Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
Author Message
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #21
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Pitt's Top-10 opponents (formula = 2025 average attendance / distance)

1. West Virginia (Big 12)
2. Penn State (Big Ten)
3. Ohio State (Big Ten)
4. Michigan (Big Ten)
5. Tennessee (SEC)
6. Virginia Tech (ACC)
7. Virginia (ACC)
8. Notre Dame (FBS Independent)
9. Michigan State (Big Ten)
10. Maryland (Big Ten)

The ACC is a better fit for Pitt than the Big 12, but lets not kid ourselves here. A school sandwiched between Columbus and State College would bend over backwards to be a member of the Big Ten. They wouldn't have to tarp off / close the upper sections of Acrisure, as Pitt would have a combination of MI/OSU/PSU/WVU visiting twice a year.

It's unfortunate that Michigan and Ohio State choose to do business with the Little 8 a century ago instead of Pitt / Eastern schools. The ACC should have won this realignment war as they have more valuable real estate than the Big Ten.
09-18-2026 01:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #22
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again. We were in the CFP a decade later (and had played in the Peach the year before).

I remember Mark May always being really cynical/negative. I recall a time a team moved to 5-0 and his reaction was “they’ll have a hard time winning a 6th.”
09-18-2026 02:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,956
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5077
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #23
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

Penn St. was never with them. Them not playing is Penn St.'s choice. WVU wants to play Pitt, but Pitt hasn't been interested most years. They played for many years before they were conference mates.
09-18-2026 02:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OSUnYSU Offline
Bench Warmer
*

Posts: 226
Joined: Aug 2023
Reputation: 32
I Root For: Ohio State and YSU
Location: Cleveland Ohio
Post: #24
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 12:29 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:17 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

Syracuse and Pittsburgh are both recent hoops giants who, like some of their other ACC counterparts, must try to catch coaching lightning in a bottle a second time.

I remember Coach K being interviewed on SportsCenter about the realignment news, he was joyful. He had a strong relationship with Jim Boeheim and supported expansion into the northeast (Duke’s natural footprint).

Why do you say that the Northeast is Duke's natural footprint? I would have thought they would prefer SEC over BIG TEN.
09-18-2026 03:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #25
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/20
(09-18-2026 03:02 PM)OSUnYSU Wrote:  Why do you say that the Northeast is Duke's natural footprint? I would have thought they would prefer SEC over BIG TEN.

Duke university alumni locations on LinkedIn...

USA: 117,759
North Carolina: 28,438
Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill area: 21,006
New York City Metropolitan area: 17,510
California: 15,346
09-18-2026 03:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
CliftonAve2 Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 342
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 43
I Root For: Jimmy Nippert
Location:
Post: #26
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 02:33 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again. We were in the CFP a decade later (and had played in the Peach the year before).

I remember Mark May always being really cynical/negative. I recall a time a team moved to 5-0 and his reaction was “they’ll have a hard time winning a 6th.”

His whole schtick was to rile up fan bases with snarky takes. I was living in Columbus, Ohio at the time and he made Ohio State fans so mad.
09-18-2026 03:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,442
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #27
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 03:02 PM)OSUnYSU Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:29 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:17 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

Syracuse and Pittsburgh are both recent hoops giants who, like some of their other ACC counterparts, must try to catch coaching lightning in a bottle a second time.

I remember Coach K being interviewed on SportsCenter about the realignment news, he was joyful. He had a strong relationship with Jim Boeheim and supported expansion into the northeast (Duke’s natural footprint).

Why do you say that the Northeast is Duke's natural footprint? I would have thought they would prefer SEC over BIG TEN.

I've been to Duke many times. IMHO, Duke's core seems like the Tri-State area (NY + NJ + PA). My wife (originally from NY) and daughter (originally from PA), who both went to school there, loved the atmosphere and felt right at home. Duke frequently plays a Christmas season basketball game in the Tri-state area...and it's always been 80%+ Duke fans.
09-18-2026 03:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
realignmentreport9239 Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 49
Joined: Feb 2026
Reputation: 9
I Root For: Realignment
Location:
Post: #28
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
I personally remember how shocked and excited I was when I had heard on the local news that Pitt had applied and been accepted into the ACC. It honestly was a surprise, not so much for Syracuse as they were originally targets of the ACC around when Miami, Boston College, and Virginia Tech agreed to terms with the ACC.
09-18-2026 03:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,306
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #29
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 03:32 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  I've been to Duke many times. IMHO, Duke's core seems like the Tri-State area (NY + NJ + PA). My wife (originally from NY) and daughter (originally from PA), who both went to school there, loved the atmosphere and felt right at home. Duke frequently plays a Christmas season basketball game in the Tri-state area...and it's always been 80%+ Duke fans.

