Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Author Message
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #81
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:23 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:51 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:10 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 03:02 PM)Akiraptor Wrote:  There's a clear divide between about half of the P4 and the G6, but there's very little difference in quality between the lower half of the P4 and the upper echelon of G6 schools. I would argue that those numbers in the OP are skewed in favor of the P4 because most mid-to-lower P4s won't schedule the better G6 teams. There's no benefit for them to do so. They've everything to lose and nothing to gain.

Also, a G6 playoff is a complete nonstarter unless a super league of the top 30 or so schools forms and everyone not in that league is included in the "G6."

Historically the bottom 12 P4 programs and top 12 G6 were relatively even on the FB field but its different now with the massively larger conference payouts in the P4 and revenue sharing.

Before you could move up to a better revenue conference, use the money to level up your coaching staffs and keep the train rolling forward. Today you can move up and struggle as one of the poorest schools in the P4.

The are definitely not 12 schools sitting in the G6 with deep pockets for P4 NIL. I do not understand why JRsec thinks that 12 schools do. I believe its because he doesn't realize that nobody in the G6 can really afford it. UConn and Memphis could survive if they had the invite but no impetus for another 10 schools. The deep pockets just are not there.
Oh I fully realize it. I post the data on it annually. But there are more than just Boise State. South Florida, San Diego State, perhaps Colorado State, Oregon State and Washington State could make the jump. Perhaps you need to improve your reading skills. I said for all 4 P conferences to move to 20. That's 2 for the Big Ten, 4 for the SEC and those six will be backfilled most likely by the ACC. Those being promoted up with the possible exception of USF would likely go to the Big 12 and would be paid Big 12 money. Could you find 12 if you leveled up their revenue even if the Big 12 payouts dropped 5 million it would be a lot more than a G6 school had been making at 28 million. I suggested 20 for round numbers and equal representation and equl chance of making the national semifinals, as I had it set up.

If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.

Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout

Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.

As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.

The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.

I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.

SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)

ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.

Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.

ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)

Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.
Wrong assumption. I look at total revenue and with the G6 the % of subsidy each school gets, and they all get at least 25%. I look at attendance, record, and whether or not the school is growing or is in a growing area. I also consider whether the state they are located in (if they are a state school) is able to continue its support or whether that state has budegtary issues. The great divide has always existed. It is greater now because the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 earners from the PAC 12 (leaving out only Stanford whose best metric was revenue). The SEC took 54% of the remaining Big 12 value with just Texas and Oklahoma. Those moves created what many here call the P2 and M2 which is also a divide. That was by the design of the networks who are pursuing the best brands playing each other more often and "best" doesn't necessarily mean winning. It does by necessity mean the ability to draw large audiences for their contests.

There is absolutely a divide in the G6 programs when it comes to earnings the difference doesn't appear to be that great. When it comes to subsidy then about the top 1/4th of the G6 schools can hang in with 25% to 35% subsidy range. The rest cannot. The more subsidy a school has the less they can afford to buy or retain top players in this new pay for play world.

What I'm suggesting is that if there are 12 schools in that top 25% of the G6 who want a chance to move up the best solution is found in allowing the SEC and Big Ten to grow to 20 each and the ACC to grow or backfill to the same. The 4th conference then picks up the rest. But included in the P4 that gives them access to the postseason and permits games between them and other P4 schools from the other 3 conferences. If a promoted G6 can't make it then you look to backfill, or perhaps to gradually reduce the number of teams from 20 to 18 or 16 for that 4th conference depending upon profitability and market penetration based on who the replacements might be versus the collection of schools left in the conference.

Generated Revenue, level of donation, gate & concessions, post season money leading to that gross revenue figure minus overhead and considering the unreliable nature of subsidy during a time of economic downturn, and a big one is looming in 5-10 years, are the indicators of health. The less subsidized the better the long-range outlook.

Conduct your business wisely and you have a shot. Don't and there is no margin for error because you aren't and won't be earning what the SEC, Big Ten, or ACC will be earning and you need to be strong enough to pay your own way in the Big 12. So, you have to be smart businesswise, and free of as much subsidy dependence as possible, and then you have be good enough to draw interest, which is easier the larger the state is. It's a tall order but that's why I tossed out the schools I mentioned. Two of them have succeeded on less in the P5. Some are growing and in growing regions of growing states. Some like Boise just punch above their weight class with success.

I believe you could find 12 schools from the G6 that would stand a reasonable chance of success in the 4th conference of the P4. That's a concession. I think the networks would prefer around 60, but might see some promise in having the extra inventory.

I'd rather the schools be in control of their post seasons in all revenue sports because there are better percentages in doing so. I simply believe the basketball tournament could pay out full shares every year instead of dividing them over six, and that invitations beyond the member conferences are in order for the best teams in that particular year.

Football absolutely needs to be expanded in the post season inside each conference. Division champs make sense because if you have 4 of them then every school in the conference has a 1 in 5 chance of making some form of the postseason and all of that generated revenue from those first two games stays with the conference and its schools. I don't want the playoff doling out money to the participants. I want to see all of the CFP revenue divided in shares for the participants and the remainder divided between the 4 conferences. And I would dearly love to see the whole matter decided on the field in 16 games total for a season for the two finalists and all of it done with no committees.
(This post was last modified: 09-14-2026 11:55 PM by JRsec.)
09-14-2026 11:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #82
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:47 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:23 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:51 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:10 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 03:02 PM)Akiraptor Wrote:  There's a clear divide between about half of the P4 and the G6, but there's very little difference in quality between the lower half of the P4 and the upper echelon of G6 schools. I would argue that those numbers in the OP are skewed in favor of the P4 because most mid-to-lower P4s won't schedule the better G6 teams. There's no benefit for them to do so. They've everything to lose and nothing to gain.

