Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Author Message
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,953
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #141
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-17-2026 03:00 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-17-2026 02:09 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 02:11 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 08:33 AM)solohawks Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 07:45 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I don’t understand the clamor for a G6-only playoff. It’s the “kids’ table” and everyone knows it. While some G6 fans have delusions of thinking that there ought to be a playoff where all G6 champs get an auto-bid (which will never happen), I’m not sure what the value is for the P4 to just snuff out even a single G6 playoff bid, particularly if there’s expansion to a 24-team playoff. There’s a massive difference between the P4 having a huge advantage over the G6 competitively versus the P4 *structurally* eliminating any G6 playoff presence entirely.

This is exactly right

A G6 playoff would not draw the dollars necessary to make it a success

Frank, solohawk,

The push for a playoff is not from the networks or really to raise a lot more money, rather its about relevance. Of the 70 non-autonomous FBS schools, only one school has a relevant post-season game. Coaches and supporters of G6 programs cite this as a growing problem for recruiting and motivation of their teams, as they are not really playing for anything. Their CCGs are pretty meaningless also, just rushed tacked on games with at most two having any relevance.

Further, all those pre-Christmas ESPN bowls G6 teams get invited to almost always are drains on the budget, forcing an emergency round of alumni fund raising. Fewer than one thousand paying supporters actually travel to these games, forcing schools --who often get a large chunk of their payout in tickets they must sell-- to open up their ticket office and spend money marketing in the bowls local area to unload tickets at discounts. Bottom line, schools tend to lose money on these bowls.

Be honest, even as an alumni, how likely are you to buys tickets to fly to Birmingham to see ECU play WMU on December 22nd? Fill in your own school and another random G6 school from another conference. It's pretty hard to sell to recruits a random pre-Christmas trip to face a random opponent as the purpose of their season.

The situation has worsened with the A4 writing rules to effectively restrict the other 70 schools to 1 CFP slot only in practice. The reality is 69 of the 70 schools won't participate. Making the CFP is less than a once in a century possibility for at least 50 of the schools, and the best odds are maybe a couple times in a decade for the very top few schools at this level. Access is nothing like March Madness, where nearly every school has made the tournament once or twice and the top mid-major teams go repeatedly, as every conference champion (important for the conferences) gets a spot. This is missing from the CFP and it is killing G6 programs.

The new 24 team CFP will also kill off the CCGs, meaningless as they have been for most G6 conferences anyway, as the playoffs will select at the start of December and need the CCG weekend for the expanded playoff, or as a rest day. That largely eliminates even the CCG as purpose for G6 schools.

In addition, the coming bowl consortium is likely to absorb nearly all remaining bowl eligible A4 schools, removing the few opportunities for crossover (A4 vs G6) bowls that actually make some money for the participating schools. The bowls simply do not work for them. Squeezing $500K from the alumni to pay for a trip to some random mid-December Tuesday Night ESPN bowl isn't attractive to the G6 schools. But that is all they have.

G6 schools look at this and are increasingly asking what is the purpose in their season? Nobody in G6 is talking about giving up the access slot or the CFP money. That is not changing. What they are looking to do is replace the bowl system for the other 69 schools not in the CFP with something more meaningful, at least for the top ten others and the conference champions. (The next twenty teams can still fill those Tuesday and Wednesday Night ESPN Bowl games)

Hosting a playoff games is logistically and financially far better for the G6 schools, even if the TV money is minimal (they will likely just replace ESPN's mid-December Saturday Bowls), as they will have reliable gate and fill the stadium, with even the travel team at least getting a guarantee. Only the Championship need be a Bowl, probably on NYD.

Frank, you need to not look at G6 as what Boise State, Tulane and a few other programs want, but what the other 60+ schools need.


Yeah, the discussion about this just feels backward to me.

#1 - This is the exact reason that all the pro sports leagues have revenue sharing, because if this happened in pro sports, you'd be killing your own business by making more and more fan bases say "there's no point to this if we cannot possibly win."

The gap between P4 and G6 isn't a cause to separate them into different divisions, it's a cry for reform and competitive balance.

#2 - It's a self-fulfilling prophesy: We would have eight or nine conferences that could compete... except ESPN consolidated the teams out of the SWC, WAC, Big East, C-USA and Pac-12 and into the Power 4.

