CSNbbs
15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) (/thread-1033055.html)

Pages: 1 2 3


15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - quo vadis - 09-18-2026 10:36 AM

... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - IWokeUpLikeThis - 09-18-2026 10:44 AM

This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - The Beaver - 09-18-2026 10:48 AM

(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

That was likely all down to Jamie Dixon, not realignment. They got tired of his "underperformance" and lowered his buyout so he could go coach alma mater (TCU.) And oh look, TCU is now significantly better than Pitt at basketball, whoever would have guessed. Dixon still can't get out of the first two rounds of the tournament though.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Gitanole - 09-18-2026 10:52 AM

(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

Oh, I think you have to put the Texas and OK move right up there.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Gitanole - 09-18-2026 10:57 AM

Fitting, then, that the two schools just played each other on national television. The timing was not a coincidence, I guess.

The Pitt Panthers are now 3–0 with their 27–13 win over Syracuse (now 1–2).

https://www.espn.com/college-football/video/_/gameId/401858225


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Wahoowa84 - 09-18-2026 11:01 AM

A few weeks earlier, Texas A&M had announced that it was leaving the B12 and seeking SEC membership. All the major realignment news was about the B12. The B12 nearly imploded in 2010 (ill fated PAC-16 proposal and Nebraska to the B1G)…Texas A&M’s decision started another wave of realignment.

Once the Texas A&M news broke, reports started circulating about the ESPN media deal provision to renegotiate rates. If the SEC was already expanding into new markets while growing beyond 12 members, then it didn’t me surprise me at all that the ACC followed the same script.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Owls9878 - 09-18-2026 11:06 AM

(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - bullet - 09-18-2026 11:11 AM

(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - CliftonAve2 - 09-18-2026 11:16 AM

I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again. We were in the CFP a decade later (and had played in the Peach the year before).


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Gitanole - 09-18-2026 11:17 AM

(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

Syracuse and Pittsburgh are both recent hoops giants who, like some of their other ACC counterparts, must try to catch coaching lightning in a bottle a second time.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Gitanole - 09-18-2026 11:19 AM

(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again. We were in the CFP a decade later (and had played in the Peach the year before).

Never predict, Mr. May. No one is asking you to. You’re not all that.

Say “We’ll see.” 03-wink


RE: 15 years ago today - Westhill 76 - 09-18-2026 11:31 AM

(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again.

That same Mark May was a color commentator for the Indoor Football League last spring.

Not sure if that was a paying gig or not.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - The Beaver - 09-18-2026 11:34 AM

(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - bullet - 09-18-2026 11:46 AM

(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Gitanole - 09-18-2026 11:49 AM

(09-18-2026 11:31 AM)Westhill 76 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again.

That same Mark May was a color commentator for the Indoor Football League last spring.

Not sure if that was a paying gig or not.

Do free nachos count?


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - thrill_house - 09-18-2026 11:55 AM

(09-18-2026 11:16 AM)CliftonAve2 Wrote:  I’ll always remember that day. Mark May went on ESPN and said Big East schools like UC would never play in a meaningful bowl game ever again. We were in the CFP a decade later (and had played in the Peach the year before).

In the present day landscape, he's not wrong.

Those "New Year's Six" Bowls are all part of the CFP and have restricted access to the Top-8 teams in the country from the Power 4 / Notre Dame.

Sure, Cincinnati can always win the Big 12 and make one of those bowl games. But the road is significantly more difficult now that Cincinnati is grouped with 15 schools that share similar (or larger) budgets, all of which are competing for 1-bid to those exclusive bowl games.

If they miss out of the CFP (which they will the overwhelming majority of the time), Cincinnati's post-season options are down to 4 bowls as the Texas bowls (Alamo + Texas) will always prioritize taking the local schools (TT, TCU, Baylor, Houston) over Cincinnati.

Those options are...

Pop-Tarts: UC's preferred destination as MCO is the #3 destination from CVG. Have to finish Top-3 in the conference to get access to this one.
Liberty: Judging by last years attendance mark, Bearcat fans have absolutely no interest in this destination.
Independence: Nightmare destination to travel to, all to play a Sun Belt school.
Cactus: A game designed for BYU to attend as the only western team currently in the Big 12's selection pool.

If they're not selected by any of those bowls, Cincinnati's best options are the Boca Raton Bowl (a pre-Christmas weekday bowl game against a G6 school), or praying that the Big Ten doesn't send a team to Charlotte this year and they can play the ACC in the Mayo Bowl.

It could be a very long time before Cincinnati plays in a bowl game which gets over 30,000 fans again. Or it could be this year. I wish Cincinnati good fortune against Iowa State, Kansas State, and West Virginia. The best of these 4 will be in Orlando over the holiday break, potentially playing Louisville.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - ohio1317 - 09-18-2026 11:57 AM

Wasn't this after it was announced Texas A&M was going to the SEC, but before Missouri. There was a lot of speculation (and likey internal SEC debate) about expanding east with them with at least one member.

I think the move was to push that the ACC could raid still itself and give it safety in numbers. Indirectly, I think this also helped push Maryland and Rutgers into the Big Ten. The ACC added them and did the deal with Notre Dame. This was also at same time as the fallout at Penn State when the fanbase was feeling a bit betrayed by the Big Ten. Iowa's AD I believe said staying still had become more dangerous (I interpret that being more long term, but still related).