Also, a G6 playoff is a complete nonstarter unless a super league of the top 30 or so schools forms and everyone not in that league is included in the "G6."

Historically the bottom 12 P4 programs and top 12 G6 were relatively even on the FB field but its different now with the massively larger conference payouts in the P4 and revenue sharing.

Before you could move up to a better revenue conference, use the money to level up your coaching staffs and keep the train rolling forward. Today you can move up and struggle as one of the poorest schools in the P4.

The are definitely not 12 schools sitting in the G6 with deep pockets for P4 NIL. I do not understand why JRsec thinks that 12 schools do. I believe its because he doesn't realize that nobody in the G6 can really afford it. UConn and Memphis could survive if they had the invite but no impetus for another 10 schools. The deep pockets just are not there.
Oh I fully realize it. I post the data on it annually. But there are more than just Boise State. South Florida, San Diego State, perhaps Colorado State, Oregon State and Washington State could make the jump. Perhaps you need to improve your reading skills. I said for all 4 P conferences to move to 20. That's 2 for the Big Ten, 4 for the SEC and those six will be backfilled most likely by the ACC. Those being promoted up with the possible exception of USF would likely go to the Big 12 and would be paid Big 12 money. Could you find 12 if you leveled up their revenue even if the Big 12 payouts dropped 5 million it would be a lot more than a G6 school had been making at 28 million. I suggested 20 for round numbers and equal representation and equl chance of making the national semifinals, as I had it set up.

If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.

Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout

Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.

As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.

The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.

I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.

SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)

ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.

Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.

ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)

Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.
Wrong assumption. I look at total revenue and with the G6 the % of subsidy each school gets, and they all get at least 25%. I look at attendance, record, and whether or not the school is growing or is in a growing area. I also consider whether the state they are located in (if they are a state school) is able to continue its support or whether that state has budegtary issues. The great divide has always existed. It is greater now because the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 earners from the PAC 12 (leaving out only Stanford whose best metric was revenue). The SEC took 54% of the remaining Big 12 value with just Texas and Oklahoma. Those moves created what many here call the P2 and M2 which is also a divide. That was by the design of the networks who are pursuing the best brands playing each other more often and "best" doesn't necessarily mean winning. It does by necessity mean the ability to draw large audiences for their contests.

There is absolutely a divide in the G6 programs when it comes to earnings the difference doesn't appear to be that great. When it comes to subsidy then about the top 1/4th of the G6 schools can hang in with 25% to 35% subsidy range. The rest cannot. The more subsidy a school has the less they can afford to buy or retain top players in this new pay for play world.

What I'm suggesting is that if there are 12 schools in that top 25% of the G6 who want a chance to move up the best solution is found in allowing the SEC and Big Ten to grow to 20 each and the ACC to grow or backfill to the same. The 4th conference then picks up the rest. But included in the P4 that gives them access to the postseason and permits games between them and other P4 schools from the other 3 conferences. If a promoted G6 can't make it then you look to backfill, or perhaps to gradually reduce the number of teams from 20 to 18 or 16 for that 4th conference depending upon profitability and market penetration based on who the replacements might be versus the collection of schools left in the conference.

Generated Revenue, level of donation, gate & concessions, post season money leading to that gross revenue figure minus overhead and considering the unreliable nature of subsidy during a time of economic downturn, and a big one is looming in 5-10 years, are the indicators of health. The less subsidized the better the long-range outlook.

Conduct your business wisely and you have a shot. Don't and there is no margin for error because you aren't and won't be earning what the SEC, Big Ten, or ACC will be earning and you need to be strong enough to pay your own way in the Big 12. So, you have to be smart businesswise, and free of as much subsidy dependence as possible, and then you have be good enough to draw interest, which is easier the larger the state is. It's a tall order but that's why I tossed out the schools I mentioned. Two of them have succeeded on less in the P5. Some are growing and in growing regions of growing states. Some like Boise just punch above their weight class with success.

The percent subsidy of a mythical budget doesn't mean as much as the overall size institutional/student fee subsidy. Those with the largest budgets in the G6 have them because they are reporting largest subsidies. They have the largest amount of athletic debt on the books. It pumps up the budget.

I do not understand how someone who is a serious Auburn fan does not understand that SEC FB is logrithimic level above in support than what James Madison or East Carolina have regardless of nice FB stadiums and good attendance. Its not just a nudge of difference. A painted logo on the field.
09-14-2026 11:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
toddjnsn Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 12,953
Joined: Sep 2009
Reputation: 167
I Root For: WMU, MAC
Location: Grand Rapids, MI
Post: #83
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
IMO, and it seems obvious to me, an official Division class of college ball shouldn't have it where it's really two Divisions in what's done & $$$, but said differently. There already already IS another D1 division class, so I agree, to make them 3 if you're falsely treating the Top 1 all the same when within that, it's clearly different.

