![]() |
|
If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? (/thread-1034784.html) |
If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - BePcr07 - 10-26-2026 12:57 PM What schools in each of the ACC and XII would be able to safely land a spot in a power conference? What schools would be left behind in a non-power conference? Here's the fuller question: If the ACC disappeared (as we know it), and the only power conferences were the B1G, SEC, and XII, what ACC schools should be confident in safely joining another power conference? Same question for the XII but with the ACC retaining power status. For the exercise, football independence and joining the B1G, SEC, ACC, XII, or Big East is considered "safe." ACC Safe: Clemson, Florida St, Miami, North Carolina, Notre Dame, Virginia Unsure, Probably Safe: Duke, Georgia Tech, Louisville, North Carolina St, Pittsburgh, Stanford, Virginia Tech Unsure, Probably Unsafe: California, Syracuse Unsafe: Boston College, SMU, Wake Forest XII Safe: Arizona St, Colorado, Kansas, Utah Unsure, Probably Safe: Arizona, Oklahoma St, Texas Tech Unsure, Probably Unsafe: Baylor, Central Florida, Cincinnati, Houston, Iowa St, Kansas St, TCU, West Virginia Unsafe: BYU What do you think? RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - The Beaver - 10-26-2026 01:33 PM Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. Maybe the bottom two in the Big XII (Cinci and one other?) are unsafe too. But that is probably not what the OP meant. If the two were to fall apart because of internal differences and never reform due to hatred the following would likely happen. For the ACC UNC and, apparently, UVA are easy immediate adds to the SEC. FSU can claw its way in too along with one more, likely Clemson. ND can send other sports to the Big East and be fine, I don't think either P2 would continue the ACC deal with them and the Big XII is probably less interesting all-sports competition than the Big East for them, plus has no traditional football rivals to play. At that point the Big Ten might rescue two to four schools, but only with their new media contract in 2030. So for the near term that falls to the Big XII, and they're spoiled for targets! I think they take NCST, VPI, Miami and Clemson, if available, Loiusville if not. But if they can convince their media partners then Stanford, Louisville and Duke are likely all additive too, GT as well if needed for membership even-ness. That leaves BC, Pitt, Cuse, Wake, SMU and Cal stranded. Then the B1G raids them in 2030. For the XII schools its worse. Should they split up the P2 won't be interested in any of their programs at all. And the ACC itself is nearly full already. I could see one school (TTU?, Kansas?, Utah?, ASU?) jumping immediately to fix the ACC's scheduling issues but the rest would have to wait. After the ACC is raided they can refill with TTU, Kansas and the remaining 4 corners, plus UCF if necessary. For the rest its off to the big Pac in the sky. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - jrj84105 - 10-26-2026 01:51 PM (10-26-2026 01:33 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. If FOX or ESPN decided not to renew the B12’s conference, the conference would not reform as is. Same for the ACC. These schools aren’t playing and affiliating with each other for G6 money. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - AssKickingChicken - 10-26-2026 02:06 PM For the ACC, let’s say Miami, FSU, UNC, and UVA go to the SEC/Big Ten. I think Clemson and Virginia Tech would quickly join the Big XII. I think Louisville and Georgia Tech would join them to make that conference an even 20 and give the conference a solid eastern block. I think the rest would try to grab whoever they could from the AAC to get to a sustainable number. Notre Dame joins the Big East and soldiers on as a full independent. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - The Beaver - 10-26-2026 03:18 PM (10-26-2026 01:51 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:33 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. Well thats not happening, the schools aren't magically losing their value and if Fox or Disney don't take them then CBS, NBCor a streamer will. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - goofus - 10-26-2026 03:22 PM If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members UNC, VA, ND, Miami --> Big Ten Flor St, Clem, VT, NCSU ---> SEC Lou, Pitt, GT, Duke, Stan, Cal ---> Big 12 Wake, Cuse, SMU, BC ---> American If the schools in Big 12 were suddenly forced to join an existing conference Ariz, Ariz St, Utah, Col, Kan, Iowa St ---> ACC BYU, TT, Ok St, Kan St, Bay, Hou, TCU --> Pac UCF, WV, Cincy ---> American RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - Wahoowa84 - 10-26-2026 03:28 PM Safe with likely financial upgrade: Notre Dame, North Carolina, Duke, Clemson, Florida State & Miami Safe with potential inconvenience: Stanford, Virginia, NC State, Kansas, BYU, Texas Tech & TCU Probably safe but some risk: Pitt, Louisville, Virginia Tech, Cal, Georgia Tech, Arizona, Iowa State, Utah, Oklahoma State, Baylor, Arizona State, Colorado, Houston & Kansas State Probably unsafe and lots of risk: Syracuse, Wake Forest, SMU, Boston College, West Virginia, Cincinnati & Central Florida RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - jrj84105 - 10-26-2026 05:22 PM (10-26-2026 03:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:51 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:33 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. ??? That’s exactly what happened to the PAC. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - Jhawkinva - 10-26-2026 05:32 PM I think the new Big 12 has one big advantage on the previous version of the Pac-12. Pac-12 leadership was rightfully concerned their fanbases might not sign up for streaming at a significant enough rate to deliver big money incentives. But you think Texas Tech, BYU, Kansas, Kansas State, Iowa State, West Virginia, etc. fans are just going to accept not having their teams available? They'll drop cable and sign up for streaming to make sure their team is on the air. They might not carry national broadcasts like a Texas or a Miami does, but they'll follow their teams. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - The Beaver - 10-26-2026 06:31 PM (10-26-2026 05:22 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:No its not, they were raided into oblivion regardless of the fact that they could have taken a streaming deal. Unless you count the 2 or 4 team version of the Pac as a power conference, which at that point it clearly wasn't. So yeah, if the ACC somehow gets raided down to BC, Syracuse, SMU, Wake, then its what happened but that is clearly not going to happen, itself.(10-26-2026 03:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:51 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:33 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - BirdHawkEagle - 10-26-2026 06:34 PM (10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members I can't see Kansas and Kansas State separating, but Oklahoma, Oregon and Washington separated from their little brothers. I'd swap out Iowa State for Houston going to the ACC. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - The Beaver - 10-26-2026 06:46 PM (10-26-2026 06:34 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members Kansas would drop K-State like a deuce if one of the P2 came calling. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - BirdHawkEagle - 10-26-2026 06:59 PM (10-26-2026 06:46 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 06:34 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members I know. I should have implied that it was possible with my first comment. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - Blust3 - 10-26-2026 07:06 PM (10-26-2026 06:46 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 06:34 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members If North Carolina can drop NC State, so can Kansas. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - BirdHawkEagle - 10-26-2026 07:14 PM (10-26-2026 07:06 PM)Blust3 Wrote:(10-26-2026 06:46 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 06:34 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members Again, I should have implied it in my first comment. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - bryanw1995 - 10-26-2026 07:14 PM (10-26-2026 12:57 PM)BePcr07 Wrote: What schools in each of the ACC and XII would be able to safely land a spot in a power conference? What schools would be left behind in a non-power conference? BYU did pretty well as an FBS independent for over a decade, and they'd have at least ND and UConn to join them. I think that they'd be fine. You could also make a much-stronger-than-a-g6 conference with the 9 leftovers (unsafe and probably unsafe) from the Big 12, though probably not the ACC b/c of their wide dispersion and lack of history together. But, taking those "probably unsafe and unsafe" schools from the Big 12: Baylor Iowa St Ks St TCU WVU BYU UCF Cincy Houston That's basically the hateful 8, but replacing Ok St, Texas Tech and Kansas with BYU, UCF, Houston and Cincinnati. Feels like about a wash in total value and extremely close in value per school, and that hateful 8 group dismantled the storied Pac 12 a year later, or at least fed on the leftovers after the B1G was done with them. Put another way, I'm not sure how you could take the other 8 schools out of the Big 12, dump them in the ACC, and say that the new ACC (that presumably lost the cream to the P2 and reloaded with half the Big 12) was a whole lot stronger. Those 9 Big 12 leftovers would reload with some combination of Memphis, Boise, SDSU, UConn and USF, and that 10-14 school "new new NEW Big 12" would still be a Power Conference, much closer to the ACC in Power and value to networks than to any of the g6. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - goofus - 10-26-2026 07:31 PM (10-26-2026 07:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(10-26-2026 12:57 PM)BePcr07 Wrote: What schools in each of the ACC and XII would be able to safely land a spot in a power conference? What schools would be left behind in a non-power conference? I thought the purpose of this hypothetical exercise was that the leftovers cant re-form their old conference and had to find an existing conference to join. Maybe I should go read the instructions, which I kinda skimmed. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - bryanw1995 - 10-26-2026 07:34 PM (10-26-2026 01:51 PM)jrj84105 Wrote:(10-26-2026 01:33 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Well, if the conference were magically disbanded I think the schools would just reform it with all current members except Wake Forest, Cal and Stanford. Yes, even SMU make the cut. If only sports media rights were skyrocketing worldwide, and if only more companies than just Fox and ESPN were interested in purchasing said rights. Oh, wait, both of those are true. The ACC and/or the Big 12 could sign a lucrative deal with the losers of the P2 rights bidding in the 2030s. Fox and ESPN are potential bidders, sure, but also Paramount/CBS, NBC, Amazon, TNT, the CW, and probably a couple others I haven't thought of or that aren't even in existence yet. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - AssKickingChicken - 10-26-2026 08:37 PM (10-26-2026 06:46 PM)The Beaver Wrote:(10-26-2026 06:34 PM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:(10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members Anyone would if the money was right. RE: If the ACC or XII Disappeared - Schools Safe or Unsafe? - BearcatJerry - 10-26-2026 08:59 PM (10-26-2026 03:22 PM)goofus Wrote: If the schools in ACC were forced to join an existing conference as full members Yeah, about that... There is no way Cincinnati is going back to "the American." Zero possibility of that happening. |