But because ESPN reports on conferences and the national picture of college football that makes all the recruits WANT to play for the P4 and not play anywhere else. When ESPN lost the Big Ten to FOX/BTN, they went all-in on the SEC and just started telling everyone the SEC was the best.... and THEN the SEC became the best because the best recruits went to the schools ESPN told them were the best.

Sure, blame ESPN.
Final AP Poll - Top 10 appearances by conference

1991 to 2004
SEC 31
Big XII/Eight 28
- Big XII 20
- Big Eight 8
Big Ten 24
PAC 21
ACC 15
Big East 12

2005 to 2012
SEC 24
Big Ten 15
PAC 12
Big XII 10
ACC 5
Big East 5

We can also compare non-conference records.

Marshall finished in the top 10 in 1999 at 13 - 0
09-17-2026 10:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #142
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-16-2026 05:23 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 05:00 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 03:06 PM)bullet Wrote:  ...

I don't see how any of this is any different than it has been for the "G" schools since the 90s, except that one actually does get into the playoffs. It really hasn't changed since the 60s except there are more bowl opportunities.

bullet,

What you forget is there was no CFP back then, nowhere near as clear lines. I mean San Jose State hosts schools like Louisville and Wisconsin in their stadium. Winning your conference was a big deal, even if winning the PCAA just meant playing the MAC Champion Toledo or Central Michigan in Fresno (Raisen Bowl). You could end the season ranked.

The NCG and then playoff steadily eroded the value of the bowls (which also became too many, devaluing themselves that way too) turning the system into a tournament like March Madness but more exclusive. Further, the major conferences steadily increased the number of conference games. The SEC used to only play 6 of the 11 game season in conference. But now they are talking about 10 reducing the cross over against G6 to as few as one game in practice, given non-con -rivalries and the kick-off or similar bigtime challenge games. The MAC moving to 9 games, which you could see the American and Mountain West move to as well, is in reaction to the decreased opportunities to play A4 schools. An extra home conference game every other year can help financially,

All this is to say the opportunities to show case a G6 program have never been fewer. It is with that in mind, more than direct revenue, which is driving the push for a "little boy" playoff.

Yeah, the window was always smaller. But today it is tiny. Coaches notice the decline in quality of players, the drop in fan and alumni interest. And they see the lack of motivation that has crept in. All while the costs are rising. To ask for money from alumni there has to be a purpose.

Again, I ask you to look at it from the perspective of schools like Louisiana Tech, Utah State, Central Michigan, Georgia Southern, FAU, San Jose State, Miami (Oh), Ball State, Nevada and so on, who know they'll never sniff the CFP. But a G6 playoff with a dozen schools they can make every few years when the stars align. A 12-team playoff means 25 of the 70 schools will be playing for something in November, not just maybe 4 or 5. That helps attendance and interest, and at the right time of year to sell early season tickets for next year.

This is what you are not seeing. The lack of massive TV money is less important than the above.

Drop in quality of players recently is driven by unlimited transfers. But before that, its driven by all those FCS schools moving up. Half the G schools weren't in FBS 30 years ago. Some didn't even play football. I've got no sympathy for that group. For the ECUs and USMs and Colorado St.'s, yes.

Below are the G6 and when they moved into the top division per the NCAA (1946 is the first possible year).

1946 American Rice
1946 American Army
1946 American Navy
1946 American Tulane
1946 American Tulsa
1946 MWC UTEP
1946 MWC New Mexico
1946 MWC Wyoming
1946 Pac 12 Oregon State
1946 Pac 12 Washington State
1946 Pac 12 Colorado State
1946 Pac 12 Utah State
1950 MWC San Jose State
1957 MWC Air Force
1959 USA New Mexico State
1960 American Memphis
1961 MAC Miami U.
1961 MAC Ohio
1961 MAC Bowling Green
1962 MAC Western Michigan
1962 MAC Toledo
1962 MAC Kent
1963 Sun Belt Southern Mississippi
1966 American East Carolina
1969 MWC Northern Illinois
1969 Pac 12 San Diego State
1971 American Temple
1973 Pac 12 Fresno State
1974 MWC Hawaii
1974 Sun Belt W Louisiana-Lafayette
1975 MAC Central Michigan
1975 MAC Ball State
1976 MAC Eastern Michigan
1978 MWC UNLV
1987 MAC Akron
1989 Sun Belt Louisiana Tech
1992 MWC Nevada
1992 Sun Belt Arkansas State
1994 Sun Belt Louisiana-Monroe
1995 American North Texas
1996 Pac 12 Boise State
1998 Sun Belt Marshall
1999 MAC Buffalo
1999 USA Middle Tennessee
2001 American South Florida
2002 i Connecticut
2002 Sun Belt Troy State
2006 American Florida Atlantic
2006 USA Florida International
2009 USA Western Kentucky
2012 American Texas-San Antonio
2012 MAC Massachusetts
2012 Pac 12 Texas State
2012 Sun Belt South Alabama
2013 Sun Belt Georgia State
2014 Sun Belt Appalachian State
2014 Sun Belt Georgia Southern
2014 Sun Belt Old Dominion
2015 American Charlotte
1996-2014,2017 American Alabama Birmingham
2017 Sun Belt Coastal Carolina
2018 USA Liberty
2023 Sun Belt James Madison
2023 USA Jacksonville St.
2023 USA Sam Houston St.
2024 USA Kennesaw St.
2025 USA Delaware
2025 USA Missouri State
2026 MAC Sacramento St.
2026 MWC North Dakota State

