(09-16-2026 05:00 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: (09-16-2026 03:06 PM)bullet Wrote: ...
I don't see how any of this is any different than it has been for the "G" schools since the 90s, except that one actually does get into the playoffs. It really hasn't changed since the 60s except there are more bowl opportunities.
bullet,
What you forget is there was no CFP back then, nowhere near as clear lines. I mean San Jose State hosts schools like Louisville and Wisconsin in their stadium. Winning your conference was a big deal, even if winning the PCAA just meant playing the MAC Champion Toledo or Central Michigan in Fresno (Raisen Bowl). You could end the season ranked.
The NCG and then playoff steadily eroded the value of the bowls (which also became too many, devaluing themselves that way too) turning the system into a tournament like March Madness but more exclusive. Further, the major conferences steadily increased the number of conference games. The SEC used to only play 6 of the 11 game season in conference. But now they are talking about 10 reducing the cross over against G6 to as few as one game in practice, given non-con -rivalries and the kick-off or similar bigtime challenge games. The MAC moving to 9 games, which you could see the American and Mountain West move to as well, is in reaction to the decreased opportunities to play A4 schools. An extra home conference game every other year can help financially,
All this is to say the opportunities to show case a G6 program have never been fewer. It is with that in mind, more than direct revenue, which is driving the push for a "little boy" playoff.
Yeah, the window was always smaller. But today it is tiny. Coaches notice the decline in quality of players, the drop in fan and alumni interest. And they see the lack of motivation that has crept in. All while the costs are rising. To ask for money from alumni there has to be a purpose.
Again, I ask you to look at it from the perspective of schools like Louisiana Tech, Utah State, Central Michigan, Georgia Southern, FAU, San Jose State, Miami (Oh), Ball State, Nevada and so on, who know they'll never sniff the CFP. But a G6 playoff with a dozen schools they can make every few years when the stars align. A 12-team playoff means 25 of the 70 schools will be playing for something in November, not just maybe 4 or 5. That helps attendance and interest, and at the right time of year to sell early season tickets for next year.
This is what you are not seeing. The lack of massive TV money is less important than the above.
Drop in quality of players recently is driven by unlimited transfers. But before that, its driven by all those FCS schools moving up. Half the G schools weren't in FBS 30 years ago. Some didn't even play football. I've got no sympathy for that group. For the ECUs and USMs and Colorado St.'s, yes.
Below are the G6 and when they moved into the top division per the NCAA (1946 is the first possible year).
1946 American Rice
1946 American Army
1946 American Navy
1946 American Tulane
1946 American Tulsa
1946 MWC UTEP
1946 MWC New Mexico
1946 MWC Wyoming
1946 Pac 12 Oregon State
1946 Pac 12 Washington State
1946 Pac 12 Colorado State
1946 Pac 12 Utah State
1950 MWC San Jose State
1957 MWC Air Force
1959 USA New Mexico State
1960 American Memphis
1961 MAC Miami U.
1961 MAC Ohio
1961 MAC Bowling Green
1962 MAC Western Michigan
1962 MAC Toledo
1962 MAC Kent
1963 Sun Belt Southern Mississippi
1966 American East Carolina
1969 MWC Northern Illinois
1969 Pac 12 San Diego State
1971 American Temple
1973 Pac 12 Fresno State
1974 MWC Hawaii
1974 Sun Belt W Louisiana-Lafayette
1975 MAC Central Michigan
1975 MAC Ball State
1976 MAC Eastern Michigan
1978 MWC UNLV
1987 MAC Akron
1989 Sun Belt Louisiana Tech
1992 MWC Nevada
1992 Sun Belt Arkansas State
1994 Sun Belt Louisiana-Monroe
1995 American North Texas
1996 Pac 12 Boise State
1998 Sun Belt Marshall
1999 MAC Buffalo
1999 USA Middle Tennessee
2001 American South Florida
2002 i Connecticut
2002 Sun Belt Troy State
2006 American Florida Atlantic
2006 USA Florida International
2009 USA Western Kentucky
2012 American Texas-San Antonio
2012 MAC Massachusetts
2012 Pac 12 Texas State
2012 Sun Belt South Alabama
2013 Sun Belt Georgia State
2014 Sun Belt Appalachian State
2014 Sun Belt Georgia Southern
2014 Sun Belt Old Dominion
2015 American Charlotte
1996-2014,2017 American Alabama Birmingham
2017 Sun Belt Coastal Carolina
2018 USA Liberty
2023 Sun Belt James Madison
2023 USA Jacksonville St.
2023 USA Sam Houston St.
2024 USA Kennesaw St.
2025 USA Delaware
2025 USA Missouri State
2026 MAC Sacramento St.
2026 MWC North Dakota State