bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: TEAM USA Act
(09-18-2026 08:09 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 07:59 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: It is a purely xenophobic nativist bill.
I think that pans more serious underlying issues. The primary function of .edu is to educate their local/regional (and rarely elite national) populations to high standards with useful employment skills and an ability to do independent critical thinking and be malleable and adaptable to the inevitable workplace shifts over the course of your career. .Edu is funded by the taxpayers directly and indirectly to further that end. Exactly how much of that system should be diverted towards foreign students? This isn't to be written off as a case of "OMG STANFORD HAS ALL THESE SWIMMERS THAT AREN'T AMERICAN, EWWWW!". There's also a whole lot of "My children can't get into UC Berkeley anymore because it gorges itself on as many foreign students as possible to make as much money as possible that it can exercise much greater internal control over." It got so bad, so egregious, that California capped the nonresident undergraduate population at 18% in the UC system, with some usual "but some are more equal than others" exceptions. Is California full of xenophobic claptrap up the very top politically as well?
There have been no shortage of threads on this site about the struggles, past, present, future, and ongoing, with .edu in coping with demographic headwinds. You're foolin' yourself if you think the UC playbook isn't being run to its fullest in other parts of the country still, and that generates just as much friction, resentment, and contempt as it did in California.
I am very, very VERY far to the left of most people on this board and every single person I know in real life when it comes to immigration and people who look/think/act differently, yet even I have questions about Texas State funds being used to help train the Bulgarian and Slovenian Olympic Teams. Ofc, I realize that Athletic Depts at the bigger schools aren't really using State Funds for this, but Texas St, Sam Houston St, and most other schools in Texas do so. These Athletic Departments are most concerned with winning, and if that means that 7/8 of the tennis team is from Europe, then so be it. If that was just at Arkansas or A&M, well, ok, there are a whole lot of 1-AAA, D2 and D3 schools out there to provide opportunities for local kids. Unfortunately, that's not usually how it works, either. In football, American kids dominate, in basketball, it's mostly Americans, but in many other sports you have to look pretty hard to find even 1 or 2 Americans, much less kids from the actual State. If you're a private school, say Stanford or Harvard, do what you want, or if you're fully funding your entire Athletic dept like at an SEC school, ok, but I can certainly see in this day and age with skyrocketing educational costs how Politicians would care that most of the D1/2/3 athletes in their own State are getting State Funds for out of Staters, even out of Country-ers.
These are schools that are nominally there to educate the kids of their own State, these bigger State schools get TONS of money from their State, as much as tens of billion$ in the cases of A&M and Texas, and it's not unreasonable to think that elected officials would want to poke their noses into this.
None of the above means that the bill makes it out of committee. They tried attaching it to the PCSA and Cruz told them to take a hike. But I also don't think that this issue is just going to magically go away, either. Politicians care about it b/c their constituents care about it, and their constituents care about it b/c their kids aren't getting scholarship offers from mostly D2/3 schools b/c those scholarship offers are in many cases going to kids outside of the school's area of concern (generally the entire State).
|
|