So roughly half of the G6 is comprised of schools that voluntarily chose to leave a division in which they could compete for a playoff spot to move to one in which their only realistic post season goal would be to achieve an invitation to a meaningless exhibition and often unprofitable bowl game. Would creating a G6 playoff suggest that many of those schools now regret their decision to move up to FBS?
09-18-2026 07:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #143
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-18-2026 07:38 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 05:23 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 05:00 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 03:06 PM)bullet Wrote:  ...

I don't see how any of this is any different than it has been for the "G" schools since the 90s, except that one actually does get into the playoffs. It really hasn't changed since the 60s except there are more bowl opportunities.

bullet,

What you forget is there was no CFP back then, nowhere near as clear lines. I mean San Jose State hosts schools like Louisville and Wisconsin in their stadium. Winning your conference was a big deal, even if winning the PCAA just meant playing the MAC Champion Toledo or Central Michigan in Fresno (Raisen Bowl). You could end the season ranked.

The NCG and then playoff steadily eroded the value of the bowls (which also became too many, devaluing themselves that way too) turning the system into a tournament like March Madness but more exclusive. Further, the major conferences steadily increased the number of conference games. The SEC used to only play 6 of the 11 game season in conference. But now they are talking about 10 reducing the cross over against G6 to as few as one game in practice, given non-con -rivalries and the kick-off or similar bigtime challenge games. The MAC moving to 9 games, which you could see the American and Mountain West move to as well, is in reaction to the decreased opportunities to play A4 schools. An extra home conference game every other year can help financially,

All this is to say the opportunities to show case a G6 program have never been fewer. It is with that in mind, more than direct revenue, which is driving the push for a "little boy" playoff.

Yeah, the window was always smaller. But today it is tiny. Coaches notice the decline in quality of players, the drop in fan and alumni interest. And they see the lack of motivation that has crept in. All while the costs are rising. To ask for money from alumni there has to be a purpose.

Again, I ask you to look at it from the perspective of schools like Louisiana Tech, Utah State, Central Michigan, Georgia Southern, FAU, San Jose State, Miami (Oh), Ball State, Nevada and so on, who know they'll never sniff the CFP. But a G6 playoff with a dozen schools they can make every few years when the stars align. A 12-team playoff means 25 of the 70 schools will be playing for something in November, not just maybe 4 or 5. That helps attendance and interest, and at the right time of year to sell early season tickets for next year.

This is what you are not seeing. The lack of massive TV money is less important than the above.

Drop in quality of players recently is driven by unlimited transfers. But before that, its driven by all those FCS schools moving up. Half the G schools weren't in FBS 30 years ago. Some didn't even play football. I've got no sympathy for that group. For the ECUs and USMs and Colorado St.'s, yes.

Below are the G6 and when they moved into the top division per the NCAA (1946 is the first possible year).

