(09-17-2026 03:00 PM)PicksUp Wrote: Sure, blame ESPN.
Final AP Poll - Top 10 appearances by conference
1991 to 2004
SEC 31
Big XII/Eight 28
- Big XII 20
- Big Eight 8
Big Ten 24
PAC 21
ACC 15
Big East 12
Sure, but no one is saying the "Good ol' days" were totally balanced, just that the reduction of competitive balance is by virtue of whom TV funds. And by TV, we generally mean ESPN because it's historically has been ESPN by a massive volume over FOX, NBC and CBS for programming reasons (ESPN has two cable channels to put basketball on all winter, FOX, CBS and NBC had Saturday afternoons from 1979 to the late 2000s/early 2010s. The other networks chose not to compete with them in that sphere).
The SEC is good at football and always has been. But the idea that conferences get paid "what they are worth" is a false premise.
#1 - Your 1991 to 2004 data is interesting, because if you include Texas, Texas A&M, Baylor and Texas Tech's 1991-1995 seasons with the Big 8/Big 12: They win 36-31 over the SEC in a comparison of two groups of 12 (Arkansas/South Carolina had none in 1991).
#2 - Texas, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, SMU, Houston, TCU... those guys were pretty good historically at football as well, and their conference got blown up for TV reasons.
The "last place" (on your lists) conference got blown up first (the Big East). But the Big XII nearly got blown up by ESPN while not being the last, and the Pac-12 had been ahead of ACC for decades when IT got blown up.
Everyone wants to talk about "the best conference," but at the end of the day, the "best conference" is the one that ESPN chooses to pay, or not blow up. We talk about "media markets" being important as an indicator of fan bases; The Big Ten and Pac-12 had more total people in their footprints of the states than the SEC. So when ESPN lost the Big Ten, they went all-in on the SEC.
#3 - It's all circular logic: The "schools" get the TV money because "more people watch," but the data shows more people are going to watch the more available channels (broadcast vs cable), better time slots, and of course, the stakes.
During the NCAA Tournament the stakes are equal on each day. So when factoring in channel availability (the CBS game always draws the most), it's the CLOSEST GAME that gets the eyeballs, because only the fans of the two teams are watching a 40-point game and everyone else is on upset alert.
I say "when factoring channels" because that's the most circular part: More people watch the ABC game than the ESPN2 game, simply because it's the ABC game and more TVs have ABC than ESPN2, ABC (historically) gets found by channel number first, and ABC/ESPN literally tells you the ABC game "IS the Big Game" and the one on ESPN2 matters less.
If a broadcast TV network picked a school and just put them on their marquee time slot every week for seven decades, that fan base is going to grow by a lot. If Tulsa football got the Notre Dame treatment every Saturday since 1934, THEY'D probably be in the SEC right now.
There's literally an ESPN propaganda movie about how "TV" MADE the Big East, and it's such a shame that it's dead; even though (a) if anyone killed it, it was the same ESPN that made it and (b) it's very much alive, and has won ONE-THIRD of the NCAA Men's Basketball Championships since!
The point is: We have the situation we have because of ESPN's budget decisions. There's dozens of factors and layers of nuance, but that's the simplest reduction of it. Lots of people want the configurations they want, mostly because of nostalgia. But from a logistical standpoint of having a fair sport season, this is a terrible way to administrate a sport and decide a champion.