The only exception (that I'd still have my complaints about, but better than now) -- would be to have bigger play-off with all conference champions with an auto-bid if they've got at least 9W+ over FBS teams after conf-championship (wins on very easily ranked FCS teams at end-of-reg season may count upon assessment). So instead of getting 1 G6 team in there, it'd usually be 1 or 2 not going. To "make up" for that putting playoff-$$ for NCAA aside but for the sport, would be to expand it to 16 teams not 12 -- but have the 2nd-half of 16 teams play each other, then the remaining 4 play the 2nd-best 4 for next round, then 8-team playoff where the Top 4 would play 2nd round winners. Or I guess you could expand it to 24 where nobody gets a bye and the Top 4 get an "easy game" (last year they'd get Duke, Kennesaw St, W-Michigan, and Boise St).

CONFERENCE CHAMPS IMMEDIATELY AFTER CC GAME (discounting non-solidly-ranked FCS team wins):
2025: Tulane 11-2, *Duke 7-5, Texas Tech 11-1, Indiana 12-0, Kennesaw St 9-3, WMichigan 9-4, *Boise St 8-4, Georgia 11-1, James Madison 11-1
2024: Army 10-2, Clemson 10-2, Arizona St 11-2, Oregon 13-0, Jacksonville St 9-4, Ohio 9-3, Boise St 11-1, Georgia 10-2, Marshall 9-3
2023: SMU 10-2, Florida St 12-0, Texas 12-1, Michigan 13-0, Liberty 13-0, Miami-OH 11-2, *Boise St 8-5, Washington 13-0, Alabama 12-1, Troy 10-2
2022: Tulane 10-2, Clemson 11-2, Kansas St 9-3, Michigan 13-0, UTSA 11-2, *Toledo 7-5, *Fresno St 8-4, Utah 9-3, Georgia 13-0, Troy 10-2
2021: Cincinnati 12-0, Pittsburgh 10-2, Baylor 10-2, Michigan 12-1, UTSA 11-1, *NIllinois 8-4, Utah St 9-3, Utah 9-3, Alabama 11-1, Louisiana 11-1
* = Not 9W of FBS-level wins

But unless you're not even going to take all Conf Champs with 10W+ of FBS-level teams -- mine as well separate the G6 into another D1 division, with G6 taking in a handful of consistently best handful from FCS and potentially dropping the bottom small stripe of G6 into FCS.
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2026 01:20 AM by toddjnsn.)
09-15-2026 01:14 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #84
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:59 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:47 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:23 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:51 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:10 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  Historically the bottom 12 P4 programs and top 12 G6 were relatively even on the FB field but its different now with the massively larger conference payouts in the P4 and revenue sharing.

Before you could move up to a better revenue conference, use the money to level up your coaching staffs and keep the train rolling forward. Today you can move up and struggle as one of the poorest schools in the P4.

The are definitely not 12 schools sitting in the G6 with deep pockets for P4 NIL. I do not understand why JRsec thinks that 12 schools do. I believe its because he doesn't realize that nobody in the G6 can really afford it. UConn and Memphis could survive if they had the invite but no impetus for another 10 schools. The deep pockets just are not there.
Oh I fully realize it. I post the data on it annually. But there are more than just Boise State. South Florida, San Diego State, perhaps Colorado State, Oregon State and Washington State could make the jump. Perhaps you need to improve your reading skills. I said for all 4 P conferences to move to 20. That's 2 for the Big Ten, 4 for the SEC and those six will be backfilled most likely by the ACC. Those being promoted up with the possible exception of USF would likely go to the Big 12 and would be paid Big 12 money. Could you find 12 if you leveled up their revenue even if the Big 12 payouts dropped 5 million it would be a lot more than a G6 school had been making at 28 million. I suggested 20 for round numbers and equal representation and equl chance of making the national semifinals, as I had it set up.

If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.

Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout

Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.

As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.

The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.

I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.

SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)

ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.

Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.

ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)

Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.
Wrong assumption. I look at total revenue and with the G6 the % of subsidy each school gets, and they all get at least 25%. I look at attendance, record, and whether or not the school is growing or is in a growing area. I also consider whether the state they are located in (if they are a state school) is able to continue its support or whether that state has budegtary issues. The great divide has always existed. It is greater now because the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 earners from the PAC 12 (leaving out only Stanford whose best metric was revenue). The SEC took 54% of the remaining Big 12 value with just Texas and Oklahoma. Those moves created what many here call the P2 and M2 which is also a divide. That was by the design of the networks who are pursuing the best brands playing each other more often and "best" doesn't necessarily mean winning. It does by necessity mean the ability to draw large audiences for their contests.

There is absolutely a divide in the G6 programs when it comes to earnings the difference doesn't appear to be that great. When it comes to subsidy then about the top 1/4th of the G6 schools can hang in with 25% to 35% subsidy range. The rest cannot. The more subsidy a school has the less they can afford to buy or retain top players in this new pay for play world.

What I'm suggesting is that if there are 12 schools in that top 25% of the G6 who want a chance to move up the best solution is found in allowing the SEC and Big Ten to grow to 20 each and the ACC to grow or backfill to the same. The 4th conference then picks up the rest. But included in the P4 that gives them access to the postseason and permits games between them and other P4 schools from the other 3 conferences. If a promoted G6 can't make it then you look to backfill, or perhaps to gradually reduce the number of teams from 20 to 18 or 16 for that 4th conference depending upon profitability and market penetration based on who the replacements might be versus the collection of schools left in the conference.