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - The Beaver - 09-18-2026 12:09 PM

(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Wahoowa84 - 09-18-2026 12:29 PM

(09-18-2026 11:17 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:06 AM)Owls9878 Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:44 AM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  This was when Pitt seemed like a national championship contender in basketball every year too (5 AP Top-10 finishes in previous 10 years). It’s crazy how they fell from a national power to a program who misses the NCAA Tournament 75% of the time after this announcement.

Big fish in a small pond. Now a small fish in a big pond. Or something.

Syracuse and Pittsburgh are both recent hoops giants who, like some of their other ACC counterparts, must try to catch coaching lightning in a bottle a second time.

I remember Coach K being interviewed on SportsCenter about the realignment news, he was joyful. He had a strong relationship with Jim Boeheim and supported expansion into the northeast (Duke’s natural footprint).


RE: 15 years ago today: The ACC announces the addition of Pitt and Syracuse (9/18/2011) - Wahoowa84 - 09-18-2026 01:30 PM

(09-18-2026 12:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:46 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:34 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 11:11 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-18-2026 10:36 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  ... and I knew as soon as it was announced what this meant for USF - a return to the netherworld of what was then called "non-AQ", and now called "G-level" football. I didn't know who else would be able to leave, but I knew it sure wasn't going to be us.

IMO easily the most impactful realignment decision of this century, save for the implosion of the PAC three years ago, and it really isn't that far behind it.

5 of the original BE plus later member Louisville ended up in the ACC. Rutgers, WVU and later member Cincinnati found homes as well. It was more like a merger. The stripping of the Big 12 and Pac 12 were much more impactful.
Its hard to argue what an "original" Big East member is since for football purposes they never had stability but the Big East dissolution left far more (and far better) programs stranded than the Pac 12 implosion did. If you mean for dominoes then yeah, sure, the Big East, as the lowest ranked power conference, could only raid "G" leagues and thus they were starting halfway down the domino line.

But I'd argue that the split has been far more destructive for the teams involved than the Big XII split has been. Where did those Big XII teams end up? The one northern one is in the Big Ten, the four southern ones (geographically, Missouri isn't actually in the south,) went to the SEC. Where did the northeastern Big East teams go? Three to the ACC. One to the Big 10. One to the Big 12. Two left behind (UConn and football member Temple.) Split four ways and a non-geographic split to boot. Thats worse than what happened to the old Pac-8 to be honest.

No, its incredibly hard to argue its hard to define! The BEFC had the same 8 members from 1991 to 2004.

Rutgers is fat and happy. 6 members are back together in the ACC. Temple got kicked out because they were so bad. UConn and USF are pretty much in the same position before they briefly got lucky because 3 members left. WVU and Cincinnati are ok and Cincinnati benefitted from their brief stay which got them into the Big 12. Other than WVU, the ones with long time football rivalries are together with those teams.

Cal and Stanford are in a conference halfway across the continent. The 4 who joined the Big 12 no longer are with California schools where they recruit. The Big 12 instead of being arguably the best football conference is now the M2. Nebraska and Colorado are both way down from their peak in the Big 12. Only the 4 SEC schools are in good positions.
Pitt's biggest rivals are PSU and West Virginia. They are not with them. They lost. Of Cincinnati's ten most long-running football series only a single one is with another Big XII member (its Houston in ninth place, for those curious.) The same is true of Louisville, except that their lone ACC member in the top ten is tenth place FSU. In truth the two of them are only "long-time rivals" in football with each-other, Kentucky and Memphis and all four are in different conferences. The only winner in joining the ACC was Virginia Tech. Everyone else came out, at best, even (Miami, Syracuse,) or for most of them lost. I suppose Rutgers won. The prize was infinite swirlies but they won non-the-less.

And then I'd say that the current Big XII schools are clearly in a great place right now, loathe though the new joinees might be to admit it. Its a great set-up for Colorado, for Utah, for the Arizona schools. They're all together, they have BYU too (great for athletics, even if embarrassing in academics), Colorado has old Big-8 foes to play against and, for whatever its worth, the Arizona schools get Texas Tech from the Border States back.

This is all wrong.

The lynchpin of the ex-Big East football cohort in the ACC was Miami. Importantly, nine of the top 10 most frequently played opponents for Miami are fellow ACC members. Interestingly, Miami and Florida State are the two schools with the most top 10 H2H opponents being fellow ACC members. Miami’s top 3 opponents: 1) FSU, 2) UF and 3) Pitt. If you want ACC membership and Miami (or FSU) are sponsoring, then the fix is in (please see the UConn versus Louisville debate in 2013). Miami has never won an ACC football title, but they’re likely one of the biggest winners from the conference consolidation phase of college football.

Pitt may not be playing Penn St (B1G has likely never offered an invitation) nor West Virginia (B12 was likely not as attractive an option) regularly, but Pitt has more long-term opponents in the ACC than any other P4 conference. Once Miami and BC paved the road, the ACC became a more comfortable transition. In addition, Syracuse and Notre Dame were transitioning to the ACC at the same time…thereby adding more familiarity.