.

They might not carry national broadcasts like a Texas or a Miami does, but they'll follow their teams.

And that’s the difference. The coasts have the money to pay for these streaming platforms, they just don’t have the interest in college sports. The PAC 12 network was a major flop. Those of us who understand the college athletics culture knew it would be. I have been around this country following college athletics my entire life. I know which areas love it and which areas don’t even know if their school is playing.
10-27-2026 07:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,372
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #58
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-27-2026 12:14 PM)BearcatJerry Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 10:13 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 08:59 PM)BearcatJerry Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote:  If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members

UNC, VA, ND, Miami --> Big Ten
Flor St, Clem, VT, NCSU ---> SEC
Lou, Pitt, GT, Duke, Stan, Cal ---> Big 12
Wake, Cuse, SMU, BC ---> American

If the schools in Big 12 were suddenly forced to join an existing conference

Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col, Kan, Iowa St ---> ACC
BYU, TT, Ok St, Kan St, Bay, Hou, TCU --> Pac
UCF, WV, Cincy ---> American

Yeah, about that...
There is no way Cincinnati is going back to "the American."
Zero possibility of that happening.

Yeah. If the top 6 listed above went to the ACC, the remaining 10 would either stand pat, or more likely refill from some Pac/American/UConn schools that they wanted.

People aren't getting this. The following list of schools was worth over $30m a year each to ESPN 4 years ago even though ESPN had 100% of the leverage, and media rights have only gone up since 2022:

BYU
Cincy
UH
UCF
Baylor
TCU
Texas Tech
Ok St
Ks St
Kansas
WVU
Iowa St

Take out Kansas and Iowa St from that group, and it's still worth the same on a per school basis. People seem to think that the 4c are some hot commodity, but they're no different than the other 12 in the Big 12...nobody wanted them in 2021 and 2022, so they joined the Big 12 as their only option. EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. That's bad in the sense that none of them are getting a P2 call, but it's good in the sense that every list of schools that the ACC might allegedly poach or attempt to poach from the Big 12 is different. Colorado? Utah? WVU? Cincy? TCU? Texas Tech? In fact, I bet we could run a poll of something like "what are the 6 most powerful/valuable schools in the Big 12" and every single school would get lots of votes from different people b/c there is no school that is clearly "bottom 6" in that conference.

So...you could literally use any metric you want, pick any 6 schools out of the Big 12, and they'd still rebuild/reload, UNLESS you took all 4 of the Texas schools at once. Good luck convincing the ACC to go to 5 schools in Texas unless they're also adding almost all the rest of the Big 12 while they're at it. Which, btw, is one of the most likely scenarios around the M2 in the coming years:

1. most likely - status quo or nearly so as the ACC loses 2-4 schools to the P2, nobody raids anybody else
2. full or nearly full merger of ACC and Big 12 after some schools join the P2, probably 4 ACC and 2 Big 12 departures at least gets everybody talking about combining resources.
3. a few schools leave one of the M2 for the other - least likely but not impossible

Either that, or, UC, UCF, and WVU (in the absolute worst case) stay together (like the PAC 2) and cobble together a replacement conference from whomever is available including the tops of "The American," the New PAC, etc...

Works for me.
10-28-2026 08:03 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jgkojak Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 992
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 47
I Root For: Kansas
Location:
Post: #59
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-26-2026 12:57 PM)BePcr07 Wrote:  What schools in each of the ACC and XII would be able to safely land a spot in a power conference? What schools would be left behind in a non-power conference?

Here's the fuller question: If the ACC disappeared (as we know it), and the only power conferences were the B1G, SEC, and XII, what ACC schools should be confident in safely joining another power conference? Same question for the XII but with the ACC retaining power status.

For the exercise, football independence and joining the B1G, SEC, ACC, XII, or Big East is considered "safe."

ACC
Safe: Clemson, Florida St, Miami, North Carolina, Notre Dame, Virginia
Unsure, Probably Safe: Duke, Georgia Tech, Louisville, North Carolina St, Pittsburgh, Stanford, Virginia Tech
Unsure, Probably Unsafe: California, Syracuse
Unsafe: Boston College, SMU, Wake Forest

XII
Safe: Arizona St, Colorado, Kansas, Utah
Unsure, Probably Safe: Arizona, Oklahoma St, Texas Tech
Unsure, Probably Unsafe: Baylor, Central Florida, Cincinnati, Houston, Iowa St, Kansas St, TCU, West Virginia
Unsafe: BYU

What do you think?

BYU is Notre Dame for Mormons and has a huge national fan base, along with a fair history of success on the field - they are safe
10-28-2026 09:07 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bill dazzle Offline
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast
*

Posts: 18,670
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2038
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
Post: #60
RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe?
(10-28-2026 09:07 AM)jgkojak Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 12:57 PM)BePcr07 Wrote:  What schools in each of the ACC and XII would be able to safely land a spot in a power conference? What schools would be left behind in a non-power conference?

Here's the fuller question: If the ACC disappeared (as we know it), and the only power conferences were the B1G, SEC, and XII, what ACC schools should be confident in safely joining another power conference? Same question for the XII but with the ACC retaining power status.

For the exercise, football independence and joining the B1G, SEC, ACC, XII, or Big East is considered "safe."

ACC
Safe: Clemson, Florida St, Miami, North Carolina, Notre Dame, Virginia
Unsure, Probably Safe: Duke, Georgia Tech, Louisville, North Carolina St, Pittsburgh, Stanford, Virginia Tech
Unsure, Probably Unsafe: California, Syracuse
Unsafe: Boston College, SMU, Wake Forest

XII
Safe: Arizona St, Colorado, Kansas, Utah
Unsure, Probably Safe: Arizona, Oklahoma St, Texas Tech
Unsure, Probably Unsafe: Baylor, Central Florida, Cincinnati, Houston, Iowa St, Kansas St, TCU, West Virginia
Unsafe: BYU

What do you think?

BYU is Notre Dame for Mormons and has a huge national fan base, along with a fair history of success on the field - they are safe

I agree.
10-28-2026 09:09 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.