Generated Revenue, level of donation, gate & concessions, post season money leading to that gross revenue figure minus overhead and considering the unreliable nature of subsidy during a time of economic downturn, and a big one is looming in 5-10 years, are the indicators of health. The less subsidized the better the long-range outlook.

Conduct your business wisely and you have a shot. Don't and there is no margin for error because you aren't and won't be earning what the SEC, Big Ten, or ACC will be earning and you need to be strong enough to pay your own way in the Big 12. So, you have to be smart businesswise, and free of as much subsidy dependence as possible, and then you have be good enough to draw interest, which is easier the larger the state is. It's a tall order but that's why I tossed out the schools I mentioned. Two of them have succeeded on less in the P5. Some are growing and in growing regions of growing states. Some like Boise just punch above their weight class with success.

The percent subsidy of a mythical budget doesn't mean as much as the overall size institutional/student fee subsidy. Those with the largest budgets in the G6 have them because they are reporting largest subsidies. They have the largest amount of athletic debt on the books. It pumps up the budget.

I do not understand how someone who is a serious Auburn fan does not understand that SEC FB is logrithimic level above in support than what James Madison or East Carolina have regardless of nice FB stadiums and good attendance. Its not just a nudge of difference. A painted logo on the field.

If you would quit trying to be insulting, you might actually make a point. Budgets are not mythical they are real. What budgets did prior to the court rulings was to try to account for the spending of enough of the revenue to remain non-profit. But as to subsidy the subsidy is usually not reported as a % of budget, on the reports generated outside the school about their revenue, but rather as a percentage of total gross revenue the subsidy represents. It's a real subsidy apportioned to the school from the taxpayers of the state earmarked for athletics and counted as a percentage of the total gross revenue. It's likely, due to the various kinds of reports that any entity generates, that it may be counted on some reports as a % of the budget, but not the reports on revenue generation.

I fully grasp the difference in the revenue levels of the majority of SEC schools versus those of a JMU and ECU as I told you I post those numbers annually. You are arguing for inclusion of G6 schools. I gave you a plan for how to do that. Your default position in an effort to either save face for your post or to keep some kind of debate going is to default to the nonsensical claim that I don't grasp a difference in the scale of revenue that I research and report on annually? Visit the SEC forum and look at the important threads section and you will find a breadth of data which illustrates why I know this. It's updated annually when new data comes out. And yes, it directly impacts realignment considerations as one of a handful of factors. By those reports the Power conferences probably should not have schools making below 145 million annually as members, if the only goal is competitive investment in athletics.

To listen to you counter the illustration I gave for the inclusion of the top G6 schools one would believe you are arguing against their inclusion. In an earlier post I laid out for you what would happen if the networks got a 24-team playoff. They would claim inclusion to begin with and when they had wrested away from the major conference's their highly profitable CCGs, they would resort to what they do in realignment. They would go back and start filling those G6 slots with large state schools with large audience bases, or national brands. Certainly, that would not happen on the initial contract, but down the road what would stop them? The networks are corporations and they have only one agenda, to make money. But they will finagle the logic of what they intend to do to make their strategy seem more broadly appealing. Left to their own they would likely only take the top 48 to 60 schools in 2 conferences or leagues and use the NFL model. The Big Ten / SEC / ACC & Big 12 might all have some or most schools represented, but not all, and that is why each is resistant. So, for the moment the objective is broad enough inclusion to make a change that might not give the networks all they want now, but which opens the door for that down the road.
09-15-2026 03:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #85
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 03:20 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:59 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:47 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:23 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:51 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Oh I fully realize it. I post the data on it annually. But there are more than just Boise State. South Florida, San Diego State, perhaps Colorado State, Oregon State and Washington State could make the jump. Perhaps you need to improve your reading skills. I said for all 4 P conferences to move to 20. That's 2 for the Big Ten, 4 for the SEC and those six will be backfilled most likely by the ACC. Those being promoted up with the possible exception of USF would likely go to the Big 12 and would be paid Big 12 money. Could you find 12 if you leveled up their revenue even if the Big 12 payouts dropped 5 million it would be a lot more than a G6 school had been making at 28 million. I suggested 20 for round numbers and equal representation and equl chance of making the national semifinals, as I had it set up.

If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.

Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout

Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.

As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.

The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.

I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.

SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)

ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.

Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.

ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)

Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.
Wrong assumption. I look at total revenue and with the G6 the % of subsidy each school gets, and they all get at least 25%. I look at attendance, record, and whether or not the school is growing or is in a growing area. I also consider whether the state they are located in (if they are a state school) is able to continue its support or whether that state has budegtary issues. The great divide has always existed. It is greater now because the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 earners from the PAC 12 (leaving out only Stanford whose best metric was revenue). The SEC took 54% of the remaining Big 12 value with just Texas and Oklahoma. Those moves created what many here call the P2 and M2 which is also a divide. That was by the design of the networks who are pursuing the best brands playing each other more often and "best" doesn't necessarily mean winning. It does by necessity mean the ability to draw large audiences for their contests.