The largest states for Duke by enrollment:

1. North Carolina (16% of total)
2. New York
3. Florida
4. California
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 03:44 PM by DFW HOYA.)
09-18-2026 03:43 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,442
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #30
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 01:49 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Pitt's Top-10 opponents (formula = 2025 average attendance / distance)

1. West Virginia (Big 12)
2. Penn State (Big Ten)
3. Ohio State (Big Ten)
4. Michigan (Big Ten)
5. Tennessee (SEC)
6. Virginia Tech (ACC)
7. Virginia (ACC)
8. Notre Dame (FBS Independent)
9. Michigan State (Big Ten)
10. Maryland (Big Ten)

The ACC is a better fit for Pitt than the Big 12, but lets not kid ourselves here. A school sandwiched between Columbus and State College would bend over backwards to be a member of the Big Ten. They wouldn't have to tarp off / close the upper sections of Acrisure, as Pitt would have a combination of MI/OSU/PSU/WVU visiting twice a year.

It's unfortunate that Michigan and Ohio State choose to do business with the Little 8 a century ago instead of Pitt / Eastern schools. The ACC should have won this realignment war as they have more valuable real estate than the Big Ten.

Per sportsreference.com, Pitt's most frequent opponents:

1) WVU/B12, 2) PSU/B1G, 3) Syracuse/ACC, 4) Notre Dame/ACC-partial, 5) Miami/ACC, 6) Navy/American, 7) Temple/American, 8) BC/ACC, 9) Rutgers/B1G and 10) Army/American.

4-ACC, 3-American, 2-BIG and 1-B12

Duke, Virginia Tech and Louisville are also close to being included in their top 10 list.

Pittsburgh is a cross-roads location, straddling the north-south and east-midwest divides. Pitt would likely be comfortable enough in the ACC, American or B1G.

Once Penn State joined, Pitt was never going to be invited to the B1G. The B1G is now all about markets and Penn State covers the entire state sufficiently.
09-18-2026 03:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,397
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #31
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

This is all wrong.

The lynchpin of the ex-Big East football cohort in the ACC was Miami. Importantly, nine of the top 10 most frequently played opponents for Miami are fellow ACC members. Interestingly, Miami and Florida State are the two schools with the most top 10 H2H opponents being fellow ACC members. Miami’s top 3 opponents: 1) FSU, 2) UF and 3) Pitt. If you want ACC membership and Miami (or FSU) are sponsoring, then the fix is in (please see the UConn versus Louisville debate in 2013). Miami has never won an ACC football title, but they’re likely one of the biggest winners from the conference consolidation phase of college football.

Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Its not about the ACC being better than the Big XII for Pitt (though it is, of course,) its about comparing the ACC with the old Big East for Pitt. And in that its clearly worse. The Big East gave them WV, more games against ND (due to the smaller conference size,) and local long-running though non-rival games with Temple and Rutgers all on top of Syracuse.
09-18-2026 04:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,035
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #32
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

FWIW, I think the Big East of the last 10 years Pitt was in the league was a bigger pond than the ACC has been during its time there. That league was extremely tough. IIRC the last eight years Pitt was in the Big East it got at least eight bids six times, the other two times it got six and seven bids.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 04:25 PM by quo vadis.)
09-18-2026 04:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,442
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #33
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 01:49 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Pitt's Top-10 opponents (formula = 2025 average attendance / distance)

1. West Virginia (Big 12)
2. Penn State (Big Ten)
3. Ohio State (Big Ten)
4. Michigan (Big Ten)
5. Tennessee (SEC)
6. Virginia Tech (ACC)
7. Virginia (ACC)
8. Notre Dame (FBS Independent)
9. Michigan State (Big Ten)
10. Maryland (Big Ten)

The ACC is a better fit for Pitt than the Big 12, but lets not kid ourselves here. A school sandwiched between Columbus and State College would bend over backwards to be a member of the Big Ten. They wouldn't have to tarp off / close the upper sections of Acrisure, as Pitt would have a combination of MI/OSU/PSU/WVU visiting twice a year.

It's unfortunate that Michigan and Ohio State choose to do business with the Little 8 a century ago instead of Pitt / Eastern schools. The ACC should have won this realignment war as they have more valuable real estate than the Big Ten.
Regarding the bolded.

Collegiate athletics is not real estate. Location is not the #1 nor #2 nor #3 variable. Historical success and institutional size are more important than location. Ohio State’s enrollment exceeds 60k and Michigan is over 50k. The institutional profile of B1G universities are of massive state flagships. The ACC was founded by midsized publics and smaller privates. IMHO, Pitt’s institutional profile is well suited to the ACC (quasi-private with about 30k enrollment, located in a city)…there’s more peers.
09-18-2026 04:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,035
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #34
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.