1946 American Rice
1946 American Army
1946 American Navy
1946 American Tulane
1946 American Tulsa
1946 MWC UTEP
1946 MWC New Mexico
1946 MWC Wyoming
1946 Pac 12 Oregon State
1946 Pac 12 Washington State
1946 Pac 12 Colorado State
1946 Pac 12 Utah State
1950 MWC San Jose State
1957 MWC Air Force
1959 USA New Mexico State
1960 American Memphis
1961 MAC Miami U.
1961 MAC Ohio
1961 MAC Bowling Green
1962 MAC Western Michigan
1962 MAC Toledo
1962 MAC Kent
1963 Sun Belt Southern Mississippi
1966 American East Carolina
1969 MWC Northern Illinois
1969 Pac 12 San Diego State
1971 American Temple
1973 Pac 12 Fresno State
1974 MWC Hawaii
1974 Sun Belt W Louisiana-Lafayette
1975 MAC Central Michigan
1975 MAC Ball State
1976 MAC Eastern Michigan
1978 MWC UNLV
1987 MAC Akron
1989 Sun Belt Louisiana Tech
1992 MWC Nevada
1992 Sun Belt Arkansas State
1994 Sun Belt Louisiana-Monroe
1995 American North Texas
1996 Pac 12 Boise State
1998 Sun Belt Marshall
1999 MAC Buffalo
1999 USA Middle Tennessee
2001 American South Florida
2002 i Connecticut
2002 Sun Belt Troy State
2006 American Florida Atlantic
2006 USA Florida International
2009 USA Western Kentucky
2012 American Texas-San Antonio
2012 MAC Massachusetts
2012 Pac 12 Texas State
2012 Sun Belt South Alabama
2013 Sun Belt Georgia State
2014 Sun Belt Appalachian State
2014 Sun Belt Georgia Southern
2014 Sun Belt Old Dominion
2015 American Charlotte
1996-2014,2017 American Alabama Birmingham
2017 Sun Belt Coastal Carolina
2018 USA Liberty
2023 Sun Belt James Madison
2023 USA Jacksonville St.
2023 USA Sam Houston St.
2024 USA Kennesaw St.
2025 USA Delaware
2025 USA Missouri State
2026 MAC Sacramento St.
2026 MWC North Dakota State

So roughly half of the G6 is comprised of schools that voluntarily chose to leave a division in which they could compete for a playoff spot to move to one in which their only realistic post season goal would be to achieve an invitation to a meaningless exhibition and often unprofitable bowl game. Would creating a G6 playoff suggest that many of those schools now regret their decision to move up to FBS?

Exactly. And there were fewer bowls during the first part of that time. 20 in the last 15 years, 9 from the start of the BCS where they had zero acces, 7 others from '87 to '96. Of the 15 from before 1960, you have Tulane, then in the SEC, Army, Navy and 12 schools from Texas to the west coast.
09-18-2026 08:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,953
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #144
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

Has VPI ever won a Natty in any varsity team sport?
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 11:20 AM by GreenBison.)
09-18-2026 11:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JSchmack Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,220
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 385
I Root For: St. Bonaventure
Location:
Post: #145
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-17-2026 02:30 PM)bullet Wrote:  These schools are in the P4 because the gap in revenue was already huge from internally generated funds (even the legacy schools with small fan support have financially supportive alumni bases). Very little of that difference has to do with their current conference. Many P4 programs generate over $200 million, with 2/3 or more unrelated to conference distributions.

And half of the G schools weren't in FBS 30 years ago. Many didn't have football programs! They don't really belong in the same division. So asking for big handouts is beyond ridiculous.

To me the biggest injustice is the student fees and transfers from the academic side in large $$s to support these schools playing at a higher level than they should be. The taxpayers and students shouldn't be soaked.

There's always been a gap, but it went from a "stadium size/ticket" gap to "a TV revenue gap." So now it's exponentially larger. The TV money went from five-figures to $80m vs $5m or $1m, or less.

No one is saying that Ohio State and Youngstown State should get the same TV money. But what happened to the Big 12 and Pac-12 regarding their TV deals should show you that it's far closer to "All handouts" for everyone than merit based.

That's the self-fulfilling prophecy. People watch the games that matter. When you eliminate the stakes of other conferences, their games don't matter. The SEC is worth $3b because ESPN lost the Big Ten to Fox, so they put $1b behind the SEC and pumped them up, telling everyone how much those games matter. (Hey, if you owned their conference network, maybe your marketing firm would want to make a slogan about that!)

We got a report that without Texas and Oklahoma the rest of the Big 12 was worth barely more than the American. But ESPN gave them a fat contract because they got their hands caught in the cookie jar, so ESPN said they were worth $380m. Which left nothing in the budget for the Pac-12... so they broke up despite having more viewers in their market footprint than the Big XII did.