There is absolutely a divide in the G6 programs when it comes to earnings the difference doesn't appear to be that great. When it comes to subsidy then about the top 1/4th of the G6 schools can hang in with 25% to 35% subsidy range. The rest cannot. The more subsidy a school has the less they can afford to buy or retain top players in this new pay for play world.

What I'm suggesting is that if there are 12 schools in that top 25% of the G6 who want a chance to move up the best solution is found in allowing the SEC and Big Ten to grow to 20 each and the ACC to grow or backfill to the same. The 4th conference then picks up the rest. But included in the P4 that gives them access to the postseason and permits games between them and other P4 schools from the other 3 conferences. If a promoted G6 can't make it then you look to backfill, or perhaps to gradually reduce the number of teams from 20 to 18 or 16 for that 4th conference depending upon profitability and market penetration based on who the replacements might be versus the collection of schools left in the conference.

Generated Revenue, level of donation, gate & concessions, post season money leading to that gross revenue figure minus overhead and considering the unreliable nature of subsidy during a time of economic downturn, and a big one is looming in 5-10 years, are the indicators of health. The less subsidized the better the long-range outlook.

Conduct your business wisely and you have a shot. Don't and there is no margin for error because you aren't and won't be earning what the SEC, Big Ten, or ACC will be earning and you need to be strong enough to pay your own way in the Big 12. So, you have to be smart businesswise, and free of as much subsidy dependence as possible, and then you have be good enough to draw interest, which is easier the larger the state is. It's a tall order but that's why I tossed out the schools I mentioned. Two of them have succeeded on less in the P5. Some are growing and in growing regions of growing states. Some like Boise just punch above their weight class with success.

The percent subsidy of a mythical budget doesn't mean as much as the overall size institutional/student fee subsidy. Those with the largest budgets in the G6 have them because they are reporting largest subsidies. They have the largest amount of athletic debt on the books. It pumps up the budget.

I do not understand how someone who is a serious Auburn fan does not understand that SEC FB is logrithimic level above in support than what James Madison or East Carolina have regardless of nice FB stadiums and good attendance. Its not just a nudge of difference. A painted logo on the field.

If you would quit trying to be insulting, you might actually make a point. Budgets are not mythical they are real. What budgets did prior to the court rulings was to try to account for the spending of enough of the revenue to remain non-profit. But as to subsidy the subsidy is usually not reported as a % of budget, on the reports generated outside the school about their revenue, but rather as a percentage of total gross revenue the subsidy represents. It's a real subsidy apportioned to the school from the taxpayers of the state earmarked for athletics and counted as a percentage of the total gross revenue. It's likely, due to the various kinds of reports that any entity generates, that it may be counted on some reports as a % of the budget, but not the reports on revenue generation.

I fully grasp the difference in the revenue levels of the majority of SEC schools versus those of a JMU and ECU as I told you I post those numbers annually. You are arguing for inclusion of G6 schools. I gave you a plan for how to do that. Your default position in an effort to either save face for your post or to keep some kind of debate going is to default to the nonsensical claim that I don't grasp a difference in the scale of revenue that I research and report on annually? Visit the SEC forum and look at the important threads section and you will find a breadth of data which illustrates why I know this. It's updated annually when new data comes out. And yes, it directly impacts realignment considerations as one of a handful of factors. By those reports the Power conferences probably should not have schools making below 145 million annually as members, if the only goal is competitive investment in athletics.

To listen to you counter the illustration I gave for the inclusion of the top G6 schools one would believe you are arguing against their inclusion. In an earlier post I laid out for you what would happen if the networks got a 24-team playoff. They would claim inclusion to begin with and when they had wrested away from the major conference's their highly profitable CCGs, they would resort to what they do in realignment. They would go back and start filling those G6 slots with large state schools with large audience bases, or national brands. Certainly, that would not happen on the initial contract, but down the road what would stop them? The networks are corporations and they have only one agenda, to make money. But they will finagle the logic of what they intend to do to make their strategy seem more broadly appealing. Left to their own they would likely only take the top 48 to 60 schools in 2 conferences or leagues and use the NFL model. The Big Ten / SEC / ACC & Big 12 might all have some or most schools represented, but not all, and that is why each is resistant. So, for the moment the objective is broad enough inclusion to make a change that might not give the networks all they want now, but which opens the door for that down the road.

More focused on your last paragraph here the PCSA would close the door on a superconfernce forming so the 48 team breakaway isn't a threat needed to be mitigated by preemptively cutting FBS in two. In fact I don't see any threat worth of preemptively cutting off 50 FBS programs to get in front of. If the PCSA fails at some point and we do see a 48 team superconference 25 years down the road so be it.

Secondly as I have said that its very possible the CFP uses the 10 game P4 schedule as a way to devalue the G6 in the rankings even further. Of course we have seen when Liberty made a CFP bowl a few years back they were hardly ranked in the Top 25 because they didn't play a P4 team. Increasingly it will be difficult for G6 programs to schedule in a P4 team on an annual basis. Thus a 24 team CFP format does carry a risk of further diluting the G6 seed. Perhaps the P4 and G6 winners can be guaranteed a bye to the second round or something to mitigate this problem.
09-15-2026 08:14 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #86
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 03:01 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:07 PM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 01:47 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  Nobody within the G6 draws 40,000 to their games. None of them bring value to the P4 except UConn with their BB. The majority of P4 fans on here for whatever reason think the answer is moving 8-10 G6 programs (fan favorite Tulane) into the P4.