I mean, I'm not sure what your metric is. PAC 12? All of those teams save for Wazzoo and OST are in A4 conferences, several of them in the P2 which is an improvement. nB12? Nebraska, TAMU, Missouri, Texas and OU are all in the P2 and the remaining nB12 schools are all still in the A4 club.

To me, none of the 2004 - 2012 Big East schools save for Rutgers (P2) are in a better place than they were in the old Big East. They lost the tight-knit rivalries and geographic cultural footprint. And even Rutgers is in a far worse place from a rivalry and competitive POV.

I mean yes, Pitt and Louisville are together in the ACC, but whereas in the 2010 Big East they were two of eight schools all (save for my USF) with similar culture and geography, their relationship is now diluted by a sprawling 18 team conference that stretches down to Miami and out to San Francisco. Very different culture, IMO.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 04:44 PM by quo vadis.)
09-18-2026 04:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,306
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #35
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
At what point does Rutgers get a... well, an offer from the Big Ten that they cannot refuse?
09-18-2026 04:42 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,442
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #36
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 04:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

This is all wrong.

The lynchpin of the ex-Big East football cohort in the ACC was Miami. Importantly, nine of the top 10 most frequently played opponents for Miami are fellow ACC members. Interestingly, Miami and Florida State are the two schools with the most top 10 H2H opponents being fellow ACC members. Miami’s top 3 opponents: 1) FSU, 2) UF and 3) Pitt. If you want ACC membership and Miami (or FSU) are sponsoring, then the fix is in (please see the UConn versus Louisville debate in 2013). Miami has never won an ACC football title, but they’re likely one of the biggest winners from the conference consolidation phase of college football.

Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Its not about the ACC being better than the Big XII for Pitt (though it is, of course,) its about comparing the ACC with the old Big East for Pitt. And in that its clearly worse. The Big East gave them WV, more games against ND (due to the smaller conference size,) and local long-running though non-rival games with Temple and Rutgers all on top of Syracuse.

From that perspective, it’s a closer call.

Temple had been kicked out, so they weren’t in the Big East. When their decision was made, Pitt’s consistent Big East football rivals in were WVU, Syracuse, ND (partial) and Rutgers. The rest of the football conference was relatively new (UConn, USF, Cincinnati and Louisville).

Pitt moved to the ACC with Syracuse and ND, so those are net washes. In the ACC, they were reunited with Miami, Boston College and Virginia Tech.

So the real trade-off was WVU and Rutgers (historical Big East opponents) versus Miami, BC and VT (historical ex-Big East opponents, that were already in the ACC). That’s not clearly worse. WVU has a longer history, but Miami was very meaningful. Given the trend towards consolidation, moving to a 14 team conference makes much more sense than remaining in an unstable 8 team unit.
09-18-2026 05:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,035
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #37
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 05:05 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 04:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

This is all wrong.

The lynchpin of the ex-Big East football cohort in the ACC was Miami. Importantly, nine of the top 10 most frequently played opponents for Miami are fellow ACC members. Interestingly, Miami and Florida State are the two schools with the most top 10 H2H opponents being fellow ACC members. Miami’s top 3 opponents: 1) FSU, 2) UF and 3) Pitt. If you want ACC membership and Miami (or FSU) are sponsoring, then the fix is in (please see the UConn versus Louisville debate in 2013). Miami has never won an ACC football title, but they’re likely one of the biggest winners from the conference consolidation phase of college football.

Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Its not about the ACC being better than the Big XII for Pitt (though it is, of course,) its about comparing the ACC with the old Big East for Pitt. And in that its clearly worse. The Big East gave them WV, more games against ND (due to the smaller conference size,) and local long-running though non-rival games with Temple and Rutgers all on top of Syracuse.

From that perspective, it’s a closer call.

Temple had been kicked out, so they weren’t in the Big East. When their decision was made, Pitt’s consistent Big East football rivals in were WVU, Syracuse, ND (partial) and Rutgers. The rest of the football conference was relatively new (UConn, USF, Cincinnati and Louisville).

Pitt moved to the ACC with Syracuse and ND, so those are net washes. In the ACC, they were reunited with Miami, Boston College and Virginia Tech.

So the real trade-off was WVU and Rutgers (historical Big East opponents) versus Miami, BC and VT (historical ex-Big East opponents, that were already in the ACC). That’s not clearly worse. WVU has a longer history, but Miami was very meaningful. Given the trend towards consolidation, moving to a 14 team conference makes much more sense than remaining in an unstable 8 team unit.