What each group of schools is worth is what ESPN decides their budget allocations are, because they are five 24/7 sports networks and a broadcast channel, and that's 1.5 the bandwidth of Fox, and 3x the bandwidth of NBC/CBS.
09-18-2026 04:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JSchmack Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,220
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 385
I Root For: St. Bonaventure
Location:
Post: #146
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-17-2026 03:00 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Sure, blame ESPN.
Final AP Poll - Top 10 appearances by conference

1991 to 2004
SEC 31
Big XII/Eight 28
- Big XII 20
- Big Eight 8
Big Ten 24
PAC 21
ACC 15
Big East 12

Sure, but no one is saying the "Good ol' days" were totally balanced, just that the reduction of competitive balance is by virtue of whom TV funds. And by TV, we generally mean ESPN because it's historically has been ESPN by a massive volume over FOX, NBC and CBS for programming reasons (ESPN has two cable channels to put basketball on all winter, FOX, CBS and NBC had Saturday afternoons from 1979 to the late 2000s/early 2010s. The other networks chose not to compete with them in that sphere).

The SEC is good at football and always has been. But the idea that conferences get paid "what they are worth" is a false premise.

#1 - Your 1991 to 2004 data is interesting, because if you include Texas, Texas A&M, Baylor and Texas Tech's 1991-1995 seasons with the Big 8/Big 12: They win 36-31 over the SEC in a comparison of two groups of 12 (Arkansas/South Carolina had none in 1991).

#2 - Texas, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, SMU, Houston, TCU... those guys were pretty good historically at football as well, and their conference got blown up for TV reasons.

The "last place" (on your lists) conference got blown up first (the Big East). But the Big XII nearly got blown up by ESPN while not being the last, and the Pac-12 had been ahead of ACC for decades when IT got blown up.

Everyone wants to talk about "the best conference," but at the end of the day, the "best conference" is the one that ESPN chooses to pay, or not blow up. We talk about "media markets" being important as an indicator of fan bases; The Big Ten and Pac-12 had more total people in their footprints of the states than the SEC. So when ESPN lost the Big Ten, they went all-in on the SEC.

#3 - It's all circular logic: The "schools" get the TV money because "more people watch," but the data shows more people are going to watch the more available channels (broadcast vs cable), better time slots, and of course, the stakes.

During the NCAA Tournament the stakes are equal on each day. So when factoring in channel availability (the CBS game always draws the most), it's the CLOSEST GAME that gets the eyeballs, because only the fans of the two teams are watching a 40-point game and everyone else is on upset alert.

I say "when factoring channels" because that's the most circular part: More people watch the ABC game than the ESPN2 game, simply because it's the ABC game and more TVs have ABC than ESPN2, ABC (historically) gets found by channel number first, and ABC/ESPN literally tells you the ABC game "IS the Big Game" and the one on ESPN2 matters less.

If a broadcast TV network picked a school and just put them on their marquee time slot every week for seven decades, that fan base is going to grow by a lot. If Tulsa football got the Notre Dame treatment every Saturday since 1934, THEY'D probably be in the SEC right now.

There's literally an ESPN propaganda movie about how "TV" MADE the Big East, and it's such a shame that it's dead; even though (a) if anyone killed it, it was the same ESPN that made it and (b) it's very much alive, and has won ONE-THIRD of the NCAA Men's Basketball Championships since!

The point is: We have the situation we have because of ESPN's budget decisions. There's dozens of factors and layers of nuance, but that's the simplest reduction of it. Lots of people want the configurations they want, mostly because of nostalgia. But from a logistical standpoint of having a fair sport season, this is a terrible way to administrate a sport and decide a champion.
09-18-2026 04:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #147
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
I have suggested this once before, it's not perfect, but if I'm the G6, I would consider having your own playoff and participate in the CFP too, but give the CFP G6 team(s) an opportunity to participate in the G6 playoff once eliminated from the CFP. Now this playoff won't be KISS because we won't know for sure if 1 or 2 G6 teams make the CFP (I presume 3 won't make it, but can still have a plan just in case). The G6 playoff format will be dependent on how many G6 teams make the CFP and the G6 CFP participates get an automatic bye to the semis of the G6 playoff. I have 10 teams in the G6 playoff, but open to do 12 teams with 2 play-in games (seeds 9-12 in 6+6) to cut main field to 10 teams featuring the bottom 4 at-large. I would play them Army-Navy during the 1st weekend of Dec., and allow Army and Navy a pass to avoid the G6 play-in, if used.