Those 8-10 belong where they are in a G6 conference. Most belong in a high G6 conference like the PAC or AC. SBC and MWC have some big ones too.

So the 45,600 for Arkansas State @ Memphis, the 41,800 for FIU @ South Florida, the 40,000 for App State @ ECU don't exist?

Not hard to believe either that App State, JMU, or Boise St (among others) could get to 40,000 if their stadiums held that much. Both App and JMU have stadium expansion projects in different phases underway.

I was talking about averaging 40,000 for the season. None of the G6 do that.

At Boise the attenance has trended down not up the last 10 to 15 seasons.

Not consistently. But USF, UTEP, ECU and Fresno have at times had seasons over 40k. USF had about 6 in a row, even over 50k, when they were in the Big East. ECU had about a 10 years streak over 40k before their program hit a bad spell.
09-15-2026 08:43 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #87
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 08:14 AM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 03:20 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:59 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:47 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:23 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.

Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout

Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.

As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.

The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.

I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.

SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)

ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.

Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.

ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)

Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.
Wrong assumption. I look at total revenue and with the G6 the % of subsidy each school gets, and they all get at least 25%. I look at attendance, record, and whether or not the school is growing or is in a growing area. I also consider whether the state they are located in (if they are a state school) is able to continue its support or whether that state has budegtary issues. The great divide has always existed. It is greater now because the Big Ten took 4 of the top 5 earners from the PAC 12 (leaving out only Stanford whose best metric was revenue). The SEC took 54% of the remaining Big 12 value with just Texas and Oklahoma. Those moves created what many here call the P2 and M2 which is also a divide. That was by the design of the networks who are pursuing the best brands playing each other more often and "best" doesn't necessarily mean winning. It does by necessity mean the ability to draw large audiences for their contests.

There is absolutely a divide in the G6 programs when it comes to earnings the difference doesn't appear to be that great. When it comes to subsidy then about the top 1/4th of the G6 schools can hang in with 25% to 35% subsidy range. The rest cannot. The more subsidy a school has the less they can afford to buy or retain top players in this new pay for play world.

What I'm suggesting is that if there are 12 schools in that top 25% of the G6 who want a chance to move up the best solution is found in allowing the SEC and Big Ten to grow to 20 each and the ACC to grow or backfill to the same. The 4th conference then picks up the rest. But included in the P4 that gives them access to the postseason and permits games between them and other P4 schools from the other 3 conferences. If a promoted G6 can't make it then you look to backfill, or perhaps to gradually reduce the number of teams from 20 to 18 or 16 for that 4th conference depending upon profitability and market penetration based on who the replacements might be versus the collection of schools left in the conference.

Generated Revenue, level of donation, gate & concessions, post season money leading to that gross revenue figure minus overhead and considering the unreliable nature of subsidy during a time of economic downturn, and a big one is looming in 5-10 years, are the indicators of health. The less subsidized the better the long-range outlook.

Conduct your business wisely and you have a shot. Don't and there is no margin for error because you aren't and won't be earning what the SEC, Big Ten, or ACC will be earning and you need to be strong enough to pay your own way in the Big 12. So, you have to be smart businesswise, and free of as much subsidy dependence as possible, and then you have be good enough to draw interest, which is easier the larger the state is. It's a tall order but that's why I tossed out the schools I mentioned. Two of them have succeeded on less in the P5. Some are growing and in growing regions of growing states. Some like Boise just punch above their weight class with success.

The percent subsidy of a mythical budget doesn't mean as much as the overall size institutional/student fee subsidy. Those with the largest budgets in the G6 have them because they are reporting largest subsidies. They have the largest amount of athletic debt on the books. It pumps up the budget.

I do not understand how someone who is a serious Auburn fan does not understand that SEC FB is logrithimic level above in support than what James Madison or East Carolina have regardless of nice FB stadiums and good attendance. Its not just a nudge of difference. A painted logo on the field.

If you would quit trying to be insulting, you might actually make a point. Budgets are not mythical they are real. What budgets did prior to the court rulings was to try to account for the spending of enough of the revenue to remain non-profit. But as to subsidy the subsidy is usually not reported as a % of budget, on the reports generated outside the school about their revenue, but rather as a percentage of total gross revenue the subsidy represents. It's a real subsidy apportioned to the school from the taxpayers of the state earmarked for athletics and counted as a percentage of the total gross revenue. It's likely, due to the various kinds of reports that any entity generates, that it may be counted on some reports as a % of the budget, but not the reports on revenue generation.

I fully grasp the difference in the revenue levels of the majority of SEC schools versus those of a JMU and ECU as I told you I post those numbers annually. You are arguing for inclusion of G6 schools. I gave you a plan for how to do that. Your default position in an effort to either save face for your post or to keep some kind of debate going is to default to the nonsensical claim that I don't grasp a difference in the scale of revenue that I research and report on annually? Visit the SEC forum and look at the important threads section and you will find a breadth of data which illustrates why I know this. It's updated annually when new data comes out. And yes, it directly impacts realignment considerations as one of a handful of factors. By those reports the Power conferences probably should not have schools making below 145 million annually as members, if the only goal is competitive investment in athletics.