About the bolded, IMO it was a very different competitive environment for Pitt being in the Big East with those teams, a conference that was close-knit geographically (save for the Florida outliers, Miami and then USF) and culturally, compared to the ACC, where they are with those teams in a sprawling 18 team conference that stretches across the country. That makes the relations among those legacy Big East teams very diluted compared to what they had in the Big East, I think.
09-18-2026 05:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,397
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #38
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 05:05 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 04:18 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 01:30 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

This is all wrong.

The lynchpin of the ex-Big East football cohort in the ACC was Miami. Importantly, nine of the top 10 most frequently played opponents for Miami are fellow ACC members. Interestingly, Miami and Florida State are the two schools with the most top 10 H2H opponents being fellow ACC members. Miami’s top 3 opponents: 1) FSU, 2) UF and 3) Pitt. If you want ACC membership and Miami (or FSU) are sponsoring, then the fix is in (please see the UConn versus Louisville debate in 2013). Miami has never won an ACC football title, but they’re likely one of the biggest winners from the conference consolidation phase of college football.

Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.

Its not about the ACC being better than the Big XII for Pitt (though it is, of course,) its about comparing the ACC with the old Big East for Pitt. And in that its clearly worse. The Big East gave them WV, more games against ND (due to the smaller conference size,) and local long-running though non-rival games with Temple and Rutgers all on top of Syracuse.

From that perspective, it’s a closer call.

Temple had been kicked out, so they weren’t in the Big East. When their decision was made, Pitt’s consistent Big East football rivals in were WVU, Syracuse, ND (partial) and Rutgers. The rest of the football conference was relatively new (UConn, USF, Cincinnati and Louisville).

Pitt moved to the ACC with Syracuse and ND, so those are net washes. In the ACC, they were reunited with Miami, Boston College and Virginia Tech.

So the real trade-off was WVU and Rutgers (historical Big East opponents) versus Miami, BC and VT (historical ex-Big East opponents, that were already in the ACC). That’s not clearly worse. WVU has a longer history, but Miami was very meaningful. Given the trend towards consolidation, moving to a 14 team conference makes much more sense than remaining in an unstable 8 team unit.
Prior to joining the Big East Pitt and Virginia Tech had never played a single game, they weren't "reuniting a rivalry". As to BC and Miami, they did play BC regularly through the 70s and 80s but it wasn't a rivalry, Pitt crushed the hapless Bostonians most years. Their history with Miami is similarly spotty, with it being an annual in the sixties but rare after that with Pitt being blown out in nearly all Big East meetings. Most Pitt fans would gladly trade all three "rivals" to be annually playing, depending on their age, either WVU or Penn State on Thanksgiving again. Not that it even matters as all of those teams were already in conference with them, and without a bunch of meaningless games against southern schools, in the Big East. Its like the ACC caused a problem and then Pitt is supposed to be happy that they half-ass fixed it partially a decade later. Well they aren't, the ACC killed northeastern football and nobody is going to thank them for it.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026 07:36 PM by The Beaver.)
09-18-2026 05:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
46566 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,625
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation: 25
I Root For: Gonzaga
Location: California
Post: #39
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.
Comparing the Big East/AAC and the PAC seems weird to me. Just to me the Big East/AAC change seemed it was bound to happen and the PAC seems self inflicted. PAC had chances to survive grow. Getting the Bulk of the Big 12 but only adding Colorado and a MWC Utah. That allowed Big 12 to rebuild. But 12 survived losing Texas and Oklahoma while PAC crumbled losing USC and UCLA. Arguably PAC overplayed their hand or schools were already half way out the door. AAC was able to survive the first wave of realignment and the second one (losing Cincinnati, UCF)

Even now PAC and it's fans think it might be the #2 football G6 without proof.
09-18-2026 07:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,654
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1106
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #40
RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011)
(09-18-2026 03:02 PM)OSUnYSU Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 12:29 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:17 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

Syracuse and Pittsburgh are both recent hoops giants who, like some of their other ACC counterparts, must try to catch coaching lightning in a bottle a second time.

I remember Coach K being interviewed on SportsCenter about the realignment news, he was joyful. He had a strong relationship with Jim Boeheim and supported expansion into the northeast (Duke’s natural footprint).

Why do you say that the Northeast is Duke's natural footprint? I would have thought they would prefer SEC over BIG TEN.

There is no SEC member that Duke was a conference mate with since South Carolina left the ACC in 1970. I wasn't even born yet! At least the Big Ten has Maryland who was in the ACC as late as 2013. The same holds true for North Carolina.

The SEC always thinks they have the right to North Carolina but forget the academic aspect.
09-19-2026 04:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.