From here is where the fun begins, if 1 CFP G6 team, seeds 5-10 play each other with seeds 2-4 getting a bye. I'd require seeds 2-4 be conference champs, and champs 5-6 host as seeds 5-7 with top at-large, these 2 rounds are played the 2nd and 3rd weekends of December. Once you get to 3 teams left + G6 CFP team, if the G6 CFP has been eliminated prior to the QFs, it's a 4 team standard bracket, but if they make the QFs of the CFP, at this point, it becomes a 4 team ladder bracket with the lowest 2 seeds remaining playing, winner plays top seed remaining, then that winner plays the G6 CFP team and provides the G6 CFP team 2 more rounds to get eliminated or make the NCG. In the event a G6 team makes the NCG of the CFP, that team and the lone remaining team from the G6 playoff are co-national champions in the G6 regardless of the outcome of the NCG in the CFP.

In the event 2 G6 teams make the CFP (reasonable with 24 teams), both teams make the G6 semis, you can still maybe have seeds 9-12 in the play-in, then seeds 3-10 play the 2nd weekend with the top 4 G6 champs remaining hosting, then the 4 winners play the 3rd weekend, then like before, if both teams eliminated from the CFP, 4 team standard bracket, but if one or both G6 teams make the QFs of the CFP, 4 team ladder bracket.

In the unlikely scenario 3 G6 teams make the CFP (not impossible with 24 teams), this gets weird because you either end up with a 12 team ladder bracket for the entire G6 playoff with the 3 G6 CFP teams guaranteed top 3 seeds or if you have 12 teams, give the 4th seeded team a bye to the QFs and have seeds 5-12 play 2 rounds to get the field down to 6 teams and have a 6 team standand bracket from there. In either format, the QFs is pushed to near NYs hoping 3 of the 8 CFP QFs isn't G6 teams. 2 would be acceptable, but 3 becomes wild in so many ways that G6 fans would love because chaos. To eliminate this, I would prefer to cap the G6 to 2 teams max.

Having typed all of this, is any of this likely? Absolutely not, but would it offer the G6 the best of both worlds with CFP access and their own playoff to crown their champion while still offering their G6 CFP team(s) the opportunity to win their championship once eliminated from the CFP, but it will require flexibility on their format that while can be concise and clear to establish, wouldn't be KISS for the general public. Also, even if the CFP went to 24 teams, you're likely looking at either playing games on Tues. and Wed. in doubleheaders or looking at opening for the CFP during the weeknights with 4-5 PM EST kicks Tues.-Fri. as best case scenarios and potentially the P4 pushing harder to remove the G6 from the CFP, which the P4 controls.

One other solution that would be more reasonable would be to allow the P4 to conduct their own 6-8 team conference tourney while the G6 plays their own 7-8 team playoff all in December to declare their champion and then the CFP down to 8-10 teams starting on New Years (maybe 2 play-ins in bowls near Christmas) takes the top 4-5 tourney champs and 4-5 top at-larges for the national playoff. It would be a little tight between the 3rd weekend of December and New Years to try to squeeze in 2 play-in games, but that may be better for the G6 overall as all of their champs have a better path to the CFP.
09-19-2026 07:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #148
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-18-2026 04:31 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(09-17-2026 03:00 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Sure, blame ESPN.
Final AP Poll - Top 10 appearances by conference

1991 to 2004
SEC 31
Big XII/Eight 28
- Big XII 20
- Big Eight 8
Big Ten 24
PAC 21
ACC 15
Big East 12

Sure, but no one is saying the "Good ol' days" were totally balanced, just that the reduction of competitive balance is by virtue of whom TV funds. And by TV, we generally mean ESPN because it's historically has been ESPN by a massive volume over FOX, NBC and CBS for programming reasons (ESPN has two cable channels to put basketball on all winter, FOX, CBS and NBC had Saturday afternoons from 1979 to the late 2000s/early 2010s. The other networks chose not to compete with them in that sphere).

The SEC is good at football and always has been. But the idea that conferences get paid "what they are worth" is a false premise.

#1 - Your 1991 to 2004 data is interesting, because if you include Texas, Texas A&M, Baylor and Texas Tech's 1991-1995 seasons with the Big 8/Big 12: They win 36-31 over the SEC in a comparison of two groups of 12 (Arkansas/South Carolina had none in 1991).