To listen to you counter the illustration I gave for the inclusion of the top G6 schools one would believe you are arguing against their inclusion. In an earlier post I laid out for you what would happen if the networks got a 24-team playoff. They would claim inclusion to begin with and when they had wrested away from the major conference's their highly profitable CCGs, they would resort to what they do in realignment. They would go back and start filling those G6 slots with large state schools with large audience bases, or national brands. Certainly, that would not happen on the initial contract, but down the road what would stop them? The networks are corporations and they have only one agenda, to make money. But they will finagle the logic of what they intend to do to make their strategy seem more broadly appealing. Left to their own they would likely only take the top 48 to 60 schools in 2 conferences or leagues and use the NFL model. The Big Ten / SEC / ACC & Big 12 might all have some or most schools represented, but not all, and that is why each is resistant. So, for the moment the objective is broad enough inclusion to make a change that might not give the networks all they want now, but which opens the door for that down the road.

More focused on your last paragraph here the PCSA would close the door on a superconfernce forming so the 48 team breakaway isn't a threat needed to be mitigated by preemptively cutting FBS in two. In fact I don't see any threat worth of preemptively cutting off 50 FBS programs to get in front of. If the PCSA fails at some point and we do see a 48 team superconference 25 years down the road so be it.

Secondly as I have said that its very possible the CFP uses the 10 game P4 schedule as a way to devalue the G6 in the rankings even further. Of course we have seen when Liberty made a CFP bowl a few years back they were hardly ranked in the Top 25 because they didn't play a P4 team. Increasingly it will be difficult for G6 programs to schedule in a P4 team on an annual basis. Thus a 24 team CFP format does carry a risk of further diluting the G6 seed. Perhaps the P4 and G6 winners can be guaranteed a bye to the second round or something to mitigate this problem.

In terms of scheduling, it's transitioning to 10 P4 games, 1 G6, and 1 FCS game for 7 home games in a 12 game season, but definitely wouldn't be shocked, and actually would like to see it, if at least the P4 went to 13 games and played 12 P4 games and 1 G6 game while the G6 plays 1 P4, 1 FCS, and 10-11 G6 games depending on if they follow the P4 to 13 games or maintain 12 games. For the P4 and their media partners, scheduling FCS opponents, while incredible when upsets happen, have too much risk for injuries and obviously hurts when you lose, but wins don't benefit you much outside 2nd and 3rd strings getting playing time. Obviously viewership is down when teams play an FCS and G6 opponent unless a team is struggling or on upset alert for media partners. I can see the P4 opting to replace the FCS game for a non-conf P4 opponent and adding a 10th conference game (since conferences will be expanding to at least 20 teams) for the 13th regular season game because media partners would be willing to pay for higher viewership games, rivalries lost to realignment being restored, and more quantity of games
09-15-2026 08:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,543
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #88
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
The P and G designations have been around for a long time and even before the FCS/FBS split it was obvious to anyone paying attention that there were de facto levels of college football. So this is hardly breaking news.

I do wish the NCAA would create an official level in the middle and crown a champion. That would help keep the P4 from leaving altogether.

If they declared fruit basket turnover and everyone had to start new leagues from scratch some Ps wouldn’t make the cut and are only P now because they just happened to have joined their conference a hundred years ago. But that’s life.
09-15-2026 08:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #89
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr attendance revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2026 09:21 AM by bullet.)
09-15-2026 09:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #90
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
This is the change in revenues of those schools. It shows that the top 7 and Tulane are definitely trying to position themselves in case there are openings.
23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 --122,093,386 --26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 --104,767,703 --(15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 --97,050,998 --5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 --89,827,012 --5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 --89,699,430 --29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 --82,229,485 --(6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 --77,272,658 --11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 --71,198,560 --878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 --68,011,262 --2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 --66,211,945 --26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 --65,857,423 --3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 --63,439,685 --7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 -- 55,794,198 --5,531,694
09-15-2026 09:19 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SFLFB Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 836
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #91
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference
09-15-2026 09:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UCBearcatlawjd2 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,044
Joined: Nov 2014
Reputation: 82
I Root For: UC
Location:
Post: #92
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

Add that group to a power conference and they will be fine.
09-15-2026 09:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #93
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
I Big 10 & SEC
II the rest
09-15-2026 09:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,609
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #94
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 09:47 AM)UCBearcatlawjd2 Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

Add that group to a power conference and they will be fine.

We have 2-3 years of ratings for SMU, UCF, BYU, Houston and Cincinnati. Only BYU’s ratings are “fine”. The rest have been lacking. Additionally, I think Houston is still struggling with attendance.
09-15-2026 11:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
2Buck Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,222
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 372
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Cackalacky
Post: #95
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:03 PM)bill dazzle Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 09:17 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 08:22 AM)4x4hokies Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 07:45 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I don’t understand the clamor for a G6-only playoff. It’s the “kids’ table” and everyone knows it. While some G6 fans have delusions of thinking that there ought to be a playoff where all G6 champs get an auto-bid (which will never happen), I’m not sure what the value is for the P4 to just snuff out even a single G6 playoff bid, particularly if there’s expansion to a 24-team playoff. There’s a massive difference between the P4 having a huge advantage over the G6 competitively versus the P4 *structurally* eliminating any G6 playoff presence entirely.

