(09-18-2026 08:09 AM)georgia_tech_swagger Wrote: (09-18-2026 07:59 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: It is a purely xenophobic nativist bill.
I think that pans more serious underlying issues. The primary function of .edu is to educate their local/regional (and rarely elite national) populations to high standards with useful employment skills and an ability to do independent critical thinking and be malleable and adaptable to the inevitable workplace shifts over the course of your career. .Edu is funded by the taxpayers directly and indirectly to further that end. Exactly how much of that system should be diverted towards foreign students? This isn't to be written off as a case of "OMG STANFORD HAS ALL THESE SWIMMERS THAT AREN'T AMERICAN, EWWWW!". There's also a whole lot of "My children can't get into UC Berkeley anymore because it gorges itself on as many foreign students as possible to make as much money as possible that it can exercise much greater internal control over." It got so bad, so egregious, that California capped the nonresident undergraduate population at 18% in the UC system, with some usual "but some are more equal than others" exceptions. Is California full of xenophobic claptrap up the very top politically as well?
There have been no shortage of threads on this site about the struggles, past, present, future, and ongoing, with .edu in coping with demographic headwinds. You're foolin' yourself if you think the UC playbook isn't being run to its fullest in other parts of the country still, and that generates just as much friction, resentment, and contempt as it did in California.
States have dramatically cut funding for public universities over the past 30-40 years. They’ve basically told their flagships that they have enough resources to support themselves on their own. So, when states are essentially telling public universities that they basically need to be financially run like private universities, of course they’re going to start acting like private universities in order to replace the funding that they’ve lost from their states. I would take the complaints of politicians about who is getting admitted to public universities more seriously if they actually funded public universities as they did when most of us were growing up.
At the same time, the *perception* of people that live in any state with a highly ranked public university is that they’re somehow letting in hordes of out-of-state in international students over “qualified” in-state students, but that’s not the reality. That is simply false. Contrary to public opinion, my kids that are applying to college right now will have lower bars to meet to get into the University of Illinois than any out-of-state or international students. On the flip side, the favorite school for one of my kids is UNC - if she were an in-state student, she would be a complete shoe-in to get admission there (not even a worry), but as an out-of-state student, it is legitimately harder to get into compared to Duke down the road. It’s the same thing for the University of California schools that you mentioned that she’s interested in - she would be easily in as an in-stare student in a way that she isn’t as an out-of-state.
Now, I don’t have an issue with public universities prioritizing their in-state students as an institutional priority. That is totally fine. However, people need to get out of their heads that it’s somehow an out-of-state or international student is “taking the place” of a similarly situated in-state student. That’s simply not true. The reality is that such out-of-state/international student is typically blowing away the in-state student on an academic basis to get that spot.
This gets to the broader point: it’s funny that free market competition is always the mantra… until some “outsider” actually beats the “insiders” in that free market competition and then it suddenly becomes about protecting who was here first as opposed to who is the best.
I’m a huge believer in free market competition. That not only means competition within America, but also competition throughout the world where there should be free and open trade where localities efficiently use resources based on their comparative advantage. The US college system has had a *massive* advantage over the rest of the world where the very best and talented in virtually every part of life - tech, science, business, performing arts, and athletics - have wanted to come HERE. Silicon Valley and tons of other areas of innovation where the US free market competition still outpaces even massive government subsidized economies elsewhere is a testament to how attractive our university system is worldwide *specifically*. We have been getting the first round draft picks of talent and grit from the entire world, yet are now actively squandering it. I don’t see how sending that talent to Europe or having Asian countries just keep that talent at home helps the US at all. That is simply denying that talent doesn’t exist elsewhere and/or cannot develop elsewhere, which is patently false.
And yes, it’s personal for me. My mother immigrated from Taiwan for college. Her family fled the Communist takeover in China to live with her family of 6 in a one room shack near salt mines, but her aunt that came to America previously was able to send just enough money so that the family could also come over for their education. My mom had zero money (needing to take full loans out just for commuter classes at UIC)… but she was extremely smart and even harder working. She was the only woman in any of her math and computer science classes, which she aced in a way that destroyed the male competition in the class grade curves (and also met my Harvey, Illinois native dad who had never been anywhere farther than Indiana but was also extremely smart although not quite as studious). She went on to become a professor in computer science and math and taught at a community college for many years to help kids that similarly had a ton of talent and grit even if they didn’t have preexisting funds to get jobs in the tech industry and be generationally transformative in their lives. From a pure financial perspective, she also figured out investing early on (rare for both the times and being a woman) and has undoubtedly paid more in taxes to the government and toward Medicare and Social Security than she’ll ever get back compared to 99.9% of the people out there complaining about immigrants supposedly taking from the system.
I don’t say this just to note that my mom is the embodiment of the American dream and is special (although she very much is), but rather she’s far from the exception. There are millions upon millions of people with a similar story. Unless you’re Native American, that is frankly the origin story of every family in America. If this country wants to be the best, then it should be bringing in everyone from across the world to unlock the best. I firmly believe that this is our single biggest advantage against virtually every other first world country.