#2 - Texas, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, SMU, Houston, TCU... those guys were pretty good historically at football as well, and their conference got blown up for TV reasons.

The "last place" (on your lists) conference got blown up first (the Big East). But the Big XII nearly got blown up by ESPN while not being the last, and the Pac-12 had been ahead of ACC for decades when IT got blown up.

Everyone wants to talk about "the best conference," but at the end of the day, the "best conference" is the one that ESPN chooses to pay, or not blow up. We talk about "media markets" being important as an indicator of fan bases; The Big Ten and Pac-12 had more total people in their footprints of the states than the SEC. So when ESPN lost the Big Ten, they went all-in on the SEC.

#3 - It's all circular logic: The "schools" get the TV money because "more people watch," but the data shows more people are going to watch the more available channels (broadcast vs cable), better time slots, and of course, the stakes.

During the NCAA Tournament the stakes are equal on each day. So when factoring in channel availability (the CBS game always draws the most), it's the CLOSEST GAME that gets the eyeballs, because only the fans of the two teams are watching a 40-point game and everyone else is on upset alert.

I say "when factoring channels" because that's the most circular part: More people watch the ABC game than the ESPN2 game, simply because it's the ABC game and more TVs have ABC than ESPN2, ABC (historically) gets found by channel number first, and ABC/ESPN literally tells you the ABC game "IS the Big Game" and the one on ESPN2 matters less.

If a broadcast TV network picked a school and just put them on their marquee time slot every week for seven decades, that fan base is going to grow by a lot. If Tulsa football got the Notre Dame treatment every Saturday since 1934, THEY'D probably be in the SEC right now.

There's literally an ESPN propaganda movie about how "TV" MADE the Big East, and it's such a shame that it's dead; even though (a) if anyone killed it, it was the same ESPN that made it and (b) it's very much alive, and has won ONE-THIRD of the NCAA Men's Basketball Championships since!

The point is: We have the situation we have because of ESPN's budget decisions. There's dozens of factors and layers of nuance, but that's the simplest reduction of it. Lots of people want the configurations they want, mostly because of nostalgia. But from a logistical standpoint of having a fair sport season, this is a terrible way to administrate a sport and decide a champion.

You have your logic backwards.

TV shows them because people watch. They didn't create the college football brands. Those developed long before ESPN existed.

Now, TV does promote the things they have on, so that increases existing gaps. The 4 team playoff REALLY promoted the few schools who kept getting in, much to the detriment of the rest of college football. That was a factor in the breakup of the PAC 12.

And schools have always moved towards more favorable conference lineups. The Big 8 schools left the Missouri Valley in 1928. The SEC schools left the Southern Conference in 1933. The ACC schools left the Southern Conference in 1953. ESPN doesn't tell schools where to go. Now ESPN and Fox do have some limited veto power over who conferences can add. But that is based on who people watch. They are in this to make money.
09-19-2026 08:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
wmubroncopilot Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,962
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 150
I Root For: WMU
Location: Anchorage, AK
Post: #149
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
I don’t really see the point of a full G6 playoff. The winner is the champion of.. what exactly?

I’d rather see an effort made to ensure G6 champions play each other in bowl games.
09-19-2026 08:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,609
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #150
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-18-2026 04:31 PM)JSchmack Wrote:  
(09-17-2026 03:00 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Sure, blame ESPN.
Final AP Poll - Top 10 appearances by conference

1991 to 2004
SEC 31
Big XII/Eight 28
- Big XII 20
- Big Eight 8
Big Ten 24
PAC 21
ACC 15
Big East 12

Sure, but no one is saying the "Good ol' days" were totally balanced, just that the reduction of competitive balance is by virtue of whom TV funds. And by TV, we generally mean ESPN because it's historically has been ESPN by a massive volume over FOX, NBC and CBS for programming reasons (ESPN has two cable channels to put basketball on all winter, FOX, CBS and NBC had Saturday afternoons from 1979 to the late 2000s/early 2010s. The other networks chose not to compete with them in that sphere).

The SEC is good at football and always has been. But the idea that conferences get paid "what they are worth" is a false premise.

#1 - Your 1991 to 2004 data is interesting, because if you include Texas, Texas A&M, Baylor and Texas Tech's 1991-1995 seasons with the Big 8/Big 12: They win 36-31 over the SEC in a comparison of two groups of 12 (Arkansas/South Carolina had none in 1991).