The G6 deserve to play for a championship against programs with similar resources to their own. Nobody wants the FCS to have a playoff spot. So the concept of different divisions playing competitions with similar resourced schools is not foreign.

You do realize VT is closer in resources to JMU than it is to Ohio State. So you are supporting VT being relegated too right?

I'm too lazy to factcheck this but I would not be surprised if you are, in fact, correct. JMU offers a robust athletics budget. I'm impressed. So for football resources ... I see your point.

But I would think the general public perception is that Virginia Tech, in a comprehensive manner, is much more similar to Ohio State (athletics, history, academics, influence, etc.) than James Madison. And that is not a slight, as JMU seemingly is doing tremendous work in many areas (academics and athletics).

In % terms, VT is much closer to Ohio St. (2nd highest in the country) on internally generated revenue (ie excluding institution subsidies and student fees). They generate almost all of their $151 million while JMU has a massive subsidy for their $68 million. VT is probably at least 5 times JMU on actual revenue. And Ohio St. at $295 million is behind only Texas. Michigan at $237 million ($86 million more than VT who is $83 million more than JMU) is #7. So VT is close to the vast majority of P4 schools. There are only 15 over $200 million. By contrast, all are over $100 million, more than $32 million ahead of JMU. And JMU is near the top of the G6 at #10 overall.

This is all chicken/egg argument. The main reason most P4 programs have the national recognition and all the resources is because they've been in the conferences providing those resources. Their athletic budgets are a direct result of the media dollars, donations, merchandise sales, ticket sales, desirable home opponents, etc that being in those conferences has afforded them. Of course JMU would drown in the B1G or SEC with current funding, but give JMU Rutgers money and see how they'd do in the B1G.

JMU beat a ranked VT team in 2010 with a fraction of the resources. If JMU magically joined the ACC the following year they'd absolutely be closer to Ohio State than the top G6 just like VT. If JMU had ACC money and kept Cignetti and staff and top players, you think there'd be as many of you holding your noses about the mere thought of JMU joining your precious conference?
09-15-2026 11:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
2Buck Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,222
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 372
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Cackalacky
Post: #96
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
What should (but will never) happen is P4 membership should be based on recent performance like European soccer. Gone would be the days of bad P4 programs sucking the teat and keeping better programs from the G6 out.
09-15-2026 11:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #97
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

Internal revenue comes first. UCF, Cincinnati, Houston and BYU were among the tops in their own, non-conference revenue. Only a few generated more than any of those 4. A certain base of attendance has to be there to generate revenue and to have sustained support once you move up. USF was drawing 40-50k in a BCS conference. That dropped as the American was dropped from the BCS, but they are still in the 30s.

As for ratings, you can look at the big difference between schools like Memphis and Boise and USF vs. the rest of the G5. Those 3 had TV ratings close to the bottom of the P5 and even ahead of a few schools like Rutgers, Kansas and Duke. Only Temple and Fresno of the schools I listed even had half the ratings that Boise and Memphis had. And none of the western schools had half the number of rated games Boise had (excluding then P5 members OSU and WSU). There's a big dropoff in interest from casual fans and TV networks after those first few G schools.
09-15-2026 11:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,609
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #98
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 11:13 AM)2Buck Wrote:  What should (but will never) happen is P4 membership should be based on recent performance like European soccer. Gone would be the days of bad P4 programs sucking the teat and keeping better programs from the G6 out.

Going .800 vs G6 opponents is not going to lead to promotion. G6 schools need to prove it vs P4 opponents. TCU, Utah and Boise were getting top 10 rankings 15-20 years ago because they were regularly beating P4 opponents. Some G6 programs go 4-8 over 5 years vs the P4 and they think they deserve a promotion. 05-nono
09-15-2026 11:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
2Buck Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,222
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 372
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Cackalacky
Post: #99
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 11:38 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 11:13 AM)2Buck Wrote:  What should (but will never) happen is P4 membership should be based on recent performance like European soccer. Gone would be the days of bad P4 programs sucking the teat and keeping better programs from the G6 out.

Going .800 vs G6 opponents is not going to lead to promotion. G6 schools need to prove it vs P4 opponents. TCU, Utah and Boise were getting top 10 rankings 15-20 years ago because they were regularly beating P4 opponents. Some G6 programs go 4-8 over 5 years vs the P4 and they think they deserve a promotion. 05-nono

Impossible, P4 won't schedule the games. JMU had VT this season but Tech dropped the game because ACC went to 9 conf games. Only way to get there is if the P4 was forced to schedule 4 or 5 games a season against top G6 so there's better sampling/comparison but will never happen.
09-15-2026 12:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #100
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 11:50 PM)46566 Wrote:  I think G6 seems closer because the bottom of G6 seems lower. I think this is due to expansion of G6 into FCS callups. Though all but 1 FCS win was top 25 FCS teams. I think FCS as a whole is weaker then the bottom of the G6. Purely as more top FCS programs are called up. We expect at least UC Davis is a FBS potential upgrade. I think FCS now has a bigger drop off then it used to have.

Davis isn't a top 10 program this year and in the past 20, has rarely been considered a top 10 program. Davis has size, money and for some it is about being in CA though it seems outside of Fresno, CA doesn't really care about college football.
09-15-2026 12:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.