#2 - Texas, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, SMU, Houston, TCU... those guys were pretty good historically at football as well, and their conference got blown up for TV reasons.

The "last place" (on your lists) conference got blown up first (the Big East). But the Big XII nearly got blown up by ESPN while not being the last, and the Pac-12 had been ahead of ACC for decades when IT got blown up.

Everyone wants to talk about "the best conference," but at the end of the day, the "best conference" is the one that ESPN chooses to pay, or not blow up. We talk about "media markets" being important as an indicator of fan bases; The Big Ten and Pac-12 had more total people in their footprints of the states than the SEC. So when ESPN lost the Big Ten, they went all-in on the SEC.

#3 - It's all circular logic: The "schools" get the TV money because "more people watch," but the data shows more people are going to watch the more available channels (broadcast vs cable), better time slots, and of course, the stakes.

During the NCAA Tournament the stakes are equal on each day. So when factoring in channel availability (the CBS game always draws the most), it's the CLOSEST GAME that gets the eyeballs, because only the fans of the two teams are watching a 40-point game and everyone else is on upset alert.

I say "when factoring channels" because that's the most circular part: More people watch the ABC game than the ESPN2 game, simply because it's the ABC game and more TVs have ABC than ESPN2, ABC (historically) gets found by channel number first, and ABC/ESPN literally tells you the ABC game "IS the Big Game" and the one on ESPN2 matters less.

If a broadcast TV network picked a school and just put them on their marquee time slot every week for seven decades, that fan base is going to grow by a lot. If Tulsa football got the Notre Dame treatment every Saturday since 1934, THEY'D probably be in the SEC right now.

There's literally an ESPN propaganda movie about how "TV" MADE the Big East, and it's such a shame that it's dead; even though (a) if anyone killed it, it was the same ESPN that made it and (b) it's very much alive, and has won ONE-THIRD of the NCAA Men's Basketball Championships since!

The point is: We have the situation we have because of ESPN's budget decisions. There's dozens of factors and layers of nuance, but that's the simplest reduction of it. Lots of people want the configurations they want, mostly because of nostalgia. But from a logistical standpoint of having a fair sport season, this is a terrible way to administrate a sport and decide a champion.

Just noticed I made a mistake, the AP poll data is from 1990 to 2004. Houston was top 10 in 1990 and A&M had 3 top 10 rankings before they joined the Big XII.

The other numbers we can look at are non-conference records to determine overall conference strength and not just the top 2-3 programs. These numbers show that the SWC was just not that strong. I also have the numbers going back to 1978 and they are very similar (37-38%) In basketball the SWC averaged only 2.1 bids per year from 1985 to 1996. It was a one bid league THREE times. The average was worse than the A-10, Metro and WAC in that same time span.

These are from 1991-2004.

Major/power conference non-conference

Conference - Record - Winning%
SEC 130-103-1 .558
Big Ten 177-156-4 .531
ACC 142-139-2 .505
Big Eight 51-50-3 .505
PAC 121-121-2 .500
Big XII 73-85 .462
Big East 116-165-1 .413
SWC 35-67-3 .348

Notre Dame 84-54-1 .608

Power vs non-power

Conference - Record - Winning%

Big Eight 51-9-1 .844
SEC 285-58-1 .830
Big Ten 191-43-1 .815
Big XII 182-44 .805
PAC 199-58-1 .773
ACC 115-35-1 .765
Big East 180-66-1 .731
SWC 42-17-2 .705

Notre Dame 26-3 .897

It all comes down to whether you believe the media can create brands or if they are created on the field or basketball court first.
09-19-2026 10:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #151
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
The P4 are now 71-2 against G6 teams, and 50-0 against FCS. The G6 are 60-6 against FCS teams. That sure looks like 3 (sub)divisions to me.
09-27-2026 02:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #152
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-27-2026 02:56 PM)ken d Wrote:  The P4 are now 71-2 against G6 teams, and 50-0 against FCS. The G6 are 60-6 against FCS teams. That sure looks like 3 (sub)divisions to me.

Yes, but reality and the truth are seldom popular these days. We are living in a time where video game fantasy surpasses sporting intent, and where regardless of the size, funding, or even the win/loss record everyone gets to play. 07-coffee3
09-27-2026 03:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.